Here is the news; the BBC's oft-criticised News 24 channel is fighting back in the ratings war with its bitter rival, Sky. It attracted more viewers in the two weeks following Sky News's multi-million pound relaunch on 24 October, which initially proved a huge turn-off for viewers. Round one to the Beeb.
But now for some news just in; Sky has re-established its lead, winning a 0.54 per cent share against News 24's 0.5 per cent over the last fortnight. There are some signs that its heavily promoted 'appointment to view' schedule, which features personality-led news programmes anchored by celebrities like Eamonn Holmes, may be finding favour with viewers.
But the real test will come when the next big news story breaks. That is when Sky traditionally attracts more viewers, capitalising on its hard-won reputation for being first with the news. In the wake of the 7 July bombings, both channels saw their viewing figures soar, but Sky's were consistently ahead of the BBC's, averaging more than 4 per cent of overall audience share, compared with News 24's 2 per cent, according to the Broadcasters' Audience Research Board (Barb).
Opinion-formers still turn to Sky for information, as the BBC's new head of television news, Peter Horrocks, acknowledged in an email to staff earlier this month, which was leaked to The Observer last week. In it, Horrocks stressed News 24 'has a long way to go' to match Sky's reputation for breaking news, and bemoaned the fact that the makers of a BBC documentary on the bombings, which he commissioned, felt compelled to use extensive Sky News footage. The fact that Sky is market leader clearly rankles, not least because BBC bosses believe its reputation for breaking news is entirely undeserved.
Horrocks claims it is based on 'a marketing trick', and liberal use of the red 'breaking news' graphic when there is often no 'new' news to report. 'Sky's claims on breaking news are hollow and misleading' he recently told BBC staff. [Its] claimed leadership is based on a definition of breaking news that is based more on a marketing strategy than on legitimate editorial definitions'.
Horrocks says his argument is supported by a study into 24-hour news carried out by Cardiff University. '[It found] that 80 per cent of Sky's "breaking news" is applied to predictable diary events. Only 12.5 per cent of News 24's breaking news is classified as predictable.'
The study did indeed draw these conclusions, although it also pointed out that breaking news represents a small proportion - 3.6 per cent - of stories across all news channels. Even so, Horrocks believes Sky's reputation for being first has a huge impact on the performance of both channels. 'One information channel's reputation is built on a misleading prospectus,' he argues. 'and it does take people in. Even the esteemed former editor of the FT, Richard Lambert, in his report for government on News 24 [in 2002], assumed that Sky was stronger in breaking news and noted that "anyone who was around a newspaper office will find them tuned to Sky News".' Lambert was right. Sky is the channel of choice in most newsrooms. The Cardiff report claims: 'This impression has more to do with Sky's liberal use of the phrase "breaking news" than their alacrity in reporting it.' Perhaps, but if journalists - and other opinion-formers - are to start reaching for their remote controls, Horrocks will have to convince them the BBC is as accurate, authoritative and, above all, as fast as its rival.
Few would dispute it meets the first two criteria, but some observers suggest it does so at the expense of the third. The BBC places great store by accuracy. Its director of news, Helen Boaden has said, in so many words, that it does not always have to be first, but it must be right. But exercising caution may allow others to relay information first, which may explain why she softened her stance recently, suggesting that viewers are mature enough to understand that not all information can be corroborated immediately.
Sky's rivals tease it by claiming it is 'never wrong for long', but anecdotal evidence suggests viewers would prefer to see information on screen quickly, along with appropriate disclaimers if necessary, even if it has to be clarified - or even contradicted - a few minutes later.
The Cardiff study found that on the few occasion when all news channels treated a subject as breaking news, Sky was first to air a report on one occasion, whereas the BBC was first twice. But the perception remains that Sky is usually first. Horrocks claims: 'We are breaking more genuinely original stories - stories that the BBC reports exclusively and our competitors then report many hours behind.'
This may not matter, of course; viewers may simply prefer Sky because, its coverage feels more dynamic. Its new state-of-the-art newsroom has enhanced its reputation as an innovative broadcaster that is not afraid to take risks, despite disastrous viewing figures in the fortnight following the relaunch. There are signs that Holmes's arrival is improving early morning ratings, but attempts to build shows around other 'personalities' are proving less successful.
It could be that viewers will switch to Sky in their droves once the new format finds its rhythm. But the battle for ascendancy may rest on the next big news event, when both channels clear their schedules, and presenters throw their scripts aside to revert to the rolling news format that has served Sky so well. Once the smoke clears, Horrocks will know whether he has convinced viewers that the BBC does breaking news better.