A boycott of Carlton and Granada programmes would have little or no effect on the two ITV companies, according to media buyers.
The Football League is hoping to hit back at the two broadcasters with a direct action campaign and has urged football fans to boycott popular ITV shows such as Coronation Street and Blind Date.
Keith Harris, the chairman of the Football League, said the boycott would add to the financial woes of the two broadcasting giants by putting advertisers off ITV.
But experts today dismissed the idea, saying even a mass switch-off by football fans would scarcely dent ITV's viewing figures.
"It's a nice idea but my view would be it's hugely unlikely to have any sustained effect on viewing levels," said David Peters, the broadcast planning director at Carat.
"You've got to remember we're only talking about clubs outside the Premiership, so it's not even all football fans. Even if all Football League supporters were to comply, I don't think it would have a massive impact."
Andy Zonfrillo, the managing partner at MindShare, points out that advertisers will have already committed their budgets for ITV up to the end of May.
"All it would do is drive up the cost of advertising per viewer if fewer people watch. Advertisers couldn't now withdraw even if the Football League were able to organise a mass boycott, which seems unlikely anyway," he said.
Nevertheless, history has shown that consumer pressure can have a huge impact on companies - particularly when it comes to football, where passions run high.
Rupert Murdoch's attempt to buy Manchester United was scuppered because of widespread disapproval of the deal, and his Sun newspaper suffered a huge drop in sales as a result of its coverage of the Hillsborough disaster.
The newspaper sparked outrage on Merseyside when it ran an article blaming fans for the tragedy in April 1989.
Sales of the Sun dropped by around 200,000 copies a day after football supporters organised a boycott and the impact is still being felt in Liverpool more than a decade later.