John Hooper in Rome 

Mystery after dark in WPP’s Italian job

Even aristocratic sleuth Lord Peter Wimsey would be hard pressed to disentangle truth from fiction in the bizarre wrangle between Sir Martin Sorrell and Marco Benatti, who for more than three years represented the Italian interests of WPP. By John Hooper.
  
  


It was shortly after one o'clock in the morning - not a time you would expect to detect much activity, even in the offices of a global conglomerate. But on January 15, at the Italian headquarters of WPP in Via Carducci, near La Scala opera house in Milan, there was plenty.

Police were advancing on the fifth floor. According to a detailed but unsourced account in yesterday's Corriere della Sera newspaper, the officers drew their guns after seeing torchlight in the building.

It could almost be a scene from Dorothy Sayers's 1933 classic, Murder Must Advertise. But even the aristocratic sleuth Lord Peter Wimsey would be hard pressed to disentangle truth from fiction in the bizarre wrangle between Sir Martin Sorrell, WPP's chief executive, and Marco Benatti, who for more than three years represented the interests in Italy of the world's second-largest advertising group.

Mr Benatti, whose offices were on the fifth floor of WPP Italy's headquarters, was fired as its country manager on January 9. In the latest development, the Guardian learnt last night that his lawyers were putting the final touches to a wrongful dismissal claim.

Sir Martin has, meanwhile, ordered a wide-ranging investigation, which informed sources say has uncovered alleged serious irregularities in the way WPP's Italian arm did business. This inevitably raises the question of why they escaped the notice of Sir Martin, a boss famed for his grasp of detail.

Those close to him say the decision to investigate was not an easy one. But they add that he made it as proof of a determination to root out any questionable dealing in his sprawling empire.

They claim that Mr Benatti had abused an arrangement whereby he introduced the group to potential acquisition targets in Italy, in return for a commission of 1% of the eventual price. It is alleged that, unknown to WPP, he was a majority shareholder in one such firm called Mediaclub. Mr Benatti's camp denies this, saying he was merely a shareholder in a fund that had a stake - never exceeding 10% - in Mediaclub. The firm was acquired in an "earnout" deal, with payments made in stages as the true value of the company emerged. Sources close to WPP say Mr Benatti's interest came to light after the final instalment fell due and he insisted that WPP - whose auditors had costed the remaining payment at only €300,000 (£206,000) - should hand over €8.9m.

Mr Benatti, on the other hand, argues that the break was down to personal differences involving the pivotal figure of Daniela Weber. The 43-year-old Swiss-born Ms Weber began her career as Mr Benatti's personal assistant long before his involvement with WPP. Last month, the Italian advertising mogul described her as a "pupil and assistant for 23 years" who became a "capable and highly regarded colleague". Indeed, Ms Weber is now WPP Italy's chief operating officer. But if there is one thing on which there is agreement in this strange affair, it is that Ms Weber is now firmly aligned with Sir Martin.

She could play a key role in the weeks ahead as one of WPP's representatives on the board of Fullsix, a company Mr Benatti is bidding to take over. The British-based conglomerate has a 26% stake. But WPP is thought unlikely to fight for Fullsix, and sources say it intends instead to pursue Mr Benatti through the courts. It has hired three teams of lawyers and the detective agency Kroll to investigate what has been going on in its Italian subsidiary. Serious accusations have already been levelled.

A spokesman for WPP Italy said this week that when the police summoned to its headquarters in Milan last month reached the fifth floor they found - not a cat burglar - but "the odd and unexpected presence of [guards from the security firm] Mondialpol".

According to WPP Italy, Mondialpol had been charged with protecting its headquarters, but had been told to suspend its activities two days before the break-in.

The spokesman added: "Mr Benatti should clarify and explain the relationship and links he has and has had in the past with Mr Claudio Noziglia, today in charge of Mondialpol."

The implication was clear. But both the implication and the facts behind it are contested by the security firm. Mondialpol's managing director, Fabio Mura, told the Guardian yesterday that Mr Noziglia was head of an investment company with a stake in Mondialpol, but had "nothing to do with management". Moreover, Mondialpol's contract with WPP, dated November 1, 2002, had "never been rescinded".

Mr Mura said that it required his firm to maintain an alarm system at the multinational's Italian headquarters and that, if any went off, his guards investigated the suspected intrusion. But on January 13, his firm had received a fax from WPP telling it to deactivate the alarms in the building because people would be working there over the weekend.

The instructions were to reactivate them at 1am on January 15. And that is why his men were in the building when the police burst in, guns in hand.

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*