British firms cut the amount of carbon dioxide released into the atmosphere by 13.5m tonnes last year, the government said yesterday, far above the targets set in the first two years of the climate change levy on electricity use.
But a large part of the decline was due to factory closures and loss of production in the steel industry, especially the rapid contraction of Corus, the largest single carbon dioxide emitter. Aluminium, chemical and cement industries also reduced emissions.
The sum of £1bn to £1.5bn has been collected by the Treasury from the 0.43p per kilowatt/hour levied on electricity use, and the money will be redistributed by Gordon Brown among the industries taking part. Those industries that reduced electricity use to below the target set at the beginning of the scheme get 80% of the levy refunded - and 88% of 5,000 companies taking part reached their targets.
Industry campaigned vigorously for the levy to be aban doned as an unacceptable extra cost to manufacturing but Lord Whitty, the minister for sustainable energy, said he expected less "whingeing" because energy bills have been reduced by efficiency measures.
The government is committed to a 12.5% reduction in greenhouse gases by 2010, about 35m tonnes of carbon dioxide less than in 1990. Industry has reduced its emissions in those 13 years by 15.8m tonnes, 10m more than originally projected. This means that Britain will surpass its targets, a better performance than any other country, Michael Meacher, the environment minister, said.
The levy scheme has also been used to introduce a carbon trading scheme in industry. Companies that cut carbon emissions more than their target can "bank" spare emissions against future and even tougher targets, or sell this surplus to other companies which have failed to reach their target. This trading scheme is already operating but because so many companies have exceeded targets the price of the surplus carbon is very low - less than £5 a tonne compared with the £12 originally predicted. Most companies have opted to bank the surplus as a result.
Mr Meacher said: "The success of the scheme demonstrates that claims that the levy was wrongheaded or misguided were misplaced. The results are very positive."
Michael Roberts, CBI's director of business environment, said: "These results show that business can and will deliver on the environment with the right incentives. But the levy is still blunting the competitive edge of too many firms for no good reason."
The government claimed that industry had discovered that there were significantly higher financial benefits from managing energy than they originally thought. There are 44 industry groups recognised by the government, each of which concluded a separate agreement on carbon dioxide reduction targets which get tougher each year up to 2010. Twenty four groups met all their targets set for the first two years, and 88% of agreements were renewed.
Industry's big clean-up
Industry Steel
Reduction target 25.4%
Actual CO2 cut 31.1%
Tonnes 9.4m *
Industry Aluminium
Reduction target 29.1%
Actual CO2 cut 31.9%
Tonnes 2m
Industry Chemicals
Reduction target 9.2%
Actual CO2 cut 14.5%
Tonnes 2m
Industry Cement
Reduction target 13.2%
Actual CO2 cut 16.6%
Tonnes 1.6m
Industry Brewing
Reduction target 2.2%
Actual CO2 cut 6.4%
Tonnes 0.29m
* Because of closures there was a 27.5% decrease in production