Greg Jericho 

In rare good news, wages have risen strongly. But Australian workers are still falling behind

Despite the highest wage growth in years, we wait for signs of workers getting ahead of inflation – or of the supposed benefits of the AI boom
  
  

Overhead view of commuters descending stairs at Martin Place train station, Sydney
‘The lack of real wage growth is the biggest story in economics right now that most economists are not talking about,’ Greg Jericho writes. Photograph: Lisa Maree Williams/Getty Images

It’s rare of late to get good economic news, but on Wednesday the wage figures from the Bureau of Statistics showed a nice bump in wages. Private sector wages rose 1.0% in the September quarter for an annual growth of 3.4%, the highest in two years. But even with these good numbers, real wages went backwards, showing just how though things are for workers.

Each year the September quarter is the big time for a wage increase. This isn’t because your boss is feeling romantic and likes to remember when “grass was green and grain was yellow”. No, it’s because it is the first quarter of the new financial year and also the quarter where workers on the minimum/award wage get a pay rise via the Fair Work Commission:

Click here if this graph does not display

The Bureau of Statistics knows this, and adjusts the figures for the “seasonal” effect. But even still, the wage rise in the months of July, August and September were enough to deliver the biggest quarterly increase since 2023:

Click here if this graph does not display

The overall figures got a bigger boost than usual due to some strong public sector pay rises – especially in the healthcare and social assistance sector, which the ABS said accounted for a third of the increase in total wage growth in the quarter. It also noted “the main contributor to public sector growth was pay rises for state government workers covered by enterprise agreements. These included nurses, midwives and police.”

The overall annual wage growth of 3.5% is certainly a bump up from 3.2%, but pretty much within the zone of where it has been for a couple years:

Click here if this graph does not display

Wages should grow about 3.5% each year. That’s a nice level to be at. And anyone suggesting these numbers are a concern because it might cause the Reserve Bank to raise rates really needs to quiet down (especially if they happen to be on the RBA’s monetary policy board).

Because yes, wages grew 3.5% in the year, but inflation (using the quarterly figures) went up 3.9%. That means in real terms, people’s ability to buy things with their wages on average fell 0.5%:

Click here if this graph does not display

This is not good, but once again it shows that wages are not driving inflation.

It also means the average wage is worth about 5% less than it was in March 2021. For someone who was earning $90,000 a year in 2021, that is equivalent to a loss of about $4,500 (before tax) and has you back where you were in 2011:

Click here if this graph does not display

If you feel like you can’t get ahead, then you are not alone.

The lack of real wage growth is the biggest story in economics right now that most economists are not talking about.

The RBA prefers to use a measure of wages from the national accounts (ie the GDP figures) than the wage price index (WPI). That is because WPI does not take into account the change in wage if you shift jobs or get a promotion.

The WPI works like the consumer price index (CPI) does for inflation. The CPI doesn’t take into account people buying less of something if it becomes more expensive (or vice versa), and yet the Reserve Bank still uses the CPI as the measure of inflation. So excuse me if I think the same method is also good enough for measuring wage rises.

The wage data on Wednesday also showed that for all the big talk about an AI construction boom, we are not seeing it in wages.

In the September quarter wage rises in construction were among the lowest – not just well behind the healthcare growth and the hospitality jump due to the award wage increase, but well below the average of all industries:

Click here if this graph does not display

This is quite different to what happened during the last construction surge in the 2000s. During the 2004-2008 mining boom, wages in the construction sector had some massive spikes and consistency stronger growth than the rest of the labour force:

Click here if this graph does not display

In the mining boom, not only were there plenty of jobs for construction workers, but the pay rises reflected that. By contrast, annual wage growth in the construction industry fell in the September quarter from 3.4% to 2.9%.

If there is an AI boom, there is no sign yet that it is doing anything to drive wages – neither across the economy or even in construction.

That’s a pretty damning finding given the Reserve Bank has used the rise in AI construction as one reason for raising rates.

And so, while the strong wage growth is to be welcomed, we continue to wait for any sign of workers being able to get ahead of inflation, or any of the supposed benefits of the AI boom.

• Greg Jericho is a Guardian columnist and chief economist at the Australia Institute

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*