Britain’s FTSE 100 has shaken off its earlier losses to end the day slightly higher.
The blue-chip Footsie has closed 9 points higher at 6,721.
Those dovish comments from New York Fed chair John Williams seem to have provided a smidgen of festive cheer. The Dow is still up, a little, too.
Connor Campbell of SpreadEx says:
The Dow Jones attempted to put a star on top of December’s rotting Christmas tree on Friday afternoon.
The thrust of the Dow’s sizeable gains came following a somewhat reassuring interview with Federal Reserve Bank of New York President John Williams on CNBC. Williams claimed that the Fed is ‘listening’, and that ‘there are risks to that outlook that maybe the economy will slow further’.
Investors seemingly took this to mean that the central bank could hike rates less frequently than forecast in 2019, sending the Dow 300 points higher and back to 23150, having hit a 14 month nadir of 22600 at its lowest point on Thursday.
That may be all for today. We’ll be back on Monday, when traders will hope to finally see a Santa Rally. GW
Newsflash: Federal Reserve Bank of New York President John Williams has said that the central bank could reassess its interest rate policy and balance sheet reduction in the new year if the economy slows.
Williams told CNBC that:
“We are listening, there are risks to that outlook that maybe the economy will slow further.”
That could be a signal to the markets not to panic, after the Fed predicted two interest rate hikes in 2019 -- more than investors expected.
William’s comments are going down well on the New York stock exchange -- the Dow is now up 350 points, or 1.55%. at 23,210.
Dow extends jump, up more than 315 points after Fed's John Williams says on CNBC that balance sheet runoff is not inflexible & that the Fed could reevaluate its view in 2019 https://t.co/xCFzj3PnR4 pic.twitter.com/1Qp1FWGHbt
— CNBC Now (@CNBCnow) December 21, 2018
European stock markets are ending the week on a low note.
The Stoxx 600 is down 0.33%, on track for a new two-year closing low.
Guy Foster, Head of Research at Brewin Dolphin, said:
“The market has been weak during the final quarter of 2018, as volatility has picked up. We see this as a symptom of monetary policy being tightened at an accelerating pace, which occurred simultaneously across the world’s major economies. That has drawn liquidity away from global equity markets, causing stocks to fluctuate further from their fundamental valuations than they had when monetary policy was loose. However, in our view, interest rates and bond yields still represent poor compensation for risk relative to equities.
Oil is also suffering in the rout, with Brent crude down 2% at just $53.26 per barrel, That’s its lowest level since September 2017 -- a boost to consumers.
Foster explains how a weak oil price can help the global economy:
“Meanwhile, falls in energy costs will act as an effective tax cut to consumers and businesses around the world, as it did during the last bout of volatility in 2016. Lower cost inflation should therefore set the stage for a recovery in economic activity and further profit growth into 2019.
Capital Economics also believe the US Federal Reserve blundered on Wednesday when it raised American interest rates to up to 2.5%.
They say:
The clear view in financial markets in the wake of the December FOMC meeting is that any further rate hikes over the coming months are likely to be reversed in 2020.
Our long-held forecast is that a sharp slowdown in economic growth next year will prompt the Fed to cut rates by 75bp in the first half of 2020, more than markets are currently pricing in.
Bloomberg’s Lisa Abramowicz explains why Wall Street is worried about Washington gridlock....
Traders don't really care about the impending government shutdown, but they're worried about what such gridlock means for the debt-ceiling battle early next year. https://t.co/ruHQVJSaww
— Lisa Abramowicz (@lisaabramowicz1) December 21, 2018
Washington chaos looms over Wall Street
Ding ding! Wall Street is open for business, on the final day of a brutal week for stocks,.
The Dow Jones industrial average has risen by around 0.5% in early trading, or 121 points to 22,981.
It’s still more than a thousand points down for this week, though, or over 4%.
The prospect of the US federal government shutting down tonight, if the Senate won’t approve funding for Donald Trump’s wall, is casting a shadow over the New York stock exchange.
Wall Street bank sums up the mood in pre-open note: "Sentiment still miserable; more Washington chaos"
— James Pethokoukis (@JimPethokoukis) December 21, 2018
A trillion here, a trillion there, and eventually all these stock market losses add up....
GLOBAL STOCK MARKET CAP LOSS SINCE JANUARY IS $16.7 TRILLION - BAML
— Quantitative Trading (@fiquant) December 21, 2018
New economic data just released has confirmed that the US economy grew pretty steadily in the third quarter of 2018.
Q3 GDP growth has been revised down very slightly to an annualised rate of 3.4%, from 3.5%.
That’s more rapid than the UK, whose quarterly growth of 0.6% equates to 2.4% on an annualised basis. It’s nearly three times as fast as France.
U.S. GDP grew 3.4% in third quarter instead of 3.5% https://t.co/HzPI58gA2Q
— MarketWatch (@MarketWatch) December 21, 2018
Updated
Lukman Otunuga, Research Analyst at FXTM, says risk-taking is off the menu this Christmas, as investors digest Donald Trump’s threat to shut down the US government:
The pain felt across global equity markets intensified today as growing fears of a U.S. government shutdown crippled risk sentiment.
It has been a remarkably terrible trading week for financial markets amid concerns over rising U.S. interest rates, decelerating global growth, Brexit uncertainty and chaos in Washington. The absence of appetite for risk was clearly reflected in Asia this morning as stocks closed broadly lower. In Europe, shares are trading in a depressed fashion and this negative mood is likely to infect Wall Street this afternoon. With geopolitical risk factors weighing heavily on investor confidence, financial markets remain at threat of concluding 2018 on a risk-off tone.
Two days after the Federal Reserve raised US interest rates, a growing band of investors reckon the Fed will be forced to CUT in 2020.
Market-based probability of #Fed cutting rates in 2020 gaining momentum pic.twitter.com/Qn6BdtVC8B
— Liz Ann Sonders (@LizAnnSonders) December 21, 2018
That suggests pessimism over the outlook for the American economy, amid chatter of a slowdown, or even a recession.
Wall Street is expected to suffer further losses when trading begins in a couple of hours.
The S&P 500 is being called down 0.5% in the futures market, as investors worry that the US government could face a partial shutdown.
The US Senate is expected to reject a finance bill that includes $5.7bn funding for a wall on the Mexican border -- as long-demanded by Donald Trump. That’s because the measure needs a 60 votes to pass, and the Republicans only have 51 seats at present.
President Trump is awake and tweeting that he would refuse to sign the spending bill unless the Senate passes the bill (which was rapidly reworked yesterday)
No matter what happens today in the Senate, Republican House Members should be very proud of themselves. They flew back to Washington from all parts of the World in order to vote for Border Security and the Wall. Not one Democrat voted yes, and we won big. I am very proud of you!
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) December 21, 2018
The Democrats, whose votes we need in the Senate, will probably vote against Border Security and the Wall even though they know it is DESPERATELY NEEDED. If the Dems vote no, there will be a shutdown that will last for a very long time. People don’t want Open Borders and Crime!
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) December 21, 2018
Shutdown today if Democrats do not vote for Border Security!
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) December 21, 2018
These tweets are from yesterday, but they largely sum up the mood in the markets today:
“The tone [this am] isn’t so much bullish or bearish but rather defeated and demoralized. The Fed on Wed was the SPX’s last hope for 2018 and with the decision disappointing there isn’t a single towel not now lying on the mat, bloodied and exhausted.” - JPM trading note
— Carl Quintanilla (@carlquintanilla) December 20, 2018
There it is. pic.twitter.com/tHaYzt0FcI
— Carl Quintanilla (@carlquintanilla) December 20, 2018
Back in the financial markets, shares are deeper in the red as the sell-off gathers pace.
All the European indices are now down today, hitting new two-year lows.
Mihir Kapadia CEO and Founder of Sun Global Investments, says gloom is everywhere as a grim week draws to a close.
“As Christmas approaches, market sentiment remains very negative. Global stocks have had a terrible December (S&P 500 and Dow are down 10% and 12% in in the month) as issues such as the ongoing US-China trade dispute as well as the prospect of a US government shutdown have added to the pessimism.
Following a slide on Wall Street in yesterday’s session, Asian markets have traded lower, with European stocks following suit on opening.
*EURO STOXX 50 EXTENDS LOSSES, SET TO ENTER BEAR MARKET
— 𝔏emasabachthani (@lemasabachthani) December 21, 2018
Economist Sam Tombs has spotted another warning sign in today’s data dump:
Remember those kind strangers who invested in the U.K. #DespiteBrexit? Well, they aren't any longer. Investment in the UK by non-residents fell in Q2 and Q3. We still need the finance (current account deficit = 5% of GDP), but we now have to sell overseas assets to pay for it pic.twitter.com/JTwJ0rVU0d
— Samuel Tombs (@samueltombs) December 21, 2018
There’s been quite a deluge of UK data this morning.
The latest national accounts (the growth figures) and public finances (borrowing) were both being released, plus breakdowns of business spending and consumer trends.
Our cup runneth over..... rather too messily for the FT’s Chris Giles:
Having waded through all these releases from @ONS today, there has to be a better way of releasing this information
— Chris Giles (@ChrisGiles_) December 21, 2018
- the number of clicks needed is absurd
- sometimes it's vital to go to the PDF, others not - crazy
- far too much information for one day
Please think again
At the very least - ONS could have scheduled public finances on a different day to national accounts
— Chris Giles (@ChrisGiles_) December 21, 2018
Both are complicated releases
The split of quarterly national accounts from the sectoral accounts is unhelpful. A balanced set of GDP figures on one day in one release is what users need
— Chris Giles (@ChrisGiles_) December 21, 2018
Business investment details, flow of funds, balance of payments can be done on different days. That would be helpful
I have made these points before to @ONS and was told it was useful feedback and they would think again. (That was September 2017)
— Chris Giles (@ChrisGiles_) December 21, 2018
But it is becoming clear that "think again" meant "la la la, we're not listening"
Sometimes you wonder who ONS think they are trying to serve
Still, here’s what we’ve learned:
- Real UK gross domestic product (GDP) is estimated to have increased by an unrevised 0.6% in Quarter 3 (July to Sept) 2018, while real GDP growth in 2017 has been revised up from 1.7% to 1.8%.
- Households, corporations and government all continue to be net borrowers in Quarter 3 2018, borrowing or running down their savings to finance their spending and investment, financed by the rest of the world being a net lender to the UK.
- The current account deficit widened to 4.9% in the latest quarter, financed primarily by a net inflow of portfolio investment, mainly reflecting equity investment, while there has been a divestment of the net acquisition of financial assets and the net incurrence of financial liabilities in each of the last two quarters.
Better news: Britain’s budget deficit (the gap between government spending and income) has narrowed.
The UK borrowed £7.2bn to balance the books last month, £900m less than in November 2017. That’s the smallest deficit for any November since 2004.
This means that the UK has borrowed £32.8bn so far this year, £13.6bn less than in the same period in 2017, and the lowest year-to-date for 16 years.
It’s a brighter picture than the current account deficit.....
Festive cheer for #Chancellor as November budget deficit (measured in terms of Public Sector Net Borrowing excluding Banks) narrowed to £7.2bn from £8.1bn a year earlier; lowest November shortfall for 14 years. Also helping #Hammond October’s deficit was revised down markedly (1
— Howard Archer (@HowardArcherUK) December 21, 2018
Howard Archer of EY Item Club is concerned by today’s data:
Disappointing & potentially worrying news saw #UK #current #account deficit widen markedly to 2-year high of £26.5bn (4.9% of GDP) in Q3 from £20.0bn (3.8% of GDP) in Q2 & £17.8 bn (3.4% of GDP) in Q1. This was the largest deficit for 2 years
— Howard Archer (@HowardArcherUK) December 21, 2018
UK household savings shrink as real incomes stagnate
Another alarming development: UK real household disposable income stagnated in the last quarter, even though earnings rose.
The ONS reports that inflation and increased payments of self-employment tax offset strong wage growth in July-September. This meant households didn’t actually have any more money to spend
This squeeze forced people to borrow more money to make ends meet.
As a result, the UK households saving ratio fell to its joint third lowest on record to 3.8%, down from 4.1% in the previous quarter.
Households spent more than they earned in Q3 2018, for the eighth quarter in a row https://t.co/pM6VG3RTgW pic.twitter.com/xGcuVb0Ko2
— ONS (@ONS) December 21, 2018
The slump in business spending suggests bosses are unwilling to buy new warehouses, offices and machinery until they have clarity about Brexit.
This chart, from the ONS, shows how UK business investment contracted last quarter -- by 1.1% to £46.9bn.
Over the last 12 months, business investment has declined by 1.8%. It has contracted for three quarters in a row; the first time in a decade.
Some early reaction to the UK’s disappointing balance of payments:
Are the benefits of sterling's post-referendum depreciation wearing off? UK current account is heading deeper into deficit. 4.9% of GDP in Q3 https://t.co/KF7cenxCKE pic.twitter.com/BAEO4Prpw2
— Ed Conway (@EdConwaySky) December 21, 2018
UK current account in surplus for the first....just kidding. It's a deficit. And a big one. -4.9% of GDP as both trade & income deficits widen. Services trade bedind the widening trade deficit, while on the income side, it was foreign-owned UK companies repatriating profits. pic.twitter.com/lUbPqOKy9z
— Rupert Seggins (@Rupert_Seggins) December 21, 2018
UK balance of payments worst since 2016
Ouch! Britain’s current account deficit has widened to its worst level in over two years.
New figures show that the gap between what the UK trades with the rest of the world, plus investment flows, widened by £6.6bn to £26.5bn in July to September.
That’s 4.9% of gross domestic product (GDP) – the largest deficit recorded since Quarter 3 2016 in both value and percentage of GDP terms.
This effectively measures the flow of money in and out of the UK.
So what went wrong? According to the Office for National Statistics, there are two main causes:
- UK’s trade balance worsened - a drop in the service sector surplus pushed the trade deficit up by £1.8bn to £8.8bn
- The primary income balance deficit worsened by £3.6bn to £11.1bn, as foreign investors received larger profits on their UK assets.
Updated
Good news! Britain was one of the best-performing major economies in the last quarter.
Bad news! That’s not as impressive as it sounds....
UK GDP growth unrevised at 1.5%y/y (or 0.6%q/q) in the third quarter of 2018. UK the third fastest growing of the G7 economies in Q3 behind the US and Canada, but since 5 of the 7 make up the slowest growing OECD economies, that's not a high bar. pic.twitter.com/Q9wTptlcJv
— Rupert Seggins (@Rupert_Seggins) December 21, 2018
Not a good sign for 2019 growth...
UK business investment fell 1.1% in Q3. Third fall in a row - the first time we've had three successive quarters of shrinking biz investment since the financial crisis pic.twitter.com/dRHA3v5gFa
— Ed Conway (@EdConwaySky) December 21, 2018
Today’s GDP report also show that Britain’s services sector grew by 0.5% in the last quarter (revised up from 0.4%).
Industrial production rose by 0.6% (revised down from 0.8%) and construction grew by 2.3% (revised up from 2.1%).
Business investment fell, though, by 1.1%.
Updated
The Office for National Statistics has confirmed that the UK economy grew by 0.6% in the third quarter of this year, matching earlier estimates.
That’s a relief; there were concerns that growth could have been downgraded.
It’s been a tough year for stock pickers.
Britain’s stock market has shed around 13% of its value this year, taking a bite out of many portfolios.
Russ Mould, AJ Bell Investment Director, explains:
“For the year to date, just six of the 39 industrial groupings which make up the FTSE All-Share are showing a gain and the best performer, Technology Hardware, has a market cap of less than £1 billion, so it is so small as to be barely relevant.
Here’s the damage:
Santa has better get his stakes on, if he’s going to bring any cheer to the City.
As Connor Campbell of SpreadEx puts it:
Santa remained on holiday this Friday, the European markets opening in a Christmassy shade of red following yet another disastrous session for the Dow Jones.
With the Dow now under 23000 for the first time in 14 months, Europe stood little chance of bucking the bah humbug trend as trading got underway.
The biggest fallers in London this morning include utility company Severn Trent (-1.9%), communications group Vodafone (-1.8%) and consumer goods giant Reckitt Benckiser (-1.5%).
Housebuilders are having a better morning, with Barratt Development, Taylor Wimpey and Persimmon all gaining at least 1%.
At the risk of overdoing the gloom, UK consumer confidence has hit its lowest level in five years.
Brexit uncertainty is being blamed after the GfK index of consumer morale fell to -14 in December, down from -13 in the previous month and -10 in October.
People are particularly anxious about economic prospects - expectations for the economy over the next 12 months tumbled to its lowest since December 2011.
Horrible UK consumer morale numbers.
— Andy Bruce (@BruceReuters) December 21, 2018
Economic confidence weakest since 2011.https://t.co/kcRNWfzgiS pic.twitter.com/j8NjyxWfMb
This isn't an erratic reading.
— Andy Bruce (@BruceReuters) December 21, 2018
Here's the GfK survey overlaid with the % of people who think the economy locally is going to worse, from the latest Thomson Reuters/IPSOS consumer sentiment survey. pic.twitter.com/owljDZZB2e
Updated
European stock markets have opened in the red, as the sell-off continues.
The Stoxx 600 index has lost another 0.35%, following last night’s losses on Wall Street.
Only Britain’s FTSE 100 is defying gravity; it’s up by 6 measly points.
Another blow: French business confidence has fallen to a two-year low this month, according to statistics body INSEE.
INSEE’s survey of business morale dropped to 102 this month, down from 103 in November, which is the weakest reading since November 2016.
It suggests that the protests that have gripped Paris in recent weeks have worried business leaders, coming on top of trade war worries.
French growth revised down
Disappointing news: French growth in the third quarter of 2018 has been revised down, from 0.4% to 0.3%.
That’s still faster than the eurozone average, of just 0.2% in July-September, but it won’t please policymakers in Paris.
It follows lacklustre growth of just 0.2% in both January-March, and April-June.
It’s been a rough year for the eurozone’s second largest member, especially as the ‘yellow vest’ protests mean growth probably slowed in recent weeks.
#France #GDP Growth Rate QoQ Final at 0.3% https://t.co/YZQGQp1rmQ pic.twitter.com/rfhuHIm9Qe
— Trading Economics (@tEconomics) December 21, 2018
It’s been a “horrible” quarter for the financial markets, says Craig Erlam of City firm OANDA.
He points out that many markets have fallen from record highs into correction territory (-10%) or even a full-blown bear markets (-20%).
We’ve gone from undeterred optimism to widespread pessimism in such a short period of time – as is often the case – and there clearly isn’t much appetite just yet to try and catch this particular falling knife.
The Trump administration’s continued hard-line approach with China isn’t helping matters and the prospect of a government shutdown isn’t doing the situation much good either.
Chinese investors have endured a rough December:
Chinese stocks drop, with the large-cap CSI 300 Index falling for a sixth day https://t.co/gBvGirCAHt pic.twitter.com/n0er8TBMef
— Bloomberg (@business) December 21, 2018
They’re not alone either... al the major indices have suffered this autumn:
Since 2/10/18 Global indices have lost following values - DJIA -14.7%, S&P -15.6%, NASDAQ -18.4%, FTSE -9.6%, DAX -13.6%, CAC -14.1%, Hang Seng -5.4%, Shanghai Comp -11.3%, NIKKEI -16.9% - Quite a correction!
— David Buik (@truemagic68) December 21, 2018
This is a worrying sign: the VIX volatility index, which measures how fearful investors are, has hit its highest level since February.
fear in markets is back @markets #markets pic.twitter.com/XimUfUDdB3
— neil chatterjee (@neilrchatterjee) December 21, 2018
Introduction: Markets end year on sour note
Good morning, and welcome to our rolling coverage of the world economy, the financial markets, the eurozone and business.
They say the Christmas sales come earlier every year. This time, the bargains include shares in companies across the world.
Global financial markets are ending 2018 with some heavy losses, as investors worry that growth is slowing... and that America’s central bank is pressing on with interest rate hikes regardless.
Last night, the Dow shed another 2%, and the Nasdaq came to the brink of a bear market, after Britain’s FTSE had slumped to its lowest level in 28 months.
This has rattled Asia-Pacific markets again; Japan’s Topix has shed 1.9%, pushing it deeper into bear market territory, while China’s Shanghai Composite index has shed 0.8%.
Associated Press explains:
Stocks usually end the year with a flourish. But investors worry global economic growth is cooling and the U.S. could slip into a recession in the next few years.
After “years of outperformance,” U.S. markets are working off “overvaluation in some areas” such as major tech companies, said Shane Oliver of AMP Capital in a report.
China and other Asian markets “fell much earlier and harder and so far are holding above their October lows,” said Oliver.
There’s not much cheer in the City this morning either, with European markets expected to open lower.
European Opening Calls:#FTSE 6689 -0.34%#DAX 10551 -0.57%#CAC 4675 -0.37%#MIB 18486 -0.49%#IBEX 8564 -0.38%
— IGSquawk (@IGSquawk) December 21, 2018
The ongoing chaos in American politics is also worrying the markets, given that the US government could actually shut down today...
As my colleague Dominic Rushe explains,
The latest fall in US markets comes as Donald Trump is threatening a government shutdown unless Congress agrees to fund his border wall with Mexico. Trump has appeared to back away from a shutdown but is now indicating he will not sign off on a stopgap budget unless there is funding for the wall.
“At this moment, the president does not want to go further without border security, which includes steel slats or a wall,” the White House press secretary, Sarah Sanders, said. Trump “is continuing to weigh his options”, she added.
Disappointing earnings reports added to the US sell-off.
Shares of Walgreens Boots Alliance dropped 3.55% as the drugstore chain’s same-store sales missed estimates.
Conagra Brands tumbled 11.33%, the most on the S&P, after the packaged foods maker missed sales estimates on delayed shipments and weak demand.
A flurry of new economic data will keep investors on their toes today, and away from last-minute Christmas shopping. We get updated growth figures for the UK, the US, Canada and France.
The agenda:
- 7.45am GMT: French GDP for Q3 2018 (final estimate)
- 9.30am GMT: UK GDP for Q3 2018 (final estimate)
- 9.30am GMT: UK public finances for November
- 1.30pm GMT: US GDP for Q3 2018 (final estimate)
- 1.30pm GMT: Canadian GDP for Q3 2018 (final estimate)