Graeme Wearden 

Euro rises as ECB president Draghi says single currency is ‘irrevocable’- as it happened

European Central Bank says ‘sense of urgency’ has diminished, as it leaves interest rates at record lows
  
  

A papier mache caricature depicting ECB President Draghi at the Rose Monday carnival parade in Cologne, Germany, in February.
A papier mache caricature depicting ECB President Draghi at the Rose Monday carnival parade in Cologne, Germany, in February. Photograph: Wolfgang Rattay/Reuters

That’s all for today.

Here’s AFP’s take on the ECB press conference.

The European Central Bank reported signs of an improving eurozone economy Thursday, but said it would keep cheap money gushing for fear of undermining the recovery.

ECB watchers were alert for any tightening of the ECB’s ultra-loose policy as inflation rates rise and prospects for growth in the 19-nation single currency area improve.

The central bank has set interest rates at record lows and buys tens of billions of euros of bonds per month in a bid to drive up growth and inflation.

At the meeting of the bank’s governing council “there was a general recognition that the balance of risk has improved, certainly as far as growth is concerned,” ECB president Mario Draghi told reporters. “There is no longer that sense of urgency in taking further actions.”

But “this is a gradual process,” he went on at a Frankfurt press conference.

“The governing council members want to be convinced they see a self-sustained adjustment in the inflation rate” before closing the money sluices, he said.

For now, faced with uncertain impacts from global upheavals abroad and elections at home, the ECB plans to continue its bond-buying scheme until December as planned, as well as maintaining its commitment to interest rates “at present or lower levels” for the foreseeable future.

“Spring is coming and the ECB is celebrating,” judged analyst Florian Hense of Berenberg bank, while noting that, despite the lifting spirits, “it has not moved significantly closer to actually tightening policy”....

Goodnight. GW

Draghi press conference: What the experts say

Kathleen Brooks of City Index says Mario Draghi has proved he was the “king of curveballs” at today’s press conference in Frankfurt.

After delivering what was arguably a dovish statement early on in his press conference, and clearly stating that for the ECB’s GDP and inflation forecasts are conditional on the implementation “of all our policy measures”, Draghi displayed a more hawkish tone during the Q&A.

The key takeaway from this month’s ECB meeting appears contradictory: QE is here to stay in the Eurozone, until at least the end of this year. However, more policy action is less likely because deflation risks have receded. Reading between the lines suggests that the next change from the ECB will be towards removing accommodation and not adding it.

Aberdeen Asset Management investment manager Patrick O’Donnell says Draghi has given a small hint that the ECB could adjust its policy stance soon:

“Draghi has ever so slightly opened the door to changing their policy stance. He’s done this by saying that the Governing Council talked about changing the language about where rates are in their monthly statement, but didn’t actually change it. This is effectively him signalling that something might change in the future, just not today.

“It’s a classic Draghi technique of saying something that will move markets without actually doing anything. Due to this, and a wordy response to a question about raising rates before QE ends, markets will now start to recalibrate on the assumption that the ECB will remove accommodation towards the end of the year.”

Jamie Dutta, senior market analyst at Faraday Research, says the ECB president “flip-flopped’ between his bearish opening statement, and some bullish remarks in the press conference.

The ECB and Mario Draghi celebrated its two year anniversary of its Asset Purchase Program by being marginally less dovish than expected in the monthly press conference. It was an interesting balancing act for Draghi between unchanged monetary policy stimulus policies and improved economic prospects. The market took the upgraded forecasts for growth and inflation in its stride.

However they reacted more positively when Draghi stated that there was no longer a ‘sense of urgency on taking further actions’ to boost inflation and the recovery. Indeed Draghi further said the ‘risks to deflation have largely disappeared’.

And Pictet’s Frederik Ducrozet shows how the ECB has raised its forecasts for inflation in 2017 and 2018:

Draghi: The euro is here to stay

The press conference ends with Mario Draghi insisting that the euro is irrevocable, and not going to break up.

The ECB president declares that:

The euro is here to stay. It’s not about whether or not it is irrevocable. It is.

The ECB president calls the euro a “channel for solidarity” (which might rankle with those suffering financial plight in Greece).

Draghi points out that Latvia, Estonia and Lithuania all joined the single currency since the financial crisis began, due to the benefits of membership.

We need to make monetary union function better, Draghi adds, to increase prosperity in the region.

And this bullish talk has helped to push the euro up. It’s currently up 0.6% at $1.06.

Updated

German bond prices are falling, driving up the yield on the debt.

Traders are reacting to the news that the ECB has dropped its pledge to use ‘all available instruments’ to achieve its mandate, and is now less worried about deflation.

Mario Draghi is treading an interesting path at today’s press conference.

On the one hand, he’s talking up the prospects for the eurozone economy and saying there is no longer a deflation risk.

But he’s also warning that there are ‘downside risks’ that could derail the recovery.

Why? Because he’s got a firm eye on upcoming elections, particularly in France.

Q: Were today’s decisions unanimous?

Enigmatically, Draghi says the discussion was ‘consensual’.....

Rather sweetly, Draghi suggests that it’s 18 months since Britain voted to leave the EU.

Just nine, old boy. Although it sometimes feels like nine years...

Draghi says the governing council did not discuss ending its QE programme, or boosting it, at today’s meeting.

Mario Draghi sounds somewhat concerned about geopolitics, warning that global risks have risen recently.

We haven’t yet seen negative consequences from the Brexit vote, he adds, but it’s not clear how various ‘risk events’ will play out.

Updated

Draghi is asked about the criticism of Germany’s trade surplus from Peter Navarro, trade advisor to Donald Trump, who argues that the euro is unfairly weak.

Draghi defends Berlin, saying he doesn’t see any merit in attacking Germany.

Germany’s currency is the euro, and eurozone monetary policy is set for the whole region, he insists.

Q: Could the ECB raise interest rates before it has ended its QE programme?

Draghi ducks the question. And that’s interesting, as he’s previously insisted that rate would not rise until the asset-purchase programme had concludes.

On deflation....Mario Draghi says that the risks have “largely disappeared”, adding:

Market-based inflation expectations have increased noticeably.

Draghi: Sense of urgency has gone

In a hawkish move, the European central bank has dropped an important line from its statement.

The pledge to use “all the instruments at its disposal” if necessary to achieve it mandates has been removed.

Mario Draghi says this has been dropped because the “sense of urgency” has gone, suggesting the ECB is less worried about the situation.

ECB raises growth and inflation forecasts

Hello again. Sorry about that breakdown - while I was away, Mario Draghi has been speaking to the press in Frankfurt.

The ECB president has announced slightly higher growth forecasts; GDP is now expected to rise by 1.8% in 2017 (up from 1.7% in December) and by 1.6% in 2018 (up from 1.5%)

It has also raised its inflation forecast this year to 1.7% (from 1.3%).

Draghi still sound cautious, saying:

The risks surrounding the euro area growth outlook have become less pronounced, but remain tilted to the downside and relate predominantly to global factors.

We’re having a few technical issues here , so might miss the start of the ECB press conference #developing....

German MEP criticises ECB for leaving rates on hold

Markus Ferber, a German conservative MEP, is unhappy that the European Central Bank didn’t raise interest rates today.

Ferber argues that the ECB should have responded to the recent rise in euro area inflation, to 2%.

“The inflation rate is picking up and the European economy is growing strongly. Now would be the perfect time for Mario Draghi to show a little courage and end the period of zero interest rate. The craving for cheap money is like an addiction that has to stop now. This is even more so as monetary policy in the USA and the EU are at risk of drifting further and further apart.

In the US, the main interest rate is already higher than in the Eurozone and the Federal Reserve plans to have two to three additional interest rate hikes this year alone. I am disappointed that the ECB missed yet another chance to initialise a normalisation of monetary policy.“

Naeem Aslam of Think Markets says investors need to watch the political landscape closely, to understand why the ECB didn’t change policy today.

We have two major events coming up which can have some serious impact on the Euro; the elections in Netherland and elections over in France. If any of these anti- euro party wins the election, this would create a lot of trouble for the European central bank. Basically, when you have the concept of euro under threat, the last thing you want to do is to create more panic in the market.

It is in Draghi’s interest to keep buying more time until we have navigated through all these storms and sailing becomes smoother.

While we wait for Draghi, here’s a photo of a papier mache caricature of Europe’s most powerful central banker, from the Rose Monday carnival parade in Cologne last month.

It must have been popular with German savers who dislike Draghi’s decision to cut interest rates to zero.

Here’s some instant reaction to the ECB announcement:

ECB: We're pushing on with QE too

The European Central Bank has also declared it will keep running its stimulus programme.

And despite pressure from hawks to start tightening, the ECB insists it could boost its bond-buying firepower if needed.

The ECB says: :

Regarding non-standard monetary policy measures, the Governing Council confirms that it will continue to make purchases under the asset purchase programme (APP) at the current monthly pace of €80 billion until the end of this month and that, from April 2017, the net asset purchases are intended to continue at a monthly pace of €60 billion until the end of December 2017, or beyond, if necessary, and in any case until the Governing Council sees a sustained adjustment in the path of inflation consistent with its inflation aim.

The net purchases will be made alongside reinvestments of the principal payments from maturing securities purchased under the APP. If the outlook becomes less favourable, or if financial conditions become inconsistent with further progress towards a sustained adjustment in the path of inflation, the Governing Council stands ready to increase the programme in terms of size and/or duration.

ECB leaves interest rates unchanged

Here we go! The European Central Bank has left interest rates unchanged at today’s meeting, and kept its pledge to cut them again in future if needed.

That means that borrowing costs stay at their current record lows, despite inflation jumping to 2% this month.

So:

  • the main rate sticks at 0.0%
  • The deposit facility rate stays at -0.4% (meaning commercial banks will be charged for leaving funds at the ECB).
  • The marginal lending rate, charged when banks borrow from the ECB, stays at 0.25%

There’s no change to the commitment to keep borrowing costs low, either. The ECB says:

The Governing Council continues to expect the key ECB interest rates to remain at present or lower levels for an extended period of time, and well past the horizon of the net asset purchases.

Capital Economics predict that Mario Draghi will resist pressure to start considering tightening monetary policy:

Here’s something for the ECB to chew on -- more than three quarters of Greek families have difficulty, or great difficulty, making ends meet.

That’s one factoid in a new UK report into national wellbeing, released this morning by the Office for National Statistics.

It says:

According to data from Eurostat, 16% of all households in the UK reported great difficulty or difficulty in making ends meet in 2015.

This was lower than the estimated EU–28 average of 26%, and was the same as Estonia (16%). The countries with the highest proportion of households reporting great difficulty or difficulty in making ends meet were Greece (78%) and Bulgaria (64%), while the lowest proportion of households were in Sweden (5%) and Finland (7%).

The full report is online:

Measuring national well-being in the UK: international comparisons, 2017

ECB Day: What to watch for

It’s nearly time for the European Central Bank to end the suspense (!) and reveal the results of today’s governing council meeting, at 12.45 GMT (1.45pm in Frankfurt)

We’re not expecting any changes to interest rates, but the ECB easily change the language in today’s announcement.

That could include dropping the suggestion that interest rates could be cut to new record lows, or that it stands ready to boost its bond-buying programme.

Nick Kounis of ABN Amro explains:

ECB expert Fred Ducrozet of Pictet Bank predicts that Mario Draghi will make some subtle changes to his statement at 1.30pm GMT (2.30pm Frankfurt time).

Fred also expects the ECB to raise its forecasts for growth and inflation this year.

Sir Martin Sorrell, the advertising magnate, isn’t suffering from the wage squeeze.

WPP has reported that CEO Sorrell will receive more than £40m though its LEAP incentive plan, pushing his total package closer to £50m.

This is the final instalment of LEAP, as my colleague Mark Sweney explains:

Updated

It’s turning into a bad week for the markets.

Shares, bonds and commodity prices have all weakened since Monday, the cost of insuring bonds has gone up, and most currencies have lost ground against the US dollar.

Market selloff picks up pace

In London the FTSE 100 index is now down 50 points, or 0.6%, at 7283, and on track for its sixth loss in a row.

Oil companies have now joined the big fallers, with Shell down 3% following the drop in the crude price. Mining stocks are being hit hard too.

There’s a generally nervous mood in the markets, as the rally that begin after the US election fades.

Chris Beauchamp of IG sums up the mood:

Signs of a broad-based risk off mentality are cropping up like spring daffodils at present. Yesterday’s plunge in oil prices took most of the attention, but the other major warning signal was the rout in junk bonds; like stocks these have gained significantly since the election, and like stocks they enjoyed more gains in February. The heavy selling in the high yield ETF over the past week sounds another alarm for equity bulls.

To add to the signs of doom, mining shares in London are in full-blown retreat, as a stronger dollar and falling commodity prices take their toll

German bankers want Draghi to signal end to stimulus

The German banking industry has urged the European Central Bank to give a signal today that it could start unwinding its ultra-loose monetary policy stance soon.

Reuters has the story:

The BdB private banking association said the fact that the threat of deflation has disappeared in the euro zone and inflation was picking up justified its recommendation.

“Such a step must be prepared very, very well” and policymakers should communicate it carefully, BdB head Michael Kemmer told Deutschlandfunk radio on Thursday.

“But it would be important, I think, that the ECB today opens the door to the exit (of its expansive monetary policy),” Kemmer said.

How would that door open?

One option is that the ECB could drop its pledge that interest rates would remain at current or lower levels for an extended period.

Or, Mario Draghi could outline how it would slow (or taper) its QE programme.

But as flagged earlier, many analysts think there are good reasons to leave the exit door locked.

Neil Wilson of ETX Capital says:

Draghi doesn’t want a repeat of 2011 or 2008, when the ECB tightened too quickly. This fear is likely to drive policymakers to remain dovish and keep the taps open. The risks remain to the downside - even with what markets consider ‘too much’ QE.

The ‘high class problem’ talked about by Draghi is that the European economy is doing better and the talk is now of tightening. The longer the ECB is minded to refrain from changing policy, the more markets will expect a rate rise or tapering to come. Indeed markets are doing a lot of the tightening work for the ECB as the front end of the yield curve is rising.

Updated

Oil price falls below $50

Newsflash: The price of US crude oil has suddenly taken a tumble, dropping below $50 per barrel for the first time since December 2016.

Traders are blaming figures, released yesterday, which showed a surge in US crude oil stocks. That caused a 5% drop in the oil price yesterday, and it looks like people are still worried...

Brent crude has also fallen, by over 5% to around $52.11 per barrel.

Speaking of weak pay.... John Lewis staff have just learned that they’re getting their smallest bonus since the 1950s.

Employees will receive an extra three week’s pay, or 6% of basic salary, under its profit-sharing scheme (John Lewis is owner by its workers, or ‘partners’).

Better than a poke with a sharp stick, of course...but it must still be a disappointment to staff at John Lewis’s department stores, and at Waitrose. This is the fifth year running that the bonus has fallen - back in 2011, the bonus was a chunky 18%.

Chairman Sir Charlie Mayfield says the retailer needs to retain cash for investment in an increasingly uncertain market.

British workers are suffering the worst decade for pay growth since Arthur Wellesley was giving Napoleon Bonaparte a bloody nose at Waterloo.

That’s the verdict of the Resolution Foundation, which has crunched the numbers in yesterday’s budget.

Director Torsten Bell says:

“The big picture from yesterday’s budget is that the big squeezes on both the public and family finances have been prolonged well into the 2020s.

“While the Office for Budget Responsibility at least delivered some good news on borrowing, the family finances picture has actually deteriorated since the autumn statement. Britain is set for a return to falling real pay later this year, with this decade now set to be the worst for pay growth since the Napoleonic wars.

They’ve also calculated that, on current form, Britain won’t eliminate its deficit until 2025 - 15 years after George Osborne’s first austerity budget.

Today’s European Central Bank meeting is also overshadowed by presidential elections in France and the Netherlands.

And that’s another reason for the ECB to sit tight today, argues Carsten Brzeski of ING:

“With headline inflation in the euro zone back at the magic 2 percent, the ECB hawks and critics will gradually sense that their moment has come to push for tapering.

“In our view, however, they will not want to add any new uncertainty in the eve of two important elections in the Eurozone.”

ECB meeting: What the experts say

Several experts are arguing that the European Central Bank should ignore calls to start winding back its stimulus programme.

Guntram Wolff of the Bruegel thinktank says underlying inflationary pressures are still too weak:

Kathleen Brooks of City Index predicts that the ECB won’t start to dial back its bond-buying programme until the autumn.

We seem to have entered a post-inflation era for central bankers, who used to try and prevent price pressures from building. Now we tend to see a willingness for central banks, including the Bank of England, the ECB and, to a smaller extent, the Federal Reserve, to look through periods of high inflation in order to protect growth. Thus, the fact that headline CPI reached 2% is unlikely to deter the ECB from keeping rates in negative territory and maintaining asset purchases, potentially into 2018. We do expect the ECB to revise up its long-term inflation forecast at tomorrow’s meeting, which could trigger some euro buying as the market anticipates a premature end to the ECB’s QE programme.

We also don’t expect the ECB to announce any plans to taper its asset purchases any time soon. Firstly, growth in the region remains uneven, for example, the Greek economy contracted sharply at the end of 2016, Finnish growth was flat and Italy could only muster growth of 1%. These are economies that need support from their central bank, and even the German finance minister in a recent speech noted that the ECB was doing a good job to balance policy for all Eurozone members. We think that the ECB is approx. 6-months away from announcing a taper to its QE programme.

Kit Juckes of Societe Generale predicts a ‘straight bat’ from president Draghi:

No policy change is expected....Mario Draghi will acknowledge the better economic backdrop and higher inflation, but avoid any watering-down of the dovish bias.

It’s two years since the European Central Bank took the plunge and started stimulating the eurozone economy with newly created money.

And just look how it’s grown....

European stock markets have opened in the red, as investors await news from the ECB at lunchtime.

Britain’s FTSE 100 is the biggest faller, shedding 44 points or 0.6% to 7289 points.

Morrisons is the biggest faller, down 5.5%. It warned this morning that there are uncertainties ahead, including the impact of the weak pound driving up imported food prices.

Mining shares are down too.

The agenda: It's ECB Day

Good morning, and welcome to our rolling coverage of the world economy, the financial markets, the eurozone and business.

The European Central Bank’s governing council may have a spring in its step today, as policymakers gather for their latest policy meeting in Frankfurt.

After years of low inflation, the consumer prices index is finally back on target at 2% - meaning that fears of a deflationary spiral can be put to bed.

But the ECB still has a problem; what to do about its massive stimulus programme that is pumping billions of euros into the eurozone each month?

Hawkish members of the ECB will be putting pressure on president Mario Draghi to start the process of winding back its bond-buying QE programme.

They’d also like Draghi to signal that the interest rates could rise, having been slashed to record lows of zero (or lower, for banks who leave money in the ECB’s vaults).

Here’s the timings:

  • 12.45pm GMT: ECB announce its decision on interest rates and QE
  • 1.30pm GMT: Mario Draghi press conference

The markets aren’t expecting any new measures today; but the key, as so often with Draghi, is the language he uses.

Analysts at RBC Capital Markets explain:

The market will be watching for any changes to the ECB’s language today, particularly whether it may drop its current bias toward lower interest rates which would likely be interpreted as a potential signal that the period of ultra-accommodative monetary policy is coming to an end, even if the ECB is still someway from signalling a readiness to raise rates. Our view is that the Governing Council will keep its forward guidance language as is for the time being pointing to the continued weakness of core inflation as justification.

The ECB will also issue new staff forecasts on growth and inflation; these are likely to be revised higher.

So it’s likely to be a lively day in the currency markets:

Also coming up today....

UK chancellor Philip Hammond will be busy defending yesterday’s budget, and the proposed rise in national insurance contributions for the self-employed.

Tory MPs aren’t happy about this apparent breach of the government’s manifesto commitments, so it could be a long day for Hammond....

Supermarket chain Wm Morrison, the Co-operative Bank, Domino’s Pizza and estate agent Countrywide are reporting results.

The John Lewis chain will be telling its staff the size of their annual bonus. It’s likely to be much smaller than in recent years, which explains why journalists aren’t invited to this year’s event.

Finance journalist Simon Neville (and his young apprentice) are disappointed...

We’ll be tracking all the main events through the day...

Updated

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*