Afternoon summary
Time for a quick recap
The single currency touched $1.1467 against the US dollar for the first time since March, after days of tough talks in Brussels, which are resuming this afternoon.
Traders are hopeful that an agreement will come, after opponents of the plan such as the Netherlands and Austria appeared to accept, in principle, that grants should be part of the package.
But there’s no agreement yet on the details - with EU president Charles Michel trying to rally all sides around a compromise. A deal may come tonight, or leaders could still require another summit.
Things are moving. Despite French push, seems like €390bn will be the figure for the grants. Now Michel will need to straighten out other outstanding parts of negotiation - including climate taeget and rule of law - to produce new negotiating draft
— mehreenkhn (@MehreenKhn) July 20, 2020
But chief economist Andy Haldane also told MPs that the recovery is underway, with the economy clawing back around half its losses in the pandemic.
He says:
Roughly half of the roughly 25% fall in activity during March and April has been clawed back over the period since.
“We have seen a bounceback. So far, it has been a ‘V’. That of course doesn’t tell us about where we might go next.
The surge in visitors back to high streets and retail parks has also faded, new research shows. Footfall in the shops only rose 5% last week, down from over 10%.
UK households are also still being squeezed, with many curbing their use of unsecured credit.
Covid-19 has also claimed music magazine Q, which is to close after suffering falling circulation.
But pharmaceutical firms say they are making progress. AstraZeneca has reported that the Oxford Covid-19 vaccine is showing promising signs...
..and Southampton biotech firm Synairgen says its protein-based inhaler therapy has helped patients.
In the markets, the FTSE 100 has closed 28 points lower at 6261, a drop of 0.5%. European markets rallied, though, on hopes of a deal in Brussels. Germany’s DAX and Italy’s FTSE MIB both ended 1% higher, with France’s CAC up 0.5%.
Here’s our latest report on the summit:
While the Covid-19 liveblog is here:
Goodnight. GW
A little more from Andy Haldane:
Chief economist of Bank of England, Andy Haldane, thinks UK economy has been growing by 1% a week since it “hit its floor” in April and had “clawed back” around half the ground lost since lockdown began in March. Says big short-term danger to the recovery is rising unemployment.
— Joel Hills (@ITVJoel) July 20, 2020
Back on Wall Street, the S&P 500 has now returned to its level on 31 December 2019, meaning it has recovered much of its Covid-19 losses.
The S&P 500 is up .03% right now YTD and for the first time since Feb 24.
— Andy Martin 🇺🇸 (@Dollarlogic) July 20, 2020
Two Bank of England policymakers have updated MPs about the impact of Covid-19 on the UK economy, at their reappointment hearings today.
Chief economist Andy Haldane told the Treasury committee that there will “inevitably” be some long-term scarring of the economy as a result of the Covid crisis, including a hit to employment.
The two key channels through which scarring of the economy’s longer-term potential might arise is through reduced business investment and dynamism, hitting the stock of physical capital, and through high unemployment depleting the skills of the workforce and shrinking the stock of human capital.
In the MPC’s illustrative scenario published in May, it was assumed that scarring of businesses resulted in the productive capacity of the UK economy being persistently lower by around 1¼%. There was little assumed scarring of the labour market. In practice, there is the potential for scarring effects in the labour market – for example, if sectoral or skills mismatches between workers and companies make it difficult for people to find new jobs, raising the economy’s equilibrium rate of unemployment and lowering its productive potential. Whether the economy experiences scarring, through businesses or workers, will depend on the actions taken by firms, as well as on policy actions taken by Government.
Professor Silvana Tenreyro, an external member of the Monetary Policy Committee, predicted that Covid-19 will have a complex impact on the economy:
Rather than a radical change, I think this shock could accelerate pre-existing technological trends; for example, more remote working, a switch to online retail, distance learning and more investment in artificial intelligence. Added to pre-existing climate change concerns, there may be a permanent shift away from long-distance air travel. These changes may have knock-on macroeconomic impacts. More remote work, e-commerce and distance learning could weight on the demand for and the rental price of commercial real estate.
The switch to online retail and greater AI could have implications for aggregate productivity, as well as driving changes in the share of income accruing to workers versus capital. Changes are also likely to depend on the success of policies put in place – countries have the opportunity to shape the nature of any turning point coming from the crisis.
Q magazine to close as Covid-19 hits media industry
The music monthly Q is to be shut after more than three decades after its publisher was unable to find a buyer as the coronavirus pandemic accelerates the shift of readers and advertisers to online media.
The German-owned Bauer Media, which owns magazines in the UK including Grazia and Empire, said that the 34-yea- old magazine would cease publishing immediately.
Last month, the company said that it had entered advanced talks to sell the music monthly and four other titles, while also deciding to cease publication of three others including Planet Rock.
While it has found buyers for some titles - including Your Horse, Sea Angler and Car Mechanics to specialist publisher Kelsey Media - Q and stablemate Modern Classics could not be saved.
“We have been unable to find equivalent new owners for Q and Modern Classics and have decided to cease publication of these titles with immediate effect,” said Chris Duncan, chief executive of UK Publishing at Bauer Media.
“We thank those teams for their work on these iconic titles.”
Q enjoyed sales of just over 200,000 at the turn of the century when it was a must-read title. But by the end of last year sales had dwindled to 28,000, according to official figures from the Audit Bureau of Circulations.
In May, the publisher began a review of the future of 10 magazines with options including complete closure, moving to online-only, a sale or merger with another title.
Duncan added:
“There tough decisions were made to help us recover and rebuild through the COvid-19 crisis. We will continue that process with our remaining portfolio of world class titles.”
The final issue of Q. On sale Tuesday 28 July. pic.twitter.com/STYJ2snH5m
— Q Magazine (@QMagazine) July 20, 2020
Updated
Meanwhile in Brussels.....
EU summit, day 4:
— Martin Trauth (@MarTrauth) July 20, 2020
Viktor #Orban arrives at the EU Council for the possible showdown: He has loosened his tie and rolled up his sleeves. Looks ready for a fight#RuleOfLaw #EUCO pic.twitter.com/48BYRMtn73
Amid all the optimism about the “promising” Oxford vaccine, biotech investor Peter Kolchinsky is recommending caution:
Oxford data consistent w/ past results... uncomfortable & fairly weak neutralizing antibody titers compared to other vaccines (until we get outcomes from large studies, we can't know if good enough). Touted t cells aren't well understood w/o strong nAbs. https://t.co/FqydI93VvZ
— Peter Kolchinsky (@PeterKolchinsky) July 20, 2020
But vaccines like Oxford's, which also generate immunity against adenoviral vector (coating delivering the vaccine instructions) probably won't be as good for seasonal reboosting. Our immune system shuts them down better after each dose, preventing delivery of instructions.
— Peter Kolchinsky (@PeterKolchinsky) July 20, 2020
So Oxford vaccine has to do all it can with the initial course of vaccination. After that, boosting of SARS2 immunity will likely need other vaccines. Same redosing limitations apply to all adenoviral vaccines (e.g. JNJ, Cansino)
— Peter Kolchinsky (@PeterKolchinsky) July 20, 2020
AstraZeneca’s shares have now dipped back from that record high, but still up around 1% today.
The company has told shareholders that the latest trial results from Oxford won’t “impact” its financial guidance this year, as the cost of developing the vaccine will be offset by funding by governments and international organisations.
There’s not much reaction in the wider stock market to today’s trial update, with the FTSE 100 still down around 0.6% or 38 points at 6252.
That’s probably because a lot of good vaccine news is already ‘priced in’ -- with so many trials underway, investors are hopeful that some will be effective, and reach the mass market.
AstraZeneca has also updated the City about the Oxford Covid-19 vaccine, which it is producing.
It highlights that interim results from the trials show that AZD1222 induced a T-Cell response (a key part of the body’s immune response), as well as antibodies (which bind to, and neutralise, the virus).
Professor Andrew Pollard, Chief investigator of the Oxford Vaccine Trial at Oxford University, says that a ‘two-dose’ strategy may work well:
“The interim Phase I/II data for our coronavirus vaccine shows that the vaccine did not lead to any unexpected reactions and had a similar safety profile to previous vaccines of this type. The immune responses observed following vaccination are in line with what we expect will be associated with protection against the SARS-CoV-2 virus, although we must continue with our rigorous clinical trial programme to confirm this. We saw the strongest immune response in participants who received two doses of the vaccine, indicating that this might be a good strategy for vaccination.”
Mene Pangalos, AZ’s executive vice president for BioPharmaceuticals R&D, says the results give the firm confidence.
“We are encouraged by the Phase I/II interim data showing AZD1222 was capable of generating a rapid antibody and T-cell response against SARS-CoV-2. While there is more work to be done, today’s data increases our confidence that the vaccine will work and allows us to continue our plans to manufacture the vaccine at scale for broad and equitable access around the world.”
Oxford Covid-19 vaccine shows promise
Speaking of vaccines... medical journal The Lancet has just reported that preliminary results show that Oxford’s Covid-19 vaccine is safe and generates an immune response.
Trial data also shows that it led to neutralising antibodies in trial subjects who received a second dose.
Further clinical trials are still needed (and indeed are already underway in the UK and Brazil, and soon in the US too), but it’s a promising sign.
NEW—UK’s #COVID19 vaccine is safe and induces an immune reaction, according to preliminary results https://t.co/rDPlB9fDKr pic.twitter.com/z2t9Aubjim
— The Lancet (@TheLancet) July 20, 2020
Shares in AstraZeneca are still proudly at the top of the FTSE 100,, up 3.5% at £95.12, on track for a record closing high.
The US stock market has started the new week with small gains.
The Nasdaq index is up 28 points, or 0.3% at 10,532, as it continued to outperform the rest of Wall Street.
The Dow is up just 4 points, or 0.01% at 26,676.
Traders are juggling concerns about the spike in Covid-19 cases with optimism that a Covid-19 vaccine will be developed.
Any readers with a spare £5.5m may be interested to know that Mark Carney’s old house is on the market.
The former Bank of England governor has left the UK, and the Victorian house rented by the Carney family in South Hampstead is now on the market.
And what a house! Eight bedrooms, an cavernous open-plan kitchen, stylish living space and an 81-foot rear garden must have made an agreeable escape when Bank duties allowed. The Mail have published the full photo gallery from estate agents Aston Chase (after the family left, alas, so there are no snaps of Mr Carney wearing an apron or mowing the lawn)
More encouraging Covid-19 treatment news, this time from Pfizer:
*PFIZER, BIONTECH EARLY POSITIVE UPDATE FROM PHASE 1/2 COVID-19
— Investing.com (@Investingcom) July 20, 2020
*PFIZER - BNT162B1 INDUCED ANTIBODIES HAD BROADLY NEUTRALIZING ACTIVITY IN PSEUDOVIRUS NEUTRALIZATION ASSAYS ACROSS PANEL OF 16 SARS-COV-2 RBD VARIANTS
Reuters has the details:
German biotech firm BioNTech and U.S. drugmaker Pfizer on Monday reported additional data from their experimental coronavirus vaccine that showed the vaccine was safe and induced an immune response in patients.
The results were disclosed from a trial in Germany testing 60 healthy volunteers, and come after the companies earlier this month reported data from a corresponding early-stage trial in the United State
M&S job cuts: instant reaction
Boris Johnson’s spokesman has told reporters that the government ‘stands ready’ to help Marks & Spencer staff, with 950 facing redundancy.
“We know that this will be worrying news for M&S employees and their families and we stand ready to support them. Affected employees will be able to access a wide-range of support including universal credit and the job seekers’ allowance.”
Andy Barr of online price-tracking website www.alertr.co.uk, says M&S is right to adjust to the changing retail landscape this year:
“As we all slowly adjust to the ‘new normal’ we can see that retailers are making changes internally to ensure a better future for all. Marks & Spencer are just the latest retailer to come out and announce job cuts, they’re not the first by any means – and we must remember that the ‘never the same again’ programme to restructure the brand was announced earlier this year.
And while it’s never nice to hear about job losses, especially in the current climate, the brand is right to say that some consumer shopping habits will never be the same again. Online shopping was making waves long before Coronavirus, but lockdown has only further boosted this. We hope that by making these kinds of cuts now, hopefully retailers will be better off for it the future.
Some new photos from Brussels:
The euro is just about holding onto its earlier gains, trading at $1.146 against the US dollar (still the highest since March).
Some European markets have shaken off their earlier losses, with Germany’s DAX now up 0.5% today (while the FTSE 100 is still down 0.5%).
Fawad Razaqzada, market analyst with ThinkMarkets, says investors seem confident that a deal on the €750bn Recovery Fund is imminent.
The euro was leading the gains after European leaders made progress in negotiating a historic stimulus package, according to media reports. This also explains why the DAX has also been outperforming, and why Italy’s borrowing costs fell to their lowest since early March today as the rally in riskier eurozone government debt saw the spread between Italian 10-year and German bund yields, an important gauge of risk in the region, tighten....
The €750 billion stimulus is going to help speed up the recovery in the euro area, where the virus situation also appears to be under control compared to the US. Investors are therefore anticipating the eurozone to perform relatively better than the US economy, driving the exchange rate higher. However, this is a global issue and if the vaccines prove not to be very effective and coronavirus does not go away, then we may well see haven demand come back for the US dollar and undermine risk assets, including the EUR/USD. But that’s a worry for another day and right now the path of least resistance is to the upside.
After a brief sleep, European leaders are returning to their Brussels summit to keep thrashing out the details of the Covid19 recovery fund.
German chancellor Angela Merkel told reporters that she hopes they can reach agreement despite the difficult negotiations in recent days.
France’s Emmanuel Macron spoke about the spirit of compromise (with the ‘frugal’ North Europeans seemingly accepting the idea of grants, although not the scale which the South says it needs).
#Germany Chancellor Merkel: We've worked out yesterday a framework for a potential agreement. That's real progress and provides us with optimism that maybe today we can have an agreement, or at least that an agreement is possible.#EUCO pic.twitter.com/bagEXT7L3Y
— Yannis Koutsomitis (@YanniKouts) July 20, 2020
#Euco Day 4 begins with von der Leyen saying she is hopeful of chances of an agreement: "we're not there yet but things are moving in the right direction" pic.twitter.com/HQECe1IQSD
— mehreenkhn (@MehreenKhn) July 20, 2020
Macron enters summit building saying there is a "spirit of compromise" this morning."Things have moved forward, we need to go into more detail". #euco pic.twitter.com/zYwkqHwZug
— mehreenkhn (@MehreenKhn) July 20, 2020
M&S confirms 950 jobs to be cut
Newsflash: Marks & Spencer has just announced that 950 jobs are at risk, as it shakes up its retail management structure.
The retailer says that it is creating a new structure “fit for the future”, and removing various duplicated functions.
M&S adds that this will provide “clearer leadership accountabilities...freeing up its retail teams to focus more on the customer” (weren’t they doing that anyway?!).
This means 950 roles are threatened across “central support functions” in field and central operations and property and store management. M&S is starting a consultation with staff, and will offer voluntary redundancy first.
Another blow for high street jobs with 950 to go at M&S - in property, store management and other head office roles. Not a fun time to be working in retail.. or casual dining.
— Sarah Butler (@whatbutlersaw) July 20, 2020
Updated
Synairgen shares soar 375% after Covid-19 treatment results
Shares in UK biotech firm Synairgen have absolutely rocketed this morning, after it reported a potential “major breakthrough” in treatment of Covid-19 patients.
Synairgen, which is based in Southampton, told the City that its protein-based treatment had shown significant success when administered to those suffering from the virus.
The procedure used a naturally occurring antiviral protein called interferon beta. Patients who inhaled Synairgen’s drug were 79% less likely to require ventilation or die, compared to those who received a placebo. They were also more likely to recover from the illness, to a point where their activities were not limited.
Interferon beta is part of the body’s first line of defence against viruses, warning it to expect a viral attack. Synairgen’s work suggests that it can significantly bolster the body’s immune response, giving the lungs more protection and helping the patient recover.
Synairgen’s tests involved 101 patients at nine hospitals. Richard Marsden, CEO of Synairgen, says this trial could significantly help those hospitalised by the pandemic.
“We are all delighted with the trial results announced today, which showed that SNG001 greatly reduced the number of hospitalised COVID-19 patients who progressed from ‘requiring oxygen’ to ‘requiring ventilation’.
It also showed that patients who received SNG001 were at least twice as likely to recover to the point where their everyday activities were not compromised through having been infected by SARS-CoV-2. In addition, SNG001 has significantly reduced breathlessness, one of the main symptoms of severe COVID-19.
This assessment of SNG001 in COVID-19 patients could signal a major breakthrough in the treatment of hospitalised COVID-19 patients. Our efforts are now focused on working with the regulators and other key groups to progress this potential COVID-19 treatment as rapidly as possible.”
Shares in the company have jumped from 36.5p to 170p this morning, up 375%.
Updated
UK shoppers trickle back to the high street
Just in: UK shoppers trickled back to the high street last week as the lockdown was eased.
Retail experts Springboard have reported that footfall across the UK’s retail destinations rose by +4.5% last week, compared to the week before.
Although shops will welcome the extra customers, this is rather less than the 10.6% jump recorded in the first seven days after reopening, on 4th-10th July.
Footfall on UK high streets rose by 6.8%, but visits to retail parks actually fell by 0.7%.
Week on week footfall rose 4.5% last week, acc to @Springboard_. That's less than half the 10.6% increase in the first week after the reopening of hospitality/leisure businesses.
— George MacDonald (@GeorgeMacD) July 20, 2020
These figures will confirm fears that the UK retail sector is still suffering badly from the pandemic, with some people nervous to enter shops - or converted to e-commerce instead.
Diane Wehrle, Insights Director at Springboard says:
“Last week demonstrated that the longed for flood of shoppers returning to bricks and mortar destinations and retail stores once again became a trickle, with a week on week rise in footfall that was less than half that in the previous week.
Despite the limited rise in footfall, the year on year result is at its most modest yet, which does provide a glimmer of hope for the struggling retail industry.”
In another gloomy sign, many UK manufacturers are planning to cut jobs due to the financial cost of Covid-19.
And companies across the board are cutting back on investment, meaning a long-term hit to growth and productivity. More here:
UK household finance squeeze continues
Just in: UK household finances continue to be squeezed by the coronavirus pandemic, as more families fret about job insecurity.
IHS Markit’s monthly Household Finance Index (HFI) has risen to 41.5 in July, up from 40.7, a level showing that purse strings remain tight as many households continue to cut back on credit.
The report found that the easing of lockdown measures in recent weeks has provided some support, allowing people in the hospitality industry to return to work. But there is still major concern about unemployment.
Tim Moore, director at IHS Markit, explains:
Almost four times as many survey respondents reported a decline in job security as those that saw an improvement in July.
Large numbers of households are therefore maintaining the cautious spending habits adopted during the early stages of the pandemic and are now focussed on paying down debt and saving where possible.”
Here are the key findings:
- IHS Markit Household Finance Index maintains its recent rebound from April’s low
- Household spending index remains far weaker than seen prior to the COVID-19 pandemic
- Demand for unsecured credit declines for the first time since the survey began in February 2009
- Another steep fall in job security recorded during July
Plus charts:
Back in the City, shares in UK housebuilders are rallying amid signs of a post-lockdown ‘mini boom’.
Online estate agent Rightmove has reported a surge in inquiries in recent weeks as the market emerges from its Covid-19 lockdown.
Its latest figures show that the average price of a property coming on to the market in Britain reached £320,265 this month, above the previous record of £312,625 reported in March, just before the housing market was put on hold.
This has lifted Taylor Wimpey, Barratt Development and Berkeley Group by over 1% each.
Pent-up demand is one factor, along with the UK stamp duty holiday announced earlier this month. Some people have also decided to move to a larger home, or out of cities, after months of working from home.
Former Finnish prime minister Alexander Stubb is confident that European leaders are close to a compromise deal.
Stubb, a veteran of EU summits during the eurozone crisis, reckons the EU is actually showing uncommon “speed and force”, although the end result will still be sub-optimal:
Having followed #EUCO from a distance, it seems clear that a deal is imminent. Next phase: interpretations of the result in 28 different press confs. Spinning on steroids. Everyone claiming victory in front of their home crowd. Not difficult because of the size of deal...1/3
— Alexander Stubb (@alexstubb) July 20, 2020
...The phase after is then to sort out what was actually decided. This will entail intense talks between the institutions, mainly the Commissiona and the Council Secretariat, long discussions among EU Ambassadors in Coreper and when necessary, interventions by Sherpas...2/3
— Alexander Stubb (@alexstubb) July 20, 2020
...All in all, if and when a deal is struck, no matter what the exact final ratios of size, division and distribution, it should be welcomed. The result will, as always, be sub-optimal. Nevertheless, the EU has never ever before reacted to a crisis with such speed and force...3/3
— Alexander Stubb (@alexstubb) July 20, 2020
A peek at the FTSE 100 leaderboard shows that Covid-19 are moving shares today.
Pharmaceuticals firm Astrazeneca hit a record high this morning, over £96 for the first time, as traders anticipate upbeat data from its early stage human vaccine trials later today.
But airline group IAG is the top faller, down 3.5%. On the FTSE 250, holiday firms TUI and Carnival are also falling, suggesting concerns over the travel industry.
Russ Mould, investment director at AJ Bell, explains:
“Markets had a shaky start to the new week with mixed progress in Asia and declines across Europe including a 1% decline in the FTSE 100 to 6,224.
“One of the select few stocks to rise on the FTSE 100 was AstraZeneca, extending a rally that’s been in motion since mid-June.
“Investors have warmed to AstraZeneca both on hopes that it will successfully develop a treatment for Covid-19 and the fact the company is making progress with other drug developments. Early stage trial data is set to be published today on its coronavirus vaccine so the shares could be in even more demand if the news is encouraging.
European stock markets have started the new week with a bit of a bump.
All the main indices are in the red, with equities failing to benefit from optimism of a recovery deal.
The EU-wide Stoxx 600 index has dropped by 0.6%, led by losses in Paris and Madrid. The energy sector is the worst performer, followed by consumer companies, telcos and banks.
Paul Donovan of UBS Wealth Management says some investors are anxious about the remorseless rise in Covid-19 cases in America, especially as some US stimulus payments run out soon:
The leaders of the EU have failed to come to an agreement on the recovery fund, and are still talking. This really should not be a surprise. Every EU summit of any importance always drags on longer than scheduled. It seems that EU leaders are only capable of agreeing anything when massively sleep-deprived. The anti-fund/frugal faction has agreed to the principle of grants being part of the recovery fund.
US fiscal policy is in focus, with US President Trump to meet Republican leaders to discuss the fifth fiscal package of the pandemic. There is some urgency, as the additional unemployment benefit payments are due to expire at the end of this month. The economy would not respond well to an abrupt ending of these payments.
There has also been some concern in markets about the spike in reported cases in the US. Fear of the virus is less than it was, so the economic response is less than it was – but fear has clearly risen. This has to be balanced against the expectation of further fiscal help. Results of Oxford University’s vaccine trial are due today.
Back in the UK, Marks & Spencer may soon add to the torrent of retail jobs cuts triggered by the coronavirus recession.
My colleague Jasper Jolly explains:
Marks & Spencer is reportedly planning to cut hundreds of jobs this week in the latest blow to high street retailers hit hard by the coronavirus pandemic.
An announcement about job losses could come within days, Sky News reported, with total redundancies potentially reaching several thousand when existing restructuring plans are taken into account.
It comes at a torrid time for the British high street, with thousands of job losses announced this month. John Lewis and Boots reported 1,300 and 4,000 job losses respectively, including store closures, while companies including the Topshop owner, Arcadia, furniture chain Harveys and menswear retailer TM Lewin have confirmed plans for thousands of redundancies.
The fashion retailer Ted Baker is preparing to axe at least 500 jobs – more than a quarter of its UK workforce. This is in addition to the 160 job cuts announced in February.
EU Summit: What the City says
Mohit Kumar of Jefferies is encouraged that EU leaders are now considering the compromise proposal of €390bn of grants for Covid-19 relief.
The size of grants is lower than the initial proposal of €500bn, but the fact that the Frugal Four have dropped their opposition to any grants and agreed to €390bn is a positive.
There are still a number of issues to be agreed on, including the conditionality of funds, the rule of law, terms of loans and the veto of aid disbursements.
Neil Wilson of Markets.com points out that a deal would be historic - leaders would be agreeing to borrow collectively to finance the fund.
With the euro marking a 4-month high it looks like traders are expecting some kind of deal is done, even if it falls short of the original plan. As noted last week, this not an ordinary summit – what’s being talked about is mutual debt issuance for the first time.
A deal would mark a breakthrough for the EU and show that the bloc can respond to an era-defining crisis with one voice. Failure today is not the end of the road by any means, but it could produce a negative reaction in Euro-area sovereign debt, European equities and the euro.
Jim Reid of Deutsche Bank says Paris’s view will be crucial:
After 3 days and long nights of the extended EU recovery fund summit, the diplomatic lake in Brussels remains frozen over even if there does seem to be signs that we’ll see a thaw today.
The very latest reports this morning (although this could be out of date by the time you read) are pointing towards a possible compromise for €390bn in grants in the recovery fund. It seems much depends on whether Macron believes this to be ambitious enough. The wires have just quoted a French official as saying “France now see a path to a recovery fund deal”.
It seems we may be on hold until this afternoon though but the fact that we are still going well into a fourth day suggests a desire to get something done.
Failure to agree a rescue package would be a heavy blow for the EU - both politically and economically.
Our Brussels correspondent Jenniter Rankin writes:
The hardest-hit countries already have access to a €540bn financial cushion, but France, Germany, Italy and Spain see this as inadequate to the scale of the looming recession.
Leaving Brussels empty-handed would also be a damaging political blow, tarnishing the EU’s prestige and raising questions about its ability to act in a crisis. It would also undermine the newish leaders of the EU institutions, European commission president Ursula von der Leyen, the architect of the recovery plan, as well the European Council president, Charles Michel, the main deal broker.
Even with a deal, this bitter summit has exposed poisonous mistrust between some leaders, as well as the EU’s struggle to deal with nationalists in central Europe, who are feared to be trampling on Europe’s basic values. A few bad-tempered days in Brussels may leave political scars.
In another sign of the tension in Brussels, French President Emmanuel Macron reportedly banged his hand on the table and threatened to walk out of the discussions.
Macron’s target - the ‘frugal four’, who he accused of undermining the European Union by trying to shrink the stimulus plan.
French officials tell me President Macron “banged his fists” on the table in the early hours of Monday morning, as he told the “frugal four” that he thought they were putting the European project in danger.
An Italian diplomat said Prime Minister Giuseppe Conte told Mr Rutte: “You might be a hero in your home country for a few days. But after a few weeks you will be held responsible for blocking an effective European response to Covid-19.”
European unity was in short supply at the summit, as leaders bickered over the details of the desperately needed recovery fund.
At one point, Hungary’s prime minister, Viktor Orbán, accused Dutch PM Mark Rutte of acting like a oppressive communist ruler, for demanding oversight of how the money would be used.
Our Daniel Boffey explains:
Rutte has insisted he cannot be expected to take on extra national debt in order for the EU to make cash payments to member states without his parliament having a say.
In response, Orbán, the nationalist prime minister of Hungary, who was an anti-communist dissident in his youth, accused Rutte of aping Soviet methods to crush dissent by failing to properly set out the terms on which funds would be blocked.
The Netherlands is seeking reassurance that commonly issued debt will be properly spent and wants the ability to hold back disbursements where there are governance concerns.
“They would like to introduce a new mechanism that didn’t exist until now,” Orbán told reporters, of the Dutch proposal for a country to be able to stop funding to member states undermining the rule of law. “I think it is questionable whether it has a basis in the treaty at all. I am coming from an ex-communist country. When the communist regime decided to attack us, they use unclarified legal terms exactly as the same as written in the proposal of the Dutch man … Saying ‘general deficiencies’. When I was arrested by the police and I asked them what I had done which is illegal, they say general deficiencies. What the hell does it mean?”
Updated
Italian government bonds are also rallying this morning - suggesting that investors expect a deal on the recovery fund (eventually).
The interest rate, or yield, on Italy’s 10-year debt has fallen to 1.14%, the lowest since early March.
Italian bond yields had spiked during on March, on fears that the Covid-19 slump would drive its national debt to unsustainable levels.
Updated
The euro has also nudged a three-week high against the pound this morning, at 91.38p.
Introduction: Euro rallies despite summit woes
Good morning, and welcome to our rolling coverage of the world economy, the financial markets, the eurozone and business.
After months of lockdown, a weekend in Brussels sounds like luxury. But I fear European leaders haven’t enjoyed their sojourn in the Belgian capital, after days of sometimes bitter arguing over their €750bn Covid-19 rescue package.
The European Summit, which began on Friday morning, temporarily broke up up around dawn today without having reached a deal. Leaders are due back at 3pm BST, for yet another push.
As suspected, the so-called ‘frugal four’ of Austria, Denmark, the Netherlands and Sweden fought the plan, unhappy about extending €500bn of grants to Southern EU members who are suffering the worst economic pain from the coronavirus.
They pushed for grants (funded by borrowing on the capital markets) to be cut to €350bn, plus €350bn of loans. They also want rebates to their EU budget contributions to sweeten the pill.
Painstaking diplomatic wrangling failed to bring the two sides together -- yet. But a compromise is on the table -- to cut the grants for struggling countries such as Spain and Italy to €390bn.
Even it that was agreed, leaders need to agree how to police the policy -- what should a country pledge in return for a grant, and how is that enforced? Dutch PM Mark Rutte caused infuriation by demanding a national veto on how the cash would be spent. There’s also the small matter of agreeing a new seven-year EU budget.
Rutte struck an optimistic tone as he exited the summit this morning, telling reporters that negotiations were ‘back on track’.
Our Brussels bureau chief Daniel Boffey reports that leaders were challenged to show some much-needed unity:
At a late evening dinner, the European council president, Charles Michel, who is chairing the summit, asked the leaders whether they were “capable of building European unity and trust. Or, through a tear, will we present the face of a weak Europe, undermined by mistrust?”
Dutch prime Minister Mark Rutte said on Monday EU leaders were making progress but warned discussions could still fall apart. “At times it didn’t look good last night, but I feel that on the whole we are making progress,” Rutte told reporters in Brussels.
Summit resumed and ended after just 7 minutes at 5.52am. Leaders were told by Charles Michel that new basis for an agreement is €390bn in grants. Meeting due to resume at 1400 on Monday afternoon with expectation of new negotiating draft after everyone gets some sleep
— mehreenkhn (@MehreenKhn) July 20, 2020
Rutte also leaving to get some sleep says negotiations are "back on track" after the 5am breakthrough tonight #euco
— mehreenkhn (@MehreenKhn) July 20, 2020
This has lifted the euro -- with traders anticipating that (in the best European traditions), a seemingly intractable crisis will be resolved in the end.
The single currency has jumped by a third of a cent this morning to $1.146, its highest level since March, and not far from an 18-month peak.
Stephen Innes of AxiCorp reckons the euro has further to climb, if leader can back a compromise.
As for the EU summit, the market seems to prefer that a deal is not rushed through for the sake of appearances An agreement delay – perhaps until later in the summer – is preferable to markets than a weak agreement.
I think there is a high probability of a deal and would push EURUSD to around the 1.16 level, fuel further equity re-allocation towards Europe and provide another boost to peripheral bond markets. #forex #EURUSD long EURO could be a keeper https://t.co/2egVXIYtm3 pic.twitter.com/iFghhVdUSg
— Stephen Innes (@steveinnes123) July 20, 2020
Otherwise, it could be a quietish day in the markets, as the summer lull looms. Investors will have Covid-19 vaccines on their mind, with Oxford publishing details of their trials today.
European Opening Calls:#FTSE 6283 -0.11%#DAX 12929 +0.07%#CAC 5067 -0.04%#AEX 573 -0.13%#MIB 20339 -0.39%#IBEX 7436 -0.06%#OMX 1768 -0.11%#STOXX 3364 -0.06%#IGOpeningCall
— IGSquawk (@IGSquawk) July 20, 2020
The agenda
- 9am BST: European Central Bank vice-president Luis de Guindos speaks about Covid-19’s economic impact
- 3.30pm BST: Treasury Committee session with Bank of England policymakers Andy Haldane, Silvana Tenreyro and Jonathan Hall
Updated