When Malcolm Wicks stepped in to his new job as Energy Minister, he faced a number of problems that needed urgent solutions.
These were spelt out for him on his first day as follows: (1) how to achieve goals on climate change while maintaining security of (energy) supply and international competitiveness; (2) how to handle the tight supply/ demand balance next winter; (3) how far he could rely on the present market framework to deliver the very large investment needed to ensure security of supply in future; (4) what role nuclear build and new technologies might play in helping to meet CO2 and supply objectives; (5) implications of energy prices staying high or going even higher.
Tricky enough without Blair choosing climate change as a key issue for the Gleneagles G8 summit this week.
Wicks says he loved the pensions job, and loves energy too: 'They are both complex and controversial and everyone has got a view. Everyone has got an opinion on nuclear, it is big stuff, it is controversial.'
So, since he brings it up, what's his opinion on nuclear? 'I don't have an opinion. I am open-minded about it, which I don't think is the same as being empty-minded.'
Does this mean the subject is closed - as it has officially been since 2003, when the last energy White Paper constructed a compromise policy that neither backed the building of nuclear power stations to generate 'carbon- free' electricity nor closed the door on them to placate both pro- and anti-nuclear ministers?
Sort of. Wicks points out that the polarised positions of the nuclear and renewable power lobbies have distorted the argument. 'A lot of enthusiasts say it is all about wind power or all about nuclear,' he says. 'Quite a chunk [a fifth] of our generation comes from nuclear. It is about whether we maintain that in future.'
The background is what makes the decision tricky. Britain will probably fail to meet its target of reducing CO2 emissions by 20 per cent from 1990 levels by 2010 - they have risen in recent years thanks to high oil and gas prices and cheap coal, which generators have increasingly used. Old nuclear and coal power stations will start closing in 2008. The DTI calculates that 25 gigawatts of generation - around a third of today's capacity - will need to be built by 2020. These will need to be low- or zero-emission.
'It [climate change] is the most pressing issue in the world, I think it is as big an issue for this department as it is for Defra [the Department for the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs]. There can be no doubt that the climate is changing in very worrying ways. People who doubt it, for whatever reasons, have got their heads in the sand.
'We disagree with the American analysis and have told them so. But that is not a reason for us to become belligerent.' He adds that some states - New England and California - have taken measures to reduce emissions.
Despite widespread scepticism in and outside the DTI, Wicks is sticking to its target of 10 per cent of electricity from renewable sources (chiefly onshore wind power) by 2010 and to its aspiration of 20 per cent by 2020, which will depend on the development of offshore wind and new technologies.
'It is a tough target to hit,' he says of 2010. 'I am very committed to it. But this is more than a story about wind turbines... it is also other technologies.' He believes that the Renewables Obligation, which supports the higher price of renewables - wind turbines, energy crops, wave and solar power - through tradeable certificates, is clearing a space in the market for these technologies. He mentions two social housing solar power schemes (among the most expensive of the technologies) he has visited: 'From what I can see, I am convinced.'
Wicks has another emerging area - directing £25 million of public money into clean coal technology, where CO2 from coal-fired power stations is separated and pumped into former North Sea oil reservoirs or into aquifers under the mainland. Opec, he says, has expressed interest in the technology and 'the Norwegians are doing it and there are some pilots in the US I want to look at'.
In reflections that might appeal to Lee Raymond, chief executive of Exxon, but be less welcome to environmentalists, he adds: 'We [he highlights India and China] are going to be burning lots of fuels, lots of coal, lots of oil and lots of gas. If we can find ways of burning the stuff more efficiently and more significantly if we can find ways of capturing CO2, maybe in the North Sea, I think we have to look at that very hard.'
Despite his view that the DTI has as important a role in climate change policy as Defra, he concedes that the key policy work is the Defra-led Climate Change Review, due to be finalised this year.
Central to that review - which deals with meeting Kyoto targets to 2010, and so will not be affected by longer-term decisions on generation - is the EU Emissions Trading Scheme, which caps the output of generators and industrial users and forces them to pay for overshooting by buying tradeable certificates from those who undershoot, who in turn receive payment. The scheme has seen the price of carbon rise from about €7 a tonne to €24 this year.
Wicks is in a difficult position. The DTI, wary of threats to business competitiveness, is fighting in the European courts to increase the UK cap. Defra wants it raised in phase two, from 2008. He repeats the DTI line that the original cap was a miscalculation and stresses the importance of competitiveness and economic growth.
But asked which is more important, competitiveness or global warming, he is blunt: 'Climate change. In the long term if you don't get that right we are all dead.'
On building new nuclear plants he says: 'We are not going to take a decision this year.' He adds that it is unlikely that a white paper on nuclear is necessary. 'What we need is a decision,' he says.
And if the answer was yes? Could they be funded privately?: 'There would have to be some kind of understanding between the government and the market.'
That would probably mean fixed-price contracts to guarantee investors a return - a highly controversial move.