Full story: Fed on collision course with Trump
And finally, here’s our economics editor Larry Elliott on today’s Fed rate cut:
The US central bank has cut interest rates for the third time this year in an attempt to keep the longest running period of growth in the country’s history continuing into the crucial election year of 2020.
But the Federal Reserve put itself on a potential collision course with Donald Trump when it signalled to the financial markets that it had no immediate intention of cutting the cost of borrowing further.
The president has put intense pressure on the Fed to boost the world’s biggest economy and his own re-election prospects by making aggressive cuts in the cost of borrowing.
But the central bank’s chair, Jerome Powell, said there was a limit to what the Fed could do and that a more effective way to stimulate activity would be for Congress to loosen fiscal policy through spending increases or tax cuts.
Here’s the full story:
Goodnight! GW
Fed rate cut sends S&P 500 to record high
Ding ding! Wall Street has closed at a new all-time high, as traders welcome today’s cut to US interest rates.
The benchmark S&P 500 index scaled new peaks -- up 10 points, or 0.3% to 2,046, a new record closing high.
The Dow Jones industrial average moved closer to its own record high too; gaining 116 points, or 0.4%, to 27,188.
US Closing Prices:#DOW 27186.69 +0.43%#SPX 3046.77 +0.33%#NDX 8083.11 +0.44%#RTY 1572.85 -0.27%#VIX 12.3 -6.82%
— IGSquawk (@IGSquawk) October 30, 2019
But we’ll only know in the future if the Fed made the right call today.
Edward Moya of trading firm OANDA says Powell may have blundered by saying rates are now in a ‘good place’, rather than leaving space for further cuts.
The Fed pretty much signaled they are in pause mode and will wait to see if we continue to see positive developments with the US-China trade war. The outlook on the economy was upbeat and this was unnecessary as they have given many hawkish hints that they could be closer to bending back toward rate increases. Inflation is anchored, albeit somewhat firmer recently, but nowhere near running the risk of running hot.
Powell delivered a hawkish cut that has pretty much locked the Fed into keeping the rates on hold in December and possibly into the spring, despite huge geopolitical risks from the trade war and Brexit. A lot could go wrong in a moments notice and this may go down as huge policy mistake.
Updated
In summary: Jerome Powell’s message is that US interest rates may not be cut again soon, if the economy holds up.... and he certainly doesn’t expect to reverse today’s cut soon either.
Fed Chair Jay Powell is a little bit hawkish in saying that the current funds rate is likely to remain appropriate. But he's massively dovish in saying that you'd need a "significant move up" inflation before the fed would consider raising rates.
— Steve Liesman (@steveliesman) October 30, 2019
Q: What do you make of Donald Trump’s claim today that America has its greatest economy ever?
Powell lets this question whizz past his helmet, as he never responds to comments from elected officials.
Here’s that tweet - maybe Trump will tweet about the Fed soon?....
The Greatest Economy in American History!
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) October 30, 2019
That’s the end of the press conference.
Powell vows to fight Japanification risk
Q: Does America risk a ‘Japanification’, if low interest rate expectations become entrenched?
There are powerful disinflationary pressures in the world economy, and the US isn’t exempt, Powell replies.
The Fed takes this risk “very seriously”, so will use policy to keep inflation close to 2%, he adds.
Q: Do you share the IMF’s concerns that rising corporate debt levels could threaten financial stability?
Leverage among corporations is historically high. We’re watching carefully and taking appropriate action, Jerome Powell replies.
Powell declines to swing at a curveball question on whether unions can play a stronger role tackling inequality (in the light of the strike at General Motors).
Updated
Wall Street has got the message....
Markets trimmed their expectations for interest rates to fall further this year after the Fed announced a 25bps cut and hinted that monetary policy may now be on hold, for one meeting at least. Next rate cut is expected in March or April at the earliest. pic.twitter.com/rQHTVN2yQp
— Holger Zschaepitz (@Schuldensuehner) October 30, 2019
Q: How does the Fed balance the divide between regions in the US, such as the rural-urban divide?
Monetary policy is a blunt tool, Powell freely admits. It can’t set different interest rates across the country.
Congress have responsibility for tackling long-term. challenges, such as income inequality, and differences in labor force participation rates.
Powell basically tells Congress to get its act together:
— Heather Long (@byHeatherLong) October 30, 2019
"If you really want the US economy to be all it can be...you need proper monetary policy, but really it’s fiscal policy that supports inclusive growth."#economy #Fed
Stocks are moving higher on Wall Street, after Powell dampened the idea of a rate rise in 2020:
Stocks extend gains as Powell says the Fed would need to see a ‘really significant’ rise in inflation before hiking rateshttps://t.co/G2uTDlSifZ pic.twitter.com/WSYpVNS2P2
— CNBC Now (@CNBCnow) October 30, 2019
Some reaction to Jerome Powell’s ongoing press conference:
Looks like this is it for #Fed cuts
— Michael Brown (@MrMBrown) October 30, 2019
- Monetary policy in a good place
- Current stance of policy likely to remain appropriate$EURUSD sub 1.11
$USD has turned lower after two tough questions from reporters. The first from @steveliesman on whether or not the Fed is hold now and the second from a reporter regarding repo. $USD
— Erik Bregar (@EBCTradeDesk) October 30, 2019
#Powell response to question on #repo operations shows #FederalReserve still doesn’t know CAUSE of liquidity shortage that led #Fed to intervene for 1st time since 2008. Problems started 7 weeks ago in mid-Sept 😢 (1/2)
— Komal Sri-Kumar (@SriKGlobal) October 30, 2019
Onto financial plumbing! Powell says the Fed is still looking at measure to help liquidity flow through the system, following recent liquidity problems.
Jay Powell then reminds the press conference of the big picture.
Three factors have weighed on the US economy: a global slowdown that began 18 months ago; trade tensions that have hurt exports and investment; the danger that low inflation pushes inflation expectations lower.
But on the upside - the economy has kept growing, and the strong jobs market means there’s still a chance to get more people into work.
The Fed is committed to extending this expansion, Powell pledges - thus today’s rate cut.
Powell: rate hike soon is unlikely
Q: Might you raise interest rates in 2020 if the US-China trade war was resolved?
An easing of trade tensions would have a positive impact, Jerome Powell replies.
But the impact probably wouldn’t be immediate.
He repeats that any interest rate rises will be dependent on inflation. So with core inflation just at 2% (the Fed’s target), the pressure isn’t there yet.
Updated
Jerome Powell insists policy is now in a “good place”, following today’s rate cut to 1.5%-1.75%.
#BREAKING Feds' Powell says cut interest rate as "insurance," policy now in "good place" pic.twitter.com/3ARdEUYdMw
— AFP news agency (@AFP) October 30, 2019
Q: Are you planning to hold rates at current levels until you’re proved wrong, or poised to move either way?
Current stance will remain appropriate as long as the incoming data is consistent with our outlook, says Powell.
That’s a hint that the Fed isn’t itching to cut interest rates again soon...
Q: What would it take to make you raise interest rates again?
Rising inflation, Powell replies, but there’s no sign of it yet.
“We’re not thinking about raising rates right now”
Q: Today’s GDP report showed that US business investment has fallen for the last six months (as covered earlier). Is that a key risk?
Powell says that some risks, including Brexit and an escalated trade war, have diminished:
It appears that the risk of a no-deal Brexit seems to have materially declined.
There’s plenty of risk left, but it’s subsided.
Q: Might firms start to cut jobs?
Powell agrees this is a risk, but there’s no sign of it yet.
Onto questions:
Q: Is this the end of your rate-cutting cycle, or what would it take to prompt another cut?
Powell says the Fed has moved policy to be more accommodative this year, with three rate cuts in 2019.
It now expects today’s rate cut will help deliver moderate growth, a strong labour market, and inflation near 2%.
“We’re going to watch all factors”, and if there’s a “material reassessment” of the situation, we’ll react, Powell adds.
Powell also cautions that Fed policy is not on a ‘preset course’ - it will respond to the data, and to events.
"Policy is not on a preset course." Do a shot! #fedpresserdrinkinggame"
— Paul R. La Monica (@LaMonicaBuzz) October 30, 2019
Jerome Powell begins his statement by telling reports that he, and his colleagues on the FOMC, are dedicated to serving the American people.
[a reaction to criticism from president Trump, perhaps?]
Today’s interest rate cut is an “insurance” against ongoing risks facing the US economy, Powell continues.
He says the jobs market remains strong - something that has helped citizens to find employment and improve their lives.
But he cites the current below-target inflation rates a danger - people could revise their inflation expectations down.
A slowdown in global growth, and trade tensions, are “ongoing risks”, Powell continues. So the Fed will continue to provide “significant support” to the economy.
Jerome Powell press conference begins
Jay Powell, chair of the US Federal Reserve, is holding a press conference now to explain today’s decision.
You can watch it live here:
WATCH LIVE TODAY: Press conference with #FOMC Chair Powell at 2:30 p.m. ET: https://t.co/R5jdupvACQ https://t.co/FJa6TbkDMt pic.twitter.com/4CtqNeRnbb
— Federal Reserve (@federalreserve) October 30, 2019
Fed cuts US rates: What the experts say
Here’s some instant reaction to the cut in US interest rates:
BREAKING: Federal Reserve cut interest rates a quarter point and signaled wait-and-see mode going forward.
— Heather Long (@byHeatherLong) October 30, 2019
Interest rates are now: 1.5 to 1.75% (lowest since spring 2018)
The Fed deleted the part of statement saying the Fed “will act as appropriate to sustain the expansion”
Richard Flynn, Managing Director at Charles Schwab:
“Today’s rate cut will provide a much-needed boost to the US economy, as the global slowdown continues to bite. However, as has been proven by the lack of positive recent economic data, subdued consumer confidence and even weaker business confidence, we continue to believe rate cuts are not the elixir for what ails the economy.
“Despite the cut, investors should not ignore ongoing macroeconomic risks, as geopolitical tensions remain unresolved. Trade war, Brexit, and the disruption in Hong Kong pose significant threats to the US economy. Further, the manufacturing sector’s deterioration in September, along with weakness on the services side, and dysfunction in Washington have kept stocks within a tight trading range.
There was zero chance the Fed in this situation was going to give up any of its optionality from here.
— Dow (@mark_dow) October 30, 2019
Candice Bangsund, Vice President and Portfolio Manager, Global Asset Allocation, Fiera Capital:
“As widely expected, the Fed met the market’s expectations with a 25 bps cut. The accompanying statement conveyed a subtle compromise for the hawks and the doves regarding the future trajectory for policy.
In a surprising hawkish-leaning development, the Fed removed the statement that policymakers will “act as appropriate” – though the Fed cushioned the blow somewhat and reinforced that policymakers are not on a preset path and will continue to monitor income economic data.
FOMC Reaction: Boring! 25bps cut & expected pause unless US data negatively surprises in Nov. Wouldn't rule out Dec rate cut (US investment worrying volatile GDP component). But this is an FX market wanting Fed liquidity action (marginal cuts irrelevant). $JPY barely cares... pic.twitter.com/Y1QBODS4Vl
— Viraj Patel (@VPatelFX) October 30, 2019
Michael Swell, Co-head of Global Fixed Income Portfolio Management, Goldman Sachs Asset Management:
“Central banks have contended with an unusual environment proactively over the past year, with policy responding to a trade shock as well as continued low inflation and tight labor markets.
Following today’s rate cut, we think insurance has been delivered to markets and the Fed’s policy path now depends on the evolution of US economic data and US-China trade relation
Fed statement in full
Here’s the full statement from the Federal Reserve, explaining why policymakers have cut borrowing costs today (by 8 votes to 2) to a 1.5%-1.75% range.
As you can see, the Fed believes the US jobs market remains strong, and household spending is growing too -- but business investment and exports are weak.
So, with inflation muted, the Fed feels a rate cut is justified.
Federal Reserve issues FOMC statement
Information received since the Federal Open Market Committee met in September indicates that the labor market remains strong and that economic activity has been rising at a moderate rate. Job gains have been solid, on average, in recent months, and the unemployment rate has remained low. Although household spending has been rising at a strong pace, business fixed investment and exports remain weak. On a 12-month basis, overall inflation and inflation for items other than food and energy are running below 2 percent. Market-based measures of inflation compensation remain low; survey-based measures of longer-term inflation expectations are little changed.
Consistent with its statutory mandate, the Committee seeks to foster maximum employment and price stability. In light of the implications of global developments for the economic outlook as well as muted inflation pressures, the Committee decided to lower the target range for the federal funds rate to 1-1/2 to 1-3/4 percent. This action supports the Committee’s view that sustained expansion of economic activity, strong labor market conditions, and inflation near the Committee’s symmetric 2 percent objective are the most likely outcomes, but uncertainties about this outlook remain. The Committee will continue to monitor the implications of incoming information for the economic outlook as it assesses the appropriate path of the target range for the federal funds rate.
In determining the timing and size of future adjustments to the target range for the federal funds rate, the Committee will assess realized and expected economic conditions relative to its maximum employment objective and its symmetric 2 percent inflation objective. This assessment will take into account a wide range of information, including measures of labor market conditions, indicators of inflation pressures and inflation expectations, and readings on financial and international developments.
Federal Open Market Committee statement: https://t.co/aql1RzrpcS #FOMC
— Federal Reserve (@federalreserve) October 30, 2019
Fed drops pledge to 'act as appropriate'
The Federal Reserve has also signalled that it may pause its rate-cutting cycle soon.
It has adjusted the language in its monthly statement, and dropped a pledge to “act as appropriate” to ensure that the US economic expansions continues.
Instead, the Fed now says it will “monitor the implications of incoming information for the economic outlook”.
That sounds like a softer commitment... Donald Trump may not be happy....
The decision is not unanimous.
Two Fed policymakers, Esther George and Eric Rosengren, voted not to cut interest rates today.
FED CUTS
Newsflash: The US Federal Reserve has cut interest rates, by a quarter point.
America’s central bank has lowered the target range for its key interest rate by 25 basis points to between 1.5% and 1.75%.
That’s down from 1.75%-2% previously.
More to follow!
Fed chair Jerome Powell’s press conference, in 30 minutes time, will be crucial.
John Bellows, portfolio manager at Legg Mason affiliate Western Asset predicts Powell will strike a dovish tone:
We think the Fed will reiterate the dovish arguments that have led to the interest rate cuts this year. That includes an emphasis on “sustaining the expansion”, a discussion of slowing growth, and an admission that inflation is too low. These dovish points would come as a surprise to analysts who are expecting a more hawkish message, and certainly would surprise anybody expecting a strong signal from the Fed that it is done cutting.
“It’s essential to remember the broader economic context here in the US. Tomorrow we will get the latest data on inflation with the consensus expectation that year-over-year core inflation will be around 1.7%, still stubbornly below the Fed’s 2% target and only marginally higher than the lows a few months ago.
Federal Reserve meeting looms
Tension is building in the markets ahead of the Federal Reserve’s decision on interest rates, in 10 minutes.
Investors widely expect the Federal Reserve to ease monetary policy, given concerns that the US economy may be slowing -- and heavy pressure from the White House.
However, today’s GDP report has shown that America is still expanding at a steady rate - almost 2% per year.
That means the Fed may deliver a ‘hawkish cut’ - lowering borrowing costs while hinting that rates won’t be cut much lower...
It's almost Fed time! I met with Tony Rodriguez, head of fixed income strategy at @NuveenAssetMgmt, earlier today to talk about what to expect. Says rate cut is guaranteed but that Fed/Powell will strongly suggest no rate cut in December. That doesn't mean the Fed is done though.
— Paul R. La Monica (@LaMonicaBuzz) October 30, 2019
Rodriguez of @NuveenAssetMgmt says he thinks Fed will hint at one more cut in first half of 2020. And then that will be the end of the rate cut cycle.
— Paul R. La Monica (@LaMonicaBuzz) October 30, 2019
Updated
Summary: US and French GDP beat forecasts
Time for a quick recap, before the drama of the Federal Reserve decision (at 6pm UK time or 2pm East Coast).
- America’s economy has grown faster than expected. GDP expanded at an annualised rate of 1.9% in July-September, very slightly slower than the 2% recorded in April-June.
- But while consumer spending rose, business investment contracted for the second quarter in a row . This pulled quarterly growth to its second lowest level of the Trump era.
- France’s economy also beat forecasts this morning, with quarter-on-quarter growth of 0.3% in Q3. Economists believe the French economy is outpacing the rest of the eurozone.
- The Economist Intelligence Unit predicts that Germany is falling into recession, while the UK may manage some growth in the last quarter (we’ll find out next month!).
- Worryingly, economic and consumer confidence in the euro area has fallen to its lowest level in several years, as households and businesses grow more pessimistic.
- The French owner of Peugeot and Vauxhall are in merger talks with US-Italian carmaker Fiat Chrysler. UK unions worry that Vauxhall’s factory in Ellesmere Port, in the North West of England, could be affected.
Another neat chart from WashPo’s Heather Long:
Trump often claims this is the "greatest economy in US history."
— Heather Long (@byHeatherLong) October 30, 2019
The chart says it all:
GDP is running at a 2.35% pace under Trump - about the same as Obama's 2nd term and W Bush's 1st.
Clinton and Reagan had over 3% GDP in their terms.https://t.co/LFuzQlCXXd via @andrewvandam pic.twitter.com/onBd7NYUrg
Don’t forget that president Trump has also ‘juiced’ the economy with tax cuts earlier in his tenure, which has also pushed this year’s budget deficit up to nearly $1trn.
Hopes of a US-China trade deal being signed at the APEC summit of Asia-Pacific leaders have been dashed -- the summit has just been cancelled!
oh...
— Neil Wilson (@marketsneil) October 30, 2019
CHILE CANCELS APEC SUMMIT IN SANTIAGO NEXT MONTH: PINERA
Chile cancels APEC summit next month.
— Michael Hewson 🇬🇧 (@mhewson_CMC) October 30, 2019
Significant as China and US could have used this summit to rubber stamp a phase 1 trade agreement
This follows days of protests about income inequality, and bloody clashes between demonstrators and police on the streets of Santiago.
Updated
White House CEA: US is outperforming G7 rivals
Donald Trump’s council of economic advisors is tweeting about today’s GDP figures:
The strong US economy is driving global growth. Among G7 countries, America is the only country with an annual GDP growth rate above 2 percent from Q2:2018 to Q2:2019 https://t.co/1SdRKvx6GB
— CEA (@WhiteHouseCEA) October 30, 2019
Because of pro-growth policies, the US economy continues to exceed expectations. Under @POTUS, real GDP is $230 billion higher than CBO’s final pre-election projection. https://t.co/1SdRKvx6GB pic.twitter.com/1mtrO5YFtn
— CEA (@WhiteHouseCEA) October 30, 2019
Today's GDP numbers show that strong economic growth benefits American families. Average annual growth in real disposable personal income under @realDonaldTrump is nearly double the pace from President Obama’s expansion period. https://t.co/1SdRKvx6GB pic.twitter.com/CGQOywtfqH
— CEA (@WhiteHouseCEA) October 30, 2019
Wall Street calm ahead of the Fed
Wall Street’s reaction to the growth figures? A weary shrug.
The main indices are barely moving in early trading, with the Dow up a mere 0.01% or 2 points at 27,073.
Traders are keeping their powder dry until they’ve heard from America’s central bankers tonight (although surely a rate cut is nailed on)?
There are some big movers, though. General Electric has jumped almost 9% after beating earnings forecasts today and raising its forecasts.
Shares in toymaker Matttel have surged by over 20%, after it also beat forecasts overnight. It also announced that an investigation into accountancy errors had cleared its outside auditors; the firm’s CFO is stepping down, though.
Handy GDP table for past four quarters pic.twitter.com/eBeQQVXLxD
— Liz Ann Sonders (@LizAnnSonders) October 30, 2019
America has just posted its second-slowest quarterly growth since Donald Trump became president.
Hat tip to Heather Long of the Washington Post for spotting this:
BREAKING: US economy grew 1.9% in 3rd quarter as the slowdown appears to be taking hold.
— Heather Long (@byHeatherLong) October 30, 2019
Q3 was the 2nd weakest of Trump era.
Q3 2019 1.9%
Q2 2019 2.0%
Q1 2019 3.1%
Q4 2018 1.1%
Q3 2018 2.9%
Q2 2018 3.5%
Q1 2018 2.5%
Q4 2017 3.5%
Q3 2017 3.2%
Q2 2017 2.2%
Q1 2017 2.3%
Updated
Analysts at Danske Bank predict the Federal Reserve will cut interest rates in a few hours time (the third cut this year).
🇺🇸#US real GDP growth is slowing. Peaked last year around 3% y/y, now around 2% y/y
— Danske Bank Research (@Danske_Research) October 30, 2019
Private consumption remains the main growth driver, while investments are under pressure (high uncertainty?)
We still expect the #Fed to deliver another cut tonight pic.twitter.com/uaGeA5X9rg
Even before the GDP data was released, Donald Trump was tweeting that the US economy was greater than ever.
The Greatest Economy in American History!
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) October 30, 2019
However, America’s year-on-year growth rate has fallen to 2%, from 2.3% three months ago.
This won’t please the tech sector:
Business investment in "computers and peripheral equipment" had it's lowest contribution to U.S. GDP since the third quarter of 2001: pic.twitter.com/Mjvqg4Xx4b
— Michael McDonough (@M_McDonough) October 30, 2019
Annotated GDP contribution analysis! pic.twitter.com/VZBcciRoY4
— Jared Bernstein (@econjared) October 30, 2019
Several economists are encouraged that America’s economy grew faster than predicted in the last quarter -- but disappointed that business investment has fallen again.
Blogge Jeroen Blokland says the investment decline is ‘ugly’:
The ugly part of today's US #GDP growth number; nonresidential investment fell 3% (annualized) in Q3. pic.twitter.com/dPNfKZ2BFL
— jeroen blokland (@jsblokland) October 30, 2019
David Rosenberg, chief economist at Gluskin Sheff fears that the US business sector is in recession:
Today's GDP report confirms a business sector recession. Consumer will follow with a lag -- as yesterday's soft Conf Board survey revealed.
— David Rosenberg (@EconguyRosie) October 30, 2019
Jared Bernstein, former advisor to US vice-president Joe Biden, sees signs of a slowdown:
Real GDP growth came in at 1.9% last quarter, abt the same as previous quarter, so a bit better than expected. However, there are signs of slowing the report. I find yr/yr growth more trend revealing and it shows clear signs of decelerating, from peak of 3 to 2 now. [thrd] pic.twitter.com/FfCqJC5pXx
— Jared Bernstein (@econjared) October 30, 2019
Analyst Joseph LaVorgna says tight monetary policy is hurting the construction sector.
Q3 #GDP rises better than expected 1.9% as consumption rose a solid 2.9% after big 4.6% gain previously. Weakest part of economy is commercial construction, the result of tight money courtesy @federalreserve. Structures were down -15.3% vs -11.1% previously. This should reverse
— Joseph A. LaVorgna (@Lavorgnanomics) October 30, 2019
US GDP: economy grows faster than expected
Newsflash: The US economy grew faster than expected in the last quarter....but business investment has fallen again.
US GDP grew at an annualised rate of 1.9% in July-September, the Commerce Department says. That’s down from 2% in April-June, but better than the 1.6% expected.
US GDP growth slowed from 2.0% to 1.9% annualised in Q3 (vs exp 1.6%). #USgdp pic.twitter.com/pJ0SGOcP4s
— James Foster (@JFosterFM) October 30, 2019
It’s the equivalent of quarterly growth of almost 0.5% - faster than France, and much faster than expected in the eurozone or the UK.
The report shows that consumer spending growth slowed, to 2.9% down from 4.6% in Q2.
In a worrying sign, business investment contracted by 3%, following 1.0% drop in Q2, with companies cutting back on new equipment.
But there’s encouraging news too - exports rose by 0.7%, following a 5.7% slump in April-June. Imports rose by 1.2%, having been flat in the previous quarter.
Reaction to follow.....
Updated
The latest US private sector jobs data is a little mixed.
Some 125,000 new jobs were created this month, 15,000 more than expected -- but September’s figures have been revised down.
ADP employment figures show 125k jobs added, 15k more than expected - but the prior number was revised 42k lower.
— Alberto Gallo (@macrocredit) October 30, 2019
The U.S. jobs engine appears to be sputtering#QEinfinity #KickTheCanEconomics #Trumponomics pic.twitter.com/GUAANDnvjG
John Westwood, group Managing Director at Blacktower Financial Management Group, says business leaders across the eurozone are growing more pessimistic.
This helped pull the overall EU confidence index down to its weakest in four years.
Westwood explains, though, that UK managers are becoming less pessimistic.
“Business and consumer sentiment in the EU and eurozone have decreased on average this month (eurozone by 0.9 points to 100.8, and the EU by 0.9 points to 99.0).
The decline appears to be due to pessimism from business managers. What may come as a surprise, is that for the UK specifically, sentiment increased from 88 to 89.8.
Many predicted this would fall, however an extension to Brexit may be propping these numbers up. UK businesses have continued to show optimism, while the rest of Europe displays the polar opposite; meaning that the uncertainty of Brexit may not be having the impact many first thought.”
Updated
UK consumer confidence has picked up slightly this month, the EC reports, from 88.0 from 89.8.
But that’s weak by historical standards -- should Boris Johnson be worried?
Consumer confidence is lower than before ALL of the LAST EIGHT general elections - including those in 1992 and 2010 just after big recessions.
— Samuel Tombs (@samueltombs) October 30, 2019
People are more pessimistic about the outlook for both the economy and their own finances.
Fertile ground for the Opposition parties? pic.twitter.com/igZ9cpv1Ij
Eurozone economic confidence hits lowest since 2015
In a worrying development, economic and consumer confidence has fallen across Europe.
The EC’s Economic Sentiment Indicator (ESI), released this morning, fell by 0.9 points to 100.8 in the euro area, and by a similar amount in the EU to 99.0.
These are the weakest readings since 2015, suggesting the region’s economy is struggling - despite France holding up well.
Economic confidence in the euro area extends its slide https://t.co/zRAxkpKeZi pic.twitter.com/L6h9dboJOR
— Bloomberg Markets (@markets) October 30, 2019
The EC found that confidence across industry, services, retail trade and among consumers all fell this month - although it did rise across the construction industry.
Here’s the damage:
- Industry confidence (-0.6): managers were more pessimistic about production expectations.
- Services confidence (−0.5): managers were gloomier about their past business situation and demand expectations.
- Consumer confidence (−1.1): There was a strong deterioration in households’ expectations about the general economic situation and their future financial situation; plus small declines in their assessments of their past financial situation and their intentions to make major purchases
EIU: Four EU countries at risk of recession
At least four EU countries are at risk of recession by the end of year.
That’s according to the Economist Intelligence Unit, whose latest Global Forecasts predict that Germany will formally enter recession when its third-quarter GDP figures are released in November.
The UK, Italy and Finland are also perilously close to recession, the EIU adds, while France looks healthier (as we saw this morning).
The EIU says:
Most EU economies will also grow sluggishly: we expect Italy’s economy to remain flat, and that of the UK to grow by only 0.1% as Brexit-related uncertainty continues to take its toll on business investment.
The bright spot in Europe continues to be France, which should continue its run of being the fastest-growing major EU economy.
It also predicts:
- Canada and the US will be the fastest-growing G7 economies in Q3 of 2019, with GDP growth expected to come in at 0.4%
- Japan faces recession risk, with a predicted fourth-quarter growth rate of -0.5%
- Of the G7 and BRICS economies, only India and the UK are expected to post third-quarter results that show an acceleration from Q2.
In further bad news to Germany, Deutsche Bank has suffered yet another loss.
Germany’s largest lender posted a pretax loss of €687m loss this morning, due to disappointing investment bank results and the cost of restructuring its operations.
Deutsche’s investment banking division saw pre-tax profits tumble 73% to €64m, partly due to weak fixed-income trading (bonds).
Deutsche’s “core bank” made a profit of €353m. But its new “Capital Release Unit”, created to help Deutsche sell unwanted assets and exit under-performing areas, made a pre-tax loss of €1bn.
Shares have fallen 6%, amid disappointment that the company’s turnaround plan wasn’t delivering better results.
Deutsche Bank shares drop >6% following dismal earnings. pic.twitter.com/sGLcSTXxps
— Holger Zschaepitz (@Schuldensuehner) October 30, 2019
The seasonally adjusted unemployment total in Germany is now 2.287 million, up from 2.28 million in September.
But September’s data was better than October’s, and showed a fall in unemployment.
Oliver Rakau of Oxford Economics says the labour market appears to have stalled:
The German labour market has stalled. Unemployment is flat over the past 3-months keeping unemp. rate at a very low 5% in October. Employment continues to edge up thanks to rising participation & immigration. Surveys suggest no improvement in near-term, but also no worsening. pic.twitter.com/y6MX6s4lPW
— Oliver Rakau (@OliverRakau) October 30, 2019
Rising unemployment puts more pressure on Berlin’s government to launch a new spending programme to boost growth, argues Bloomberg.
It says:
German unemployment resumed its rise as factories remained in a slump, increasing the pressure on the government to step in with fiscal stimulus.
Bloomberg also points out that Germany’s factory sector -- a powerhouse for so long -- is now struggling.
Manufacturers are being hit by uncertainty over global trade protectionism, and the auto sector is struggling with a fundamental shift to electric vehicles. While domestic consumption has so far held up, the fear is that the weakness will spread to the services sector as factories dismiss workers.
October’s gain in joblessness is rooted exclusively in rising claims for unemployment benefits on the back of weakening economic momentum, the labor agency said. Demand for workers receded and the number of vacancies declined.
German unemployment resumes its rise as the economy battles recession https://t.co/Flqz4HWoa4 via @pgordon66 @sachgau #tictocnews pic.twitter.com/glPj5aCZeb
— Zoe Schneeweiss (@ZSchneeweiss) October 30, 2019
German unemployment rises
Newsflash: Germany’s unemployment total has risen, and by more than expected too.
The number of people out of work in Germany rose by 6,000, on a seasonally-adjusted basis.
Economists had expected an increase of 2,000 to 3,000, as German factories (such as carmakers) cut workforces in the face of falling orders.
- Germany Unemployment Change (Oct): 6K (est 3.0K, prev -10.0K)
— LiveSquawk (@LiveSquawk) October 30, 2019
- Germany Unemployment Total NSA (Oct): 2.204Mln (est 2.194Mln, prev 2.234Mln)
- Germany Unemployment Claims Rate SA (Oct): 5.0% (est 5.0%, prev 5.0%)
Detlef Scheele, the head of Germany’s Labour Office, says:
“The recent economic weakness is leaving its marks on the job market. But all in all, it still proves to be robust.”
The jobless rate held steady at 5.0% - slightly above the record-low of 4.9% reached earlier this year.
More to follow....
France’s economy has also benefitted from government spending increases, designed to calm the yellow-vest protests.
Last December, Emmanuel Macron’s administration announced €10bn of additional expenditure, including raising a bonus for low-paid workers, and removing overtime taxes and pension surcharges.
Last month, the government also promised €10bn of tax cuts in its 2020 budget to boost investment and consumer confidence. Brussels isn’ happy, though, as France is likely to breach EU budget targets again.
Full story: French GDP beat is boost for Macron
Here’s Reuters’ take on France’s better-than-expected growth figures:
French economic growth defied expectations for a modest slowdown in the third quarter, expanding instead at the same 0.3% pace from the previous quarter, the INSEE national statistics office said on Wednesday.
The resilience in French gross domestic product will be good news for President Emmanuel Macron, at a time of concerns about a global slowdown brought about by international trade disputes which have hit the nation’s main trading partner Germany hard.
A poll of analysts surveyed by Reuters had forecast 0.2% growth for the euro zone’s second-largest economy in the three months to end-September.
Philippe Waechter, an economist at Ostrum Asset Management, said growth was supported by the government’s injection of public funds to boost households’ spending power.
“This is important in a risky international context,” he said.
Domestic demand was the main driver of growth, adding 0.5 points in the third quarter, while trade subtracted 0.4 points and inventories made a small 0.1 point contribution.
French households’ spending picked up, growing at a 0.3 percent pace in the third quarter after expanding 0.2 percent in the previous three months, while business investment slowed to an increase of 0.9 percent this quarter from a 1.2 percent gain. The negative contribution from trade reflected a faster increase in imports than exports.
Shares in Fiat Chrysler and Peugeot have both spiked at the start of trading, as traders hail the prospect of a merger between the two car makers.
Fiat is up 10% in Milan, while Peugeot gained over 5% in Paris.
Renault, which had also courted Fiat, are down 3% though.
European aerospace corporation Airbus is also among the fallers, down 2.6%, after cutting its 2019 delivery target by up to 30 aircraft
And in London, high street fashion chain Next has dropped 2% to the bottom of the FTSE 100 leaderboard. It reported that sales surged by 5% up in October thanks to the cold weather, but cautioned that November and December won’t be as strong.
European Equity movers this morning:
— RANsquawk (@RANsquawk) October 30, 2019
Fiat Chrysler (FCA IM) +9.9%
PSA Group (UG FP) +5.3%
Total (FP FP) +1.0%
Renault (RNO FP) -3.0%
Airbus (AIR FP) -2.6%
Next (NXT LN) -2.0%
EssilorLuxottica (EL FP) -1.2%
Deutsche Bank (DBK GY) -1.0%
France is the first G7 country to report growth figures for the third quarter of 2019, and has laid down a marker for rivals to beat.
The US GDP report, due in a few hours, is expected to show quarterly growth of around 0.4% in July-September, down from 0.5% in April-June.
The eurozone is expected to have barely grown at all. Its GDP, released tomorrow, is forecast to rise by a mere 0.1%.
Germany may have suffered another small contraction (putting it in recession), while Italy is expected to have stagnated.
And the UK? Economists expect growth of 0.3%, which would mean Britain dodges a recession after contracting in Q2.
France GDP growth beats expectations in the third quarter, growing 0.3 per cent in contrast to weaker performances expected in Germany and Italy. French household spending and services boosted growth, while trade and manufacturing were negatives. https://t.co/i1SFuzr6vp via @FT
— Martin Arnold (@MAmdorsky) October 30, 2019
Peugeot owner in merger talks with Fiat Chrysler
There’s also a big merger brewing in the auto sector.
France’s PSA Group, which owns Peugeot and Vauxhall, is in talks with Fiat Chrysler Automobiles (FCA) about a merger that would create one of the world’s biggest carmakers.
Here’s the full story:
French companies are shrugging off slowdown fears, and the ongoing Brexit uncertainty, by investing more in their businesses.
🇫🇷 French resilience in one chart. Corporate investment kept increasing at a solid pace in Q3 (+1.2% q-o-q after 1.1%) pic.twitter.com/nTPiDxDC7T
— Nadia Gharbi (@nghrbi) October 30, 2019
Philippe Waechter, chief economist of Ostrum Asset Management, says consumption and investment are ‘at the heart’ of France’s growth right now:
#GDP Growth in #France is 0.3% in Q3 as in each of the previous two quarters. The carryover is 1.2%. Domestic demand is at the heart of this expansion, while foreign trade contributes negatively due to a sharp rise in imports.
— Philippe Waechter (@phil_waechter) October 30, 2019
Consumption is at 0.3% (0.4 in Q1 and 0.2 in Q2) and investment at 0.9% (0.5 in Q1 and 1.2 in Q2) are at the heart of growth. Note the slowdown in housing investment while companies remain very proactive on this point (1.2 after 1.1 in Q2)
— Philippe Waechter (@phil_waechter) October 30, 2019
This internal dynamic reflects the economic policy that supports domestic demand to limit risk on growth. The momentum of the economy is not excessive but the risk of rupture is reduced. This is important in a risky international context
— Philippe Waechter (@phil_waechter) October 30, 2019
INSEE, the French stats body, says domestic demand excluding inventory changes “remained dynamic” in the last quarter.
It contributed 0.5 points to GDP growth, points out Nadia Gharbi of Swiss bank Pictet.
🇫🇷 French GDP rose by 0.3% q-o-q in Q3, same pace as in Q2. Domestic demand (excluding inventory changes) remained dynamic and contributed 0.5 points to GDP growth. In contrast, net trade contributed negatively to GDP growth. pic.twitter.com/n0N0ot80SS
— Nadia Gharbi (@nghrbi) October 30, 2019
Updated
Chart: French GDP
This chart shows how net trade dragged France’s economy back, despite decent growth in consumer spending, inventories and gross fixed capital formation (investment):
Updated
Introduction: French growth beats expectations
Good morning, and welcome to our rolling coverage of the world economy, the financial markets, the eurozone and business.
France’s economy has defied the doubters by growing faster than expected, despite signs of a global slowdown.
The eurozone’s second-largest economy expanded by 0.3% in the third quarter of 2019, new official figures show.
That’s faster than the 0.2% expected, and matches the 0.3% recorded in April-June.
EUR France Perlim 3Q GDP
— DailyFX Team Live (@DailyFXTeam) October 30, 2019
QQ Actual: 0.3%
Forecast: 0.2%
Previous: 0.3%
YY Actual: 1.3%
Forecast: 1.3%
Previous: 1.3%
INSEE, the national statistics office, reports that household spending accelerated over the summer. It rose by 0.3% in July-September, up from 0.2%, as consumers kept the economy ticking over.
However, net trade had a negative impact on growth. That’s because imports jumped by 1.4% (having shrunk 0.3% in Q2), while exports only rose by 0.3% (up from 0.1%). A sign that trade conflict is hurting, perhaps.
But with companies continuing to invest (+0.9%, down from 1.2%), and restocking their inventories, the overall growth rate remained steady.
On an annual basis, France’s economy has only grown by 1.3% over the last year. That’s hardly spectacular.
But at a time when the eurozone is struggling, and the world economy is slowing, president Emmanuel Macron may be quite content with today’s data.
#France's economy shows resilience. Q3 #GDP growth +0.3%, higher than expected. YoY GDP growth +1.3% pic.twitter.com/UU7YJ6yCIF
— jeroen blokland (@jsblokland) October 30, 2019
More to follow.....
Also coming up today
We don’t get Q3 GDP data from Germany until next month, but today’s unemployment figures may bolster fears that it is in recession.
New GDP data for America is expected to show growth slowed, as the trade war with China hits demand and confidence.
Then the big event, the Federal Reserve decision. America’s central bank will probably vote to cut interest rates for the third time this year, to a 1.5% to 1.75% range.
Fed chair Jerome Powell will then hold a press conference, where he’ll probably field more questions about the state of the economy, inflation expectations, and recent liquidity shortfalls in the money markets.
He’ll also be asked about the stream of attacks from Donald Trump (who keeps claiming the Fed is clueless).
“Over in Europe and Japan they have NEGATIVE RATES. They get paid to borrow money. Don’t we have to follow our competitors?” @Varneyco Yes we do. The Fed doesn’t have a clue! We have unlimited potential, only held back by the Federal Reserve. But we are winning anyway!
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) October 29, 2019
The agenda
- 8.55am GMT: German unemployment total for October - expected to rise by 2,000
- 10am GMT: Eurozone economic, business and consumer confidence figures for October
- 12.30pm GMT: US GDP for Q3 2019:
- 6pm GMT: Federal Reserve monetary policy decision
- 6.30pm GMT: Fed chair Jerome Powell’s press conference
Updated