Graeme Wearden 

Mario Draghi’s ECB press conference after leaving rates on hold – as it happened

Rolling coverage as the European Central Bank leaves interest rates at record lows again
  
  

Watch the ECB’s press conference live

Summary: ECB gets ready for a summer break

That wasn’t the most dramatic or exciting press conference in the European Central Bank’s 18 year history.

Instead, there was a real end-of-term feeling, as Mario Draghi basically told reporters to come back in September and see if the ECB has decided to boost its stimulus programme.

Given some of the dramas we’ve seen in recent years, a dull ECB meeting should be welcomed (as long as it doesn’t become a habit, Mario). So what did we learn?

1) The ECB isn’t panicking about Brexit yet, although it believes it is a risk to the recovery.

Draghi struck a pretty reassuring tone, declaring that:

Following the UK referendum on EU membership, our assessment is that euro area financial markets have weathered the spike in uncertainty and volatility with encouraging resilience....

What is clear is that financial markets and the banking sector have reacted in a fairly resilient fashion to the event.We haven’t observed any disruption either in financial markets or the banking sector.”

2) Assessing the full impact of Brexit will take some time. That’s why the ECB didn’t launch any new stimulus measures today.

Over the coming months when we have more information including new staff projections we’ll be in a better position to assess the underlying macroeconomic conditions.

3) Draghi has given eurozone politicians a nudge to provide more financial support for the banking sector.

The most interesting part of the press conference, I think, was Draghi’s comments about the non-performing loans which bedevil Europe’s banks, notably in Italy. More than once he hinted that a public backstop is needed to help banks shift their non-performing loans.

Draghi warned that these NPLs are threatening the recovery:

“The longer we have this (non-performing loan problem) in place, the less functioning will be the banking system, or at least will be the banks with high NPLs.

And so the less capable will be these banks to transmit our monetary policy impulses to the real economy. Also, a high level of NPLs makes banks especially vulnerable to the markets.”

This chart shows that Southern European countries need help the most:

4) We might get fireworks in September.

Draghi insisted that the ECB has the “readiness, willingness and ability” to take fresh action, if needed, to stimulate the economy. By September, the ECB will have fresh economic forecasts - and a better idea of Britain’s Brexit plans.

5) QE might be tweaked soon.

Economists are pretty confident that the ECB needs to adjust the rules of its asset-purchase scheme, to allow it to buy more bonds from individual companies.

Draghi was adamant that the ECB won’t run out of things to buy, saying:

“In the past we’ve given enough evidence ... of our ability to adapt our purchases to reach 80 billion euros a month until March 2017 or beyond.”

That’s all for today. Thanks for reading and commenting. GW

Trevor Charsley of currency trading firm AFEX says Draghi’s comments show we’ve entered a ‘phoney war’ following the EU referendum.

“In commenting that there was no Brexit induced disruption apparent in the banking sector, Draghi was merely confirming that, after a knee jerk reaction in the markets immediately following the EU referendum, we have effectively entered a period of limbo or a ‘phoney war’ while we await more economic data, while political decisions are made and holidays taken.

This situation could last for several months, he adds:

As we receive the announcement of a plan from the UK government, a few months of post-Brexit economic data and a potential triggering of Article 50, the fog will begin to clear and we’ll see then how the central banks respond

Bank shares boosted by Draghi's comments

Mario Draghi’s call for a public backstop to help banks shed their bad loans has sparked a small rally in bank shares.

Reuters has the details:

Deutsche Bank shares, which opened flat, rose 3% following Draghi’s comments.

The FTSE Italian All Shares Banks index rose nearly 2%.

The broader euro zone banking index rose 1.7%.

Traders are calculating that Draghi’s intervention could help struggling eurozone banks to shift their bad loans, which are dragging them down and hurting confidence and profitability.

Ian Kernohan, Economist at Royal London Asset Management, is quick out of the traps with some reaction to the ECB’s meeting:

While we think Brexit uncertainty is mainly an issue for the UK economy, there is also bound to be some knock-on impact on the Eurozone. With post-Brexit evidence still patchy, we think the ECB will wait until the September meeting before extending its QE timetable.

Inflation remains far below the ECB’s target of 2% and while headline inflation will rise later in the year, thanks to the fading impact of a lower oil price, underlying inflationary pressures still remain very low. Delaying until September will allow an assessment of any Brexit impact to be outlined in the new ECB staff forecasts.

Final question....

Q: European bank shares are at record lows, so is there a fundamental lack of confidence in the eurozone banking sector?

Draghi says that the problem is about the future profitability of banks, not their solvency. That’s partly due to concerns about non-performing loans (which is why Draghi is pushing for a new market for them to be traded).

But he is confident that this situation, and the perception in the rest of the world’s eyes, can be improved.

And that’s it

Now we’re DEEP into conspiracy territory...

Q: Your son is a bond dealer in London, Mr Draghi, so isn’t that a conflict of interest?

Draghi says that he explained five year ago that his son was a trader, not a bond dealer, so there is no conflict of interest. The European Parliament agreed at the time.

OK, we’re wandering into conspiracy territory now, with a journalist asking Draghi if the ECB is committed to using notes and coins as sole legal tender.

Yes. Of course. There is, says Draghi, looking a little puzzled.

Q: So why did you bury the €500 note?

We didn’t bury it, Draghi says. We decided to stop printing it from 2018 to stop it being used by criminals.

Draghi: Public backstop for NPLs would be very useful

Q: Could you elaborate on your comments that a public backstop is needed for banks with non-performing loans?

Draghi says that such a backstop would be “very useful”, but it should be agreed with the Commission.

The bad debts in Italy’s banking sector are a “very big problem” and it will take time to address them - as it has taken time in other countries, Draghi continues.

But the situation needs to be tackled, as:

The longer we have this in place, the less functioning will be the banking sector - and less effective the banks will be at transmitting our monetary policy.

The idea of a public backstop is likely to go down badly in Germany, which doesn’t like to see taxpayers on the hook for bank losses.

Draghi is asked about the ECB’s presence in the “troika” which oversees eurozone bailouts.

He says it’s not his decision; it’s due to legislation passed by the European Parliament which wanted its expertise involved. The eurozone now has more expertise, but MEPs would have to pass new legislation if they want to get the ECB out of the Troika.

Francesco Papadia, a former senior ECB policymaker, reckons Draghi wants out:

Q: What impact will the political crisis in Turkey have on the eurozone recovery?

It’s very difficult to understand how these big geo-political issues will affect the economy, Draghi replies. It’s not obvious how they would be channeled into the euro economy.

At least with Brexit you have the trade channel - although that may not be the best thing to look at.

With Turkey, it’s hard to see an immediate near-term hit to the euro recovery, he concludes, although it is likely to hurt confidence.

Updated

Q: What message would you like to hear from G20 finance ministers and central bankers when they meet in Shanghai later this week?

We need to hear a message of stability, Draghi replies. Banks and financial institutions are much stronger than before the last financial crisis.

The euro has jumped by half a cent as investors react to Mario Draghi’s straight bat to all tantalising questions about future stimulus plans.

Hmmmm this might be interesting. Draghi has dangled the idea that governments should step in, if needed, to protect a bank that needs to sell non-performing loans.

This would avoid the risk of “firesales”, in which a bank is forced to sell assets at a big loss.

That’s pertinent in Draghi’s homeland of Italy right now, as the government tries to find a way to strengthen its banks without breaching EU rules.

Q: How much damage will Brexit do to eurozone growth? Does Draghi believe that estimates of 0.2%-0.5% knocked off the growth rate are accurate?

We should take such estimates with a grain of caution, the ECB president replies. It is too early to see the financial impact, and we needs to wait and see the eventual outcome of the vote.

Draghi then repeats that eurozone markets have been “fairly resilient” since the vote on June 23.

We haven’t seen any disruption in the banking sector or the financial sector, he says, which is testament to the contingency measures drawn up by policymakers and the large amounts of liquidity available.

Europe’s banks are in better shape than in 2009, Draghi declares, partly thanks to the ECB’s efforts to strengthen the sector and boost solvency.

He then embarks on a long explanation about the need to tackle non-performing loans (NPLs) to improve bank profitability.

Important stuff, but not the fireworks we might have hoped for:

Updated

Twenty minutes into this press conference, and there’s no sign that Draghi is going to pull a rabbit out of his hat.

It appears that the ECB wants everyone to go away and come back in September.

Q: Could the ECB have already done enough to stimulate the economy and support inflation expectations?

Draghi says there is a difference between public surveys of inflation expectations, and the market-based expectations.

Surveys of professional forecasts show that inflation will increase....close to the ECB’s targets in the medium term, but market expectations suggest investors are rather more pessimistic.

And he repeats that the governing council believes it is too early to agree new measures at today’s meeting.

However, he insists that the ECB has the readyness, willingness, and ability to act, if needed.

Updated

Onto questions:

Q: Did the ECB consider changing the terms of its asset-purchase scheme, to avoid it running out of government bonds to buy?

Draghi repeats that the ECB believes it is too early to assess the need for fresh measures, so it will consider the situation at its next meeting in September.

There wasn’t any real discussion about the details of such changes, he adds.

As usual, Draghi is urging eurozone politicians to step up the pace of structural reforms, to improve their business environment.

He suggests that governments could boost infrastructure projects, to increase employment and investment.

Fiscal policies should also support the recovery, he adds -- a hint to governments to spend more (without breaching eurozone deficit rules).

All countries should strive for a more “growth-friendly” mix of fiscal policies, Draghi concludes (a message we have heard several times...)

Draghi: Risks still tilted to the downside

The eurozone recovery faces several headwinds, and the risks remain tilted to the downside, says Draghi.

He cites the UK referendum, slowing emerging markets and the slow pace of structural reforms as key threats to the recovery.

Draghi says the eurozone recovery is continuing at a moderate pace, but will have slowed in the second quarter compared to the first three months of the year.

Draghi: Markets have handled Brexit shock well

President Draghi begins by confirming that the governing council left the key interest rates unchanged, and expects them to stay at present or lower levels for some time.

He confirms that the ECB plans to run its asset purchase scheme at €80bn per month until at least March 2017, or longer if needed to bring inflation back to target.

Then he turns to Brexit, saying markets have coped relatively well:

Following the UK referendum, euro area financial markets have weathered the spike in volatility with encouraging resilience.

But given the uncertainties, the ECB will monitor market developments closely.

And Draghi then drops a clear hint that he could announce new stimulus measures soon, declaring:

If warranted.... the governing council will act by using all the instruments available under its mandate.

Updated

Mario Draghi has arrived in the press conference room in Frankfurt, and is posing for a few photos with colleagues.

And we’re off......

Watch Mario Draghi here

Here’s a live feed of Mario Draghi’s press conference, which starts in 5 minutes (I’ll try to embed it at the top of this blog too)

The ECB’s press conference

Naeem Aslam of City firm Think Markets says the ECB was right to leave interest rates unchanged today while it gauges the impact of the Brexit vote:

There was no smoke from the ECB’s gun as the bank has decided to hold its fire as expected. Perhaps, it was the best move because the bank certainly wants to assess the consequences of Brexit which has triggered the need for more QE and dragged the bond yields in negative territory.

Aslam also warns that the markets could slide if central banks don’t deliver the stimulus which investors expect:

The market is addicted to this medicine and most of the boom which we have experienced in the equity market is based on the basis of this cheap funding.

If these liquidity tanks start to run dry, we may start to see the heavy sell off which many have been waiting for....

More reaction:

Here’s some instant reaction to the ECB’s announcement, and predictions about what we might hear from Mario Draghi in 30 minutes:

The ECB statement in full

The European Central Bank has declared that it expects interest rates to remain at their current record lows, or lower, for a long time.

It has also confirmed that its quantitative easing bond-buying programme will run until at least next March.

That’s not a change of policy – however, it’s unusual to see it spelled out explicitly in the monetary policy announcement. We don’t normally get quite as much information at 12.45pm.

Here’s the full statement from Frankfurt:

At today’s meeting the Governing Council of the ECB decided that the interest rate on the main refinancing operations and the interest rates on the marginal lending facility and the deposit facility will remain unchanged at 0.00%, 0.25% and -0.40% respectively. The Governing Council continues to expect the key ECB interest rates to remain at present or lower levels for an extended period of time, and well past the horizon of the net asset purchases.

Regarding non-standard monetary policy measures, the Governing Council confirms that the monthly asset purchases of €80 billion are intended to run until the end of March 2017, or beyond, if necessary, and in any case until it sees a sustained adjustment in the path of inflation consistent with its inflation aim.

The President of the ECB will comment on the considerations underlying these decisions at a press conference starting at 14:30 CET today.

Updated

ECB leaves interest rates on hold

Newsflash: The European Central Bank has left interest rates unchanged across the eurozone.

Despite the uncertainty created by Britain’s EU referendum, the governing council has decided not to take any immediate steps.

That means the headline rate remains at zero, while banks will continue to be charged 0.4% for leaving money in the ECB’s vaults.

Analysts look for September stimulus

Danae Kyriakopoulou of the Centre for Economics and Business Research predicts that Mario Draghi will hint at another stimulus boost after the summer hols.

If that happens, then the euro might spike in 15 minutes, and then dip once Draghi’s press conference begin.

There are just 30 minutes to go, until the ECB announces its monetary policy decision.

Reminder, economists are currently expecting no change to the current rates, which are:

  • Headline interest rate: 0.0%
  • The deposit rate (paid by commercial banks who leave money at the ECB): - 0.4%
  • The marginal lending facility (charged to banks who borrow from the ECB): +0.25%.

Nordea Markets analyst Aurelija Augulyte points out that a surprise can’t be ruled out.....

Updated

Investors have paid to lend money to Spain for the next three years, for the first time ever:

It’s a sign of the nervousness in the markets, with investors keen to put money into safe-haven government debt.

It’s also a consequences of Mario Draghi’s bond-buying programme, which has helped drive down bond yields to record lows. Whoever bought these bonds could theoretically sell them onto the ECB at a profit (the lower-threshold for bond purchases is -0.4% yield).

There’s more on the ECB’s agenda than Britain’s EU referendum, says FXTM Research Analyst Lukman Otunuga:

Although Brexit remains the biggest risk threatening Eurozone’s recovery, there are more challenges to be addressed when the central bank meets later today, such as the troubled Italian banks and the plunging yields on governments’ debt which makes it difficult for the ECB to pursue its €80 billion monthly debt purchases without amending the terms of their program.

He also expects no fresh action today, especially as the ECB has already boosted its stimulus programme once this year. That will leave the scene clear for Mario Draghi’s press conference:

Mr. Draghi’s only tool is likely to be his dovish words on opening the door for further easing if economic conditions deteriorate.

Updated

European stock markets have all lost ground this morning, as investors wait to hear from ECB president Mario Draghi.

The main indices are down around 0.5%:

City investors expect reassuring words from Draghi at his press conference, at 1.30pm BST.

Chris Beauchamp of IG explains:

The relatively shallow pullback seen in eurozone markets this morning would seem to indicate a calm atmosphere – given the myriad problems facing the eurozone, and indeed the UK and EU, it seems highly likely that Mario Draghi will seek to soothe frayed nerves with a generally dovish statement.

Updated

More from Jack Lew in Athens:

From Brexit to Grexit...

Over in Athens, US Treasury secretary Jack Lew has urged the Greek government to stick with its bailout plan.

Lew says Greece needs to deliver the privatisation plans and economic reforms agreed with its creditors, so it can unlock the next loan tranche this autumn.

Sounding like a man who doesn’t fancy another Greek bailout crisis, Lew declared:

“Putting Greece’s debt on a sustainable path is critical to Greece’s long-term economic health and I encourage all parties to be flexible to successfully conclude this fall’s negotiations.”

Peter Rosenstreich, head of market strategy, Swissquote Bank, also predicts that the European Central Bank will leave its powder dry today.

He expects monetary policy will be unchanged, while president Mario Draghi will probably hint at stimulus measures later this year:

With the true extent of the Brexit effect still unclear, and the Euro on the weaker side (due to renewed expectations for a September Fed rate hike), the central bank is under no real pressure to act. Draghi will therefore most likely adopt a wait-and-see approach.

We expect the meeting and press conference to contain warnings that economic downside risks have grown and that the bank remains ready to ease monetary policy further, if necessary.

The Economist Intelligence Unit concurs:

Hammond welcomes borrowing figures

Britain’s new chancellor, Philip Hammond, has welcomed the £2.2bn drop in UK public borrowing last month:

“These public finance figures highlight the underlying strength of the British economy. Ahead of the referendum monthly borrowing continued to fall, with the deficit in June the lowest it has been since 2007.

“As our economy now adjusts to reflect the referendum decision it is clear we will do so from a position of economic strength.”

This chart shows how Britain is expecting to borrow around £55bn in the 2016-17 financial year, although the Brexit vote could shake that plan....

Updated

Analyst: ECB may have to tweak its QE programme

Here’s a great preview of today’s European Central Bank meeting, from Ipek Ozkardeskaya of London Capital Group.

The European Central Bank (ECB) delivers its first monetary policy verdict after the UK’s decision to leave the European Union. At his press conference, the ECB’s President Mario Draghi is expected to comment on Brexit, on low-to-negative sovereign rates in the Eurozone as a result of an out-of-control appetite post-Brexit and the crisis in the Italian banking sector.

The ECB is expected to maintain the status quo at today’s meeting. September’s meeting could signal more monetary stimulus, according to consensus. Not the size but rather duration of the ECB’s Quantitative Easing (QE) programme, as well as the composition of its portfolio are expected to be the major talking points.

The ECB is currently buying €80bn of government and corporate bonds each month. As mentioned earlier, it could run out of things to buy, having pushed up prices and absorbed so much debt already.

Ipek says liquidity in eligible bonds in the Eurozone sovereign complex is “dangerously drying up”.

As of today, $3.2 trillion worth of Eurozone bonds are yielding below zero; 60% of eligible German bond yields are below the ECB’s deposit rate of -0.40%, which is also defined as the lower limit for the ECB purchases. Digging a bit deeper, the abnormally low sovereign rates could, according to many, push the ECB towards the limits of its bond buying programme sooner rather than later.

This gif shows how many eurozone bonds are now priced outside the ECB’s remit (because their prices are so high, pushing the interest rate on the bonds deep into negative territory)

Updated

We also have new UK government borrowing figures.....which show that Britain borrowed £7.8bn to balance the books in June.

That’s £2.2bn less than in June 2015, and the smallest figures for any June since 2007 (just before the credit crunch struck).

UK retail sales fall by 0.9%

Breaking: UK retail sales have fallen at their fastest pace since last December.

Bad weather, rather than Brexit, appears to be to blame.

The volume of stuff bought in the shops fell by 0.9% in June, the Office for National Statistics reports, worse than the 0.6% drop which economists expected.

The amount of stuff bought from retailers also fell by 0.9%.

It’s mainly due to another fall in clothing sales, as bad weather in June deterred shoppers from buying new outfits.

The ONS also flags up that retail prices have kept falling over the last year, helping to keep inflation close to zero:

  • all store types except textile, clothing and footwear stores showed increases in the quantity bought compared with June 2015
  • all store types saw falls in average store price compared with June 2015; the largest fall was shown in petrol stations.

It says that retailers didn’t report any anecdotal evidence that the Brexit vote had hurt spending. But these figure are weaker than expected, so....

The Daily Mail was a big supporter of the Brexit campaign.

But now that the victory is in the bag, its parent company says it’s suffering as nervous advertisers wonder what the future holds:

Budget airline easyJet has spooked the travel sector with a gloomy financial update and a warning that the Brexit vote will hurt demand.

Shares in easyJet have slid by 4.4% this morning, to the bottom of the FTSE 100, after it posted a 2.6% drop in sales in the last three months. It blamed poor weather and air traffic control strikes.

CEO Carolyn McCall warned that this summer could be challenging, as the recent fall in sterling makes it more expensive for Brits to holiday abroad. She also cited last week’s failed Turkish coup and the latest French terror attacks:

Currency volatility as a result of the U.K.’s referendum decision to leave the EU as well as the recent events in Turkey and Nice continue to impact consumer confidence.”

Anthony Cheung of Amplify Trading flags up the key issues on the ECB’s agenda today:

The third point is important – basically, the ECB is running short of some government bonds to buy, having mopped up so many already.

German bunds is in particularly short supply, due to the current limits which prevent the ECB buying more than 33% of a country’s debt.

Naeem Aslam of ThinkMarkets UK explains why a change may be needed:

The Bundesbank needs to purchase 253 billion euros of debt by the end of this month, but due to the present issuer limit of 33%, the world of eligible assets stand at 216 billion euros.

It will be a big surprise if the ECB launches new stimulus measures today, rather than waiting until its next meeting in September:

The boss of William Hill has been abruptly dismounted from his position at the bookmaker.

CEO James Henderson’s unexpected departurture was announced to the City this morning.

He has paid the price for its disappointing online performance, which has hit profits recently. It’s a glum end to his 31-year career at the bookmaker.

Danske Bank: ECB will launch stimulus in September

Analysts at Danske Bank also predict that the ECB will resist the temptation to launch new stimulus measures today.

They predict that it will boost its bond-buying QE programme in September, when they’ll have new forecasts and a better picture of the Brexit impact.

Brexit is a double whammy for the European Central Bank.

As well as generating economic uncertainty, it could create more political instability in the eurozone.

Florian Hense, economist at German bank Berenberg, explains why it’s a difficult time for the ECB:

Political risks loom unusually large, and the British vote on exiting the EU exemplifies the danger which the surge in anti-establishment sentiment presents.

Investment could contract, while private consumption growth will slow. Recent attacks in Nice and the attempted coup d’etat in Turkey could further weigh on confidence.

Hense expects that the ECB will leave monetary policy unchanged today.

The press pack are already gathering in Frankfurt, where Bloomberg’s inflatable euro looks like it needs a holiday:

The agenda: ECB to discuss Brexit and Italian banks

Good morning, and welcome to our rolling coverage of the world economy, the financial markets, the eurozone and business.

It’s ECB Day! Investors around the world are looking to Frankfurt as the European Central Bank meets to set monetary policy, and discuss the latest political and economic crises on its patch, and beyond.

This is the first ECB meeting since Britain voted to leave the European Union, so the governing council must consider how to protect the eurozone economy from the Brexit fallout.

It’s probably too early for them to cut interest rates, or to boost the existing stimulus programme.

But Mario Draghi’s comments at this afternoon’s press conference should give insights into the ECB’s plans to avoid Europe’s recovery being derailed.

Mike van Dulken of Accendo Markets reckons Draghi will take his cue from the Bank of England, which left interest rates on hold last week:

Today’s focus will be the European Central Bank’s (ECB) latest monetary policy update from which no change is anticipated but any hints/forward guidance will be much appreciated by markets regarding further stimulus being required in light of the UK’s Brexit vote.

With the BoE having held off this month saying it was too early to react to Brexit, its continental peer may well strike a similar tone today.

Here’s the key timings:

  • ECB interest rate/stimulus decision: 12.45pm BST (1.45pm Frankfurt)
  • President Mario Draghi’s press conference: 1.30pm BST (2.30pm Frankfurt)

Policymakers also need to talk about Italy’s banks, as the struggle to bail out Monte dei Paschi di Siena continues.

Prime minister Matteo Renzi is still trying to find a way to pump money into Italy’s third-largest lender, without breaching EU rules blocking state aid.

According to the Financial Times today, Renzi has a cunning plan...

Rather than inject state money directly into Monte Paschi as originally planned, Italy is exploring ways to buyout its bad loans at favourable rates with money from private and state-backed institutions. This would use the existing privately backed fund, called Atlante, and would not need preapproval from Brussels.

The terms of any intervention, however, would be closely watched by Brussels to ensure it involves no hidden state support

More here: Italy eyes private deal to bail out bank

Draghi is a former Bank of Italy governor, so his views on this innovative scheme could be interesting...

Meanwhile in the UK, we get the latest retail sales figures at 9.30am. They’ll show if consumer spending took a hit from Brexit uncertainty in June.

Yesterday, the Bank of England reported that the economy doesn’t appear to have suffered a slowdown since last month’s vote.

On the corporate front, we’re getting results from drinks chains SAB Miller and Britvic, media group Daily Mail and General Trust, consumer group Unilever, budget airline easyJet, and online white goods group AO World.

And Europe’s financial markets are likely to remain calm, at least until Mario takes his seat....

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*