This mollycoddling is unjustified

As the top brass at BT convene this morning to review the dismal response to the news that the BBC's Sir Christopher Bland is taking over from Sir Iain Vallance as chairman of the directionless telecoms conglomerate, they should start with the statement issued by the organisation yesterday morning.
  
  


As the top brass at BT convene this morning to review the dismal response to the news that the BBC's Sir Christopher Bland is taking over from Sir Iain Vallance as chairman of the directionless telecoms conglomerate, they should start with the statement issued by the organisation yesterday morning.

The red-hot clue is sitting there in the second sentence: "Sir Iain will step down as a board director and will remain with BT as president emeritus until July 2002."

To be sure, the man has served his term - 20 years on the BT board. But he really cannot deserve the mollycoddling that this honourary position suggests, coming as it does on top of a £600,000 "terminal bonus" agreed last year and at the end of a part-time job paying £746,000, plus perks.

Forgive the cynicism, but with Sir Iain off the board, outsiders will not automatically get a look at what the ex-chairman is being paid during his last 14 months of consultancy as he glides exquisitely into retirement.

For shareholders and customers alike, the Vallance years have been wasted years.

At home, the company's pole position in its sector was squandered as it pursed a strategy aimed purely at defending its traditional revenue base, rather than developing new areas of the telecoms business with any sort of flair or enthusiasm. It is no exaggeration to state that the latest exhibition of this insular culture - frustrating the roll-out of broadband internet access in order, we assume, to protect its high margin fixed-line voice traffic - has probably caused lasting damage to the UK economy as whole.

Meanwhile, BT's efforts at international expansion have proved chaotic and costly, and there is every expectation that the next set of figures will show Sir Iain's personal favourite venture - the Concert alliance with America's AT&T, serving international corporate customers - withering on its virtual vine.

Some 17 years on from the initial privatisation, this key British company is reduced to trying to stave off its bankers by pawning its fleet of vans.

Of course, we have all known for many months just how bad the numbers are at BT. And Sir Christopher can assure himself that the 6% drop in BT's share price yesterday did not reflect a City view that he will be 6% worse at the job than Sir Iain; the new man at the top simply brings the rescue rights issue into view, which is something that no trader could resist selling into.

But in trying to effect a soft succession, fuelling suspicions of corporate old-boyism in the process, Sir Christopher risks throwing away the one thing this company so desperately needs: a culture of change.

Shire story

If Shire Pharmaceuticals' merger with BioChem Pharma was a novel, it would be a door-stopper. The deal was delayed again yesterday, and Shire's lugubrious chief executive Rolf Stahel was even less chatty than usual about the reasons.

Shire will only say that it is still negotiating over the deal with the Canadian government. The assumption is that these talks concern pledges for jobs in Quebec, but it is hard to see how such an issue can take five months to resolve.

Arbitrage dealers suspect a hidden agenda. They are deliberately depressing Shire's shares to ensure it issues more stock for BioChem. The longer the deal takes, the more arbitrageurs will lose patience, close their positions and drift away, thus allowing the shares to creep back up. Arbitrageurs can be viewed as parasites or as wealth creators who aid liquidity. Mr Stahelis likely to take the former view.

If there is a good reason why the merger has been delayed, Shire and Canada's industry minister, Brian Tobin, should tell us. If not, it is hard to escape the view that Mr Stahel and Mr Tobin are prolonging talks as much as possible. That way, Shire's shareholders suffer less dilution and Mr Tobin looks tough when he stands for re-election.

Hard talk

Agreeing the terms of any "merger" is never easy, particularly when the talks have been leaked. But the problems facing Halifax and Bank of Scotland are more difficult than most, given national sentiment and the unusual status enjoyed by BoS. This is not just symbolic but also structural, as the Edinburgh-based firm is not a conventional plc but founded by a special charter.

None of this will ease the decision of where to locate the headquarters of any combined bank, especially as Halifax is important to the Yorkshire town.

James Crosby, the Yorkshireman running the Halifax, and his Scottish chairman, Lord Stevenson, are more aware than most of the sensitivities. They will be trying to gauge whether registered office status - good enough for Lloyds TSB - will appease the Scots.

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*