When will adland add up?

Jamie Doward on how recovery in the world of advertising will be slow - and hard-won.
  
  


Every day the bad news flows in medialand: a steady trickle of corrosive information which undermines economic confidence. Be it journalists losing their jobs on the Independent or the Mail on Sunday, a tranche of middle management biting the bullet at ITN, or Granada announcing more redundancies, it is clear the advertising downturn is taking its toll at every level of the industry.

Some might think this bad news only for the owners of Soho wine bars, but the fact is that advertising is a key indicator of the health of the wider economy.

'There is a clear and strong correlation between the growth or fall in ad revenues and the rise or drop in the overall strength of the economy,' said Anthony Jones, European Research Director with media planning agency Optimedia.

Thus everyone has a vested interest in the advertising market remaining buoyant. Unfortunately evidence suggests the industry is sinking, although there is little consensus on how quickly.

Optimedia estimates that total advertising revenue in the UK will drop 3 per cent to £11.2 billion this year. The agency says that television has borne the brunt of the economic downturn with revenues down 11 per cent. As a result, TV advertising prices have been slashed by 13 per cent this year.

Optimedia says national newspaper advertising revenues will be down 5 per cent to £2.1bn this year compared with 2000. Even radio, which has enjoyed consistently high levels of growth, will see advertising revenue drop 7 per cent to £421 million.

Optimedia estimates advertising revenue will grow by 2 per cent next year, although it is not predicting a recovery in the advertising market until September at the earliest. 'We don't think it will come cranking back until after the next six to nine months - and this assumes we're not going into World War Three and that there will not be a major crash in the world economy,' Jones said.

Much will depend on whether the worsening situation in the US advertising industry is transferred to the UK.

But Optimedia seems more optimistic than many in the industry. The Media Planning Group (MPG) says in its latest report that 'The uncertainty within the US markets and the potential "knock-on" effect will ultimately impact on consumer confidence in the UK. This will delay any upturn in the advertising market until Q4 of 2002 at the earliest.' MPG predicts ITV's ad revenues will fall by 4.2 per cent next year, while the newspaper market will remain largely flat.

The Billett Consultancy estimates that 2001 has been a much tougher year for UK advertising revenues than Optimedia believes. 'We were predicting it would be down around 8 per cent but there has been a bit of a recovery in November and December and it looks like this year will be down 6 or 7 per cent,' said Andy Pearch, managing director of Billett.

Advertising company Zenith Media will tomorrow publish its long-awaited report on the health of the industry. Those looking for good news will be disappointed. This year, after nine years of growth in the industry, Zenith calculates advertising will be down 5.8 per cent. And Zenith predicts the UK advertising market will shrink by 1.4 per cent next year - although compared with the global picture, Britain gets off lightly.

Such pessimism is shared by Sir Martin Sorrell, chief executive of advertising giant WPP. 'Next year will probably be another difficult year both in advertising and marketing services, although the latter will probably grow faster,' Sorrell said.

If history is anything to go by, Sorrell's predictions are correct. Following the recession at the start of the 1990s, the cost of advertising on TV fell dramatically in 1990 and 1991 and only marginally recovered in 1992. Many in the industry believe history is repeating itself and that the advertising Industry is only half way through a two-year downturn.

The one wild card is 11 September. 'Maybe 11 September accelerated what otherwise would have been a slow decline,' Jones said.

This could suggest a bounceback might happen more rapidly than the industry was expecting - a classic, short, sharp 'v-shaped' advertising recession.

Sorrell said: 'Some believe that we will see a deepened V next year, driven by the stimuli of fiscal and monetary policies, with a recovery in the second half particularly driven by "kitchen-sinking", ie heavy provisioning in the second half of 2001 will make performance better in the second half of 2002.'

But no one is certain if this is the case, as Sorrell points out. 'Others believe that 11 September and such terrorism is effectively a tax on globalisation, and will result in a slowing of growth in the world economy. You pay your money and you take your choice.'

Amid such uncertainty, predictions of when the good times will roll again are not copper-bottomed. Granada's executive chairman, Charles Allen, admitted as much last week when he said that although the company had seen ad revenues fall by 'only' 12 per cent during the last three months, compared with 16 per cent the previous quarter, the City should not 'draw any conclusions from this, because there is no visibility for January'.

Certainly Granada's rival Carlton is not expected to help matters this week when it unveils full-year results which show pre-tax profits (excluding ITV Digital) are around £94m compared with £194m the previous year.

Carlton's bad news is unlikely to be the last. It is ugly out there in advertising land and things are likely to get worse before they get better. It may not be until Christmas 2002 that the festive spirit is found in the wine bars of Soho.

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*