Charles Allen 

We all make the best of limited budgets. Why shouldn’t the BBC?

ITV boss Charles Allen supports the licence fee, but says the 40 per cent rise the corporation asked for is just brass neck.
  
  


Unlike the BBC, ITV is a commercial company, constantly looking at where we focus our efforts and where we invest our shareholders' money. We know that funds are not limitless, so spending money in one area inevitably means spending less in another.

We should not complain: knowing that the taxpayer or shareholder won't automatically write out cheques focuses the mind. That discipline is the spur for innovation and efficiency.

But the BBC remains an institution where the language of priorities is yet to be understood, at least at the top. It is cut off from the disciplines of the market and the accountability of public spending.

Now that the white paper on the BBC has been published, attention has moved to the funding settlement. The BBC is asking for an inflation-busting 40 per cent rise in the licence fee over just seven years - an extra £6bn. What would that mean? Ten years ago the BBC's licence fee income was roughly equivalent to ITV1's advertising revenue; today it is almost twice the size. On its own numbers, by the end of the funding period the BBC's income would outstrip not just ITV's income but total TV advertising.

ITV strongly supports a licence-fee funded BBC. The genius of UK public service broadcasting (PSB) has been that the main broadcasters have competed on quality for audience, not for revenue. So while it may be in our interest for the BBC to continue to be funded out of the licence fee, this is also in the viewer's interest: a licence-fee funded BBC can focus on its PSB role and allow its commercial PSB competitors, ITV and Channel 4, maximum scope to sustain their own important PSB contribution.

But, as the Lords committee recently concluded, supporting the licence fee and supporting the BBC's licence fee pitch are two very different things. A rise in licence fee funding anywhere near the level proposed by the BBC would have severe consequences for competition between public service broadcasters. It's no wonder that ISBA, the advertising trade body, is up in arms about the BBC's pitch. It has the potential to fundamentally alter the carefully balanced ecology of British broadcasting.

The enormous rise in the BBC's income would make it nearly impossible for commercial public service broadcasters to maintain their position in the market, sustain their investment in programming and develop services to deliver content and generate new revenue streams. While we are ready to step up to the increasing commercial challenges we face, we should not have to face unfair competition from a super-funded BBC. And the loser in all this would be the viewer.

The BBC wants an additional £1.6bn to put into improving its content, even though it already spends significantly more than its PSB competitors. And it wants £1.2bn for digital services, an area where it already spends well over £300m a year. These represent exactly the kinds of areas where exciting commercial opportunities could be crowded out by what looks like a concerted publicly funded land grab.

Take the BBC's interactive Media Player, which has so far only been trialled. It has had no public value test. There has been no market impact test. No approvals process by the board, the trust, Ofcom or the Secretary of State. But the BBC is seeking to bill us for it anyway.

What is absent from the BBC's approach is any sense that if it starts entering expensive new territory with new products and services, it might want to consider reining back on its activities elsewhere. It is as if it has not occurred to it that - like the rest of us - it should have to prioritise. In the world of the BBC, it seems, you can have it all.

Faced with the sheer brass neck of the BBC's funding pitch, how should government react? Well, first it should demand more detail. If the BBC isn't prepared to justify its pitch, it deserves short shrift. Second, there needs to be public scrutiny of the figures. The public deserves real accountability.

Finally, government should consider a funding settlement that takes the BBC at its word. The BBC's fag packet calculations include claimed savings of nearly £4bn over the funding period. What this should mean is that the BBC's licence fee income can go down by £4bn over the period while preserving the corporation's spending power in real terms. After all, this is how the rest of the public service operates, with local government, schools and hospitals making the best use of limited resources. Why should the BBC be any different?

· Charles Allen is chief executive of ITV.

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*