Closing summary
Time for a recap, after another wild day in the markets.
World stock markets have been hit by fresh turbulence, a day after their worst rout since the financial crisis.
Fears over the coronavirus outbreak and the launch of an oil price war continue to rattle traders, leading to very volatile trading.
The day began, and ended, with optimism that the White House was planning payroll tax cuts and support for businesses hurt by the current turmoil. But in between, fears of a global downturn weighed on stocks too.
European markets closed in the red for the second day running, suffering fresh losses after their worst day since 2008. The Stoxx 600 lost almost 1% more, with Italy leading the selloff as economists predicted a deep recession this year.
Britain’s FTSE 100 also began the day strongly, rising by over 3%, but that rally fizzled out. It closed flat at 5960. a four-year low, after slumping by almost 500 points yesterday.
However, Wall Street jumped by almost 5% tonight, after president Donald Trump said his administration were helping travel and holiday companies. Last night, Trump promised a big response to the Covid-19 threat (while still playing down the scale of the crisis).
Wall Street rebounds after Monday's massive losses, gaining almost 5% Tuesday. The Dow scores its third-best point gain on record, while Nasdaq and S&P 500 see their best day in more than two years. See BU-116TU. pic.twitter.com/H4pEQA99Vj
— CNN Newsource (@CNNNewsource) March 10, 2020
According to Bloomberg, the risk of a US recession is now over 50%.
With this in mind, Trump’s White House appears to be aiming to persuade Congress to back a stimulus package to shield the economy from the fallout from the coronavirus outbreak.
According to one report, that could include assistance for the shale oil and gas production industry.
Trump also lashed out at the US central bank, calling it “pathetic” for not cutting interest rates faster.
Energy companies were in the firing line again today, with Saudi Aramco announcing plans to pump millions more barrels of oil each day - as part of a plan to drive down the oil price and put rivals out of business.
In the UK, banks promised help for small firms and mortgage holidays for consumers affected by the coronavirus outbreak, as the number of cases continues to rise.
On Wednesday, Britain’s new chancellor Rishi Sunak is expected to pledge billions of extra pounds to help the NHS, and boost infrastructure spending.
Meanwhile in Europe, officials are preparing to suspend the EU’s use-it-or-lose it rules on airport landing slots, ending the spectre of airlines running “ghost flights” with few or no passengers at all.
Thanks for reading and commenting. Goodnight! GW
Wall Street’s finest are looking more cheerful tonight, after watching stocks recover from Monday’s rout:
Speculation is mounting that Mark Carney will use his final week as governor of the Bank of England to announce a dramatic package of support for the British economy to help it through the coronavirus outbreak, my colleague Richard Partington writes.
City traders believe Threadneedle Street could announce an immediate cut in interest rates, and ease borrowing conditions for high street banks, to coincide with Rishi Sunak’s budget on Wednesday, as part of a concerted effort to help households and businesses amid the unfolding economic crisis.
Economists expect the Bank will cut interest rates by as much as 50 basis points to 0.25%, taking borrowing costs back down to the lowest level in the central bank’s 325-year history.
Does today’s Wall Street rally mean it’s time to pile into the markets again?
Not according to Oxford Economics, whose analysts urge caution.
They predict some companies (perhaps US shale producers?) will face financial problems in the coming weeks:
Specifically, investors face three key considerations: (1) continuing spread of coronavirus in the West, (2) the fall-out of the financial tightening for fragile US corporate balance sheets and weak European banks and (3) policy responses.
Only (3) is risk positive while (1) and (2) are continuing to develop. Moreover, there are legitimate doubts about whether policy response can be effective.
The key underlying vulnerability that the coronavirus-led impairment can expose and cause to unravel is US corporate sector balance-sheet weakness. Given high levels of debt, weak profitability and low interest cover, risks of corporate sector distress remain particularly high.
Bloomberg: US recession risk over 50%
Tonight’s stock market rally came despite predictions that the US economy could start shrinking this year, due to the coronavirus.
Bloomberg News’s Recession Tracker has calculated that the probability of a US downturn has jumped over 50%, based on various financial indicators, economic data and other factors.
They explain:
The surge in the recession probability reflects a sharp deterioration in financial conditions that began in mid-to-late February. As the number of cases -- and deaths -- from the rapidly spreading coronavirus increased, stocks plummeted and credit spreads widened.
The market suffered yet another blow after a collapse of OPEC+ talks led to a price war between Russia and Saudi Arabia, sinking oil prices.
It’s imminent.
— Otavio (Tavi) Costa (@TaviCosta) March 10, 2020
Bloomberg probability for a US recession just surged above 50%.
The highest since the GFC.
Remember:
% of yield curve inversions already breached the critical 70% level this cycle.
That, since 1970, never failed in predicting economic downturns. pic.twitter.com/H7VDO4kz6w
Another 1,000 point move for the Dow at the close today, but today, it was higher. Stocks closed up, recovering some of their losses from yesterday's brutal sell off. https://t.co/D3knUuQmTd pic.twitter.com/7dFKJaGAwY
— CNBC (@CNBC) March 10, 2020
Optimism that the White House might launch a stimulus programme, or take steps to support oil companies, airlines and cruise operators, drove all three Wall Street indices higher tonight.
The S&P 500 bounced by almost 5%, recovering from its 7.6% slump on Monday -- worst day since the financial crisis more than a decade ago.
But as we’ve been covering tonight, there are some doubts about president Trump’s pledge to cut taxes.
As Marketwatch puts it:
Stock-index futures found support Tuesday after President Donald Trump advocated for payroll tax relief and other measures to help businesses deal with the economic slowdown resulting from the coronavirus epidemic.
Lawmakers in both parties though expressed skepticism about a payroll-tax cut to bolster the economy.
Well done!
— IGSquawk (@IGSquawk) March 10, 2020
US Closing Prices:#DOW 25018.16 +4.89%#SPX 2882.22 +4.94%#NDX 8372.26 +5.34%#RTY 1350.89 +2.85%#VIX 46.64 -14.36% https://t.co/ZA2a2Wz58W
Wall Street rebounds
Boom! That’s last-minute scramble into stocks had helped Wall Street recover around half Monday’s crash.
The Dow has jumped by 4.89% to finish at 25,018.16 , a gain of 1,167 points.
Wall Street is ending the day with a rally!
The ‘plunge protection team’, as they’re known on Wall Street, appear to be back:
Regulators ramping up oversight of markets amid coronavirus turmoil. The President's Working Group on Financial Markets -- which we last heard from during the deep selloff at the end of 2018 -- held a call today to discuss markets, Treasury says.
— Pete Schroeder (@peteschroeder) March 10, 2020
That suggests the White House is worried about the market selloff....
Bailing out the US shale industry would be controversial - especially if the White House resists calls for more paid sick leave for workers who may have the coronavirus.
Here’s why:
BREAKING: White House likely to push federal aid for shale companies hit by coronavirus/international energy shock
— Jeffrey Stein (@JStein_WaPo) March 10, 2020
Trump confidante & oil billionaire Harold Hamm lost $2 billion yesterday. Hamm reached out to admin but says he didnt make “direct" contacthttps://t.co/GsjHIJE6VI
Also: Trump and advisers have been taking calls since Monday from energy sector allies exasperated w/ oil prices & warning against sweeping paid sick leave policy
— Jeffrey Stein (@JStein_WaPo) March 10, 2020
w/ @willenglund @StevenMufson @costareports https://t.co/GsjHIJE6VI
Washington Post is reporting that America’s shale oil producers could get a lifeline, to help them cope with the Saudi price war:
The Trump administration is "strongly considering" federal assistance for U.S. oil producers facing distress due to the steep decline in prices, the Washington Post reports.https://t.co/dREKpZZdYU
— Axios (@axios) March 10, 2020
Here’s what’s I mean about Donald Trump downplaying Covid-19 (which has now killed 4,000 people)
#NEW: President Trump gives update on meeting w/GOP congressional leaders on coronavirus response & getting tested himself:
— Jennifer Franco (@jennfranconews) March 10, 2020
"Some very good numbers coming out of some countries where it started earlier."
"I don't think its a big deal...I feel very good."pic.twitter.com/mdOMXCHnt5
Back in Washington, Donald Trump has told Republicans he favours a tax break that would run until the presidential election:
Scoop: Trump told Republican senators in private lunch that he wants a payroll tax holiday *through the November election,* sources tell me. He doesn’t want taxes to go back up before voters decide whether to return him to office. Story out soon.
— Jennifer Jacobs (@JenniferJJacobs) March 10, 2020
That might suit Trump’s electoral hopes - but it’s hardly the best and only way to protect Americans.
Especially as criticism of the White House’s approach of downplaying the virus is growing:
NEW Sen. Chuck Schumer slams Pres. Trump:
— Jennifer Franco (@jennfranconews) March 10, 2020
"I'm going to be blunt. We are very worried about the president's incompetence and lack of focus on fighting the spread of coronavirus…one word could describe thus far the administration's response: incompetence."pic.twitter.com/lRnQPOamc3
Trump just claimed there were only 600 cases of COVID-19.
— Kurt Eichenwald (@kurteichenwald) March 10, 2020
Off by more than 25%. It is up to 804. And growing faster.
Yah, I feel comfortable that the president is either not getting properly briefed or not paying attention so that he misses one-quarter of Americans infected.
Europe’s top central banker is pushing for governments to boost spending - to fight the risk of a recession this year:
ECB President Lagarde demands a rapid fiscal response from EU leaders in call $EURUSD
— DailyFX Team Live (@DailyFXTeam) March 10, 2020
A Barclays employee in New York has tested positive for Covid-19, Reuters is reporting.
Meanwhile, the World Trade Organisation (WTO) has said all meetings are suspended for 10 days, after a colleague went down with the virus (as flagged earlier -- not the WHO as I wrongly typed, sorry).
And another one. @wto suspends meetings following confirmation staff member has contracted #COVID19. Those #geneva hoteliers must be wringing their hands.
— Imogen Foulkes (@ImogenFoulkes) March 10, 2020
One of America’s largest shale oil producers has announced it is slashing its dividend, hard, following the outbreak of the oil price war.
Payouts to shareholders are being slashed by over 86%, as Occidental cuts capital spending to between $3.5 billion and $3.7 billion, from its earlier forecast of between $5.2 billion and $5.4 billion.
Occidental is also planning additional cost-cutting measures, as the slump in crude oil prices takes a massive bite out of its revenues.
Our economics editor Larry Elliott agrees that Italy faces a recession this year -- and probably a rather deep one:
With schools, universities, theatres and cinemas shut and its hugely-important tourist industry facing a washout summer, the economy is going to shrink in both the first and second quarters of 2020.
The big question is whether such a downturn creates contagion across Europe, creating another eurozone crisis:
For the rest of Europe Italy is a country that is too big to fail. So what’s really at stake is not whether Italian GDP contracts by 1.5% or 4.5% in the second quarter but whether its financial crisis proves contagious. As it might.
Charles Dumas, of TS Lombard, says: “The [Italian] banking system is unlikely to be able to remain solvent or liquid in the current conditions of nationwide lockdown. The tourist industry is effectively dead for 2020. Fiscal stimulus could be counter-productive if, as is possible, investors demand a much wider credit spread to accept fresh Italian paper. Italy will need massive support from eurozone partners to avoid going the way of Greece.
In another blow to Italy, the number of Covid-19 deaths and infections has risen sharply again:
#italy #coronavirus update: 168 more deaths in the last 24 hours, taking the total to 631. 981 more cases - up to 10,149 #COVID19
— Jonathan Samuels (@jonathansamuels) March 10, 2020
Coronavirus cases in Italy rise over 10,000 with 631 deaths
— DailyFX Team Live (@DailyFXTeam) March 10, 2020
- BBG
The human cost of this crisis (which matters much more than the financial one) is rising sharply.
Updated
Expert: Italy needs a precautionary bailout
Ashoka Mody, formally a deputy director of the International Monetary Fund’s European Department, fears that the coronavirus will trigger a deep recession in Italy this year.
He argues that policymakers should devise a precautionary bailout of €500bn to €700bn, to reassure markets that it can meet its debt obligations.
Writing on Marketwatch, he says:
The coronavirus will almost certainly cause the Italian economy to contract by about 3% in the first half of 2020, although the damage could be much larger than that.
As the Chinese economy slows down further — and very likely itself contracts— in the coming few months, the lack of Chinese supplies of critical parts and ingredients will cause continuing damage to world production and trade. That damage is spreading to Germany, which even as it struggles remains Europe’s strongest economy and an important market for Italian manufacturers.
In Italy, the virus has forced not just the lockdown of the country’s most vibrant regions — Lombardy and its fashion and finance hub in Milan, as well as large parts of Veneto and Emilia-Romagna regions — but now the entire country as of Tuesday. As people stay home and demand for services falls, the economically vulnerable — especially young Italians on precarious temporary jobs — will lose incomes, and demand will shrink further. And with one of the oldest populations in the world (about 23% of the people are above the age of 65), the coronavirus-induced illness and mortality — and the associated economic and financial stress — could persist longer than elsewhere.
On why Italy needs a large precautionary financial bailout (500 to 700 billion euros). Now. The cracks along the Italian fault line are deepening. https://t.co/wceqMmSo17
— Ashoka Mody (@AshokaMody) March 10, 2020
Traffic levels in Milan - a proxy for economic activity - has slumped in recent days as the coronavirus lockdown is imposed:
A couple weeks ago I was doing this for Wuhan and Beijing. Here's congestion/traffic data for Milan as Italy goes on lockdown: pic.twitter.com/uMeHWEfxeW
— Tracy Alloway (@tracyalloway) March 10, 2020
Trump: We're helping airlines and cruise operators
Here’s a clip of Donald Trump speaking at the White House earlier, promising (vague) help for cruise operators and airlines.
Trump says he is working with the cruise and airline industries on the coronavirus without offering any details: "We are working very closely with them. We are helping them. They're two great industries and we'll be helping them through this patch." https://t.co/TYdFuoEbec pic.twitter.com/ndGG7bhxIz
— Bloomberg TV (@BloombergTV) March 10, 2020
The CBI have compiled a handy list of questions and answers for UK businesses, to help them understand how the coronavirus affects operations.
It covers issues including whether to hold or attend conferences, travel advice, and how to help employees who are sick or need to self-isolate. Online here.
- NEW coronavirus help for businesses -@cbitweets has compiled answers to the top Frequently Asked Questions firms have on:
— Nicole Sykes (@NicoleSykes_) March 10, 2020
📢Communication
🤝Meetings, Travel & Events
👩🔧Employment
🧼Cleaning
🏭Supply Chains
💰Government & Financial Support
https://t.co/97gsBgGZ90
European markets slump into the red
Newsflash: European stock markets have closed in the red, as it fails to recover from Monday’s huge losses.
The Stoxx 600 index has provisionally ended the day down almost 1%, having been over 3% higher in early trading.
In London, the FTSE 100 subsided.... ending the day 5 points lower -- on top of the 496-point plunge yesterday. It was propped up by the pound, which has weakened by 2 cents against the US dollar (boosting exporters and multinationals).
Italy’s FTSE MIB ended the day down 3%, as economists feared its economy will shrink sharply this year, while Germany’s DAX lost 1%.
That shows that the panic which triggered yesterday’s crash has not abated. Instead, stocks have been highly volatile today -- as hopes of government stimulus packages have crashed against fears of a global downturn.
And there it is!
— Luke Kawa (@LJKawa) March 10, 2020
The Stoxx Europe 600 has never been up this much in a day -- +4.1% at its peak -- only to end up finishing the session in the red. pic.twitter.com/zHmmPqvkWg
The coronavirus has reached the World Trade Organization.
The Geneva-based organisation has confirmed that a staff member has been infected with Covid-19. “All necessary precautions” are being taken.
If the WTO follows precedent, its headquarters could soon be closed for cleaning and staff could be self-isolated.
Updated
The COVID-19 outbreak has forced the Royal Economic Society to cancel its Annual Conference.
It was due to be held at Queen’s University, Belfast from 6-8 April 2020, but has now been axed.
There is compensation for Belfast - they’ll get the 2021 annual conference instead (it is usually held at a different university each year).
Updated
News of Trump and Pence’s meeting with healthcare CEOs has dragged the US stock market back into positive territory.
But the S&P 500 is only slightly higher, having earlier surged by 3.5%.
Pence: US healthcare bosses to waive coronavirus charges
Newsflash: president Donald Trump is holding a meeting with healthcare bosses in the White House now.
Vice-president Pence is telling Trump that all the insurance companies at their meeting today have agreed they will not charge customers for Coronavirus testing, by waiving the ‘copays’ which would normally be levied.
Some states had already been insisting on free testing for Covid-19, but this announcement appears to make it a national policy.
The bosses have also agreed to extend medical coverage to include coronavirus, Pence says, and to cover telemedicine for patients, such as the elderly, who get health care at home.
These measures could encourage US citizens to be tested for the coronavirus, and protect them from medicals bills.
VP Pence notes health insurance companies are waiving cost-sharing on #coronavirus testing.
— Bertha Coombs (@berthacoombs) March 10, 2020
“We want Americans to know they are covered through private insurance.” A big question is what about the estimated 27 million Americans who are #uninsured? pic.twitter.com/8SOA1zQvkx
Trump also weighed in, saying that the US authorities will help airline companies and cruise operators.
They’re two great industries and we’ll be helping them through this patch, and so far I think it’s been going very well”
Rally fizzles out amid doubts over Trump's plan
The rally is fizzling out, as global stock markets continue to remain highly volatile.
The Dow Jones industrial average has now turned negative on Wall Street, having been up 1,000 points when it opened two hours ago.
The S&P 500 index, which was up 3.7% earlier, has now dropped back to last night’s closing levels.
Investors may be losing faith in Donald Trump’s stimulus plan, with insiders telling CNBC that it’s not written yet.
We have a plan. Press conference tomorrow. Dow up 1000. Well, not so much a plan yet. Trump might have misspoke and was early, Dow loses 2/3.
— Rich Riker (@richriker) March 10, 2020
Democratic politicians are also insisting that any coronavirus stimulus programme provides proper sick pay for workers, to help people to actually self-isolate. They’re not happy about simply pushing through tax cuts which would help the rich,
House Democratic Caucus Vice Chair Katherine Clark told reporters at a news conference that potential aid should include paid sick leave, enhanced unemployment insurance, food security and affordable testing and treatment.
So with Wall Street losing its mojo, European markets have that sinking feeling again...
rally fade, dead cat bounce it was pic.twitter.com/fxbUSRSUg9
— Neil Wilson (@marketsneil) March 10, 2020
European market rally fades
With 90 minutes to go, the European stock market rally is fizzling out.
Italy’s share index has sunk by 2%, as traders digest the implications of the nationwide lockdown announced yesterday.
British Airways and Ryanair have both cancelled all international flights to and from Italy today, which will hurt tourism revenues (although clearly the right thing).
London stocks are also fading, being dragged down by cruise operator Carnival (-4%).
FTSE heading to close below the open, still up on Monday's close but below the open = bearish and would confirm my feelings that this is a deceased feline pic.twitter.com/2o9OBOwrm5
— Neil Wilson (@marketsneil) March 10, 2020
Updated
Britain’s FTSE 100 has lost 20% of its value this year. European stocks are down 17%, while Wall Street is roughly 13% lower.
But that doesn’t necessarily mean it’s a good time to buy, argues Clark Fenton, Portfolio Manager at investment company RWC Partners. Fenton reckons many stocks are still overpriced, despite the recent rout.
“Investors should not be putting money to work yet in equities. It is too early to start buying simply on the basis that equity indices have sold off from their all-time highs. All that has happened in US equity markets, for example, is that they have gone from extremely overvalued to very overvalued, and that’s before taking into account the ultimate effect of the COVID-19’s impact on earnings. That doesn’t scream buy to us.
“In our fund equity exposure is therefore flat. We have, however, taken profits on positions that benefit from spikes in volatility, which served the fund well in February.”
Ouch! Deutsche Bank’s chief German economist has predicted that Europe’s largest economy will contract this year, due to the coronavirus.
Stefan Schneider told Reuters that German economy will probably shrink 0.2% in January-March, and a hefty 0.8% in March-June. That would push it into recession.
Newsflash: The European Union is getting ready to relax the rules which force airlines to keep flying routes, even if planes are empty, or lose their landing rights.
European Commission president Ursula von der Leyen has announced that these ‘airport slot’ regulations should be temporarily stopped.
At present, they mean airlines must operate 80% of scheduled services. But the slump in demand for flights to China and Italy, for example, make them an added burden on the industry.
Von der Leyen told reporters in Brussels that airlines, and the environment, would both benefit.
It will relieve the pressure on aviation industry and in particular on smaller airline companies”
EU Commission President @vonderleyen announces measures to help the aviation industry struggling with #CoronaVirus effects.
— Dave Keating (@DaveKeating) March 10, 2020
They can now keep airport slots even for flights that have stopped operating. This will stop them from operating empty “ghost flights” to keep slots. pic.twitter.com/LkSWAq0NQN
Back in the UK, some major media groups are practicing for the coronavirus by getting thousands of staff to work remotely later this week.
Mediacom, which is part of WPP, and Sky, will both test whether they can cope if staff are quarantined at home:
New: WPP-owned Mediacom, the UK’s biggest media buying agency with clients including Sky, Tesco, Lloyds and Adidas, has told all 1,300 staff to work from home on Friday to test working systems in case coronavirus spread necessitates offices being shutdown
— Mark Sweney (@marksweney) March 10, 2020
New: Sky has told all non-essential staff at its European HQ in Osterley, London to work from home on Thursday in coronavirus contingency planning. Only “business critical” employees - including some involved in broadcasting - of the 7,500 based there are being told to come in.
— Mark Sweney (@marksweney) March 10, 2020
Take note, business leaders.
United Airlines has revealed that its CEO and president will forgo their bases salaries through until the end of June, as fears over the coronavirus hits demand.
The airline has already announced dramatic cuts to its schedules within the US, and internationally, -- and its top brass are going to share the pain.
A precedent for others?.....
Updated
Trump: Pathetic Federal Reserve must cut interest rates
Newsflash: President Trump has launched a new assault on the US central bank, labelling it “pathetic” for not cutting interest rates more deeply.
In another example of Trump’s distain for central bank independence, he is pushing the Federal Reserve to get US interest rates down towards 0%.
Our pathetic, slow moving Federal Reserve, headed by Jay Powell, who raised rates too fast and lowered too late, should get our Fed Rate down to the levels of our competitor nations. They now have as much as a two point advantage, with even bigger currency help. Also, stimulate!
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) March 10, 2020
The Federal Reserve must be a leader, not a very late follower, which it has been!
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) March 10, 2020
Last week, the Fed announced an emergency rate cut which lowered its Funds rate to 1%-1.25% (and promptly triggered a market sell-off).
In contrast, the UK’s interest rates are 0.75%, and the eurozone is 0% (or Minus 0.5% for bank deposits at the ECB).
The Fed’s policymakers meet next week - and are likely to cut again. Indeed, the markets are now pricing in US interest rates close to zero soon.
1- stocks plunged when Fed cut 50bps last week
— Joumanna Bercetche (@CNBCJou) March 10, 2020
2- EUR has appreciated 5% in the last month
3- US rates already collapsed and are implying Fed cut to 0 anyway
Shares in some of America’s biggest companies are rallying today, but they’re still sharply lower than on Friday night:
Bull Market turns 11, despite Monday's rout
Wall Street won’t let the bull market die! Especially not on its 11th birthday.
Every stock on the Dow Jones industrial average is rallying this morning, as stocks bounce back.
Energy companies, banks and travel firms, who led yesterday’s slump, are among the top risers this morning.
Goldman Sachs are up 5.4%, followed by oil producers Chevron (+5.2%) and Exxon (+4.3%).
Last night’s selloff left the S&P 500 index down 19% from its recent peak - close to entering a Bear Market...but not quite.
The current bull market started right back on 10 March 2009, when the sell-off triggered by the financial crisis finally ended. But it would only take one more selloff to end it.
The bull market started 11 years ago today on March 9, 2009. The record run of 11 years without a 20% drawdown for the S&P 500 could end soon. #Markets can change directions quickly. It was less than 3 weeks ago when the S&P 500 was at a record high. #stocks pic.twitter.com/hiyW2yVMDE
— Cetera Investment Management (@ceteraIM) March 9, 2020
BREAKING: US stocks jump with the Dow up 870 and S&P 500 up 3.4% at the opening bell.
— Heather Long (@byHeatherLong) March 10, 2020
It's welcome relief after the worst day of losses for stocks since 2008.
But the US is still uncomfortably close to ending the 11-year bull market. https://t.co/TzvbvigrYT #stocks
Wall Street jumps at the open
NEWSFLASH: Shares are surging on Wall Street, as investors return to duty after the worst one-day slump since the dark, troubling days of 2008.
Stocks are jumping, pushing the main US indices up by around 3%. The Dow has risen by over 800 points.
That would normally be a very big move, but it doesn’t even recover half of Monday’s rout.
But still, president Trump’s promise of a stimulus programme is helping traders to regain their poise, and calming some of the fears of a global recession (even though White House insiders say the plan isn’t written yet....)
Updated
Here we go again!
US STOCKS-Wall Street set for a rebound on stimulus hopes:
— Las Finanzas (@lasfinanzas) March 10, 2020
* Energy stocks, banks set to lead rebound
* Trump's news conference due on Tuesday
* Futures up: Dow 2.99%, S&P 2.97%, Nasdaq 3.14%
Oh dear. White House insiders have been pouring some cold water on Donald Trump’s promise of a “major” economic relief package to protect the US economy from the coronavirus.
Unnamed administration officials have told CNBC that the White House is not ready to roll out specific economic proposals, such as the payroll tax cut floated by the president.
One was stunned by Trump’s claim Monday that he would hold a press conference Tuesday to announce an economic plan.
“That was news to everyone on the inside.
“It’s not there right now....A lot of details need to be worked out.”
This is pulling Wall Street futures down from their earlier highs, but we’re still expecting stocks to bounce back strongly from Monday.
Wall Street bank JPMorgan thinks the markets got carried away yesterday.
JPMorgan’s chief U.S. equity strategist Dubravko Lakos-Bujas has calculated that Monday’s slump implies a 65% to 75% chance of recession in the next 12 months.
But that’s too pessimistic, he writes:
“In our view, however, the market has gone ahead and priced in too severe of an adverse scenario, assuming we get timely and strong counter-policy response and a COVID-19 outbreak that peaks in the coming weeks.”
JPMorgan says recession risk is overblown
— Maggie Kate Fitzgerald (@mkmfitzgerald) March 10, 2020
“The market has gone ahead and priced in too severe of an adverse scenario, assuming we get timely and strong counter-policy response and a COVID-19 outbreak that peaks in the coming weeks."https://t.co/hsuUOFIucP
But those assumptions may not transpire, of course....
Updated
Not so fast, Wall Street!
Economic professor Nouriel Roubini isn’t convinced that Donald Trump will push a tax cut through Congress, as he proposed last night.
Instead, “Dr Doom” fears any US coronavirus stimulus package could become bogged down by partisan fighting on Capitol Hill.
Expect a dead cat bounce today as Trump proposes a payroll tax cut. Why would Dems accept it & damage Social Security solvency? Dems will rightly propose transfers to middle/working class folks paid with taxes on rich/corps. But Reps Senate will vote against it. Dead Cat Bounce!
— Nouriel Roubini (@Nouriel) March 10, 2020
Yesterday’s rout was the busiest day ever for investment platform AJ Bell.
And interestingly, many customers were bargain-hunting -- snapping up stocks which were suddenly much cheaper. The most popular stocks were oil giant BP and Shell, who led the tumble - and are leading today’s recovery.
Laura Suter, personal finance analyst at AJ Bell, explains:
BP saw its share price fall almost 20% yesterday, while Shell saw an 18% fall following the collapse in the oil price. While the dividends of both of these stocks may be put under pressure following the oil price fall, at current valuations the dividend yield looks very attractive for income-seeking investors.
Airlines easyJet and International Airlines Group (British Airways parent company) were both in demand too, having fallen by a quarter in recent weeks.
Suter adds:
“UK finance firms were also top of the buy list for investors, including banking giants Lloyds and Barclays, and insurance groups Aviva and Legal & General. All the companies saw a 10% fall on markets yesterday, adding to already significant falls over the past few weeks.
With the FTSE 100 up 3.5% today, those who took a punt yesterday should be sitting on profits today. But
City economists and fund managers are spending a lot of time analysing the latest statistics for Covid-19’s spread across the globe.
History professor Adam Tooze points out that China’s infections are dropping, following the extreme measures imposed by Beijing. That may explain why Italy is now quarantining its entire population.
If you believe these numbers from China, we now know what you have to do to contain a coronavirus outbreak.
— Adam Tooze (@adam_tooze) March 10, 2020
Italy seems to be drawing the necessary conclusion. @GoldmanSachs data via @SoberLook pic.twitter.com/R5qaNnJShC
Charlie Robertson, chief economist at Renaissance Capital, has also been tracking this data closely, and points out that school closures have helped curb Covid-19.
Robertson reckons the UK is roughly two weeks behind Italy, based on the current infection rates.....
Some in the markets are looking at Korea which, like China before it, seems to be controlling the #coronavirus spread. Don't. East Asians are not seeing the active case infection rate double every 3 days but Europe (even Italy still) and the US are. See next tweet pic.twitter.com/LIhfUGqL3O
— Charlie Robertson (@RencapMan) March 10, 2020
East Asia has had school shut downs for weeks which has helped. Europe/US have not which means they are following the Italy playbook. The active #coronavirus case number per 100k in Switzerland is 6 days behind Italy. All schools were closed in Italy 5 days ago ...meanwhile ..
— Charlie Robertson (@RencapMan) March 10, 2020
France and Germany are about 8-9 days behind Italy. Expect the Bundesliga to be suspended in 8 days and German schools needing to be closed in 5 days (it is a big debate in Germany already). The UK is probably 13-14 days behind Italy with implications for schools/football etc..
— Charlie Robertson (@RencapMan) March 10, 2020
The S&P 500 futures contract has now hit its limit, for the second day running.
But this time, the contract is too high! It’s not permitted to jump (or fall) by over 5%, you see.
It suggests Wall Street is going to rebound strongly from Monday’s shocker.
US Stock Futures approach 5% limit up levels!
— IGSquawk (@IGSquawk) March 10, 2020
Details on the CME's website.https://t.co/ob7Inb9nM6
Updated
RBS offers to defer mortgage and loan payments for coronavirus-hit customers
Royal Bank of Scotland is offering to defer mortgage and loan repayments for three months, for customers affected by the Covid-19 outbreak.
The bank is also making it easier for customers to access cash without penalty, to help prevent cash flow problems (as is reportedly happening in Italy too).
An RBS spokesperson explains:
“We are monitoring the potential impact of Coronavirus across all our customers to ensure we can support them appropriately through any period of disruption.
We have a strong track record in working with our customers who are affected by disruption outside of their control.
RBS says it is supporting personal customers in five ways:
- Mortgage and loan repayment deferral for up to three months
- Customers can close fixed savings accounts to access cash with no early closure charge
- Refunds on credit card cash advance fees
- Customers can apply for increased temporary credit card limit
- Customers can request an increased cash withdrawal limit of up to £500
RBS has also “proactively” contacted 5,000 business customers to offer support, it adds.
🇬🇧🏦🦠 RBS offering mortgage reprieve for those impacted by #Coronavirus
— PiQ (@PriapusIQ) March 10, 2020
ROYAL BANK OF SCOTLAND PLEDGES MORTGAGE AND LOAN REPAYMENT DEFERRAL FOR UP TO THREE MONTHS FOR CUSTOMERS IMPACTED BY CORONAVIRUS
Updated
Lloyds offers £2bn funding for SME hit by Covid-19
UK banks are taking steps to support British businesses through the economic shock of coronavirus.
Lloyds Banking Group has pledged to offer £2bn of new funding for small firms, which won’t come with any arrangement fee, to help their cashflows cope with Covid-19.
This will mean:
- No arrangement fees for new overdrafts or overdraft limit increases, for small companies
- No arrangement fees for new or increased invoice discounting and finance facilities
- In certain circumstances, repayment holidays to be provided, to those businesses impacted the most
These measure should help fundamentally healthy firms cope with a short-term hit, if the UK imposes significant quarantine measures in the weeks and months ahead.
David Oldfield, group director for commercial banking at Lloyds Banking Group said:
“We fully understand how worrying these times are for business owners, concerned not only about their and their own family’s health and wellbeing, but also of their employees. They are also worried what the outbreak might mean for their business and with no knowledge of how or when they might be affected.
As our customers face into such uncertainty, we want to provide reassurance to them that, if needed, we are here to help with additional working capital to get them through temporary interruptions to their business and to their cashflow.”
Standard Life creates 'red' and 'blue' teams, to ride out Covid-19
Standard Life, one of the UK’s biggest investment companies, has suspended all international travel as it tries to deal with the coronavirus outbreak.
The Edinburgh-based fund manager has also split its investment and functions staff into red and blue teams in Asia Pacific, with some working from home and others working in the office – and they have their temperature checked twice a day.
The firm is rolling this out in the UK and the US in the coming weeks.
Standard Life boss Keith Skeoch revealed this as he warned of more market turbulence this year. He said yesterday’s heavy sell-off was driven by “pure panic”. He noted that markets have priced in a global recession, but said how western countries deal with the virus outbreak will be crucial.
If they are “as good as China” in containing the epidemic, we could get a short, sharp downturn followed by an economic recovery in six months’ time.
Just in: Iraq has followed Saudi’s lead, by cutting oil prices.
Iraq lowers April crude pricing to Europe by $4-5/bbl and lowers April crude pricing to US by $2.5-3/bbl
— DailyFX Team Live (@DailyFXTeam) March 10, 2020
After falling into a bear market yesterday, today’s rally might drag European stocks out again.
UBS on where we're at on European markets:
— Katie Martin (@katie_martin_fx) March 10, 2020
"European equities are now down 21% from the February 19 peak. This is one of the largest corrections in the last 30 years outside a sustained Bear market and has taken place in half the usual time."
Wall Street to rally after worst day since 2008
Wall Street is set to rebound today, partly thanks to Donald Trump’s promise of tax cuts to support the US economy through the coronavirus crisis.
The Dow and S&P 500 are UP 4% in pre-market trading, after both sliding almost 8% yesterday.
This is driving European markets higher now, with France’s CAC, Germany’s DAX and Italy’s FTSE MIB now up 3%.
But tax cuts won’t fix a healthcare crisis, as analyst Ricardo Evangelista of ActivTrades points out:
The dollar bounced back against other major currencies following political statements from the White House that showed a willingness to act, through concerted economic policies, to mitigate the fallout from the coronavirus crisis.
The focus of the markets is very unlikely to divert from the virus’ impact on the public health and economic prospects of several countries, including of course Italy, but also, and crucially, the United States, where some suspect the numbers of infected may be much higher than the figures published so far indicate.
Some of yesterday’s anxiety was driven by the fear of seeing the US finding itself in a situation similar to that already witnessed in China and Italy. The next few days will determine if today’s rebound in the market is to continue, or if it is not more than the proverbial ‘dead cat bounce’.
Saudi Aramco confirms oil price war is on
Saudi Aramco, the Kingdom’s oil giant, has confirmed that it is flooding the markets with crude.
From April 1, Aramco will offer customers 12.3m barrels of oil per day, up from 10m bpd previously, it says.
This is confirmation that Saudi Arabia is launching a price war against rivals, after Russia refused to back Opec’s proposed output cuts last week. That move was a major cause of Monday’s rout.
That’s 300,000 barrels per day MORE than Aramco’s ‘maximum sustained capacity’ -- implying that Saudi authorities plan to reduce their own oil reserves, to fuel the price war (having already driven the price down 20% yesterday).
Energy analyst: "The output hike puts Aramco supply above its maximum sustainable capacity, indicating that the kingdom is even tapping its strategic inventories to dump as much crude, and as quickly, as possible onto the market."
— Paul McNamara (@M_PaulMcNamara) March 10, 2020
It’s a blow to the new wave of US shale oil producers. Their shares plunged yesterday, some by almost 50%, on fears that the industry won’t cope with oil below $40 per barrel.
Energy analyst Gregory Bree explains:
US shale has changed the whole global oil picture. But companies are drowning in debt. The squeeze started late last year, as Wall Street started pressing firms to tighten up and impose some fiscal discipline. Folks expected in 2020 to see the pace of growth in the US patch slow.
— Gregory Brew (@gbrew24) March 8, 2020
But what we might see now is a bloodbath. Gas prices have been floating between $50-60 all year. Most companies can turn a profit at that level. But now prices are in the $40s, with the Saudi surge likely to send them into the $30s. The impact will be massive.
— Gregory Brew (@gbrew24) March 8, 2020
Economically, this could get very bad for Texas and North Dakota, where the oil and gas industry carries a lot of weight. Most companies are hedged, so even sweeping bankruptcies or defaults might not produce economic impacts—a shale bubble might not impact the broader US economy
— Gregory Brew (@gbrew24) March 8, 2020
Updated
Britain’s index of mid-sized companies, the FTSE 250, has jumped by 3% this morning - recovering half of Monday’s slump.
The technology, telecoms, industrial, consumer cyclical and healthcare sectors are leading the rally.
Italy 'to suspend mortgage payments'
Reuters is reporting that mortgage payments are be suspended across Italy, as part of Rome’s measures to tackle the coronavirus outbreak.
That would help families cope with the economic cost of the quarantine measures being imposed, which will hurt some sectors such as retail and tourism.
Here’s the story:
Payments on mortgages will be suspended across the whole of Italy after the coronavirus outbreak, Italy’s deputy economy minister said on Tuesday.
“Yes, that will be the case, for individuals and households,” Laura Castelli said in an interview with Radio Anch’io, when asked about the possibility.
Italy’s banking lobby ABI said on Monday lenders representing 90% of total banking assets would offer debt moratoriums to small firms and households grappling with the economic fallout from Italy’s coronavirus outbreak.
Here’s some instant reaction:
Crikey!
— Andy Bruce (@BruceReuters) March 10, 2020
ITALY'S DEPUTY ECONOMY MINISTER CASTELLI SAYS PAYMENTS ON MORTGAGES TO INDIVIDUALS AND HOUSEHOLDS WILL BE SUSPENDED ACROSS WHOLE OF ITALY AFTER CORONAVIRUS OUTBREAK
This is how you do fiscal support in a health crisis. Mortgage relief for households, not tax breaks for companies. Well done, Italy. Britain, take note. https://t.co/ZZgWFirT6f
— (((🕷Frances Coppola, Philosopher ))) (@Frances_Coppola) March 10, 2020
WE'RE ALL GOING ON A... MORTGAGE HOLIDAY!
— Stanley Pignal (@spignal) March 10, 2020
Italy pulling out the big guns by suspending mortgage payments. Seems like a very questionable policy to me: well intentioned but kicks up a lot of issues. https://t.co/l9XepzjD8b
Nearly every stock on the FTSE 100 is up this morning. Quite a contrast with Monday, when virtually everything was down.
The coronavirus crisis is forcing more and more conferences to be postponed, my colleague Mark Sweney reports, on top of Informa’s warning this morning.
And another one goes: London-based Advertising Week Europe moves to September https://t.co/nK4wuLs352
— Mark Sweney (@marksweney) March 10, 2020
Future has postponed The Photography Show and The Homebuilding & Renovating Show, both at NEC Birmingham, due to coronavirus. Both will take place later this year. The company, which owns brands from Techradar to Metal Hammer, says overall there will be no impact on profits
— Mark Sweney (@marksweney) March 10, 2020
Informa, world’s biggest event company, has rescheduled or cancelled almost 130 events valued at £425m.
— Mark Sweney (@marksweney) March 10, 2020
Updated
Just a dead cat bounce?
The UK FTSE 100 is pushing higher, as the recovery in London gathers pace.
The Footsie is now up 121 points or 2% (which recovers roughly a quarter of yesterday’s losses).
It’s being led by miners and oil companies, following the recovery in the crude price this morning.
But European markets are lagging behind, with Italy’s FTSE MIB only 0.6% higher today. It crashed by 11% yesterday.
It’s not unusual to see the markets rise after a day of heavy falls -- and it doesn’t mean the crisis is over.
As Kit Juckes of Societe Generale puts it:
The expression ‘dead cat bounce’ was invented for mornings like this.
Neil Wilson of Markets.com agrees:
European stock markets looked to recover some ground early on Tuesday on hopes of a round of stimulus measures as the market tried to rally the troops after the rout of Black Monday.
Investors are licking wounds and there is a stabilisation of the rout, but this looks like a short-term bounce on oversold levels, not a meaningful turn.
It smells like a dead cat. The stimulus is coming, but the situation on the ground gets worse. It seems comments from Donald Trump, and overnight some emollient tones from the Japanese authorities, are helping.
Japan is expected to announce a second stimulus package to combat the coronavirus later today.
Updated
The wild losses of Crash Monday dominate today’s UK newspaper front pages:
Tuesday's Guardian: "Stock markets in biggest fall since 2008 as virus fears trigger panic selling" #BBCPapers #TomorrowsPapersToday (via @hendopolis) pic.twitter.com/EiI8DPcanf
— BBC News (UK) (@BBCNews) March 9, 2020
Global markets plunge amid coronavirus fears#TomorrowsPapersToday @hendopolis pic.twitter.com/7On1WXbAJt
— The Times Pictures (@TimesPictures) March 9, 2020
Tomorrow’s @CityAM front page after an oil spat sends global markets into a downward spiral #tomorrowspaperstoday pic.twitter.com/jhrQLWYSim
— Andy Silvester (@silvesterldn) March 9, 2020
TELEGRAPH BUSINESS: Trillions of pounds wiped off global stock markets #TomorrowsPapersToday pic.twitter.com/KiOe8FrOL4
— Neil Henderson (@hendopolis) March 9, 2020
Tuesday's FT: "Oil price plunge sends tremors through battered global markets" #BBCPapers #TomorrowsPapersToday (via @hendopolis) pic.twitter.com/cfTQlvXZYS
— BBC News (UK) (@BBCNews) March 9, 2020
Conference giant Informa hit by coronavirus
Informa, the world’s largest exhibition company, has postponed or cancelled almost 130 events worth £450m in revenue due to the coronavirus outbreak.
The company, which has already suffered a £1bn drop in its market value since the start of the year as a result of share price falls, said that its events arm accounts for about 65% of £2.9bn in total group revenues.
Stephen Carter, chief executive of the FTSE 100 company, says:
“We are facing a 2020 impact from COVID-19 in our events-related businesses and so we have used our strong customer and supplier relationships to swiftly deploy a material postponement programme shifting our events calendar to later dates in 2020,”
This morning’s rally has lifted Brent crude by over 5% this morning, to $36.29 per barrel.
That suggests markets are coming to terms with Saudi Arabia’s threat to flood the market with cheap oil, but still close to yesterday’s four-year low:
Europe opens higher
Newsflash: Stocks are rising in Europe at the start of trading, as investors try to put Monday’s rout behind them.
In London, the FTSE 100 has gained 73 points, or 1.2% -- a small improvement on Monday’s 7.7% slump.
Mining companies such as Rio Tinto (+4.5%) and Anglo American (+3%) are among the risers,.
Oil giants BP (+3.5%) and Shell (+4%) are also gaining, after losing almost 20% each yesterday. They’re benefitting from a recovery in the oil price today - up 5% (after tumbling over 20% yesterday).
The EU-wide Stoxx 600 index is up 1%, with Germany gaining 0.9% and France up 1.3%.
Asia-Pacific stocks jump as Xi visits Wuhan
Asia-Pacific stocks have clawed back some of Monday’s huge losses, amid hopes that China’s coronavirus crisis may be easing
- Australia’s S&P 500 has jumped by over 3% today, having slumped by 7% yesterday.
- Japan’s Nikkei, which fell 5% yesterday, has gained 0.85%.
- China’s Shanghai Composite index recovered more than half of Monday’s 3% slide, with a 1.8% bounce
Traders were cheered to see China’s president Xi Jinping visiting Wuhan today, meeting frontline medical workers, military, community staff, local party officials and residents. That could be a sign that Beijing thinks it’s winning the battle.
Updated
Trump: Workers shouldn't be penalised over Covid-19
Faced with Wall Street’s worst day in a decade, Donald Tump tried to assure Americans last night that he would tackle the economic impact of coronavirus.
He told reporters that:
- His administration would ask Congress to pass payroll tax relief and other quick measures.
- He would seek help for hourly-wage workers to ensure they’re “not going to miss a paycheck” and “don’t get penalized for something that’s not their fault”.
Trump continued to argue that Covid-19 had caught everyone on the hop (even though the first US case was reported back on 25 January).
This blindsided the world, and I think we’ve handled it very, very well, they’ve done a great job.
But Trump refused to respond to questions about whether he’d been tested himself.
That’s not an idle question. Several members of his political circle are currently self-quarantining after they came into contact with a man later diagnosed with the disease, CNN reports. It’s not escaped anyone’s notice that Trump, along with Democratic rivals Joe Biden and Bernie Sanders, are all in the 70+ age bracket susceptible to the virus.
Introduction: Turnaround Tuesday after Crash Monday?
Good morning, and welcome to our rolling coverage of the world economy, the financial markets, the eurozone and business.
After their worst day since the financial crisis, European and US stock markets are expected to rebound from Crash Monday today.
Investors are catching their breath, counting their losses, and hoping that governments will step up and protect their economies from the coronavirus threat.
Last night, president Trump signalled that he’s considering providing tax relief to companies who are struggling with the impact of Covid-19.
Trump, who’s under fire for downplaying the virus, said he was planning “a timely and effective response to the coronavirus.”
He told reporters:
“We are to be meeting with House Republicans, [Senate majority leader] Mitch McConnell, and discussing a possible payroll tax cut or relief, substantial relief, very substantial relief.”
Any sign that Trump is taking Covid-19 more seriously is welcome, given criticism that US authorities were slow to test citizens and quarantine them.
But a tax cut will not protect people from the virus, or stop it spreading. And it will not encourage consumer spending if people are too scared to visit the shops -- or are quarantined anyway.
Other governments are devising stimulus measures too. Yesterday, Ireland announced a €3bn package that will include more health spending and early sick pay for all workers.
But after Monday’s losses, investors are deeply concerned that coronavirus will become a pandemic - inflicting significant economic harm (as well as many more deaths and illnesses around the globe).
Yesterday’s rout ended with the FTSE 100 at a four-year low, down almost 7.7% at 5965 -- wiping out £125bn off leading stocks.
Wall Street had a shocker too, with the Dow ending down 2,000 points or over 7%. We’ve not seen such wipeouts since the aftermath of Lehman Brothers collapse.
Our story on tomorrow’s front page after a chaotic day for global stock markets, w/ @graemewearden https://t.co/fsaUYYPCZe
— Richard Partington (@RJPartington) March 9, 2020
The markets are also still coming to terms with the oil price war triggered by Saudi Arabia over the weekend, which wiped nearly a fifth of BP and Royal Dutch Shell last night.
We’ll be tracking all the action through the day....
The agenda
10am GMT: Eurozone fourth-quarter GDP