Mark Sweney 

British Gas rapped for price claims

8am: Scottish Power has won a battle against British Gas over a television campaign that stated that changing providers would not result in a decrease in prices. By Mark Sweney.
  
  


Scottish Power has won its battle against British Gas over a television campaign that stated that changing providers would not result in a decrease in prices.

The Advertising Standards Authority ruled that the TV campaign for British Gas and its subsidiary Scottish Gas was misleading and must not be shown again in that form, following a complaint by rival supplier Scottish Power.

British Gas claimed in the ads there was no point customers changing supplier as competitors were likely to follow suit in raising prices and that bills would be "balanced out".

Scottish Power disputed this phrase and the implication that there were no price difference benefits to be had by switching supplier.

Ads that ran in Scotland also used an animated pair of evenly balanced scales to drive home the point.

Scottish Power argued that British Gas had raised energy prices by 14%, while it had raised its electricity tariffs by up to 8% and gas by 12% from prices that were already lower to start with.

One Scottish Gas ad featured an animated character called Archie saying: "Last year I heard that prices were going up. In fact I read it in the local press. And I thought well, if we change, the other provider might change and put theirs up as well. So we just sat tight. The other provider did put their prices up and I believe it's all balanced out."

British Gas supplied figures to back up their claim. The ASA checked these against figures supplied by Energywatch, the independent watchdog for gas and electricity customers, which showed that dual-fuel customers very often paid more taking their energy from British Gas or Scottish Gas than with competitors.

Other ads in the British Gas campaign were worded similarly but did not use the animated weighing scales.

· To contact the MediaGuardian newsdesk email editor@mediatheguardian.com or phone 020 7239 9857

· If you are writing a comment for publication, please mark clearly "for publication".

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*