Markets continue Santa rally
Shares moved ahead again despite a turnaround in the oil price which saw early gains eroded, on renewed fears of oversupply and falling demand as well as comments from the Saudi Arabian oil minister that his country would not intervene to support the crude price. So energy shares fell back but consumer shares were stronger - on the basis that lower petrol prices could mean more money to spend. So the final scores showed:
- The FTSE 100 finished 31.47 points or 0.48% higher at 6576.74
- Germany’s Dax added 0.81% to 9865.76
- France’s Cac closed 0.3% better at 4254.43
- Italy’s FTSE MIB rose 0.48% to 19,074.04
- Spain’s Ibex ended up 0.07% at 10,371.0
In Russia, the rouble is up more than 4% against the dollar at 55.5, while the RTS index is up 5.5%.
On Wall Street, the Dow Jones Industrial Average is currently up more than 80 points or 0.47%.
As for oil, Brent crude is now down nearly 2% at $60 a barrel.
On that note, it’s time to close up for the evening. Thanks for all your comments, and we’ll be back tomorrow.
Updated
The recent drop in oil prices should persist and could boost global economic activity by 0.3% to 0.7% next year, according to two senior IMF economists in a new blogpost. Reuters reports:
Brent crude prices have fallen more than 46% since the year’s peak in June of above $115 per barrel, sped up by the November decision of the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) not to reduce production.
“Overall, we see this as a shot in the arm for the global economy,” Olivier Blanchard, the IMF’s chief economist, and Rabah Arezki, the head of the commodities research team, said in the blog, adding that futures markets suggest oil prices will stay lower than levels in previous years.
The risk of default in Ukraine is rising and there is a high likelihood of a bond restructuring next year for the country, which has $28bn of external debt due next year, according to ratings agency Moody’s. It said:
Political turbulence and fragile external finances weigh on Ukraine’s (Caa3 negative) economic prospects and will hinder its ability to cover its upcoming debt maturities in the coming years. The rating agency notes that there is a high likelihood of a Ukrainian bond restructuring next year.
Moody’s expects Ukraine’s economy to contract by 7.5% in 2014 and by a further 6% in 2015, although the latter is subject to a high level of uncertainty depending on if and how the crisis is resolved. The 2014 result is in part due to a drop in domestic demand following the steep hryvnia depreciation of more than 50%, which caused inflation to rise to over 20%, as of early December this year. Moody’s expects the central government deficit to come in at around 5% of GDP in 2014.
The conflict in Ukraine’s Eastern regions and the economic downturn have also caused Ukraine’s public finances to deteriorate. Foreign exchange reserves fell to $8 billion in November, which is about one month’s worth of import cover using reduced 2014 estimates of import levels.
The risk of default is rising as the government faces roughly $28 billion in external debt maturities next year, with new credit from the IMF, EU and other official lenders likely to be insufficient to cover these payments, says Moody’s. External financing needs of banks and companies -- state-owned oil and gas company Naftogaz especially --also remain substantial.
To meet these needs, the rating agency expects that the government will seek other sources of funding, including privatization of state assets, in the near future. These will likely include companies in the energy sector, which remains a drag on the economy.
Depending on the cost and volumes of gas imports and the flexibility of Gazprom, the Russian state-owned gas company, with regard to payment arrears for previously supplied gas, and assuming little or no capital flight -- which is unlikely -- Ukraine will need to borrow at least another $15-$20 billion beyond what is provided by existing programs over the next 12 months, the rating agency notes. In the estimate, Moody’s assumes that the Russian government will not call for the early repayment of its $3 billion Eurobond due in December 2015.
The National Association of Realtor’s chief economist Lawrence Yun said trading was choppy throughout the country in November:
Fewer people bought homes last month despite interest rates being at their lowest levels of the year. The stock market swings in October may have impacted some consumers’ psyche and therefore led to fewer November closings. Furthermore, rising home values are causing more investors to retreat from the market.
The full release is here:
Existing-Home Sales Lose Momentum in November as Inventory Slightly Tightens
Larry Yun blames tumble in home sales on volatile October stock market which "impacted some consumers’ psyche"
— zerohedge (@zerohedge) December 22, 2014
US existing home sales and inventory pic.twitter.com/BcjGmqYlQK
— cigolo (@cigolo) December 22, 2014
The US housing market recovery is looking a little bumpy.
After two months of increases, sales of existing homes fell to a six month low in November. According to the National Association of Realtors, they dropped 6.1% to an annual rate of 4.93m units. Analysts had been expecting a figure of around 5.2m.
October’s sales rise was revised slightly down from 5.26m units to 5.25m.
Eurozone consumer confidence figures have come in slightly better than expected, although still in negative territory.
According to an initial estimate from the European Commission, consumer confidence in the eurozone rose to -10.9 from a revised -11.5 (previously -11.6) in November. (The revision came from a change in Italian consumer survey data).
Analysts had been expecting a figure of -11.
Updated
Wall Street is keeping the market rally going in the shortened Christmas week.
The Dow Jones Industrial Average is up around 80 points in early trading, while the FTSE 100 is currently around 36 points or 0.56% higher. Germany’s Dax is up 0.8% and France’s Cac up nearly 0.5%.
Back with Russia and the rouble has gained more than 6% to around 54 to a dollar, while the RTS index is up 8%.
Another sign of the times...
New iPhone 6 prices in Russia will start at 54,000 rubles (were at 34,990 rubles in November) http://t.co/xhANb8Xnu3
— Elena Holodny (@elenaholodny) December 22, 2014
Updated
Summary: Russian crisis claims first bank, and could get worse
Time for a recap.
Russia’s unfolding financial crisis has claimed its first victim. Mid-size lender Trust Bank is being bailed out with 30bn roubles from the Central Bank of the Russian Federation.
Here’s our take: Trust Bank becomes first financial casualty of Russia’s currency crisis
The rescue comes four years after Trust Bank signed up actor Bruce Willis to promote its wares....
Russia’s former finance minister, Alexei Kudrin, has warned that the situation will worsen:
“Today, I can say that we have entered or are entering a real, full-fledged economic crisis. Next year we will feel it clearly.”
“The government has not been quick enough to address the situation ... I am yet to hear ... its clear assessment of the current situation.”
Russia’s immediate financial crisis eased a little today; the rouble has strengthened by almost 6%, and the RTS stock market jumped by 8%.
But with analysts predicting an oil price of around $64/barrel in 2015, Russia appears to be heading for a painful recession.
And the slump in the oil price has worried policymakers at the Bank of England, who fear it could fuel geopolitical tensions and push inflation even lower in Europe.
Russia’s biggest bank, Sberbank, has denied a report that it has suspended taking new requests from retail clients for car and mortgages loans until February.
- RUSSIA’S SBERBANK DENIES RIA NEWS AGENCY REPORT IT HAD SUSPENDED TAKING NEW REQUESTS ON AUTO LOANS, MORTGAGES - DEPUTY CEO TO REUTERS
Former Russian finance minister warns of deepening crisis ahead
Trust Bank’s bailout was announced as Moscow was digesting a grim warning from one of the country’s most experienced and well-regarded politicians
Alexei Kudrin, former finance minister, declared that Russia was careering into a full-blown economic, and blamed president Putin’s government for not responding to the sanctions imposed by the West.
Kudrin told reporters that real incomes could fall by between 2% and 5% next year, as Russians feel the impact of the crisis:
“Today, I can say that we have entered or are entering a real, full-fledged economic crisis. Next year we will feel it clearly.”
“The government has not been quick enough to address the situation ... I am yet to hear ... its clear assessment of the current situation.”
Kudrin predicted that Russia’s credit rating will be slashed to junk in 2015, and said it will suffer a deep recession in 2015:
“If the oil price is $80 a barrel, GDP will fall 2 percent or more. If it’s $60 a barrel, the GDP decline will be 4 percent or more.”
As covered earlier, analysts expect Brent crude to average $74/barrel in 2015.
Kudrin is a well-respected figure in the financial markets, having rebuilt Russia’s credibility and financial reserves after the 1998 default.
He also served as deputy prime minister for several years, and has been cited as a potential successor to Dmitry Medvedev, so today’s intervention is pretty significant.
News that the rouble crisis had claimed its first banking casualty has not shaken the Moscow markets.
The rouble has strengthened further, up over 5% at 55.2 roubles to one US dollar. Perhaps traders are encouraged to see the Central Bank taking action.
The RTS share index continues to rally, up over 7% today, with bank stocks among the biggest risers:
Updated
*BANK OF RUSSIA TO BAIL OUT NB TRUST BANK - effects of #rouble drop starting to come through
— Jasper Lawler (@jlawler_cmc) December 22, 2014
Trust signed up Bruce Willis back in 2010. Reuters reported that:
Trust bank, a top-30 lender by assets, hung pictures of the “Die Hard” star on the streets of Moscow on Monday with the phrase “Trust is just like me, but a bank.”
The “Die Hard” star replaces Trust’s previous frontman, Russian weight-lifter Vladimir Turchinsky, who unexpectedly dropped dead last year at age 46.
The choice of all-American action hero Willis as the face of a Russian mid-size bank did raise some eyebrows; banking analyst Jacob Jegher blogged that:
How the bank came to choose Bruce Willis is beyond my comprehension. I find it particularly interesting (and kind of funny) considering Willis’ role as a bank robber in the 2001 movie Bandits.
Why did Trust Bank need bailing out?
Today’s bailout shows how far Trust Bank has fallen since it signed up Hollywood star Bruce Willis to advertise its wares:
So what went wrong?
It appears that, during the good times, Trust offered attractive savings rates and consumer loans.
That helped it expand while the Russian economy was ticking along. But the rouble crisis, and the shock caused by Western sanctions, has hit demand for credit and left some borrowers unable to repay their debts.
The Wall Street Journal explains:
The lender is active in Moscow and other large cities, offering high interest on deposits and easy consumer loans. Presently the bank is offering up to 21% annual interest on ruble accounts and up to 8% on the deposits nominated in foreign currency.
Trust Bank had prospered on burgeoning consumer spending. But with the economy grinding to a halt and approaching a possible contraction in 2015, consumer spending has slowed causing a rise in the volume of nonperforming loans across the banking system and a slowdown in consumer lending.
Updated
Russia bails out Trust Bank
A Russian bank has just been bailed out; the first since the currency crisis began.
The Central Bank of the Russian Federation is injecting as much as 30 billion roubles (around $517m), into Trust Bank to save it from bankruptcy, and putting it under direct supervision.
The CBR is now looking for an investor, probably another Russian bank, to take control of Trust.
Last Friday, Russian MPs rushed through a bill authorising a 1 trillion rouble recapitalisation of the country’s banks, which have suffered big losses through the currency crisis.
Sky News has more details:
The decisions were taken at an emergency meeting and were designed to provide Trust with sufficient liquidity to continue operations without any repercussions for clients.
Unable to borrow on Western markets due to US and EU sanctions over Moscow’s role in the Ukraine crisis, Russian banks have found themselves pressed by the plunge of the rouble, that has lost nearly half its value in the past year.
Rouble Crisis Sparks Russia Bank Bailout http://t.co/yHKyyEqnTl
— Sky News Business (@SkyNewsBiz) December 22, 2014
Updated
Oil analysts have slashed their forecasts for the oil price in 2015, but still reckon it will pick up from its current lows.
A Reuters poll found that Brent crude is expected to average $74 per barrel, down from $82.50 in a poll in November.
Bank of England warns oil slide could raise geopolitical risks
While we were offline, the Bank of England’s financial policy committee revealed that it’s worried that the fall in crude prices could fuel geopolitical risks (Russia, anyone?).
It could also drive the eurozone closer to deflation, they point out.
That’s according to the minutes of this month’s FPC meeting, just released, which show that it discussed the likely implications of the sharp fall in oil prices.
And while committee members don’t see any immediate threat to the UK, the global implications are more worrying:
Here’s the key section:
The Committee noted the positive impact on global growth and concluded that the decline in oil prices seen to date was unlikely to pose an immediate, significant risk to UK financial stability.
If the fall in oil prices were to be sustained, it could impact the ability of some businesses, such as US shale oil and gas exploration firms, to service their debt. US oil and gas firms accounted for 13% of the outstanding debt in US high-yield bond markets; an increase in their perceived or realised credit risk could lead to sales by investors and potentially illiquidity in the broader high-yield bond market. A sustained lower oil price also had the potential to reinforce certain geopolitical risks. There was also a risk that, in economies where core inflation was already weak, particularly some parts of the euro area, low headline readings would further depress expectations of future inflation. This, in turn, could result in slower rates of growth of nominal incomes, increasing the burden of existing debts.
Apologies for the silence, a few IT Gremlins have invaded the office...
We're having some internet problems at Guardian HQ. Apologies for any inconvenience.
— The Guardian (@guardian) December 22, 2014
The rouble crisis has had a nasty knock-on effect on one of the USSR’s former satellite states, the Republic of Belarus.
Last night, Belarusians found they were blocked from using various internet shopping sites. The move came after the Belarus ruble hit a 16year low against the US dollar.
The ripples from Russia’s currency crisis had already prompted the government to impose capital controls, including a 30% tax on buying foreign currency, on Friday night.
After 15 years, DIY chain Kingfisher has realised that it can’t crack the Chinese market on its own.
It has sold 70% of its B&Q China, after struggling to transfer its ‘do it yourself’ model into the fast-growing Chinese market.
As Jennifer Rankin explains:
B&Q opened its first store in China in 1999 and now has 39 outlets employing 3,000 people, but the London-listed group struggled to transplant its business model to a country where doing odd jobs around the house is not seen as a leisure activity.
Chinese consumers have not embraced DIY, partly because low wages mean there is a plentiful supply of people to do household jobs. The US chain Home Depot shut its big box stores in 2012, after finding not enough Chinese consumers had caught the DIY bug.
More here: Kingfisher sells B&Q China stake as DIY fails to take off
China retail - it's harder than you think: B&Q owner Kingfisher to sell controlling stake in its China business to Wumei Holdings for £140m
— Kamal Ahmed (@bbckamal) December 22, 2014
Kingfisher to sell 70% stake in B&Q China to Wumei Holdings for £140m. It wants to concentrate investment in its core European market.
— Sky News Business (@SkyNewsBiz) December 22, 2014
Updated
Despite today’s rally, the recent slump in the oil price would make a big dent in the finances of an independent Scotland.
The Financial Times reports that:
Scotland’s North Sea revenues would have slumped to one fifth of Holyrood’s preferred forecasts in its first year of independence if Scots had voted Yes in September, according to an Office for Budget Responsibility simulation using current oil prices.
The Yes Campaign, which lost September’s referendum on independence, had budgeted for oil to be around $110 per barrel, not today’s $62 level.
More here: Oil rout would have wrecked an independent Scotland’s finances
Oil revenue for Scotland's first year as an independent country would have been £1.25bn instead of £6.9bn http://t.co/Xr3hN6ESpl
— Alberto Nardelli (@AlbertoNardelli) December 22, 2014
A Bank of England policymaker has warned against assuming that the recent oil price falls means inflation will be low in the medium term.
Speaking on BBC Radio 5 this morning, Martin Weale argued:
“What we have seen over the last few months is a very sharp fall in oil prices that has a direct first-round effect on the rate of inflation.
“But it’s a separate issue to where inflation is going to be in, say, two years’ time.”
Weale has been voting for UK interest rates to rise since August, despite inflation dropping to just 1.0% this month.
Many other economists are less convinced that inflationary pressure are going to rise in 2015 and 2016, pointing to signs of weakening economic growth in China and Europe.
Stan Shamu of IG says investors are speculating that crude oil prices may be about to recover:
After seeing a rebound on Friday, many have been calling a bottom in oil prices and feel this is a beginning of a recovery. With Saudi Arabia pledging its commitment to seeing stability in oil prices (see yesterday’s story), many took this as a catalyst for a recovery.
The jump in the oil price is also giving European stock markets a lift, as the Santa Rally continues.
All the main European stock markets are up this morning, led by energy companies.
London’s FTSE 100 has jumped 64 points to 6610, led by Royal Dutch Shell (up 2.7%), Tullow Oil (+2.5%) and BP (+2.2).
Traders are also taking comfort in last week’s Federal Reserve meeting, where the US central bank promised to show patience when raising interest rates.
Rouble up 3.5% to 56.5 against the dollar in early trading, recovering from last week's 80 per dollar low with Brent crude up 2.15% to $62.6
— TimesBusiness (@TimesBusiness) December 22, 2014
Russia’s stock markets is on a charge this morning, helped by the rouble and the oil price.
Moscow’s RTS index has jumped by 5.4% to 809 points. That’s almost a third higher than last Tuesday’s crash, when the currency crisis exploded:
Rouble jumps 3%
The overnight jump in the oil price has helped to push the Russian rouble higher.
The rouble is up 3% in early trading, at 56.4 roubles to the US dollar. A calmer start after last week’s turmoil, which saw the rouble hit the 80-to-the-dollar mark.
Anton Startsev, head analyst at Olma investment house, says the oil price rally should give the rouble some relief.
He writes:
“The easing of the situation on the oil market ... can help improve the situation on the Russian (currency) market in early trade as well as provide the basis for further firming of the rouble.”
The #ruble has appreciated more than 25% from its intraday low last week. pic.twitter.com/V2eINLGaVs
— jeroen blokland (@jsblokland) December 22, 2014
The rouble is benefiting from the central bank’s plan to relax accounting standards to cushion banks from the impact of the currency crisis.
The finance ministry’s plan to sell surplus currency reserves to support the rouble also appears to be helping.
The agenda: Oil price picks up
Good morning, and welcome to our rolling coverage of the financial markets, the world economy, the eurozone and business.
Christmas time is nearly here, by golly, and that means it may be a quiet day. Shares in Europe are expected to rise, as traders get into the festive spirit.
Oil is the main mover this morning, jumping by 2%. That pushed up the cost of Brent crude by more than $1 per barrel, to $62.64.
Analysts suggest that oil may have bottomed out, as Michael Hewson of CMC Markets explains:
This stabilisation in the oil price has, raised the expectation that we may well have found a short term base, and mitigating concerns that further declines could well prompt large scale losses on highly leveraged oil producers and governments.
Oil has plunged by a third since late September, giving consumers a much-needed boost to their wallets.
This morning’s rise comes despite Saudi Arabia reaffirming that yesterday it will not cut production levels, despite the recent tumble in the oil price.
As my colleague Julia Kollewe reports:
The Saudi oil minister, Ali al-Naimi, said in Abu Dhabi on Sunday: “The kingdom of Saudi Arabia and other countries sought to bring back balance to the market, but the lack of cooperation from other producers outside Opec and the spread of misleading information and speculation led to the continuation of the drop in prices.”
Referring to producers outside Opec, he said: “If they want to cut production, they are welcome: We are not going to cut; certainly Saudi Arabia is not going to cut.”
Full story: Saudi and UAE oil ministers defend Opec response to falling prices
There aren’t many treats in the economic calendar today, alas, but we do get the latest measures of Eurozone consumer confidence for December at 3pm.
We’ll be tracking all the main events of the day as usual....
Updated