Cosima Marriner 

Coming up after this shorter break …

It's risky and expensive but Capital FM put its ad-lite plan on the airwaves. By Cosima Marriner.
  
  


When Daily Mail and General Trust (DMGT) launched a new radio station in the competitive Sydney market promising "no more than two ads in a row" in 2001, it was not only the local players who sat up and took notice.

In London, GCap Media boss Ralph Bernard - then in charge of GWR - was also paying close attention to how the fledgling station, called Nova, fared with its novel strategy. And when Nova knocked the market leader, Austereo, off its number one perch, Mr Bernard was even more intrigued. He toyed with introducing a similar concept in Britain, possibly piloting it in Leicester.

But it was not until six weeks ago, when Rajar figures revealed that GCap's flagship London station Capital had slumped to third place in the ratings, that Mr Bernard made up his mind. With Capital's audience half that of four years ago, it was clear the station could no longer justify the premium it had been charging advertisers. Rather than cut Capital's ad rates, Mr Bernard decided to follow DMGT's lead and and halve the amount of advertising played instead.

"The premium value of Capital's inventory was massively under threat and we had to do something to protect it," GCap operations director Steve Orchard said. GCap hopes Capital's promise of "never more than two ads in a row" which went on air yesterday will also woo back listeners from the commercial-free BBC. Rather than charge advertisers more for the fewer ad spots, it is relying on audience growth to boost revenues.

But analysts warn that simply slashing advertising will not bolster Capital's flagging ratings. Rivals Heart and Magic (owned by Chrysalis and Emap respectively) play the same amount of ads (10 minutes an hour), and their audiences have grown. "It's not advertising that is the problem, it's the fact Capital's programming is crap," Bridgewell analyst Patrick Yau said. "It's a case of making their music better, cutting a lot of the announcer drivel." Mindshare media buyer Howard Bareham agrees. "Cutting the ads is not going to generate bigger audiences, it's the sound of the station that makes the difference," Mr Bareham said. This has been DMGT's experience in Australia, where Nova has now settled into fifth place in Sydney. Vega, DMGT's second Sydney station, which it launched recently (which also plays a limited number of ads but is aimed at an older audience), came bottom in its first survey.

Rivals attribute Nova's early ratings success to the fact it was the first new station to hit Sydney's airwaves in 20 years - rather than its advertising policy. Austereo chief Michael Anderson said: "Being the first new entrant into the market after more than 20 years ... they were always going to do well. But now they're just another radio station. Being new is a far more significant advantage than playing two ads in row has proved to be."

Mr Orchard concedes that advertising clutter is only half of Capital's problem. "We've removed the tune-out and created a point of difference," he said. "We've now got to create the 'tune-in' - a more compelling reason for audiences to listen ... The quality of the content in between the commercials is what determines the success of the strategy."

GCap will unveil a new format for Capital on January 3. Audience research has revealed listeners are sick of all the DJ chat, think Capital plays too broad a range of music, and want the station to be more relevant to London life. Despite dismal ratings in the vital breakfast slot, Mr Orchard said Johnny Vaughan would keep the show in the new format. "He's the best breakfast talent in the market."

The programming changes need to deliver a 30% increase in audiences at Capital to offset the cut in ad minutes. It also wants to double the proportion of revenue it derives from sponsorships, promotions and online services.

But GCap shareholders will have to endure a fair bit of financial pain before the new strategy starts to bear fruit. GCap has given itself three years to make "never more than two ads in a row" pay, and has warned it will cost £7m in lost revenue in 2006.

"We're prepared to take a hit in the first couple of years," Mr Orchard said. DMGT has yet to recoup the $A700m (£300m) it has spent in the past five years on its FM radio network in Australia.

Although investors dumped GCap shares when the new strategy was announced last month, management claims it retains the support of key shareholders, which include DMGT and Fidelity. "They appreciate it is a bold initiative," Mr Orchard said.

"They see us tackling the fundamental issue for GCap, which is Capital." He is confident the station's fortunes will begin to turn around in the second half of next year. "The bottoming out of the decline may happen quite early in the new year."

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*