Soft soap and the advertising trade

Sir Martin Sorrell last year described the downturn as 'saucer shaped' - a long decline, followed by an elongated period of stagnation, and then a long, slow recovery. Sadly, that forecast is proving uncannily accurate.
  
  


Sir Martin Sorrell, boss of the leading advertising agency WPP, last year described the likely downturn and eventual recovery in his industry as "saucer shaped" - a long decline, followed by an elongated period of stagnation, and then a long, slow recovery. Sadly, that forecast is proving uncannily accurate.

GWR, the radio group, was doing its best to identify a few green shoots yesterday, and we can expect similar hallucinations from the TV sector (in the share of Carlton and Granada) over the next few days. Yet just a few months ago every pundit in the sector seemed to be predicting a substantial boost to confidence around this time, with advertising spending taking off again in time for the World Cup.

The tournament is about to arrive and anecdotal evidence suggests revenues are starting to pick up. But the advertising has not arrived in the quantities needed to revitalise media spirits.

Meanwhile, staggering on through another very difficult year, the big advertising agencies have other, more structural forces to contend with, too.

Schroder Salomon Smith Barney, for example, has just taken a scalpel to its forecasts for WPP on the seemingly esoteric suggestion that a gradual move away from commission-based revenue to a fee-based model (where companies buying airtime or newsprint pay the advertising agency a set amount, rather than a portion of their total spend) will delay the recovery - in profit terms - for even longer.

The investment bank's Patrick Wellington, whose analysis counts for more than most in this sector, makes the point that advertising agencies have much less cyclical gearing than the last time the business was in recession 10 and a bit years ago.

Nowadays, fees typically have a 12-month time lag. So a good portion of last year's ad campaign revenue reflected fee negotiations carried out during the much more buoyant times of 2000, while this year's fees will reflect the deeply pessimistic corporate mood of last year.

We can only guess at the levels of fees now being negotiated for advertising campaigns which consumers will only see during 2003. With the big advertisers having already ratcheted advertising rates sharply lower over the past year, it is assumed they will continue to apply the same pressure to those, like WPP, who negotiate the airtime and the newspaper space.

It is in this context, where those companies doing the buying enjoy exceptional levels of control, that we should look at the latest apparent coup by Unilever, the world's largest single advertiser.

The consumer goods combine has signed a £320m four-year deal on airtime with Carlton and Granada. Full terms have not been released, although we do know is that this agreement provides a clean break from the one-year ad campaign arrangements which were standard - until this weekend.

The Unilever deal also introduces a performance element, whereby ITV will have to bring in extra viewers if it wants more cash. Whether the £320m headline figure shrinks if ITV's audience figures continue to deteriorate has not been stated.

Granada and Carlton may argue that this sort of deal brings the TV companies certainty over the medium term. But given the current balance of power in the advertising industry the only real "certainty" here is that Unilever has dictated an exceptionally large discount.

Flights of fancy

Does anyone really care what Britain's package holiday companies call themselves? Their senior executives seem to think so, having indulged in an orgy of rebranding which makes Consignia look like a brainwave.

Airtours last year became MyTravel, while Thomson Travel is now part of the curiously twee World of Tui, illustrated by a sinister red smile.

Thomas Cook plunged in yesterday, announcing that it was ditching the name JMC for its airline, having painted it on to its 24 planes less than three years ago. JMC was supposed to be an umbrella brand for all the group's products, costing close to £10m, but has apparently failed to get holidaymakers' juices running.

JMC will remain only for mid-market family holidays. Cheap deals, previously JMC Essentials, will become Sunset, while Thomas Cook will return for up market packages. Confused? We certainly are.

Sunseekers heading for the Costa del Concrete, beer guts squeezed into bulging shell suits, are not always the sharpest tools in the box. But few of them are sufficiently stupid to pick a holiday on the basis of which operator has the nicest name.

Trading is tough in the package world - MyTravel warned on Wednesday that it had a million summer holidays still on the shelf with just six weeks to go before the start of peak season. They fervently deny it, but it seems likely that tour operators are struggling to cope with the threat of low-cost airlines.

As shown by the National Lottery's decision to become Lotto, there is a temptation among big corporates to try a new name when times get tough. The strategy does not inspire confidence - it is a very tenuous straw and it is not worth clutching.

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*