Advertising revenues at ITV showed renewed signs of faltering yesterday amid growing fears about the strength of the economy and concern about prospects for the media sector as a whole.
In a report on ITV entitled "A further turn for the worse", influential Merrill Lynch analyst Neil Blackley expressed "deep concern" about the network's advertising revenues and slashed his earnings targets on its owners, Carlton, Granada and Scottish Media Group.
February bookings are thought to be down 6% on last year, with March potentially off more than 10%, he predicted.
Figures circulating among advertising agencies supported his suspicion, with some media buyers believing that March could in reality be down as much as 15%.
The revenue fall reflects poor ITV viewing figures last year because advertising rates reflect historic audience numbers. Early indications in 2003 are that schedule changes and extra investment in programming have increased ITV's share of audience considerably since the autumn.
Mr Blackley cut his UK television advertising revenue growth targets for 2003 from 3.3% to 2.2%.
Analysts at Cazenove rejected the speculation blaming "scare stories", while an ITV source suggested February bookings were down less than 4% and that it was too early to call March.
Granada shares fell by as much as 7% during the day before closing down 4% at 69.5p. Carlton dropped 9% but rallied to end off 2% at 120p.
The performances compounded a gloomy week for the media sector which has seen the release of several analyst reports predicting little growth in the sector during 2003 because of declining consumer confidence, a weak US dollar and fears over a war in Iraq.
On Wednesday Dresdner Kleinwort Wasserstein and Bear Stearns trimmed advertising forecasts for the year. Yesterday Deutsche Bank reiterated its "sell" advice on Carlton and Granada shares.
Sir Martin Sorrell, the head of advertising group WPP, believes industry rev enues may not begin to grow again until 2004, when George Bush is expected to "pump-prime" the economy ahead of his re-election campaign and firms start marketing around the Athens Olympics.
"After a dire three years of media sector performance, predicting where the sector goes next remains as difficult as ever," Credit Suisse First Boston analyst Michael Picken wrote in a note to clients.
Even some of the most robust media stocks have been unable to lift themselves out of the mire. Mr Blackley also questioned the ability of publisher Reed Elsevier to meet its objective of delivering double digit earnings growth this year, despite being one of the sector's best run and most stable businesses. He blamed weakening demand for Reed's educational and legal products, predicting that costs will need to be cut to hit targets.
The fall in ITV advertising revenues follows a poor audience ratings performance last year. During the first few weeks of 2003 the network has performed strongly against the BBC by increasing its share of viewers and attracting more advertiser friendly upmarket younger viewers.
If it can maintain the growth, advertising revenues are likely to recover as clients start to reassess how much they spend on each channel.
Cazenove analyst Mark Braley played down the importance of March's expected advertising fall, blaming the timing of Easter. Last year the holiday fell in March, prompting big campaigns from travel companies and retailers such as B & Q, but this year it is in April.
The month also coincides with the start of many companies' fiscal years, when new advertising budgets will be revealed.
Marc Bignell, head of television at media buyer OMD UK whose clients include Vodafone and Camelot, said that ITV was working hard to improve but had been beset by bad luck, including the resignation of long-serving presenter Cilla Black, and arrests of stars Michael Barrymore, John Leslie and Matthew Kelly.
"ITV is beginning to turn the corner but hasn't quite done it yet," he said. "The programme output has been strong, the viewing performance has been good but they've had a lot of things go wrong that were outside their control."
Carlton and Granada shares have also come under pressure owing to concerns that their proposed merger may be blocked by competition authorities fearful of the combined group's influence over the TV advertising market.
"There clearly is a 'genuine risk' that the merger could be blocked although we would see such a risk as being substantially below 50%," said Cazenove's Mr Braley. "We remain of the view that even if the merger is blocked, the companies will simply try again ... and will eventually succeed."
Finally? The good news
ITV's advertising revenues are under pressure because of previous poor ratings but is 2003 witnessing a turnaround?
Official figures show:
· In the second week of January, ITV's peak audience share was up by 1 share point year on year while BBC1 was down by 1.5 share points.
· ITV1 took a 47% share of all adults watching adverts during the first week of the year, up 6% on autumn last year
· During the first week of 2003, the volume of adults watching ads on ITV1 rose by 13%. C4 was up 7%, while Five was down 2%
· ITV1's year on year growth in upmarket ABC1 adults - a lucrative audience for advertisers - was up 17%
· ITV1 daytime audiences are up 15% helped by popular shows including Trisha and This Morning
· Coronation Street has delivered the best audience of any soap from any channel including BBC1's Eastenders
Source: BARB/GE Overnights System/ DDS/ Ratecard Weighted impacts