Claire Cozens 

ITV to blame for Airey defection, say advertisers

12.45pm: ITV missed out on Dawn Airey because of in-fighting between Carlton and Granada, media buyers have warned. By Claire Cozens.
  
  

Dawn Airey
Airey: 'Sky is full of ball-breakers... but it's not a sea of testosterone' Photograph: Public domain

ITV missed out on Dawn Airey because of in-fighting between Carlton and Granada, media buyers have warned, with one describing the situation as "symptomatic of the way ITV operates at the moment".

The Channel 5 chief executive's 11th-hour defection to BSkyB could not have come at a worse time for ITV, which is in the middle of its negotiations with advertisers for the coming year and had hoped to offer them some much-needed good news about the network.

Ms Airey's decision also adds to advertisers' growing frustration at the rivalry between ITV's main shareholders, Carlton and Granada, which, they claim, is exacerbating the network's problems.

"You can just imagine the conversations between them, with one saying 'let's pay her this' and the other vetoing it. Instead, they should have just said: 'Damn it, let's make sure we get her'," said one TV buyer.

"There's no clear direction there. Instead you've got a management hodge-podge run by two sales people whose resources are being stretched beyond belief."

Ms Airey's possible move to ITV was regarded as a done deal among advertisers, with some saying they expected the Channel 5 head of programmes, Kevin Lygo, to join her.

"We thought she was just about to sign, so it's pretty disappointing. She had been having a lot of dinners with [Granada chief] Charles Allen and you don't do that unless you're taking the offer pretty seriously," said Andrew Canter, the head of broadcast at media agency MPG, whose clients include Orange and Thomson Holidays.

Mr Canter said there were other possible candidates for the ITV job but warned ITV bosses against a knee-jerk reaction to the loss of their favoured candidate.

"What ITV needs is long-term stability. Whether it's Michael Grade or someone else, they need to make sure whoever takes the job will stay for at least a few years to have a chance to get in there and sort it out," he said.

Jonathan Allan, the head of broadcast at media agency OMD UK, which buys space for advertisers such as Peugeot and Vodafone, warned the vacancy at the head of the troubled network would not be easy to fill.

"Anyone who goes into that ITV job might be able to slow the decline but they won't be able to turn it around," he said. "I can understand why Dawn turned it down."

Buyers were sceptical about the possibility that Mr Grade, a former Channel 4 chief executive, could be in line for the top ITV job.

"Michael Grade is a fantastic character but he has done it all before. He would be better than no one - and I can see him wanting to have a go at Greg Dyke - but I wonder how much ambition he has left," said one.

But David Jowed, the deputy broadcast director at Britain's third biggest media agency, MediaCom, said ITV was already beginning to show signs of improvement.

"In fairness, I think ITV has got its act more in order now than it has for years. There seems to be more direction from the top and the legacy of David Liddiment [ITV's outgoing director of programmes] will last well into next year," he said.

"Losing Dawn is not ideal, but it's not the be all and end all."

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*