The upside for adland

It's not all gloom for the advertisisng industry, says Sarah Ryle. Some sectors are growing and the future looks bright.
  
  


Fear of Anthrax has some curious, even positive, side-effects. Junk mail - direct marketing as business labels it - has become very unpopular in America since 11 September. Companies are loath to add to the national nervousness about unexpected envelopes.

This is one of the findings from Zenith Media, which will tomorrow publish an advertising health-check together with a medium-term prognosis that can best be summarised as 'pretty poorly'.

But Zenith, and Media Planning Group, the other agency that has new forecasts this week, agree the downturn is not as bad as the last time the economy caught a cold. Recovery, they say, will start in late summer or early autumn.

'Is this the death of advertising? Of course not,' says Adam Smith, head of knowledge management at Zenith. 'Advertising moves in cycles and we have no more uninvented that than we have invented the new economy.'

He firmly rejects comparisons with the last recession. 'In 1990, the UK advertising market fell 11.7 per cent and in 1991 it fell by 10.2 per cent. This time, in 2001, it will have shrunk by 5.8 per cent and next year it will be 1.4 per cent.'

Globally the picture may be much worse as the American downturn affects the rest of the world, but here in the UK the future is not so dark and advertising spend is likely to return to growth in the summer, according to Smith.

Media Planning Group takes a gloomier view, predicting a decline of 7.6 per cent for this year and no recovery in the key sectors of press and TV advertising until October next year. But even MPG sees a total market shrinkage of only 1 per cent in 2002, admittedly a comparison against a bad year.

The reason is that TV and press, which account for 70 per cent of the total market, will see revenue loss slow up significantly. Radio, outdoor and cinema are actually growing. Outdoor sites, at bus stops and train stations for example, are benefiting from innovations such as plasma screens, which appeal to advertisers. Cinema is set for another strong year thanks to a schedule of sequels to box office hits including Harry Potter II, Star Wars: Attack of the Clones, Matrix II and Men in Black II.

You cannot keep the British consumer down. Official and industry statistics show that retail and leisure spending remains solid, if a little slower than earlier in the year. 'Consumer confidence is the missing link and we see it hitting a trough in the middle of next year then picking up,' says Smith.

Advertisers whose business depends upon flaunting their wares to shoppers are particularly resilient. Retailers may be spending less as a group than they were last year but many high street giants anticipate at least maintaining, and in some cases increasing, their marketing budgets in 2002.

'We are not looking to reduce our marketing spend, far from it,' said Francis Thomas, spokesman for Boots. 'I would imagine that our presence in print and broadcast will not diminish.'

Most retailers recite, parrot fashion, examples of companies which increased spending during the last recession and survived (Barclaycard) and those which cut back and are no longer here to tell the tale (Access).

'In general, prices are back to 1998 levels,' said Mark Mendoza, managing director at MPG. 'How many things can you say that about? It is bargain time for those who have got the bottle. For anybody who wants to build a brand there has been no better time to do it in the last five years from a cost perspective. There are deals to be done.'

The relative strengths and weaknesses of display advertising in newspapers and consumer magazines are an interesting case in point. Black and white adverts have declined faster than colour ones, according to MPG, which are holding up much better in the mid-market and pops than they have done in the quality broadsheets. This is in part due to the tendency of mass-market retailers to take space in - guess what - mass-market newspapers.

Consumer magazines are actually recording year-on-year growth in display advertising revenue, according to MPG, although this is due to a ploy called 'shield yield', which reduces supply in order to boost rates.

'There has been reduced pagination across all issues for the remainder of the fourth quarter of 2001,' explained MPG. 'This seems to artificially restrict supply to drive up demand and rates.'

Not that demand is particularly down in areas where magazines source their glossy adverts. Gucci, Estée Lauder and Hermes are unlikely to commit brand suicide by opting out of Vogue or Elle.

The problem in print is the classified sections. As companies have laid off staff, recruitment campaigns have dried up. But Zenith sees this levelling off in the medium term. 'There is the prospect of corporate profits returning next year, although at the cost of jobs,' said Smith.

In the world of advertising, the glass is always half-full, never half-empty.

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*