Graeme Wearden 

Bank of England surprises City by leaving interest rates on hold – as it happened

UK central bank has voted 8-1 to leave borrowing costs at 0.5%, and hinted that it will launch a stimulus package in August
  
  

Governor of the Bank of England Mark Carney may cut borrowing costs to fresh record lows today..
Governor of the Bank of England Mark Carney has dashed expectations of a rate cut today. Photograph: Matt Dunham/PA

That's all for today

The dust is settling across the City after the Bank of England ducked away from cutting rates to fresh record lows.

Economists and analysts are turning their attention back to Downing Street, as Theresa May continues to reshape the government....

...although some traders are being distracted by Mont Ventoux instead:

So, that’s a good moment to wrap up. Here’s our news story on the Bank of England’s decision:

Have a good evening. GW

Good reasons for not cutting rates today

Our economics editor, Larry Elliott, says there are five good reasons for leaving interest rates on hold:

Firstly, the Bank wants to have a closer look at the state of the economy before moving. There has been very little hard data since 23 June but the picture will be clearer by the time of the next MPC meeting in early August, which coincides with the release of the Bank’s quarterly assessment of the state of the nation.

This will provide forecasts for growth and inflation over the coming months, and provide a justification for whatever the Bank decides to do.

Secondly, the financial market reaction since the referendum has been less acute than looked likely in late June. Share prices have bounced, the pound has stabilised and even edged up a bit on the foreign exchanges, and long-term interest rates have fallen.

Thirdly, the economy has received something of a stimulus from the fall in the pound – which boosts exports – and from the Bank’s decision to ease the capital requirements on commercial banks, which increases their capacity to lend.

Fourthly, it is hard to see what material effect a cut in interest rates to 0.25% will have, given that they are already at record low levels. The situation is different now from the aftermath of Black Wednesday in September 1992, when borrowing costs could be cut aggressively from 10%.

Finally, there was a risk that by acting in a kneejerk fashion, the Bank could make matters worse. If consumers and businesses get the impression that the Bank is being rushed into action, it could further dent confidence.

Updated

No chance of a quiet August....

The pound is now on track for its best week in over six years, according to Jeremy Cook of World First.

But as this graph shows, sterling is still around 10% below its pre-referendum levels.

Rates on hold: What the economists say

More reaction is flooding in, and many economists are saying the Bank made the right call by leaving interest rates unchanged.

Andrew Sentance, senior economic adviser at PwC, calls it a “very sensible decision”.

Sentance, a former member of the MPC, argues that the Bank should also sit tight in August:

Though political events have been fast-moving, there is a need for stable economic policy until we are clearer how the economy is performing in the wake of the EU Referendum result. That will not be clear until the Autumn, and the MPC should hold fire until then. The MPC still won’t have enough information in August to make a proper assessment of the post-Brexit economic situation.

“Looking further ahead, the MPC needs to recognise that interest rates are already extremely low and have been for seven years. So there is very little that monetary policy can now do to support the economy. We need to look to fiscal policy - government spending and tax measures - and supply-side policies, which aim to make the UK a more attractive environment for business activity, to offset the shock of the Brexit decision.”

Arnaud Masset, market analyst at Swissquote Bank, believes the Bank is rightly hesitant to commit to any major moves while the Brexit situation is uncertain.

This wait-and-see approach is now appropriate, especially given the fact that the UK’s future relationship with the EU remains so unclear. The BoE will continue to wait for the smoke to clear before pushing the panic button.”

Ranko Berich, Head of Market Analysis at Monex Europe, says it all depends on the data:

“The Bank of England has stayed true to form and today’s decision is consistent with its “wait and see” approach to monetary policy.”

As recently as this week’s FPC testimony, Carney was emphasising that the direction of the monetary policy response to Brexit would depend on the relative effects of demand, supply, and sterling. Under this model, the BoE’s decision to hold fire on rates makes sense as there’s not yet enough data to decide on the appropriate response, even if most committee members are clearly leaning towards easing policy.

City analyst Louise Cooper questions whether a rate cut would actually do any good:

James Andrews, Head of Investment Management at Redmayne-Bentley, an investment management and stockbroking firm, cautions that an August rate cut isn’t guaranteed:

“It remains to be seen whether we will see a cut next month once the Bank of England have more hard data on the economic impact of the vote to leave. It’s clear that currently all they have is sentiment, rather than hard data on which to base a decision, and have therefore erred on the side of caution.

In the short term, we would expect further pain for domestically focussed UK listed companies as no further stimulus/support for the economy has been forthcoming at this time.”

Bloomberg’s Kevin Young captured the moment when the City learned that UK interest rates were on hold, sending sterling up by two cents:

Is Mark Carney the 'unreliable boyfriend' again?

Alan Clarke, economist at Scotia Bank, has blasted Mark Carney for creating the impression that the Bank of England might cut rates today.

He writes that Carney, who was famously labelled an ‘unreliable boyfriend’ early in his tenure, should have known better.

If ever there was a case for abandoning forward guidance and central bankers keeping quiet, this meeting is it.

Virtually nobody was going for a rate cut at this meeting before Carney’s intervention a couple of weeks ago. Most assumed that the weakness of the pound and the need to wait for incoming data would lead to a pause at least until August. But for no apparent reason, Governor Carney decided to tease the market, let it price in a high probability of a rate cut, only to disappoint.

As if the situation wasn’t volatile and uncertain enough, the BoE Governor poured petrol on the flames. This was a completely unnecessary intervention.

Duncan Weldon, head of research at the Resolution Group, has an interesting theory.

He reckons that Bank of England might not cut rates next month either, and might launch more quantitative easing or a new funding for lending scheme (FLS) instead.

He’s basing that on the Bank’s minutes (the part I posted a few minutes ago)

Shares in London have fallen back following the surprise news that UK interest rates are on hold.

The FTSE 100 index, which was up 60 points at 11.59am, is now flat.

That’s largely due to the surge in sterling -- a stronger pound will eat into the overseas earnings of the large multinationals in the blue-chip index.

UK interest rates have never been this low, and they’ve rarely been unchanged for this long.

With interest rates remaining stable, there is no need to update our monetary policy symphony....

70 years of interest rates, in one piece of music

Commercial property prices are going to suffer ‘sizeable’ falls following last month’s Brexit vote, says the Bank of England.

It has also trimmed its forecast for house price rises.

Today’s minutes state that:

Regarding the housing market, a preview of the June RICS survey had pointed to a marked weakening in expected activity and prices following the referendum result. Bank staff had lowered their forecast of housing investment significantly and had revised down the near-term outlook for house prices.

The forecast for housing investment had a direct read-across to GDP, while the outlook for house prices was expected to act as a drag on household consumption. Staff were also expecting sizeable falls in commercial real estate prices in the near term.

Updated

Bank of England leaves rates on hold: instant reaction

Lionel Barber, editor of the FT, reckons the Bank of England didn’t want to cause alarm by slashing rates today.

Sky News’s Dharshini David believes the BoE needs more evidence about the UK economy following the Brexit vote.

Economist Marc Ostwald reckons the Bank made the right decision.

Why the Bank left rates on hold

You can see the minutes of the meeting online, here.

The key section comes at the end, where the Bank explains that its policymakers decided to resist easing monetary policy until they have done more analysis of the situation.

Here’s a flavour (I’ve bolded up the key points).

The MPC was committed to taking whatever action was needed to support growth and to return inflation to the target over an appropriate horizon. To that end, most members of the Committee expected monetary policy to be loosened in August.

The Committee reviewed a range of possible stimulus measures and combinations thereof. It considered the potential interaction between various measures and the financial system, and therefore their influence on output and inflation. Committee members had an initial exchange of views on various possible packages of measures.

The exact extent of any additional stimulus measures would be based on the Committee’s updated forecast. Their composition would take account of any interactions with the financial system and their effectiveness in supporting the domestic economy. Further detailed analysis across all policy areas of the Bank would be required.

Against that backdrop, most members judged it appropriate to leave the stance of monetary policy unchanged at this meeting.

For one member, the subdued economic outlook before the referendum had already come close to warranting further stimulus. The early evidence supported the view that demand was likely to weaken further following the referendum. The resulting outlook for medium-term inflation – even taking into account the boost from the lower level of sterling – therefore justified an immediate loosening of monetary policy, to be supplemented by a package of additional measures in August.

So, Mark Carney then proposed leaving interest rates on hold -- most of the committee backed him.

However the newest member, Gertjan Vlieghe (a former hedge fund economist) pushed for an immediate rate cut.

Bank: Brexit vote is now hurting the economy

The Bank of England’s agents, who work across the UK, are seeing signs that the economy is weakening.

It says:

Official data on economic activity covering the period since the referendum are not yet available. However, there are preliminary signs that the result has affected sentiment among households and companies, with sharp falls in some measures of business and consumer confidence.

And the BoE singles out the housing market as a significant concern:

Early indications from surveys and from contacts of the Bank’s Agents suggest that some businesses are beginning to delay investment projects and postpone recruitment decisions. Regarding the housing market, survey data point to a significant weakening in expected activity. Taken together, these indicators suggest economic activity is likely to weaken in the near term.

As well as leaving rates on hold, the Bank of England voted 9-0 to leave its quantitative easing programme unchanged at £375bn.

Good news for holidaymakers heading to Europe this summer.... the pound has jumped by 1.5 cents against the euro to €1.20.

Bank of England: We'll probably stimulate in August

The Bank of England has also delivered a clear signal that it will ease monetary policy in August.

The minutes of today’s meeting state that:

“In the absence of a further worsening in the trade-off between supporting growth and returning inflation to target on a sustainable basis, most members of the Committee expect monetary policy to be loosened in August,

“The precise size and nature of any stimulatory measures will be determined during the August forecast and Inflation Report round.”

That will give the Bank’s economists more time to actually see the impact of the Brexit vote on the UK economy.

One Bank of England policymaker, Gertjan Vlieghe, voted to cut interest rates to 0.25%.

But the other eight members of the MPC voted to leave borrowing costs on hold until August.

Sterling surges after Bank leaves interest rates on hold

The pound is surging!!

It’s up by two cents against the US dollar, to $1.336, following the surprise decision to leave interest rates at 0.5%.

Updated

BANK OF ENGLAND INTEREST RATE DECISION

Breaking news! The Bank of England has left interest rates unchanged, dashing expectations of a rate cut.

More to follow!

FIVE MINUTES TO GO......

Currently the pound is trading at $1.323 against the US dollar, up almost a cent today.

And the FTSE 100 is up 62 points, or almost 1%, at 6732.

The Bank of England faced a very tricky decision this month... weighing up the risks to economic growth against the prospect of higher inflation.

Mark Carney and colleagues will also be aware that they can’t cut interest rates much lower -- although negative borrowing costs are an option. So a quarter-point cut to 0.25% would give leeway for further cuts in the future.

Fawad Razaqzada, market analyst at Forex.com, explains how political developments will also have influenced the BoE:

The Bank of England is widely expected to do something today, possibly deliver a 25 basis point rate cut. But it could also restart its bond buying programme and introduce other measures to support lending to households and businesses.

However, the swift appointment of a new Prime Minister in the UK means the political situation here is now a lot less uncertain, while the pound’s sharp depreciation in the aftermath of the Brexit vote means import costs are rising which may be passed onto the consumer. So, inflation could be on the rise.

Therefore, the BoE may actually hold off cutting interest rates at this meeting or at the very most deliver a small cut – certainly no more than 25 basis points, in my view. A small rate cut will still keep intact the bank’s credibility because it will have done something as promised, while at the same time it will unlikely overcook inflation.

Tension is rising in the City as the clock hands tick towards noon....

Just thirty minutes to go, until the most eagerly awaited Bank of England interest rate decision since the height of the financial crisis.

Most City traders appear to be expecting an interest rate cut. But most City traders expected Britain to vote to stay in the EU three weeks ago.....

As Augustin Eden at Accendo Markets puts it:

“Equity markets are in the green this morning, perhaps worryingly so given the potential for a negative surprise from the Bank of England at midday.

Traders are currently pricing in an 80% chance of a rate cut, but just take a step back and recall the last time markets priced in an 80% chance of something happening.

US Treasury secretary to meet Hammond today

It’s no secret that the US government is very concerned about the Brexit vote.

And that’s why Treasury secretary Jack Lew is racing to London from Berlin today, where he’s been meeting Germany’s finance minister.

Before jumping on his flight to meet chancellor Philip Hammond, Lew told reporters in Berlin that both sides need to be pragmatic and flexible.

Reuters has the key quotes from Lew:

“I will be meeting with the new chancellor this afternoon, I look forward to it.

“We believe that it is in the best interests of Europe, of the United States and the global economy to end up with a result that produces a highly integrated relationship between the UK and the EU.

“We think it is critical that negotiations take place in a pragmatic, transparent and smooth manner and for both sides to demonstrate flexibility.

Lew has originally been expecting to meet George Osborne, before Theresa May wielded the knife with such vigour.

The decision on interest rates will dominate the headlines, but the real story may be in the minutes of the Monetary Policy Committee meeting.

The Bank could use the minutes to signal its concerns about Brexit, but won’t want to spark panic in the City either, so the wording will be crucial.....

Guardian: UK needs fiscal boost as well as rate cuts.

Cutting interest rates to fresh record lows would be a start, but it’s not enough to rescue the economy from the swamp of a Brexit-induced recession.

Britain also needs a big dose of government spending to help the real economy, in a reversal of George Osborne’s austerity agenda.

That’s the Guardian’s view. Here’s a flavour:

The Bank should drop rates, starting this Thursday. But while historic, even a cut would not achieve what might be expected in normal times. Interest rates are already very near what’s called the zero lower bound – the point at which cuts will not stimulate further growth.

As for the Bank going in for more quantitative easing, £375bn has already been pumped into the financial system, benefiting the rich and pumping up London house prices. The real boost to growth will only come with a big burst of public spending on infrastructure, services and benefits – the areas that have suffered most under austerity. Theresa May has already talked about infrastructure bonds, but she will need to go a lot further than that.

That may be ideologically uncomfortable for the Tories, now seeking ways to mitigate economic and social damage from the referendum they called. But they should consider the words of Mr Carney: “One uncomfortable truth is that there are limits to what the Bank of England can do.”

European stock markets have hit their highest levels since the EU referendum on 23 June.

But that’s not a sign of economic confidence. Instead, traders are expecting even more monetary easing from the world’s central bankers.

Philippe Gijsels, head of research at BNP Paribas Fortis in Brussels, explains:

“European shares have made up most of the lost ground after the Brexit shock. The main, if not only, reason for this is that they anticipate a strong policy response from central banks.

“A rate cut by the BoE is almost a certainty.”

Here’s a great chart from the Resolution Foundation, showing how the markets have consistently expected interest rates to rise....and been consistently disappointed.

The last decade have been a ‘game of two halves’ at the Bank of England.

Once the credit crunch struck in 2007, it slashed borrowing costs to record lows and pumped hundreds of billions into the economy through QE.

But in recent years, the BoE has been sitting on its hands, while telling the UK that borrowing costs were likely to soon start rising. They never did, though, and now a cut seems rather more likely.

Here’s a timeline of the key events:

The Brexit referendum has already sent a chill through Britain’s housing market.

The Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors’ latest survey shows that enquiries from potential buyers fell sharply last month.

Surveyors are also much gloomier. Expectations of future sales fell at the fastest rate since the survey began in 1998, and the balance of surveyors expecting house prices to fall in the next three months hit a five-year high.

Video: Hammond rules out emergency budget

Here’s a video clip of Britain’s new chancellor telling the nation not to expect an emergency budget this summer:

No emergency Brexit budget, says new chancellor Philip Hammond

The Bank of England actually took its decision yesterday, but won’t announce it until noon today.

Normally, that delay wouldn’t matter. But a lot has happened in the last 24 hours....

Fact of the morning: None of the nine policymakers on the Monetary Policy Committee have ever voted to cut UK interest rates.

One, Ian McCafferty, spent months arguing that borrowing costs should go up.

FTSE 100 hits 11-month high

Britain’s stock market has hits its highest level since the turmoil of last summer, as investors await the Bank of England’s decision in three hours time.

The FTSE 100 index of major blue-chip companies jumped by almost 1% in early trading to 6,742, a level not seen since August 2015.

The rally is led by miners, including Anglo American and UK housebuilders such as Barratt Development and Taylor Wimpey.

That suggests investors are anticipating fresh action from the Bank of England to help the economy.

The FTSE 250 index, which contains more UK-focused firms than the FTSE 100, has risen by 0.6% today.

Tony Cross of TrustNet says the sight of Theresa May getting down to work has brought calm to the City.

The FTSE-100 is bounding higher ahead of that key MPC rate verdict that’s due at midday and perhaps once again an air of confidence that’s building in the market as the new prime minister announces her cabinet.

That said, a cut from Mark Carney today is far from guaranteed and there’s also this theme emerging of trying to ensure that the BoE doesn’t actively talk the country into recession.

James Rossiter, economist at City firm TD Securities, expects a quarter-point rate cut today (from 0.5% to 0.25%).

That would be followed by further easing in August, predicts Rossiter, who is a former Bank of England staffer.

He told Bloomberg TV that the Bank will “want to send a message to the markets that they are ready to act”.

Rossiter adds that the BoE will probably “look through the inflationary shock” caused by a much weaker currency, rather than hike interest rates to cool prices (as this would hurt economic demand).

Bloomberg has polled the City, and confirmed that a majority of economists predict a rate cut at noon today.

But a significant majority believe the Bank of England will hold off until they have more information about how the economy is faring.

Here’s the details:

Thirty of 54 economists asked by Bloomberg predict a reduction, with the majority of those seeing a cut to a record-low 0.25 percent. Still, a lack of data on the outlook means 24 of those surveyed see no change this month.

More here: Bank of England Rate Cut in Focus as Brexit Rattles Economy

Pound up ahead of rate decision.

The pound is rallying his morning, up three-quarters of a cent against the US dollar at $1.322.

That suggests traders aren’t expecting a massive new stimulus boost from the Bank of England (as this would typically weaken the currency).

Investors may also be reassured that Britain now has a new prime minister, and will soon have a new cabinet. That provides more certainty, despite one surprising appointment....

Updated

Hammond: Economy has taken a Brexit shock

Philip Hammond is now speaking on Sky News, as his whistle-stop tour of the TV studios continues.

He warns that the UK economy has “taken a shock”, as businesses and consumers weren’t expecting the public to vote to leave the European Union.

The number one challenge is to stabilise the economy, send a message that Britain is “open to business”.

He adds:

We are not turning our back on the world. We are determined to maintain our outward-looking stance, and determined to maintain the prosperity of our people.

Chancellor Hammond backs Mark Carney

Britain’s new finance minister has given the Bank of England a vote of confidence, as it prepares to possibly cut interest rates.

Philip Hammond has told the BBC that Mark Carney is doing an “excellent job”, and revealed he’ll be meeting the governor this morning.

He also warned that the UK economy is already suffering from Brexit uncertainty.

Hammond has also confirmed that he won’t deliver an ‘emergency budget’ in the next few weeks.

“The prime minister made clear we will do an autumn statement in the usual way in the autumn and we’ll look carefully over the summer at the situation.

I’m seeing the governor of the Bank of England this morning and we’ll take stock of where we are.”

The emergency budget idea was floated by his predecessor George Osborne - who has been relegated to the back benches.

The Agenda: Will Bank of England cut rates today?

Good morning.

There’s one question on the lips of investors worldwide - will the Bank of England slash UK interest rates to fresh record lows today?

With Britain at risk of recession following the Brexit vote, many economists in the City are predicting that rates will be cut to 0.25% at noon London time.

That would end a seven-year stretch in which borrowing costs have been pegged at 0.5%.

Governor Mark Carney has already given clear signs that the BoE will act soon. Two weeks ago, he declared:

“In my view, and I am not prejudging the views of the other independent MPC members, the economic outlook has deteriorated and some monetary policy easing will likely be required over the summer.”

And as this chart shows, investors reckon there’s an 80% chance of a rate cut today:

But it’s not a nailed-down certainty. The Bank of England could decide to leave interest rates on hold today, and wait until August to respond to Britain’s new economic challenges.

They also have to consider inflation, which could burst back into life as the weak pound forces up the cost of imported goods (and the UK imports a lot).

Rate cuts aren’t the only weapon in Mark Carney’s arsenal. The BoE could launch a new quantitative easing programme – pumping more money into the economy, by buying bonds from commercial banks. Or it could announce new measures to boost lending to the real economy.

The decision comes at noon today, along with the minutes of this month’s meeting. They will give an insight into the Bank’s thinking about the state of the UK economy, and the consequences of the Brexit vote.

Expect the markets to move sharply at noon -- especially if the Bank does something unexpected....

We’ll be tracking the build-up to the big decision, and instant reaction and analysis from noon.

Plus other key developments in the City and beyond, as Britain’s new chancellor - Philip Hammond – gets to work.....

Updated

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*