Here’s our news story on Bank of England policy Michael Saunders’ hint that interest rates could be cut soon:
Heads-up: the US government is considering curbs on US investors putting money into China, according to CNBC.
The movewould intensify the trade war, so the report has knocked shares in Chinese companies listed in New York.
CNBC says:
The White House is considering limits on U.S. investment into China, aggravating the protracted trade dispute between the globe’s two largest economies....
One of those options includes limiting all U.S. investment in China. Though the person cautioned that the discussion was still in early stages, such an action could send shockwaves throughout financial markets and involve the billions of dollars in investments tied to major indexes.
BREAKING: Stocks slide sharply after report that the White House is weighing U.S. portfolio flows into China; Alibaba plunges over 6% https://t.co/0m9bH1lPWg pic.twitter.com/8Qu0WOSk0D
— CNBC Now (@CNBCnow) September 27, 2019
Our latest health check on the UK economy is out:
The latest economic data out of America is a little mixed.
On the downside, consumer spending rose by just 0.1% last month, weaker than the 0.3% expected.
#consumer #spending grew by a weaker-than-expected 0.1% in August, following a 0.5% gain in July. The strongest gains were in purchases of durable goods. Personal #income rose by 0.4%. Real #inflation-adjusted) consumer spending was up 2.3% Y/Y, a declining comparison. pic.twitter.com/z31ULu8TDb
— Dr Thomas Kevin Swift (@DrTKSwift) September 27, 2019
On the upside, Americans are more confidence about economic prospects, according to the University of Michigan.
Michigan Consumer Sentiment: Remains Favorable in September https://t.co/bKfisaNTIa pic.twitter.com/LzsTGkjXET
— Real Macro Economics (@RealMacroEcon) September 27, 2019
The latest high-profile Wall Street flotation is going badly.
Peloton, which sells exercise bikes and treadmills that can stream online classes, joined the New York stock exchange yesterday - and promptly tanked by 11%.
$PTON pic.twitter.com/cZ587CXXmr
— Ivan the K™🆒 (@IvanTheK) September 27, 2019
Having brushed themselves down overnight, the company’s stock is... down another 7% in early trading today.
Peloton is one of those ‘hot’ companies, billing itself as a “social connection” firm. It’s premise is that health-conscious consumers can join classes remotely, creating a community buzz that encourages them to work up a sweat as they work out.
The problem, I suspect, is that investors have spotted that Peleton is loss-making, doesn’t expect to make a profit until 2023, and sells rather expensive kit (£1,990 for the bike!) - suggesting its potential market may not be huge...
There’s a lot of drama in the oil price today.
Crude prices fell sharply, following reports that Saudi Arabia has agreed to a partial ceasefire in Yemen, where it has been fighting Houthi militants since 2015.
This has bolstered hopes that tensions in the region could ease, following the attack on Saudi Aramco’s oil production site.
Brent Crude #Oil drops on report Saudi Arabia agrees to partial cease fire in Yemen. pic.twitter.com/XAuSGoh7Kh
— Holger Zschaepitz (@Schuldensuehner) September 27, 2019
Iran’s president, Hassan Rouhani, also excited the markets, by claiming that the US had offered to remove all sanction in exchange for talks.
Rouhani said he hasn’t accepted the offer due to the current “toxic atmosphere”.
President Trump has firmly denied Rouhani’s claim, though.
Iran wanted me to lift the sanctions imposed on them in order to meet. I said, of course, NO!
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) September 27, 2019
Brent crude is 2% lower at $61.47, close to its levels before the Aramco attack two weeks ago.
The process to bring Thomas Cook’s holidaymakers home is continuing today.
By the end of the day, the Civil Aviation Authority expects to have returned another 16,000 people. That means 77,000 customers will have been repatriated since the company went into liquidation on Monday morning.
This isn’t much relief for the 9,000 Thomas Cook staff who are losing their jobs.
But there is some hope there too. Manchester Mayor Andy Burnham says a jobs fair has been organised at Manchester Airport next week:
Pleased to confirm that we’ve managed to set up an Employment Fair for ex-Thomas Cook employees on 3/10/2019 at Manchester Airport with many big employers in attendance & free travel provided by @OfficialTfGM. See below for details. https://t.co/Kf776VgSBz
— Andy Burnham (@AndyBurnhamGM) September 27, 2019
Stocks boosted by fiscal spending hopes
Despite ongoing Brexit uncertainty, and the drop in eurozone business confidence, European stock markets are all rising today.
London is leading the way, thanks to the weaker pound. But Germany is also up, on hopes that Berlin could boost public spending to boost growth.
The EC’s next economic commissioner is also pushing for governments to spend more.
Former Italian PM Paolo Gentiloni argued today, in written answers to lawmakers, that politicians should make “full use of the flexibility allowed in the rules” to raise public spending and support their economies.
Over in the eurozone, economic sentiment has tumbled to its lowest level in five years.
The European Commission reports that factories became even more glum this month, as trade war worries hit confidence.
This “substantial deterioration” in industrial confidence dragged its monthly gauge of economic measure down to just 101.7 points from 103.1 in August. That’s the weakest since 2014.
Euro area economic sentiment indicator (ESI) fell markedly in September (by 1.4 points to 101.7). The decrease resulted from a significant deterioration of confidence in industry (-3.0 to -8.8). pic.twitter.com/NS34tfX1ut
— Nadia Gharbi (@nghrbi) September 27, 2019
Michael Saunders’ speech has highlight the marked weakening of the UK economy over recent quarters, says Fiona Cincotta of City Index.
She points out that Brexit uncertainty will linger for a long time, so the BoE will be cautious about risking higher interest rates.
Even if the UK did manage to pull the rabbit out the bag and leave the EU with a deal, the elevated levels of uncertainty are unlikely to end there. Uncertainty over future trade agreements with the EU and other countries could leave companies in the lurch and unsure how to prepare for the different possible outcomes of those trade agreements.
The other scenario, that Brexit is once again extended, would also mean continued uncertainty over the future. As BoE Governor Mark Carney pointed out earlier this month, this scenario could also lead to a rate cut.
The Bank of England is right to keep interest rates low, argues Artur Baluszynski, Head of Research at Henderson Rowe.
Even if we avoid a no-deal Brexit, the last three years have done enough damage to the UK economy to warrant a ‘lower for longer’ approach to interest rates.
With a short average fixed-term period on their mortgages, UK households are very sensitive to any hikes in interest rates so unless we experience a currency crisis, the Bank of England should continue to keep the ‘cost of money’ reasonably low.”
Here’s another chart from the Saunders speech, showing the drop in business investment since the Brexit vote:
Business investment in the U.K. and the G7 (ex UK), courtesy Michael Saunders @bankofengland pic.twitter.com/DBqkEHfoyH
— Jason Douglas (@wsj_douglasj) September 27, 2019
A no-deal Brexit could be very bad news for rural businesses, with fears that one in four could go bust.
Our environment correspondent Fiona Harvey explains:
Farmers are particularly vulnerable to a no-deal Brexit because tariffs would be levied on exports, imports of cheap food could flood the market, and because decisions must be made now which will have an impact for the next year. Arable farmers are putting crops in the ground now for spring, and livestock farmers are preparing to breed sheep and other livestock for next year.
Tim Breitmeyer, president of the Country Land and Business Association, said farms and the rural businesses that rely on them were not in a position to absorb the shock of Brexit, and estimates suggested a large number would be in danger.
FTSE 100 hits two-month high
To no-one’s surprise, the drop in sterling has pushed up the FTSE 100 index of blue-chip shares.
The Footsie has hit 7,420 points, up 70 points or 0.95% today, to its highest level since late July (just before its August plunge).
Mining companies are leading the rally, with Anglo American up 3%, and BHP Group gaining 2.5%. International packaging firms DS Smith and Smirfit Kappa are both up around 2.8%.
A weaker pound boosts the value of overseas earnings, so this is an obvious reaction to the pound’s drop.
Sebastien Clements, currency analyst at OFX, says Michael Saunders’ dovish speech has given the pound a jolt:
“Sterling had a rude awakening this morning, tumbling downwards after BoE member Saunders’ comments on the future of the British economy soured market sentiment.
“Saunders considers current monetary policy inadequate, and claims the BoE could conceivably cut rates, even if a no-deal Brexit is avoided.
“In a period of sustained market fickleness, we can expect the pound to reposition itself once further Brexit announcements are made.”
Michael Saunders is now taking questions from business people at the Barnsley & Rotherham Chamber of Commerce, having given his speech on the ‘shifting balance of risks’ created by Brexit uncertainty.
Saunders says he’s not a fan of negative interest rates, as they weaken the banking sector and threaten financial stability (Reuters reports).
He reckons the floor of UK interest rates is “close to zero”, but “marginally positive”. Bank rate is currently 0.75%, having hit a record low of 0.25% after the 2016 EU referendum.
He also says that the Bank could launch further asset purchases (ie, restart its QE programme), if rates hit rock bottom.
He also argues that the UK economy would be in its best position for several decades, if it wasn’t for Brexit uncertainty.
Bloomberg’s Lucy Meakin has more details:
“The economy has not crashed,” Saunders says. “But the effect of Brexit uncertainties is perhaps akin to the economy developing a slow puncture such that growth has slowed to a mere crawl.”
— Lucy Meakin (@lucy_meakin) September 27, 2019
Michael Saunders speech: snap reaction
Joumanna Bercetche of CNBC says this is the first time that the Bank of England has said explicitly that a Brexit extension beyond October 31 could prompt a rate cut.
Key line from Saunders :"prolonged high brexit uncertainty could warrant looser monetary policy if global growth is disappointing"
— Joumanna Bercetche (@CNBCJou) September 27, 2019
This is 1st time they suggest a rate CUT with ongoing brexit uncertainty (i.e: an extension)
Finally catching up with the interest rate market..
Joshua Mahony of IG points out that the Bank of England has shifted its position significantly -- a few months ago it was forecasting interest rates hikes.
So they went from 'rate hikes in any case post-Brexit', to 'rate cut in event of no-deal Brexit', and now 'Rate cut irrespective of the outcome'. The BoE switcheroo https://t.co/GGbP0YltYs
— Joshua Mahony (@JMahony_IG) September 27, 2019
Markets.com’s Neil Wilson says the BoE is catching up with investors...
Michael Saunders just saying what we know
— Neil Wilson (@marketsneil) September 27, 2019
BOE'S SAUNDERS: U.K. MAY NEED RATE CUTS EVEN WITH BREXIT DEAL
via @RedboxWire
Charts: Brexit uncertainty hurts economy
Michael Saunders has also provided two charts for his audience of business leaders in Barnsley, showing how the Brexit crisis is hurting the UK economy.
The first shows that more than 50% of firms say that Brexit is an important source of uncertainty for their business:
Saunders explains:
This index of Brexit uncertainty is close to the peaks seen around the turn of the year, just before the previous cliff edge, and is far above the levels seen in 2017 and most of 2018.
The high level of Brexit uncertainty is broadly based across industry sectors, reflecting the widespread impacts of Brexit across the economy.
The three sectors reporting the highest levels of uncertainty are wholesale and retail (the sector most reliant on EU imports), accommodation and food (largest user of EU migrant labour), and manufacturing (the biggest exporter to the EU)
This second chart shows that business fear Brexit uncertainty will linger for a long time, which is bad news as their firms are suffering:
Saunders explains:
There is extensive evidence that high uncertainty with downside risks is bad for economic growth. The key point is that for households and businesses, many major decisions (eg on investment, house purchase, hiring, R&D) are costly to reverse.
Hence, when uncertainty – and especially the scale of downside risks – is high, there is a clear incentive to defer such major decisions until the situation is clearer
Michael Saunders helpfully put the three key points from his speech at the top, presumably to make sure we didn’t miss them.
They are:
- With persistently high Brexit uncertainties and softer global growth, the UK economy has weakened markedly in recent quarters, opening up a modest amount of spare capacity.
- The economy could follow very different paths depending on Brexit developments. But in my view, even assuming that the UK avoids a no-deal Brexit, persistently high Brexit uncertainties seem likely to continue to depress UK growth below potential for some time, especially if global growth remains disappointing.
- In such a scenario – not a no-deal Brexit, but persistently high uncertainty – it probably will be appropriate to maintain an expansionary monetary policy stance and perhaps to loosen further. Of course, the monetary policy response to Brexit developments will also take into account other factors including, in particular, changes in the exchange rate and fiscal policy.
Pound hit by rate cut hint
The pound has fallen to a two-week low, following Michael Saunders’ rate cut hint.
Sterling has shed half a cent to $1.228, tumbling as soon as Saunders’ comments hit the wires.
Investors are concluding that the Bank of England has turned more dovish, and is preparing to slash borrowing costs back towards recent record lows.
Updated
BoE's Saunders: Brexit uncertainty may mean rate cut
Newsflash: Bank of England policymaker Michael Saunders has suggested that UK interest rates will be cut soon, due to Brexit uncertainty.
Speaking to local firms in Barnsley, Saunders says that confusion over Britain’s exit from the EU has hurt business confidence.
So, with the global economy weak, he argues there’s a significant chance that borrowing costs are cut.
Saunders, a member of the Monetary Policy Committee which sets rates, says:
If the UK avoids a no-deal Brexit, monetary policy also could go either way and I think it is quite plausible that the next move in Bank Rate would be down rather than up.
One scenario is that Brexit uncertainty falls significantly and global growth recovers a bit... In this case, some further monetary tightening (limited and gradual) is likely to be needed over time.
Another scenario, and this is perhaps more likely to me, is of prolonged high Brexit uncertainty (even without a no-deal Brexit actually occurring). In this case, it might well be appropriate to maintain a highly accommodative monetary policy stance for an extended period and perhaps to loosen policy at some stage, especially if global growth remains disappointing.
He also put this slide in his speech, showing how uncertainty drags on growth:
This is quite a dovish position from Saunders, especially as he was arguing in June that interest rates might rise sooner than expected....
More to follow....
Chipmaker Micron has added to the gloom, by issuing disappointing profit guidance last night.
It blamed trade war tensions, and weaknesses in the global economy.
Micron also warned that sanctions on China’s Huawei are hurting business.
“We have applied for licenses with the U.S. Department of Commerce that would allow us to ship additional products, but there have been no decisions on those licenses to date.”
Worries about China’s economy have knocked the oil price.
Brent crude has fallen nearly 1% today to $62.22 per barrel.
Most Asia-Pacific stock markets fell into the red today, with Japan down 1.1% and South Korea losing 1.3%.
The fall in Chinese factory profits was one factor, but there’s also plenty of political anxiety.
The impeachment probe into Donald Trump’s conversations with the president of Ukraine is a particular worry for the markets, especially after a leaked conversation showed the president comparing the whistle-blower to a spy.
Ipek Ozkardeskaya, senior market analyst at London Capital Group, says the markets are vulnerable to the next tweet from the White House.
The market’s destiny is at Donald Trump’s fingertips. A single tweet from Donald Trump could send equities rallying, as it could shatter the market sentiment. And Trump’s next move is anybody’s guess.
Jeffrey Halley of Oanda believes the inquiry will loom over us for a while:
“The impeachment of Trump will now become a drawn-out saga that feels like annoying supermarket music.”
Introduction: China's industrial profits take a tumble
Good morning, and welcome to our rolling coverage of the world economy, the financial markets, the eurozone and business.
It’s a worrying time for the markets, thanks to political dramas burning across the globe.
With an impeachment inquiry into Donald Trump, the deepening Brexit crisis, ongoing pro-democracy protests in Hong Kong, and no end to the US-China trade war, there’s plenty to concern investors.
Yesterday we saw four profit warnings from FTSE 100 firms, with IAG, Imperial Brands, Pearson and Carnival all admitting earnings are below forecasts.
And overnight, we’ve learned that earnings at China’s factories contracted in August.
Industrial profits fell 2% in August, year-on-year, to 517.8 billion yuan (£58.9 billion), the National Bureau of Statistics reports. That’s a blow, as profits had risen by 2.6% in July, and indicates that China’s factory sector is struggling under the weight of US tariffs.
NBS also reported that industrial profits in January-August have fallen 1.7% to just over 4 trillion yuan.
This comes a week after Chinese factory output growth hit a 17-year low, and fuels concerns that the global economy is weak.
Shane Oliver, chief economists at AMP Capital, tweets:
#China China Aug industrial profits -2%yoy, revenue +3.2%yoy
— Shane Oliver (@ShaneOliverAMP) September 27, 2019
Consistent with soft growth pic.twitter.com/PMeGCNpu9U
Faced with such a slowdown, Beijing may be forced into new stimulus measures to ward off a hard landing.
As Nomura analysts told clients today:
“Given strong growth headwinds and elevated U.S.-China trade tensions, we expect the economy to worsen before getting better and believe Beijing will likely ramp up its policy stimulus.”
Also coming up today
One of the Bank of England’s interest-rate setters, Michael Saunders, is giving a speech this morning.
We also get new consumer confidence data from the eurozone and America, plus fresh US durable goods orders.
The agenda
- 8am BST: Bank of England policymaker Michael Saunders speaks in Barnsley
- 10am BST: Eurozone confidence data
- 1.30pm BST: US durable goods orders for August
- 3pm BST: University of Michigan survey of US consumer sentiment
Updated