Graeme Wearden 

UK tipped to fall to bottom of European growth league next year – as it happened

New EC growth forecasts warn that rising global uncertainty, international trade tensions and higher oil prices will weigh on Europe
  
  

European Commissioner Pierre Moscovici giving a press conference on today’s Autumn 2018 Economic Forecast
European Commissioner Pierre Moscovici giving a press conference on today’s Autumn 2018 Economic Forecast Photograph: Stéphanie Lecocq/EPA

Full story: UK economic growth tipped to be slowest in Europe next year

Here’s my colleague Richard Partington on today’s EC growth figures:

The UK will sink to the bottom of the European economic growth league next year to join Italy as the slowest-growing economy in the EU, before falling further the year after to anchor the table alone, according to European commission forecasts.

The EU’s gloomy predictions are based on a soft Brexit – meaning Britain is expected to lag behind all its EU peers even if Theresa May can reach a deal with Brussels before 29 March.

The commission forecasts that consumer spending growth will remain weak, continuing a subpar performance since the EU referendum in June 2016. It said business investment would stay subdued, while external demand for UK goods will dwindle. The commission predicted the result would be GDP growth of 1.2% in 2019 and 2020.

That’s probably all for today....

The latest US jobs data shows its labor market remains historically strong.

Just 214,000 people filed new claims for unemployment benefit last week, not far from the lowest level ever.

The number of people receiving benefits after an initial week of aid dropped by 8,000 to just 1.62 million, the lowest level since July 28, 1973.

With such strong data, the Republicans might have been expected to put up a stronger fight in defending the House of Representatives....

Germany's economy may have shrunk

Economists at HSBC have bad news for Germany: they believe its economy probably shrank over the summer.

The first estimate of German GDP in the third-quarter of 208 is released next Wednesday. HSBC believes it will show the economy contracted by 0.1%, down from a previous forecast of +0.4%.

In a new report, they say:

After thirteen consecutive quarters with positive quarterly growth rates, the German economy seems likely to have taken a breather in Q3 2018.

That’s partly due to the slump in exports in September, in the face of trade conflicts (as covered earlier this morning).

HSBC explain how this could mean net trade dragged on growth:

The headwinds from the slowdown in world trade might also have been weighing on German export activity, which could have affected GDP negatively on the expenditure side.

At the same time, import growth remains quite strong, resulting in the trade surplus hitting its lowest level since March 2014 in July.

New European car emission tests have also hurt vehicle production in recent months, a key area of the German economy.

Set your alarm clocks for 7am GMT next Wednesday, when the German growth figures are released.

Newsflash: The International Monetary Fund has just weighed in on the EU-Italy budget row, backing Brussels.

In a new report, the IMF predicts that Italy’s growth will sink to just 0.9% in 2020 (worst than the UK). It also says Rome should focus on cutting its debts, rather than borrowing more to spur growth....

It’s worth noting that the UK’s independent Office for Budget Responsibility is less gloomy about growth prospects.

Last week the OBR forecast UK growth of 1.3% in 2018 (matching the EC’s view). The fiscal watchdog then spies growth accelerating to 1.6% in 2019, dipping to 1.4% in 2020.

That’s significantly better than the EC’s prediction of just 1.2% growth each year.

And the OBR has an advantage: It knew about Philip Hammond’s ‘giveaway budget’ when it produced its number. The EC’s forecasts were inked in on 22 October, a week before the budget.

So Britain might not be in as much peril as the EC believes.

Sky News’s Ed Conway has tweeted this point too:

Today’s growth forecasts have also escalated the row between Brussels and Rome over Italy’s budget.

The Commission’s forecast that Italy will grow by only 1.2% in 2019 is below the 1.5% predicted by its new government.

That means the EC believes Italy’s budget deficit will hit 2.9%, not the 2.4% predicted by Rome (which Brussels has already rejected).

Brussels insists that Italy submits a new budget by next Tuesday, which would mean dropping some of the spending plans which its coalition government promised in this year’s election.

EU commissioner Moscovici has told reporters in Brussels that:

“There cannot be a sort of negotiation on this.”

But Italy’s administration hasn’t shown signs of backing down, arguing that the economy needs stimulating, and that a fiscal boost will pay for itself in higher growth.

You can read the EC’s new Autumn economic forecasts online here. The UK section starts on page 140 (p152 of the pdf).

Why the EC expects UK to lag behind

The EC is keen to point out that its forecasts are based on the “purely technical assumption” that the EU and UK maintain their current trading relationship after Brexit.

In other words, Britain is expected to lag behind Europe in the event of a soft Brexit, rather than a hard Brexit that causes significant disrupion to trade.

On that basis, the EU predicts that:

  • Consumer spending growth will be weak in 2019, as real wage growth will be modest.
  • Business investment growth will rebound in 2019, but remain “relatively subdued following a prolonged period of heightened uncertainty.”
  • Net trade’s contribution to growth will continue to dwindle, “alongside slowing external demand”.

That adds up to growth of just 1.2% in both 2019 and 2020.

But the EC also warns there are large, downside risks to these forecasts - if Brexit is less benign, growth will be slower, it fears.

Updated

Moodys: global growth is slowing

In ANOTHER gloomy warning, credit rating agency Moody’s has predicted that global economic growth was likely to slow in the next two years.

Reuters has the details:

“We expect global growth to slow to under 3.0% in 2019 and 2020, from an estimated 3.3% in 2017-18”, the agency said in a new report.

Moody’s also fears that the US-China trade war will intensify in 2019, hurting the wider global economy.

It wasy:

“In both countries, the overall direct macro impact on growth will be manageable.

However, persistent and broadening tensions between the two largest economies globally are increasingly likely to have widespread negative implications by undermining investment.”

Table: UK expected to hit bottom of EU growth league

The UK is expected to be the third slowest-growing EU member this year (at +1.3%), behind Italy (+1.1%) and Denmark (1.2%).

Today’s EC forecasts show the UK sinking to joint last place with Italy in 2019, at +1.2%.

In 2020, the UK is expected to underperform every EU member with growth of 1.2%, while Italy creeps up to 1.3%.

These forecasts are inevitably speculative, as the Commission simply doesn’t know how Brexit will pan out. It also can’t be sure what policies Italy’s new populist government will follow. But it’s not a great outlook for either country....

Updated

UK unemployment expected to rise

The European Commission’s latest assessment of the UK economy isn’t terribly encouraging, as Britain prepares to leave the EU next year.

The EC expects growth to remain weak, and unemployment to rise:

UK GDP growth is currently subdued and expected to remain so over the forecast horizon. Private consumption growth is forecast to remain weak as real wages grow modestly and households look to maintain savings.

Heightened uncertainty means that business investment growth is likely to remain constrained. The net trade contribution to growth is projected to decrease in-line with a moderation in external demand.

Employment growth is expected to slow significantly, leading to a modest rise in unemployment. Inflation should ease as the impact of sterling’s 2016 depreciation unwinds.

Updated

The Commission is optimistic that unemployment will keep falling over the next couple of years.

The eurozone jobless rate is already at a 10-year low, dropping to 8.1% in September.

The EC hopes it will fall to 7.5% in 2020 -- if so, it would still be much higher than in the UK (4%) and the US (3.7%).

UK expected to lag behind the EU

The EC predicts that Britain’s economy faces a tough few years.

UK growth is forecast at just 1.3% this year, and 1.2% in 2019 and 2020.

That’s the joint lowest for any (current) EU country next year, alongside Italy.

Germany, in contrast, is expected to grow by 1.7% this year, 1.8% in 2018 and 1.7% in 2020.

The UK growth forecasts are based on the assumption that Britain and the EU maintain the current “status quo” in their trading relationship after Brexit.

That’s not guaranteed, given the slow progress in agreeing a withdrawal agreement...

Valdis Dombrovskis, Vice-President for the Euro and Social Dialogue, says Europe needs to take precautions before the next down:

“All EU economies are set to grow this year and next, which will bring more jobs. However, uncertainty and risks, both external and internal, are on the rise and start to take a toll on the pace of economic activity. We need to stay vigilant and work harder to reinforce the resilience of our economies. At EU level, it means taking concrete decisions on further strengthening our Economic and Monetary Union.

At national level, there is even a stronger case for building up fiscal buffers and reducing debt while making sure that the benefits of growth are also felt by the most vulnerable members of society.”

The EC is hopeful that “barring major shocks” Europe should be able to sustain above-potential economic growth, robust job creation and falling unemployment.

However, this baseline scenario is subject to a growing number of interconnected downside risks, from a possible oil spike to the risk of an intensified trade war.

EC: European growth to slow

Newsflash: Europe’s economy will slow steadily over the next few years as trade wars, geopolitical tensions and higher oil price all bite.

That’s according to the latest projections from the European Commission, just released.

They show that growth in the euro area is forecast to ease from a 10-year high of 2.4% in 2017 to 2.1% in 2018.

It is then seen dropping to 1.9% in 2019, and 1.7% in 2020.

The wider European Union is expected to growth by 2.2% this year, slowing to 2.0% in 2019 and 1.9% in 2020.

The Commission blames three factors, saying

Rising global uncertainty, international trade tensions and higher oil prices will have a dampening effect on growth in Europe.

More to follow!


Germany isn’t the only European country hitting a soft patch.

Spain’s industrial output shrank by 0.1% in September, official data shows, the first drop since July 2016.

Separately, French manufacturers have slashed their investment plans. They now expect to spend 1% less this year than in 2017, not 4% more.

Updated

European stock markets have shrugged off Germany’s export slowdown.

The Stoxx 600 index has risen by 0.6%, as shares benefit from the prospect of the Democrats keeping Donald Trump in check.

Kit Juckes of Société Générale says:

There is very little going on, and yet there’s a lot happening.

US election uncertainty removed, equity markets hope they’ve found the ideal combination of slightly less fiscal easing and slightly less monetary tightening that a more restrained president Trump will have to deliver. An outbreak of glee has hit markets....

But in the longer run, US political deadlock will lead to slower growth from mid-2019 onward, Juckes adds.

China tells US: Lets solve trade dispute

German factory chiefs will be hoping for a breakthrough in the US-China trade dispute soon, before the slump in exports deepens.

And overnight, a top Chinese diplomat has suggest that presidents Trump and Xi could make progress at the G20 world leaders’ meeting in Argentina in three weeks time.

Politburo member Yang Jiechi told U.S. national security adviser John Bolton that:

“China is committed to working with the U.S. to achieve a no-confrontational, conflictless, mutually respectful co-operation in which both sides win.

“Both sides should seek an appropriate solution through equal and mutually beneficial negotiations.”

Yang’s comments were released by China’s Foreign Ministry, suggesting Beijing is keen to get its message out.

Carsten Brzeski of ING agrees that Germany exporters are suffering from slowing world trade.

He also blames new car emissions tests; production has suffered as automakers scramble to meet these tough new rules.

Brzeski fears next week’s German GDP figures for July-September could be a stinker:

Today’s trade data ends a disappointing week for German industry. Available monthly data suggests that the economy had its worst quarterly performance in 3Q since the beginning of 2015.

The first GDP estimate will be released next week on Wednesday.

The 0.8% drop in German exports in September is the biggest since February.

The FT reckons it “could be another sign that Europe’s largest economy is feeling the effects of a slowdown in global trade”.

Monthly data can be volatile, but German exports have looked underwhelming for several months now:

The agenda: German exports slide as trade tensions grow

Good morning, and welcome to our rolling coverage of the world economy, the financial markets, the eurozone and business.

Germany has suffered a drop in exports as the trade tensions swirling around the globe hit Europe’s largest economy.

German exports shrank by 0.8% in September, statistics body Destatis reported this morning, dashing expectations of a 0.3% rise. Imports declined by 0.4% (against expectations of a 0.8% rise).

This shrank Germany’s trade surplus to around €17.6bn, from €18.2bn in August, on a seasonally adjusted basis.

Alarmingly, exports were actually lower than in September 2017, even though the world economy has expanded over the last year.

Here’s the details, from Destatis:

Exports, September 2018

  • €109.1bn
  • -0.8% on the previous month (calendar and seasonally adjusted)
  • -1.2% on the same month a year earlier

Imports, September 2018

  • €90.7bn
  • -0.4% on the previous month (calendar and seasonally adjusted)
  • +5.3% on the same month a year earlier

It’s the latest sign that Germany’s economy has slowed sharply this year. Third-quarter GDP figures due next Wednesday may confirm that growth stalled over the summer.

German exporting powerhouse seems to be suffering badly from America’s protectionist stance on trade. The tariffs imposed on EU steel, and a swathe of Chinese products entering the US, are creating new frictions and dampening demand.

Also coming up today

Asian stock markets have rallied, as investors continue to welcome the US election results.

Last night, the Dow jumped by 545 points (or 2.1%), the best day post-midterm rally since 1982, as Wall Street anticipated gridlock in Congress now the Democrats have control of the house.

European markets are likely to gain ground at the open too, with the FTSE 100 called up 20 points:

The European Commission issues its latest forecasts for the European economy this morning, and may confirm that growth is slowing.

Investors will also be waiting to hear from the US Federal Reserve, when it sets monetary policy tonight. The Fed isn’t expected to raise rates until December, but its views on the US economy may move the markets

The agenda

  • 10am GMT: European Commission
  • 1.30pm GMT: US weekly jobless figures
  • 7pm GMT: Federal Reserve interest rate decision
 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*