Retailers are squaring up for battle with the government because John Prescott has rejected a string of proposals for superstores on the grounds that they take trade from town centres and increase car use.
Planners say the deputy prime minister wants smaller stores closer to where people live. With several retailers, notably the Ikea furniture stores and Tesco supermarkets considering legal challenges in the high court, Mr Prescott is preparing planning guidelines to prevent further out-of-town developments.
Although John Gummer, then environment secretary, attempted seven years' ago to curb malls such as the Trafford Centre, outside Manchester, and Lakeside, near Thurrock in Essex, supermarkets found a way around his guidelines.
These set a "sequential test" under which retailers had to prove that they could find no suitable town centre sites before looking to edge of townand greenfield sites. In many cases, they argued successfully that small central sites were incapable of accommodating superstores. Mr Prescott closed in on them by rejecting new stores around the country and extensions on established sites.
"There is very clearly a tougher line, with Mr Prescott throwing down the gauntlet to some of them who want large out-of-town formats," said Chris Goddard, head of retail planning at consultants CB Hillier Parker. "He is asking 'why are they necessary?' A series of recent decisions has sent shock waves through the industry on how policy is being interpreted."
Goddard says retailers, particularly Tesco, have clashed directly with the deputy prime minister over what big stores should sell. "They are saying customers want everything under one roof and, when you're buying your weekly groceries why shouldn't you be able to get a knockdown deal on a microwave. But he is saying these (non-food) items can be sold in town centres, so forget it, you need to be flexible."
Matters have come to a head at Rugeley, in Staffordshire, where Mr Prescott ruled that a £20m Tesco superstore would affect the "vitality and viability" of the town centre. Tesco argues that the site is edge-of-town, not out-of-town.
When Mr Prescott rejected an Ikea for Stockport, he told the firm to consider specialist shops in city centres. Yesterday his department said: "We're as strong as ever in our commitment to reinvigorate town and city centres, rather than allowing out of town developments."