The G8's commitment of $50bn (£29bn) of additional aid at Gleneagles last July re-engaged the aid debate. Half of this pledge will be directed towards Africa, doubling the amount that the continent currently receives. But is increased aid alone really going to bring about equitable and sustainable development? And, if aid budgets are to be increased, how should we best direct them?
In the last 40 years, the west has spent $450bn on foreign aid to Africa. However, experience and research shows that aid has often failed to achieve many of its objectives. Aid campaigners frequently overstate the effectiveness of aid and underestimate its harmful effects. Programmes are often badly designed and not tailored towards individual recipients. At the macro-level, aid can encourage a cycle of dependency on the west, preventing governments from promoting self-sustaining practices, and can inflate real exchange rates, undermining competitiveness and crowding out export industries. Furthermore, the publicity of massive aid efforts enhances the perception that Africa cannot help itself. Most commentators now accept that aid is not enough.
Aid does not offer long-term solutions but investment, and specifically investment in private sector enterprises, does. The creation of wealth is the only long-term antidote to poverty, and it is only business that is able to generate that wealth. We need only look at the recent histories of Ghana and South Korea. In the 1960s, South Korea was among the least developed countries in the world, and at a similar stage to Ghana. In fact, Ghana's rich and abundant natural resources, efficient civil service and well-structured education system was seen as the more viable economy. Today, South Korea is the 13th largest economy in the world with a GNI per capita of $14,000; Ghana's is $380.
So how did the paths of development differ so dramatically between these two countries? Initially, South Korea introduced agrarian reforms to ensure the population had enough to eat and then embarked on a steady phase of private sector investment in export-led industrialisation, through steel, shipping, electronics, and ICT. Earlier this month, Ghana's minister for foreign affairs stressed that, in order to fuel development, Ghana should emulate the rapid advancement of South Korea, especially in the field of technology. The real lesson here is that development requires more than aid. Growth worked for the poor.
Uganda, Tanzania, Mozambique, Bangladesh and Sri Lanka are all good examples of countries that have raised their growth rates whilst achieving progress towards the millennium development goals. Making profits in developing countries should not be addressed with scorn. By generating wealth, we can attack poverty. Yes, the rich get richer but the poor also get richer.
International businesses operating in developing countries expand and professionalise the supply chain, benefiting small, local entrepreneurs, transfer skills through social and economic training and generate jobs. It is estimated that more than four jobs are created for each one in the international business. And nationally owned businesses can have similar effects. As Hilary Benn has said recently, "Ask poor people where the best prospect for escaping poverty lies - they'll tell you it is through self-employment or business - a good job". It does not matter who provides that job, whether it be an internationally owned or a locally owned business.
The New Economics Foundation is correct to point out that growth needs to be sustainable and equitable. Private sector investment should never proceed without these aims. In the investment industry, our fund managers share valuable skills and experience in management and corporate governance. Such skills are vital to professionalise the private sector, and sets demands in environmental and social sustainability from African business.
In order to stimulate growth, we need to create the right conditions for the private sector to invest and do business. A key area is infrastructure. If Africa grows at 7% per annum - the rate necessary to meet the millennium development goals - it will need approximately 36,000MW of extra power capacity. That is 80 medium-sized power stations, which would cost approximately $30bn in the next four years. Infrastructure is a bilateral benefit: good for individuals and good for business. CDC's investment in the Maputo Corridor toll road in Mozambique has brought considerable benefits to the region; fruit exporters in Limpopo estimate savings of 33% in transportation costs and local communities have benefited from employment opportunities, community participation programmes and support for SMEs.
Many African businesses are hampered by being uncompetitive in the global market place as a result of over burdensome and inefficient government bureaucratic processes and the lack of well trained staff. These are all areas where aid can be very effectively deployed. According to the World Bank "Doing Business" report, sub-Saharan Africa is the most difficult place to do business when it comes to red tape. By directing aid to alleviate regulatory obstacles, ease of starting a business and getting credit, private sector investment would be able to facilitate economic growth more easily. More aid-financed business training is also vital. DfID's African Enterprise Challenge Fund and the Investment Climate Facility are both working to boost private enterprise in Africa.
There is clearly a vital role for aid in short-term emergencies but aid alone cannot make poverty history and can even do harm. By ignoring job creation and growth and showing hostility to private enterprise, aid campaigners are failing the interests of the poor. Despite increases last year, our aid budget is not finite. Exactly how we spend the aid "cake" is not an easy debate and will undoubtedly entail hard, courageous and unpopular choices. But more aid needs to be directed towards programmes to encourage and catalyse business growth and that may mean that the more "traditional" aid programmes have to be reduced. We need to encourage more debate on how aid is spent and developing aid programmes that are business friendly. By stimulating business, we will stimulate long-term human development.
· Richard Laing is chief executive of CDC, a government-owned fund of funds business with assets of £1.5bn focusing on developing countries. It has committed capital to 49 funds in Africa, Asia and Latin America