Henry Northover 

Creditors have little to celebrate

The end of 2000 was marked with mutual backslapping by rich country governments and international financial institutions.
  
  


The end of 2000 was marked with mutual backslapping by rich country governments and international financial institutions. Self-imposed deadlines had been met as 22 countries entered the latest debt scheme - the enhanced heavily indebted poor countries initiative (HIPC). But for debt campaigners the new year was a missed opportunity for cancelling the poorest countries' unpayable debts.

Creditors agree that the rationale for debt reduction is poverty reduction. But they accept no obligation to write off the debt necessary to finance poverty reduction or to meet development targets of halving global poverty by the year 2015.

For creditors, debt relief is more about how much debtor countries can afford to pay, taking export earnings as the principal measure of debt sustainability. So there is an asymmetry between ends and means at the heart of the creditors' debt relief project. They are committed to debtor countries meeting the 2015 development targets, but will not use these benchmarks to decide how much debt cancellation governments need.

For Cafod, social justice and good economics are inseparable. The more stable variable by which to judge the capacity of a country to repay its debts is the incidence and depth of poverty.

Debt sustainability should be judged on the revenue governments can feasibly earn without further punishing the poor or developing distortions in the economy. How much government income is it reasonable to use for servicing debt?

Having calculated a government's feasible revenue, there is a trade-off between meeting debt servicing obligations and financing poverty reduction expenditures needed to meet the 2015 targets. The funding of poverty reduction should take precedence over meeting external debt servicing obligations.

Government revenues are limited by both the extent and the depth of poverty. It is not reasonable to tax those earning less than a dollar a day, and this means that the slice of taxable GDP taken by the government is limited. Even if countries managed to raise the figure to 25% of GDP - and in reality they are unlikely to get close to this - it is clear that for most HIPCs these revenues would be dwarfed by the costs of meeting the 2015 targets, such as universal access to primary health care and primary education.

But also, if the depth of poverty - the amount by which the very poorest fall below the one dollar a day threshold - is taken into account as a shortfall in people's income that can be alleviated or reduced by government financed programmes, then for all HIPCs there will be no residual government revenue available for debt servicing.

According to Cafod's calculations, most highly indebted poor countries need not only 100% debt cancellation but also substantially increased levels of grant aid. The choice for creditors is simple: either cancel enough debt to help the world's poorest countries meet development goals of halving poverty or carry on with self-congratulation over piecemeal debt write-offs.

• Henry Northover is a policy analyst with the aid agency Cafod

Useful links

Jubilee 2000

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*