Claire Cozens 

Indy relaunch doesn’t go far enough, say media buyers

12.15pm: Media buyers have given a cautious welcome to the new-look Independent but say it won't make a big difference to circulation, writes Claire Cozens.
  
  

Independent
The Independent Review Photograph: Public domain

Media buyers have given a cautious welcome to the new-look Independent but say the redesign is too limited to make a significant difference to the paper's circulation.

Most say they like the tabloid-sized Review section and welcomed magazine-style features such as the daily Ten Best consumer guide, which today features a review of the top 10 luxury men's watches by the GQ editor Dylan Jones.

"They described the Review as a daily magazine and there are some nice touches, with more use of colour and some very consumery features," said Steve Goodman, the group press director at MediaCom.

"It's also saddle-stitched, which gives it more of a magazine feel than the others. I'm reasonably impressed although it would look better if they'd used heavier paper."

Buyers also approved of the decision to move the comment and letters pages from the Review into the main newspaper.

But some felt the changes had not gone far enough.

"I only wish they'd been more radical and made the whole thing tabloid," said Sarah Leach, media director at PHD.

"I think that would be right for the young, urban readers they say they're going for, who are going to be reading it on a packed train or a tube."

Others welcomed the changes, but expressed concern at the lack of promotion surrounding the relaunch.

"They're not massive changes. They've moved the letters and comment into the main section, which is the right place for them -- the review section was a bit of a mish-mash before," said Neil Allen, the head of press at MediaEdge CIA.

"But the biggest issue they face is telling people about it. They're not doing any TV advertising and there's no evidence of any price-cutting or sampling.

"There's a danger, as with the relaunch of the Sunday Independent, that you spend all this money relaunching then no one knows about it."

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*