Damien McCrystal 

Luke may have widened the menu from mussels to posh nosh but the City still thinks Signature lacks muscle

Writedown: 'I hear he is interested in buying a plastic surgery business. He clearly needs more expertise in this area' - Damien McCrystal on Luke Johnson, mastermind of Belgo.
  
  


Monks aren't very popular in the West, especially not in Ireland or the United States. Just ask Catholic clerics who are having to apologise for their brethren's child abuse. Or would-be customers of Belgo, the restaurant chain that dressed its waiters as monks and has had to close a number of branches. Or City analysts and traders, who have refused to be enthused by Belgo's performance.

Luke Johnson is the mastermind of Belgo, which was the name of the publicly quoted holding company until last November. Then, Johnson accepted one level of defeat and renamed the group, hoping to give it a new image. He tried another old trick - a share consolidation - because its price was so low that it triggered thoughts of dodgy tip-stocks in the minds of prospective buyers.

When the changes were made, the shares had dipped to just 1p - one-eleventh of their high point a couple of years earlier.

That was when Johnson could do little wrong and investors were so crazed with their own success that they would back any old idea. So when the man who made his fortune at Pizza Express before taking over the mad monks of Belgo said he wanted to buy the two most fashionable restaurants in London, Le Caprice and the Ivy, everyone said: 'Marvellous, why didn't we think of it before?'

He persuaded the owners to accept a large chunk of their payment in Belgo shares, then trading at about 10p, and locked them in by giving them seats on the board. A year later, the shares were below 3p, the new directors had lost most of their sizeable nest-eggs, and they retired to Wales, where I believe they are still licking their wounds. The problem was that, although the Ivy and Le Caprice continued to perform brilliantly, Belgo didn't. And its overseas expansion plans - New York, Dublin, Bristol - were not going well. The stock market eventually got wind of these problems and treated the shares accordingly.

It might have seemed to some outsiders that Johnson had performed a clever trick, swapping Belgo shares at their peak for something of real value. Surely this should convince the City that he was onto a good thing?

Not a bit of it. At one point, Belgo was making £4m a year but had a market capitalisation of only £12m. This made its shares, on traditional City measures, one of the market's best buys - except that no one wanted to buy them.

Maybe folks were concerned that Johnson was spreading him self too thinly. He has continued to toy with a wide range of activities, taking stakes and directorships in companies, plotting bids, and sticking his fingers into as many pies as possible, attempting to buy Waterstone's and so forth. But he is, according to many, too clever by half - a great insult in the City and a judgment that makes other investors wary.

It does not help that he has fallen out with his old friend Hugh Osmond, who beat him in a battle to buy 3,000 pubs from Whitbread. Johnson was said to be 'incandescent' that Osmond had invoked legitimate contractual undertakings that prevented Johnson from competing with him.

It does not help that Belgo's shares were tipped by Anil Bhoyrul, the former Daily Mirror journalist at the heart of investigations into controversial share dealings in various companies while they were being tipped in the Mirror's financial page (Bhoyrul now tips Belgo in the Express, under an assumed name).

And to cap it all Johnson has a reputation for being arrogant and dismissive, like his father, the columnist Paul Johnson. No wonder some people are reluctant to become involved in projects with him.

Perhaps the combined weight of these disappointments is leading him to turn his back on the City, for he is now attempting a management buyout of Signature Restaurants, the new name he gave Belgo. We are unsure how far advanced these plans are, for Johnson has made no comment. Nor do we know if he is behind the 14 per cent stake in the firm built up by a Virgin Islands investment vehicle, Kintaro, whose ultimate ownership, incredibly, remains a mystery despite requests for clarification from Signature's board.

Talk of a buyout has certainly helped the shares, which are up to 56p. Bearing in mind last year's consolidation, in which 20 old Belgo shares became one new Signature share, they have risen from 1p to the equivalent of 2.8p.

Johnson will be getting the company for a steal at this price, and he can well afford it. His fortune has been estimated at £40m, but I think it is probably rather higher - particularly as he continues to look at new bid opportunities as well as the £20m that Signature would cost him.

I hear he is interested in buying a plastic surgery business. He clearly needs more expertise in this area, for his attempts at cosmetic surgery on Signature left much to be desired.

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*