John Cassy, media business correspondent 

Cordiant isn’t working so the banks are called in

Cordiant's woes highlight the folly of pursuing size rather than excellence, reports John Cassy.
  
  


Under the Saatchi & Saatchi banner it was one of the most admired advertising agencies. Blue chip clients such as British Airways flocked to it for corporate reinvention while its "Labour isn't working" campaign is credited with a crucial role in bringing Margaret Thatcher to power in 1979.

Yet the folly of the pursuit of size rather than excellence that the renamed Cordiant pursued following the bust-up that led to the departure of brothers Charles and Maurice Saatchi in the late 90s was underlined yesterday.

The marketing services group was forced to admit that it was in talks with bankers about renegotiating loan agreements and was ready to write £155m off the value of companies bought at the height of the dotcom boom.

In an unscheduled statement the group confirmed it was selling three businesses to reduce borrowings, which had risen to £249m, and made an unspecified number of job cuts.

The new write-off means that it has blown more than £350m on acquisitions in the past three years as it failed in an attempt to emulate the global advertising holding companies WPP and Interpublic.

Analysts said the collapse in advertising spend and the effects of the September 11 attacks had crippled the company. "They're up against the wall," said Susannah Bell, analyst at Teather & Greenwood.

Investor unease about the performance of the group has seen its shares fall by more than 90% from their peak.

The chairman, chief executive and finance director in charge during the period have all left over the past year.

David Hearn, brought in as chief executive at the start of this year to stabilise the business, said yesterday that worse than expected conditions in the revenue-starved sector had given him no choice but to renegotiate loan agreements struck less than a year ago.

"We are not expecting any growth in the market in 2003. Clearly we are looking to make a very serious reduction to our debts but we are not forced sellers or under any pressure from our lenders. This is our plan and we will not sell if we don't get offers that value the business correctly."

Cordiant hopes that by selling off German subsidiary Scholz & Friends, British public relations firm Financial Dynamics and a large portion of its Australian operations it can as much as halve its debt load. "We have had several expressions of interest in all three assets," Mr Hearn said.

Cordiant has an option to sell a 25% stake in media buyer Zenith Optimedia, valued at £75m, to French rival Publicis by January next year but Mr Hearn said the transaction could be brought forward.

The £155m non-cash charge largely relates to the collapse in value of public relations division Lighthouse, the owner of Financial Dynamics. Less than a year ago Cordiant wrote off £200m on the value of Lighthouse and a number of other companies it had bought in an attempt to move from pure advertising into branding and market research.

Mr Hearn said a further £45m of costs would be taken out of the business during 2003, largely through job losses. He refused to say how many staff would go.

Bates Worldwide, the best known part of the business, does advertising for B&Q and Woolworths. But it has been hit by a string of account losses including car group Hyundai and failed Australian airline Ansett. Mr Hearn dismissed speculation among rivals that it is an agency in freefall. "Bates profits are solidly up on last year and revenues are increasing. Clients are supportive of what we are doing and not one of our top 10 customers is up for review."

Group revenues for 2002 are likely to be down 11% to £533m, due to tough conditions and account losses in the US. Cost cuts are expected to enable operating profits before exceptional items and writedowns to come in at £37m. Restructuring is expected to bring a charge of about £45m.

Mr Hearn said the changes were imperative because "market conditions remain depressed and we see little prospect of revenue growth this year". Or, as the Saatchis might have said: "Cordiant isn't working."

Beanz to Benz - who has who

Not for sale

Bates Advertising

Advertising agency, offices in UK, US, Asia.

Clients include Heinz, Royal Mail

Network 141

Marketing services company.

Clients include Audi, BAT

Healthworld

Healthcare marketing

Clients include Novartis, GlaxoSmithKline

Fitch

Branding and design company

Clients include Virgin Trains, Nissan

Up for sale

Financial Dynamics

Financial PR agency

Clients include Aviva, GlaxoSmithKline

Scholz & Friends (77% stake)

German advertising agency

Clients include DaimlerChrysler, Davidoff

George Patterson Bates

Australian advertising agency

Clients include National Australia Bank, Rugby World Cup

Possible sale in 2004

Zenith Optimedia (25% stake)

Media buying agency

Clients include Hyundai, BT

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*