For those who followed the many months of government dithering over whether to approve production at the Jackdaw gasfield off the coast of Aberdeen, Scotland, there was a treat on social media this week.
It was the sight of Michael Shanks, energy minister, almost dancing a jig of delight as the first output from Jackdaw flowed into the national gas network. “It will increase domestic production and further boost our energy security during the transition to electrification and decarbonisation,” he declared.
To which the only possible response is: if the security benefit of using domestic gas during transition is so clear (and it is, as argued here from time to time) why did it take a year of ministerial agonising before the inevitable thumbs up arrived?
Still, you might think, at least the government now has a joined-up approach to gas. The long-term part is about rolling out the renewables and heat pumps to continue the decline (albeit slowly) in annual gas consumption.
The other necessity is to ensure the infrastructure is sufficiently robust to handle those bleak, still and overcast winter days when electricity generation still relies on gas-powered stations and domestic demand for gas for heating is still high (23m gas boilers won’t disappear overnight).
But here is the now-annual reminder of the “emerging risk”, in the delicate official language, to gas security.
A year ago, a scary report from the government’s in-house body, the National Energy System Operator (Neso), warned of a danger of having too little gas to meet demand during a cold snap as soon as 2030 if a large piece of infrastructure – a gas import terminal, say – were to be out of action.
Now Neso, in its latest update, is saying it all over again. “Our updated analysis shows that the risk identified in our 2025 assessment remains, and that there is an ongoing need for an enduring solution to secure future gas supply,” said the report on Wednesday.
What could an enduring solution be? It will have to involve more than greenlighting more North Sea gas production – even with Jackdaw and any follow-on projects, the UK will still rely on imports. So we’re talking import terminals, interconnecting pipes to the continent, or – very likely – reliable domestic gas storage. Or a combination of all three.
On the storage front, though, events are moving faster than the government’s decision-making. Centrica hasn’t been filling Rough, the largest offshore storage facility, and will close it next spring unless a deal can be done with government.
Now fellow FTSE 100 energy firm SSE says it is preparing to start the process of closing its Atwick facility near Hornsea in East Yorkshire. The cavern represents about 20% of Great Britain’s onshore gas storage.
In both cases, the firms are acting rationally, commercially speaking. The economics of gas storage rely on summer prices being reliably lower than winter ones to ensure a profit margin.
In a more global world of LNG, or liquefied natural gas transported by tanker, such spreads have disappeared; and geopolitics, such as the closure of the strait of Hormuz, can complicate matters.
Atwick, it should be said, could probably be reopened after closure. But that is less true of Rough. So is the government up for a negotiation to secure even the current gas storage capacity?
The position hasn’t moved since the summer when the government conceded for the first time that it may have to intervene.
“We recently confirmed plans to explore commercial support for storage and the wider sector, to help protect our gas security,” the energy department repeated on Wednesday. “We will set out proposals in due course.”
It is leaving things late. It is already the case that belt-and-braces gas security for this winter required an eleventh-hour deal with Belgium to avert a planned cut in interconnector capacity. The storage question cannot wait much longer – and delay, one fears, has already handed negotiating clout to the operators if ministers ultimately decide they need to do a deal.
The security problem has been recognised for years, even before the first Neso report. The threat of a gas crunch isn’t fresh news.
The remarkable aspect is simply how long successive governments have taken to get a strategy together, even as the current one urges households to stockpile to improve national resilience. Before gas storage facilities start to close and narrow options further, it’s time for a plan.