Leader 

After Chairman Bland

What happens to British Telecom is very important for the economy: what happens to the BBC is very important for our cultural life. That is why Sir Christopher Bland's move from one to the other is a big event.
  
  


What happens to British Telecom is very important for the economy: what happens to the BBC is very important for our cultural life. That is why Sir Christopher Bland's move from one to the other is a big event.

He is right to carry on with both jobs until after the election since that will help to take the decision out of the party political arena and allow more time to ponder what exactly it is that we require of the BBC's governors in the new multimedia age.

Sir Christopher leaves the BBC with a reputation for being one of the most interventionist chairman in recent memory - which raised a potential conflict of interest between his putative executive role and his constitutional duty as a governor to monitor the executive.

It is easy for cynics to say that he simply presided over the structural revolution of the Birtian era and its reversal under Greg Dyke. He has a lot to answer for, for that discontinuity - but he leaves the BBC as a still formidable player in the new multichannel, digital age and with a website that has been so successful that its commercial rivals have been crying "foul". His boldest move was to insist that Greg Dyke became the new director general against the opposition of some colleagues.

This has - so far - turned out to be an inspired move. If, and it is still an "if", Mr Dyke fulfils his potential, then media historians will look with favour on the Bland regime. Of all the responsibilities the governors have (a list so long and onerous you wonder how they can do it meeting only once a month) none is more important for the operating success of the organisation than appointing the DG.

The most urgent question after the election is who should succeed Sir Christopher. The successful candidate will be required to preserve the BBC's values first as it negotiates its future with a government wanting it to come under a wider multimedia regulatory regime and later when it renegotiates its own charter. During this period it will be competing with hundreds of digital channels, many owned by Rupert Murdoch, and also with the internet as it mutates into a medium for radio and television.

The most obviously qualified candidate is Gavyn Davies. A rich Goldman Sachs economist, he is the sitting vice- chairman of the BBC governors and chaired the government inquiry into the future funding of the BBC in 1999. The problem is that, even though a fiercely independent economist, he is too closely linked to New Labour and Gordon Brown in particular. The Conservatives are bound to complain about this. Their pathetic record in appointing Tories to the BBC when they were in power makes it hard to take their criticisms seriously. But Greg Dyke is also a Labour sympathiser and to have two Labour inclined people running the BBC would not only be rightly controversial but disastrous for the checks and balances within the BBC that the governors are suppose to uphold.

There is no shortage of other candidates including DeAnne Julius, the woman who single handedly took on the suits on the Bank of England's monetary policy committee to get interest rates down, Baroness Jay, Liz Forgan, former director of network radio at the BBC, or one of a number of liberal minded Conservatives such as Michael Heseltine and Lord Cranborne.

The new appointment should be combined with a reappraisal of the role of governors. It is no longer possible or desirable that the governors have sole responsibility for regulating the BBC in a multichannel digital age. The BBC is no longer the sole national broadcaster but a major player in a fast moving and very complicated world of interacting new media in which it is important to have a level playing field. In this new world the governors must fight the case for a continuing licence fee against complaints of unfair competition from the Murdoch press (ditto for taking advertising on the BBC's overseas web activities) but they can't expect to be the sole or even the main referee. The role of the governors ought to be more that of a trust dedicated to preserving the soul of the organisation and maintaining its high standards of equity - leaving regulation to a wider body overseeing commercial television, telecommunications and the internet.

Meanwhile, Sir Christopher will need more than luck to revive BT. We welcomed his appointment to the BBC where he already had many of the media skills needed. But the problems at BT, with £30bn of debts, are of a different order of magnitude. Like other former national utilities it has failed to adjust to the new age of wireless and fierce competition. It has failed to produce an international strategy to satisfy the City while at the same time failing to bring its domestic monopoly operations into the 21st century. The first thing Sir Christopher should do is to apply the public service ethos learned at the BBC to force BT to drop its feeble excuses and roll out broadband internet connections to as many homes as possible. That would be a good first step towards restoring BT's long lost reputation as a prime mover in the digital age. But only the first step.

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*