At the time of the last dramatic slump in the amount of money being spent on advertising there was little need for head scratching to find the reason why. Inflation in 1990 was running high, consumer spending was in negative territory, as was gross domestic product.
The picture in 2001 is more difficult to understand. The worldwide economy has, of course, slowed. But while the US economy is jittery, it is not in recession. In Britain the tills are still ringing in the high streets and the consensus forecasts for GDP growth are around 2%. And yet the advertising picture is bleak and prospects for a much hoped for recovery in the second half are fading fast.
The decline, which first emerged at Britain's biggest advertising medium, ITV, has bled out through the entire media sec tor. Recruitment freezes are being imposed, jobs are starting to go, magazines are beginning to fold, and the profit warnings are coming thick and fast from the advertising agencies at the sharp end. Some 50 jobs have just gone at Saatchi & Saatchi's London office.
Media analysts at investment bank ABN Amro were last week warning that advertising growth had somehow become "dislocated" from GDP growth suggesting the current trough may be structural rather than just cyclical. ABN is forecasting global growth in advertising spend of just 1.3% for 2001, a decline of 0.9% in real terms. Worldwide advertising growth in 2000 was 10.3%.
As advertising executives gather in Cannes for the annual international advertising jamboree they are being forced to ask whether the long term upward trend for the global advertising market be sloughing off for good.
"This is the worst advertising market I've seen in 20 years. It's worse than 1991 and that was bad," says Roger Parry, chief executive of Clear Channel International, the US media group that owns the Adshel outdoor business. "Major advertisers aren't spending money. April, May and June have been absolutely appalling."
It doesn't take much digging to find evidence of the downturn. ITV remains the hardest hit among the TV channels. Granada recently disclosed that during the nine months to the end of June, ITV had suffered declines of 10.6%.
Forward bookings suggest the picture will only worsen. For July, Granada is forecasting a slump of 18%. Last week it announced a restructuring which will eliminate 100 middle management jobs and save £20m a year.
The figures, though, look equally bad for some of Britain's largest radio groups which have come to a juddering halt after years of above-average growth.
Recruitment freeze
Capital Radio was last month forced to issue its second profits warning in the space of three months. Advertising in April and May was 15% lower than the previous year and full-year profits are now expected to be down 25%. "It's bad out there," says chief executive David Mansfield. "You have a situation where unemployment is low, inflation is low, mortgage rates are low and consumer spend is forging ahead. Why, then, aren't advertisers spending?"
According to market research firm Nielsen, the display market in national newspapers in April, the most recent data, was 15% lower than in the same month in the previous year. Although nothing compared to the scale of the cuts in the City, jobs are starting to go. Associated Newspapers has told departments at the Daily Mail and Mail on Sunday to make cuts. A recruitment freeze has been implemented at News International and there have again been selective redundancies at some of its newspapers. Pearson has imposed a freeze at the Financial Times and cut jobs at FT.com.
Everywhere the talk is of lack of "visibility". When advertisers are spending money they are doing so at the last minute.
"GDP is still strong and this is the worst advertising recession in 10 years," says Daniel Kerven, media analyst at ABN. "There has been a decoupling so there must be other factors at work here. People buy these stocks because they are cyclical but they will not come back like cyclical stocks."
Technology , dot.com and telecoms advertisers were the main drivers of the exceptional ads growth in the past few years. Their subsequent retrenchment has been the chief reason for the decline and there is little hope of recovery.
Many of the dot.coms trying to build their brands have simply disappeared. But even the likes of the mobile phone networks are making worrying noises. Tougher market conditions have caused the networks to begin focusing on customer retention and away from acquisition, something which requires less above-the-line advertising. The arrival of third generation services to kickstart new growth is now unlikely before 2003 and even then there is widespread cynicism about the level of consumer interest.
Hi-tech companies everywhere are focusing on delivering profits at the expense of rapid growth to assuage the fears of investors and marketing is a cost which is usually cut back first. The hi-tech collapse has inevitably had a knock-on effect and jarred sentiment among more traditional advertisers in consumer goods who have cut back on discretionary spend.
Ironically, the tech-led slump has compounded the troubles of the online market which has been blown away before it had a chance to establish itself as a real alternative to traditional media for advertisers. Even the likes of Yahoo! are struggling and the advertising model for online services has become widely discredited.
The problems, too, are across all the developed economies. That was evident on Friday from the profit warnings issued by Interpublic and True North, the top 10 marketing services groups which have exposure worldwide. French outdoor advertising firm JC Decaux was forced to slash the price range for its impending flotation by 20%.
There have been one-off factors in Britain. Government advertising through the central office of information grew substantially last year and, during the general election, dropped off again, hurting radio in particular. There was also the Euro 2000 football tournament which guaranteed high audiences and premium prices but most of the factors inflating demand including the dot.com boom, have now passed. ITV's July figure compares with growth of only 1.6% last year. That means there can be no more hiding behind exceptional circumstances.
But ITV, as the leading mass medium, has its own unique problems. The fall in TV advertising as a whole disguises much better figures elsewhere. Channel 4's advertising, for instance, is only 2% down for the first half of the year.
Assumption
Mr Parry comments: "Forward bookings for outdoor sites are looking better in the next quarter - but I suspect it may be a more structural change in broadcasting. Media has fragmented. There are so many more ways of spending money. Until four years ago Procter & Gamble never used outdoor advertising and now they are our second biggest client. The days of the great dominance of TV may well be over."
Years of airtime inflation on ITV have underlined the growing trend for traditional consumer goods advertisers and car makers to look for other ways to spend their money, be it price promotions, public relations or junk mail.
Joe Lamb at the Incorporated Society of British Advertisers said: "A lot of people tied up their advertising budgets for this year on the assumption that the levels of inflation on airtime that we have witnessed for the past 10 years would continue, something which has been a genuine frustration for advertisers. Instead they cast around and started to look for better deals elsewhere whether it be outdoor, radio or Channel 4."
The marketing director of Nestlé, one the highest spending advertisers in Britain, recently told a conference of his peers that the company was increasingly turning its back on TV. He cited chocolate bar KitKat. Until a couple of years ago, the brand was promoted solely by TV and posters. Now Nestlé uses TV, radio, press, outdoor, sponsorship and new media, including text messaging. TV accounted for the company's entire marketing budget 10 years ago, 80% five years ago, 67% last year and 65% this year. Within three years, TV will account for "much less than two-thirds" of the marketing budget.
Little wonder that the likes of WPP and True North have been falling over themselves to buy direct marketing, PR and sales promotion agencies. Ironically, better ratings and lower demand means that ITV is now 30% cheaper to advertise on than it was 12 months ago.
The only sector that has shown any kind of robustness is the business magazine sector, the least glamorous but a haven for investors in times of trouble.
The most worrying interpretation for this depressing set of figures is not that advertising spend has been decoupled from the wider economy - but that it is an indicator for what is to come.
If that is the case, then the world is heading for the kind of recession that gripped the global economy 10 years ago.