Adam Sweeting 

The price is wrong

It's been a bad week for music fans - but a good week for the industry. Adam Sweeting on why the CD swindle has to stop
  
  


The trade paper Music Week has reacted indignantly to news that the office of fair trading is to launch a new investigation into the pricing of CDs in Britain. The OFT appears to have been prompted to take action after finding "reasonable grounds" to suspect that the major record labels have banded together to restrict parallel imports of CD releases - in other words, cheaper copies from other EU countries. In particular, the companies' ploy of releasing "UK only" versions of albums, featuring extra tracks in an attempt to justify the UK's high retail prices, seems to have triggered the OFT's suspicions.

As a trade magazine dependent on record company support, Music Week doesn't have much alternative but to support the poor, put-upon multinational conglomerates that choose to honour British consumers with their unscrupulous marketing practices. But it's probably not even worth moaning about it - previous price-fixing investigations have gone on for months, cost millions of pounds and ended up giving the impression that even if the record business is up to its ears in corruption, there's nothing the British government or the expenses-fiddling jobsworths in Brussels can do about it.

However, you won't find any punters in the street claiming that a price of £15.99 for a CD is a jolly good thing. Even if they are still grudgingly prepared to pay it for an album they feel they must own, they know very well that the Americans and many of our European confrères are paying about four quid less. But in the same way that a combination of the internet, EU regulations and mounting consumer indignation has belatedly delivered a wounding blow to the price-fixing racket in the UK motor industry, record companies and music retailers have arrived at a watershed. Either prices will fall or people will find other ways of gaining access to music. In fact they're going to do so whether prices fall or not, so the question is how much the industry can slow the process down and limit the damage to its profits.

All eyes in the pop biz have been on this week's court of appeal ruling in California to determine the fate of the internet music company Napster, and its potential impact on the future of internet music delivery. Metallica, one of the world's most obscenely wealthy rock acts, are crowing triumphantly about the court's decision that Napster must prevent copyrighted material from being exchanged over its network. But this merely emphasises how much the band have changed since their early days as renegades of New Metal.

The biz has a long and notorious record of trying to demonise any new technological development as a threat to its well-heeled existence. Having moaned about the threat that FM radio posed to their financial well-being, the record companies tried to persuade their learned friends that home taping would destroy the industry, when in fact both developments only helped to boost music's global profile. Having reaped an incalculable financial harvest from re-releasing everything ever recorded via CD, the industry has never shown any gratitude to consumers, only spite and paranoia when it decides the music-buying public is trying to get something for nothing. Whatever Napster's fate, internet delivery of music is assuredly coming. What remains to be decided is how much control the labels can maintain over it, and how much they will charge users for the privilege.

Techno-terror aside, how much does the 21st-century record industry have to be proud of? It likes to portray itself as a great British success story and a driving force in the UK economy (shame it can't sell any records to the Americans, but never mind, it's only the world's largest market). But the self-evident truth is that the UK industry has lost the knack of finding acts that will appeal to a broad international market indifferent to the UK's insular fixation with zero-quality pop nonentities.

The listless inertia of UK consumers - surely the most important factor in the way multinationals have been able to take us for a ride for so long - guarantees that the charts will remain stuffed with prefabricated idiocy for the foreseeable future. For proof, look no further than the success of ITV's breathtakingly cynical Popstars. The series carefully dismantles the sordid process of manufacturing a pop group while being designed to generate fat profits for a PR company and Polydor Records - as well as guaranteeing ballooning prime-time ratings for ITV. If anything, the top priority of the OFT should be to take a close look at this pernicious little conspiracy of self-promotion, but instead Popstars has become a popular success and a tabloid sensation. Apparently the public has got what the public wants.

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*