Heather Connon 

The great asbestos bonanza

Legal actions could total $200bn and last 40 years, writes Heather Connon.
  
  


Packaging company Georgia Pacific last week made a $350million provision for it; oil services company Halliburton has been forced to deny that the cost of it will force it into bankruptcy, as has happened to 12 other firms in the past 18 months; Smiths Group has seen its value fall because of it; and Royal & Sun Alliance is expected to add at least a third to its provisions against it.

The 'it' in all these cases is asbestos, or litigation by people who have been exposed to it. This has become one of the fastest-growing sorts of legal action in the US. The latest estimates are that the total cost will exceed $200 billion, paid to more than a million people, and that suits will continue for at least the next 40 years.

That is bad news for an insurance industry already rocked by the World Trade Centre attacks and the Enron collapse. Insurance information company AM Best, a leading expert on the issue, predicts that the worldwide cost to insurers will be $65bn - a huge increase on the $40bn estimate made five years ago - and it warns that many companies will need to increase their provisions to cover it.

The firm's Gerard Altonji estimates that the industry's reserves for these cases are now around $10bn and that the firms have paid out $22bn so far. That leaves around $32bn still to find.

This is likely to be borne out in the forthcoming reporting season, as most of the leading global companies increase their reserves against claims. Britain's Royal & Sun Alliance is making its triennial review of its provisions, and analysts expect a big increase.

There are fears that the situation could worsen even further following the destruction of the World Trade Centre, where asbestos was used to build at least 60 floors. Environmental campaigners are concerned about the level of asbestos in the air, while up to a third of firefighters are suffering from what has become known as World Trade Centre cough.

Insurance experts are uncertain whether the discovery of the fire-resistant material in the stricken building will increase liability for the disaster.

One insurance executive said: 'The clean-up is being covered by the property insurers, who are already assuming they will have to pay up to the limits of the cover. Whether the firemen, who were sent in by the city authorities, would have a claim against someone else is another matter. But I do not believe it is included in initial estimates.'

Yet asbestos has not been manufactured in the US for more than 30 years, not since the time litigation first started. And leading experts on the serious conditions it can cause, such as mesothelioma or lung cancer, believe that the number of people contracting them will now start to fall.

Whether or not that is the case is unknown. What is certain, however, is that more and more people are claiming, and getting, compensation. In the early Nineties, the average defendant faced perhaps 20,000 claims a year. Now, that has risen to between 40,000 and 60,000. Claims against the Manville Trust, which assumed the liabilities of asbestos maker Johns-Manville when claims forced it into bankruptcy, are rising by more than 80 per cent a year and have now reached more than 500,000 - five times the number originally estimated.

There are a number of reasons for this: people are living longer, so they have more chance of contracting the diseases, some of which can take up to 40 years to appear; diagnosis is improving; and treatment is becoming more costly.

The main reason for the surge, however, is Americans' fondness for litigation and the growing realisation that almost anyone can get a windfall by jumping on the bandwagon. For the first time in two decades, newspapers and TV stations are carrying adverts encouraging people to join the litigation tide.

Their success owes a lot to the peculiar nature of asbestos litigation. Lawyers tend to assemble what are described as 'inventory cases' - bundling together perhaps 1,000 defendants and suing as many as 40 different companies simultaneously. While a small proportion of these people will have mesothelioma or asbestosis, the vast majority will have conditions such as thickening of the lung lining, which often does not develop into a serious condition.

Rather than get taken to court in states such as Texas or Mississippi, which have a reputation for awarding high levels of damages, defendants are settling these claims. And, while the amount awarded per claimant may be only a couple of hundred dollars, multiply this by a number of defendants, and it is enough to boast about down in the local bar.

The key question is whether the tide of litigation can be stemmed. Some insurers are trying. Equitas, the vehicle which took on most of the liabilities from old Lloyd's of London syndicates, along with some other insurers in the London market, announced last year that it would cover defendants' settlements only if they could prove that the payments were made to claimants suffering from asbestos-related diseases - thickened lung linings would not count - and that the defendant's products caused the damage. This is a brave attempt, but it is being challenged in a number of cases and it is too early to say whether it will be successful.

The US government has been debating for years whether to implement a national agreement to take on unsettled cases - so far to no avail. Dick Cheney, the US Vice-President, used to be a director of Halliburton, so he will be the familiar with the issue, although the White House may prefer not to take any more action that looks as if it is simply being friendly to corporate America.

If the tide of bankruptcies continues, it may have to. Already, household names in America, such as WR Grace, Federal Mogul and Owens Corning, have filed for bankruptcy, citing asbestos liabilities as a key reason.

If the pace of collapse continues, there will be no one left to sue.

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*