Early evening summary
- The government will guarantee £330bn of loans to businesses in an “unprecedented” package of financial support to shore-up the British economy as the coronavirus outbreak escalates. As Richard Partington reports, the chancellor, Rishi Sunak, said if more help was needed it would be provided, with a pledge to deliver “whatever it takes” to keep companies and people solvent. Saying the British state would need to intervene in the economy in ways that were unimaginable just weeks ago, the chancellor said he would also provide tax breaks and other measures worth £20bn to protect companies and households suffering amid the economic collapse triggered by the virus.
- Boris Johnson has likened the fight against coronavirus to a wartime enterprise. In his opening remarks at the press conference where Rishi Sunak announced the rescue package for business, he said:
We must act like any wartime government and do whatever it takes to support our economy. That’s the main purpose of this press conference this afternoon ...
Yes this enemy can be deadly, but it is also beatable – and we know how to beat it and we know that if as a country we follow the scientific advice that is now being given we know that we will beat it.
And however tough the months ahead we have the resolve and the resources to win the fight.
And, to repeat, this government will do whatever it takes.
- Johnson has hinted that the government is moving closer to announcing the closure of schools. (See 5.48pm.) Earlier the largest teaching union, the National Education Union, called for schools to be shut. (See 11.50am.)
- Dominic Raab, the foreign secretary, has said the government is advising against all non-urgent travel abroad for the next 30 days. (See 12.44pm.)
- Sir Patrick Vallance, the government’s chief scientific adviser, has said that the restrictions on social contact announced yesterday will be in place for months. (See 2.47pm.) When it was put to him that they could last 18 months, he said he did not know - but he did not reject the possibility outright.
That’s all from this blog for tonight.
But there will be more coverage on our general coronavirus outbreak live blog all evening. You can read it here.
Updated
Here is some comment on the Rishi Sunak package for business from thinktanks and journalists.
From the Resolution Foundation, a thinktank focusing on work, poverty and inequality
Our response to the Chancellor's statement on the government's new package of measures to tackle the impact of coronavirus on the economy 👇 pic.twitter.com/9dgPVzruiA
— ResolutionFoundation (@resfoundation) March 17, 2020
From the Telegraph’s Jeremy Warner
The UK Government will have to go much further than this in the weeks ahead. Not much here for those losing their livelihoods. Sunak hints at income support to come.
— jeremy warner (@JeremyWarnerUK) March 17, 2020
From the BBC’s Andrew Neil
Sunak unveils massive assistance package for business hit by the virus. Dwarfing budget measures.
— Andrew Neil (@afneil) March 17, 2020
From my colleague Aditya Chakrabortty
The loans and grants for business also big -- but nothing further on sick pay or on benefits.
— Aditya Chakrabortty (@chakrabortty) March 17, 2020
Six days ago, Sunak unveiled a corona-budget with statutory sick pay at its heart. The pandemic's impact has grown since then - businesses are closing. what measures for those laid off?
I'm sorry to write this, but just as in its tackling of the pandemic itself the UK's economic response lags far behind our European neighbours. Johnson talked about this being 'wartime', so why are we wielding a peashooter?
— Aditya Chakrabortty (@chakrabortty) March 17, 2020
From the BBC’s Faisal Islam
Some details the Covid-19 Commercial Paper facility if for 1 year commercial paper that was investment grade before the Covid outbreak. Set up in an entity separate from Bank of England. HM Treasury indemnified all losses. pic.twitter.com/heCPsE0S2H
— Faisal Islam (@faisalislam) March 17, 2020
And this is from Frances O’Grady, the TUC general secretary.
The Chancellor is right to provide emergency support for business. But this can’t be just a bailout for boardrooms. It has to put money in workers’ pockets too. Unions stand ready to work with govt to tackle this crisis. As always our priority is protecting jobs and livelihoods.
— Frances O'Grady (@FrancesOGrady) March 17, 2020
Sunak's plans do not go far enough to protect workers and renters, says Labour
Labour says the Rishi Sunak package of measures does not do enough to protect workers. In a statement John McDonnell, the shadow chancellor, said:
People are being laid off today and losing their incomes. We are disappointed that this package does not address their concerns.
The further announcements laid out by the chancellor lack the certainty required amidst growing public anxiety and still do not go far enough in protecting workers, renters and those who are losing their jobs, or in fully supporting businesses at the scale necessary.
In particular, the chancellor’s claim that new forms of employment support will be developed does not appreciate the urgency and gravity of the situation. Workers and businesses need to know now that they will be supported, not in a few days’ time.
Rishi Sunak’s coronavirus rescue package for business - Details
Here are the details of the coronavirus rescue package for businesses announced by Rishi Sunak, the chancellor.
There is plenty here to appeal to people who run businesses. But Sunak had very little to say about measures that will directly help employees. (Workers, of course, benefit if their employers do not go bust, but there are millions of people who face losing pay because they are off sick, or because their hours have been reduced, or who work in the gig economy, who will be looking for more immediate support.) Sunak insisted that an employment support package was on its way, and that he needed to finalise the details first with business and the unions, but the balance of today’s announcement may fuel suspicions that the concerns of owners and managers are taking precedence over the concerns of those on the payroll.
1/ We will support jobs, we will support incomes, we will support businesses, we will help you protect your loved ones. We will do whatever it takes.
— Rishi Sunak (@RishiSunak) March 17, 2020
Today, I am making available an initial £330bn of guarantees – equivalent to 15% of our GDP. Measures include:
2/ Any business who needs access to cash will be able to access a government-backed loan, on attractive terms.
— Rishi Sunak (@RishiSunak) March 17, 2020
If demand is greater than the initial £330bn I’m making available today, I will go further and provide as much capacity as required.
3/ To support lending to small and medium sized businesses, I am extending the new Business Interruption Loan Scheme I announced at the Budget last week, so that rather than loans of £1.2m, it will now provide loans of up to £5m, with no interest due for the first six months.
— Rishi Sunak (@RishiSunak) March 17, 2020
4/ I announced last week that for businesses in the retail, hospitality and leisure sectors, with a rateable value of less than £51,000, they will pay no business rates this year.
— Rishi Sunak (@RishiSunak) March 17, 2020
Today, I provided those businesses with an additional cash grant of up to £25,000 per business.
5/ I am also extending the business rates holiday to all businesses in those sectors, irrespective of rateable value.
— Rishi Sunak (@RishiSunak) March 17, 2020
6/ That means every single business in the retail, hospitality or leisure sector will pay no business rates whatsoever for 12 months, and if they have a rateable value of less than £51,000, they can now get a cash grant as well.
— Rishi Sunak (@RishiSunak) March 17, 2020
7/ I also announced last week that we would be providing £3,000 grants to the 700,000 of our smallest businesses.
— Rishi Sunak (@RishiSunak) March 17, 2020
To support their cash flow, today I can increase those grants to £10,000.
8/ Following discussions with industry, I can announce today that for those in difficulty due to coronavirus, mortgage lenders will offer a three month mortgage holiday – so that people will not have to pay a penny towards their mortgage while they get back on their feet.
— Rishi Sunak (@RishiSunak) March 17, 2020
9/ In the coming days, I will go much further to support people’s financial security. In particular, I will work with trade unions and businesses to urgently develop new forms of employment support to help protect people’s jobs and incomes through this period.
— Rishi Sunak (@RishiSunak) March 17, 2020
10/ The measures I have announced today are part of a comprehensive, coordinated and coherent response to what is a serious and evolving economic situation.
— Rishi Sunak (@RishiSunak) March 17, 2020
These are only the first steps – I will set out the next stage of our response in the coming days.
Updated
Johnson is winding up now.
He says the more thoroughly people can follow the advice they have been given, the more they will be able to save lives and protect the NHS, and the more quickly they will get through this.
And that’s it. The press conference is over.
I will be posting a summary and reaction shortly.
Q: Will you level with people about how bad this will be for the economy? Is a recession inevitable?
Sunak says this will have a significant impact on the economy.
But it will be temporary, he says.
Q: If you close schools, what will you do to help people reliant on free school meals?
Johnson says, as the government comes to this decision, it will have a plan to address this. They want to ensure parents and children get the help they need.
(It sounds from this very much as if it is more a matter of when, not if, schools are closed.)
Updated
Q: People are confused what the rules are about staying at home. Can you explain?
Johnson says people are being told to avoid all unnecessary contact where they might get the disease, and to avoid groups, large and small.
Q: You made a joke about a “last gasp” attempt to get ventilators. Is that appropriate?
Johnson says he was referring to the fact that manufacturers only have a few weeks to build more manufacturers.
This question refers to a joke revealed in the London Playbook briefing. Here is the story, which describes the PM’s conference call with manufacturers yesterday.
Some participants came away from the conference call less than impressed with Johnson’s own performance. “He couldn’t help but act the clown, even though he was a on call with serious CEOs from goodness knows how many companies,” one participant told my POLITICO colleague Charlie Cooper. This individual said the PM “joked” that the enterprise to build more life-saving ventilators could be known as “Operation Last Gasp.” Ugh.
Updated
Q: What will you do to ensure this £330bn is allocated properly?
Sunak says he is confident this can be delivered properly. There will be a retail compaign, so they hear about the coronavirus business interruption loan.
Q: What will you do about shops? People are still panic buying.
There is no need for that, Johnson says.
Updated
Q: What inputs to the model changed that led you to change strategy?
Vallance says the aim is to save the maximum number of lives. He says the proportion of people who make require ventilation looks higher.
But it was not so much the model that changed as the place the UK was judged to be in the epidemic.
Q: What sort of employment support are you looking at? Will the state pay wages?
Sunak says he wants to find a way of helping businesses meet the fixed cost of paying their staff without having to let them go. There are international models available. But he wants something that will work quickly.
Q: People are being laid off today. Would you urge firms to look at these measures first?
Sunak says he hopes this announcement will tell business that help is on its way. He does not want them to lay people off.
Q: People are confused by the advice about schools. You tell people not to mix, but you tell them to take their kids to schools where they will mix. When will you close schools?
Johnson says the position with schools is “under continuous review”.
Q: Many firms facing falling demand. Why is your help in the form of lending when these firms have no way of knowing what the future holds. They may not want to take on more debt? And why not announce today what you will do to ensure people are not penalised for staying away from work?
Johnson says this is an extraordinary package of measures.
One day the economy will bounce back, he says.
Sunak says businesses have fixed costs, on rent and staff. For rent, the government is making cash grants available.
On employees, Sunak says there have been improvements to SSP (statutory sick pay) and ESA (employment and support allowance).
But he wants to develop a bold and ambitious employment support package, he says.
There are options for this. He is working urgently on them with business and the unions.
Q: The Imperial College paper yesterday said these measures could be in place for 18 months, while we look for a vaccine. Is that right?
Sir Patrick Vallance, the government’s chief scientific adviser, says Imperial College have been working with the government all along. He says the suppression techniques need to be done in such a way that they can be released at some point. But he says no one in the world yet knows how to do this.
He says vaccines are the answer. It used to take 20 years to develop one. Now work on one is starting already. But he says he does not think it will be ready within a year.
Q: You are offering loans. How will people pay them back?
Sunak says the loans are just one aspect of the policy.
He says fiscal policy and monetary policy both play a part. There has been a significant monetary policy response already.
He says this is a very comprehensive and sizeable package of direct fiscal support for businesses, in addition to the loans.
And he says he plans to go further in terms of employment support. He will work with businesses and unions on this.
Q: Do you take responsibility for the advice? And will you take responsibility for your dad?
Johnson says of course he takes responsibility. The more people follow the advice, the more people will be saved.
They are now taking questions.
Q: Can you guarantee that firms who need to pay wages now, and people who need to pay rent now, will not lose out?
Johnson says the state is asking people to make considerable changes to their lives. And so it is only right that the state should stand behind them, he says.
Sunak says people need this support as quickly as possible. With all these interventions, he has born in mind the need to operationalise them as soon as possible.
Anyone who urgently needs help should speak to the local authority. They have got emergency funds, he says.
And he says they could talk to the banks. He says the banks have assured him that they will be supportive.
Updated
Sunak says these are only the first steps.
He is willing to do whatever it takes, he says.
Sunak says mortgage lenders will give a three-month mortgage holiday to people who need help.
And he says he will be working on more measures to help people in employment.
Sunak says he announced last week that some firms would have to pay no business rates this year.
Those business will now get grants of up to £25,000, he says.
And he says the business rates holiday will apply to all firms in the hospitality or retail sector.
He says he is also making grants worth £10,000 available to the smallest firms.
- Sunak says the total package of help being given to businesses worth £20bn.
Sunak says he will make £330bn available in lending to keep firms in business
Sunak says he is making available £330bn of loan guarantees to businesses.
Any business that needs it will be able to access a loan on attractive terms.
If he needs to go further, he will, he says.
To support liquidity amongst larger firms, he has agreed a facility with the the Bank of England.
And for smaller firms he will extend the business interruption loan scheme, which will offer loans of up to £5m,
He says both schemes will be up and running by next week.
And there will be special help for airlines.
Sunak says he will do whatever it takes to protect jobs and incomes
Rishi Sunak, the chancellor, says we have never in peacetime faced a fight like this one.
In the budget he promised to do whatever it took, he says. He says he said he would be willing to do more than the measures he announced last week, and he says he will begin that process.
This is not a time for ideology or orthodoxy, he says. This is a time to be bold.
He says he will do whatever it takes to protect jobs and incomes.
Johnson says we have the resolve and the resources to win this fight.
The government will do “whatever it takes”, he says.
Johnson says a combination of measures will be needed to beat this disease.
While we need national unity, we also need international cooperation.
Yes, this enemy can be deadly. But it is also beatable. But we know how to beat it.
Johnson says the government must boost the NHS, and research the disease.
But it also has to take a wartime approach and boost the economy, he says. He says Rishi Sunak will say more in a moment.
And the government has to protect public services too, he says.
Boris Johnson is speaking now.
He says the government’s plan starts with fighting coronavirus.
The measures announced yesterday will have an effect on the spread of the disease, he says.
- Johnson says the government may have to “go further” in terms of announcing measures to fight the disease, even though yesterday’s proposals were extreme.
In the US President Trump has just been announcing details of his own stimulus package. “We’re going big,” he said.
NEW: Trump and Mnuchin absolutely clear they want to get cash to Americans' pockets asap. Pushing for speedy legislation. Interested in $1000/month for the needy idea. Trump: "We're going big."
— Ben Riley-Smith (@benrileysmith) March 17, 2020
There is more on our US politics live blog.
Boris Johnson/Rishi Sunak press conference
Boris Johnson and Rishi Sunak, the chancellor, are due to hold what will be the second of the daily coronavirus press conferences now being staged by the press conference.
Sunak is expected to give details of a coronavirus rescue package that will help businesses and workers who face bankruptcy or unemployment as a result of the measures being implemented to tackle coronavirus. He announced measures in the budget (worth £12bn or £30bn, depending on how you count them), but only six days later those sums look wholly inadequate to the task.
Today Sunak is under pressure to announce something gargantuan by comparison. One figure doing the rounds earlier was £450bn. (See 10.15am.)
These are from my colleague Heather Stewart on what to expect from the Boris Johnson/Rishi Sunak press conference.
Hearing Rishi Sunak will bring a "blunderbuss" to this afternoon's Downing Street press conference, as the government tries to halt the plunge in confidence and reassure families and markets.
— Heather Stewart (@GuardianHeather) March 17, 2020
Experience of the 2008 crisis suggests that to have an impact, policymakers need to go early, and go big, instead of taking piecemeal steps. And the immediate impact on consumer demand this time is - visibly - much, much bigger.
— Heather Stewart (@GuardianHeather) March 17, 2020
14 more coronavirus deaths in England, taking total to 67, says NHS England
Here is the latest statement from NHS England on coronavirus deaths.
A further 14 people, who tested positive for the coronavirus (Covid-19) have died, bringing the total number of confirmed reported deaths in England to 67.
Patients were aged between 93 and 45 years old and had underlying health conditions.
Their families have been informed.
Peter Foster, the Telegraph’s Europe editor, says that, despite No 10 claiming the Brexit transition has to end on 31 December (see 4.22pm), there is now an acceptance at the top of government that the UK will have to agree to an extension. He has explained why in a Twitter thread. It starts here.
EXC: As this week's #Brexit talks formally canned, understand now top-level acceptance that UK WILL seek extension - just question of timing& choroeography. Details here 1/threadhttps://t.co/zYxXVElmeD
— Peter Foster (@pmdfoster) March 17, 2020
And here is one of his conclusions.
Have asked around and presumption is that some non-contentious formula can be found - can't see either side wanting to cut up rough.
— Peter Foster (@pmdfoster) March 17, 2020
Just make it a fait accomple - and a 'flextension' that can fall away when deal is done depending on #coronavirus timelines /9
According to Dawn Butler, a candidate for Labour’s deputy leadership, the government’s decision to announce an abrupt escalation of its anti-coronavirus strategy yesterday was prompted by Labour demanding to see the modelling used to justify the original strategy.
The science didn't change. What changed was @UKLabour asked to see the science and the modelling. #Corvid19uk
— (((Dawn Butler))) (@DawnButlerBrent) March 17, 2020
UK-EU trade talks called off for this week, but transition won't be extended, says No 10
Downing Street has confirmed that the UK-EU trade talks that were scheduled to take place this week have been cancelled. Originally they were due to take place face-to-face in London, from tomorrow until Friday. The plan for the two teams to meet in person was abandoned last week, but at the time both sides said there was a chance of the talks going ahead via video conferencing. Now they have been shelved for good.
Significantly, No 10 is also ruling out extending the Brexit transition – echoing what Dominic Raab told MPs earlier. (See 1.48pm.)
A government spokesperson said:
In light of the latest guidance on coronavirus, we will not formally be convening negotiating work strands tomorrow in the way we did in the previous round.
We expect to share a draft FTA [free trade agreement] alongside the draft legal texts of a number of the standalone agreements in the near future still, as planned.
Both sides remain fully committed to the negotiations and we remain in regular contact with the European commission to consider alternative ways to continue discussions, including looking at the possibility of video conferencing or conference calls, and exploring flexibility in the structure for the coming weeks.
The transition period ends on 31 December 2020. This is enshrined in UK law.
The final sentence in the statement refers to the fact that the EU (Withdrawal Agreement) Act contains a provision saying ministers must not extend the transition.
Updated
All but essential visits to hospitals to be banned to help them cope with coronavirus, says Stevens
Back in the health committee, Simon Stevens, the NHS England chief executive, says he wants to ban all but essential visits to hospitals during the coronavirus crisis to help hospitals cope.
He says there would be exceptions for parents with children in hospital, or for patients facing end-of-life care. He goes on:
But the presumption should be against - trying to reduce as much visiting as possible.
Updated
Johnson sets up new government committee structure to coordinate response to coronavirus
Boris Johnson has set up a new set of government committees to coordinate the response to coronavirus, or Covid-19. He will continue to chair the Cobra emergency committee regularly, No 10 says. There is also a C-19 meeting taking place daily.
And there will be four implementation committees: healthcare, chaired by Matt Hancock, the health secretary; general public sector, chaired by Michael Gove, the Cabinet Office minister; economic and business, chaired by Rishi Sunak, the chancellor; and international, chaired by Dominic Raab, the foreign secretary. The chairs of those committees will attend the daily C-19 meeting.
Schools across England are struggling to stay open, with some forced to partially or fully close as staff and students stay at home, while the UK remains one of only two European countries – alongside Belarus – with a policy of keeping them open, my colleagues Richard Adams, Sally Weale and Caroline Bannock report.
Updated
Here is an extract from the letter sent to hospitals telling them to cancel non-urgent elective surgery by 15 April. Simon Stevens mentioned it in his evidence to the committee earlier. (See 3.06pm.)
This is from the Health Service Journal’s James Illman.
BREAKING: NHS to postpone all non-urgent elective operations from 15th April at the latest, for a period of at least three months. - letter sent to all hospitals pic.twitter.com/WVloPnkf4K
— James Illman (@Jamesillman) March 17, 2020
Q: Will the four-hour A&E target still apply during this crisis?
Stevens says he would expect NHS trusts to do the right thing. That normally involves seeing patients promptly anyway, he says. But he says coronavirus will be the priority.
Stevens says, as there is a slow down in elective surgery, more anaesthetists will be available to help with patients on ventilators.
Q: How many ventilators are in use now?
Stevens says it is not just a question of using the machine. It involves a complicated procedure, with someone being being monitored all the time for 10 days. Staff have to be trained.
Powis says the number of people on ventilators changes hour by hour.
Q: Will you give guidance to intensive care doctors if they have to prioritise between particular patients?
Powis says he understands the issue. He will be working with colleagues to address this point.
Q: But doctors want guidance?
Powis says he wants to work with colleagues on this.
But he stresses that he hopes the NHS will not have to get to the point where people make these choices.
Q: But if you do, will that guidance be available?
Powis says he would work on that guidance.
Q: Should all staff be wearing masks, in case they come into contact with a coronavirus patient?
Stevens says staff have a right to expect proper protection.
Prof Steve Powis, NHS England’s national medical director, says guidance on this has been evolving as the coronavirus outbreak has developed.
Stevens says the NHS has 28m masks.
Hunt says there is a story about masks having a use-by date of 2016, with a sticker on top giving an alternative 2020 use-by date.
Prof Keith Willett, NHS England’s director of acute care, says he knows about that case. The masks were tested, he says, and so the new use-by date was accurate.
Jeremy Hunt, the former health secretary who chairs the committee, reads out a letter from an A&E doctor. He says it is “absolute carnage”. Doctors do not have the protective equipment, the doctors says. The doctor says the only protection he has had has been a piece of paper (ie, a mask) over his face. The doctor says he thinks medical staff will die as a result.
Hunt says he would like a date for when these localised distribution problems will be sorted out.
Pritchard says these problems are being sorted out right now.
Q: Do we have enough protective equipment?
Amanda Pritchard, NHS England’s chief operating officer, says nationally the NHS has the supply it needs. But there are some distributional problems. It is not all in the right place, she says.
Stevens says the NHS will need more equipment. This problem will not be resolved quickly, so there will be a need to “ramp up domestic production” of this equipment, he says. More stock will be needed in the coming months.
Q: Does the modelling show that, if all goes according to plan, we will have enough ventilators?
Stevens says it will be easier to say once we have seen what impact the changes announced yesterday will have.
He says, less than 24 hours after those measures was announced, there is still a degree of uncertainty.
Q: How many ventilators do you have?
Stevens says there are 6,699 adult mechanical ventilators, 750 paediatric ones, 691 in private hospitals and 35 in the Ministry of Defence. That makes 8,175, he says.
But he says another 3,799 are due soon, and that will take the total to around 12,000.
He says the PM has also launched an initiative to get manufacturers to make more.
NHS England chief executive says he plans to free up 30,000 NHS acute beds for coronavirus
The NHS England session is now starting.
The four witnesses are: Sir Simon Stevens, NHS England chief executive; Prof Keith Willett, its director of acute care; Amanda Pritchard, its chief operating officer; and Prof Steve Powis, its national medical director.
Q: How many acute beds to you have?
Stevens says there are 98,000 beds. The occupancy rate is below 90%
He says there are 3,700 critical care beds for adults.
But he says he wants to free up another 30,000 beds.
He says elective surgery will be suspended from 15 April for three months. And he says he is working with health authorities to unblock the discharge process.
Q: Will you have enough intensive care beds?
Stevens says this will be kept under review. If necessary, more measures will be introduced.
The hearing with Sir Patrick Vallance has now finished.
The health committee is now going to take evidence from NHS England.
Q: Does the concept of herd immunity play any role in the advice for the over-70s?
Vallance says the advice for the over-70s and the under-70s is the same. But the point is that the over-70s should follow it more stringently, he says.
He also says that, for the over-70s, the advice is primarily about what they need to do to protect themselves. For others, it is as much about protecting others from infection, he says.
Over-70s should avoid Sunday lunch with family, says chief scientific adviser
Jeremy Hunt asks Vallance if the social distancing advice for over-70s announced yesterday means that people that age should avoid Sunday lunch with their children or grandchildren.
Yes, says Vallance.
Here are the latest coronavirus figures for the UK from the government.
UPDATE on coronavirus (#COVID19) testing in the UK:
— Department of Health and Social Care (@DHSCgovuk) March 17, 2020
As of 9am 17 March 2020, a total of 50,442 people have been tested:
48,492 negative
1,950 positive
The latest confirmed number of deaths will be announced later today.
The digital dashboard will be updated later today. pic.twitter.com/ob25TmIowt
Anti-coronavirus restrictions will be in place for months, says chief scientific adviser
Asked if the measures announced yesterday would have to be in place for 18 months, Vallance said he did not know how long they would have to last. But he said it would certainly not be just a couple of weeks, he said. He went on:
It is going to be months - I do not know how many months.
Chief scientific adviser Patrick Vallance questioned by MPs
Sir Patrick Vallance, the government’s chief scientific adviser, is being questioned by the Commons health committee. The hearing started earlier than planned, and here are some of the key points so far.
- Vallance sidestepped a question about whether the government had changed its strategy from mitigation to suppression.
Chief Scientific Advisor Sir Patrick Vallance is now before health select committee
— Sam Coates Sky (@SamCoatesSky) March 17, 2020
Asked if gvt changed goal from mitigation to suppression, PV says it's a matter of "semantics whether it's suppression, delay or mitigation". The goal is saving lives & protecting vulnerable
- He said 55,000 people having coronavirus in the UK was a reasonable estimate.
Chief scientific adviser Sir Patrick Vallance says 55,000 people infected with coronavirus in the UK is a "reasonable ball park" estimate.
— Kevin Schofield (@PolhomeEditor) March 17, 2020
- He said keeping the number of deaths from coronavirus below 20,000 would be a good outcome.
Sir Patrick Vallance: "seasonal flu tends to lead to 8k excess deaths, so if we can get [the number of deaths from covid19] down to 20k and below, that's a good outcome of where we would hope to get to with this outbreak"
— Tom Rayner (@RaynerSkyNews) March 17, 2020
Vallance on the coronavirus death rate: "If we can get this down to numbers 20,000 or below, that's a good outcome. But it's still horrible."
— Kevin Schofield (@PolhomeEditor) March 17, 2020
NEW: Chief Scientific Adviser SIr Patrick Vallance tells the Health Select Committee the social distancing measures that have now been introduced should reduce the peak of the spread by around 50%
— Tom Rayner (@RaynerSkyNews) March 17, 2020
- He said there was a need for a big increase in coronavirus testing. And he said NHS staff would be the next group to be prioritised.
Sir Patrick Vallance tells MPs NHS staff are "the next group of people" who will be prioritised for testing
— Tom Rayner (@RaynerSkyNews) March 17, 2020
'Britain's needs a big increase in testing .. and I'm pushing hard for it' - UK chief scientific advisor to MPs
— Ben Quinn (@BenQuinn75) March 17, 2020
Subtle insight from Sr Patrick Vallance into the debate which is going on inside govt/expert circles
https://t.co/zwGUQ7QGza
Updated
Raab claims he is confident Brexit trade talks with EU can still be concluded in 2020
Back in the Commons Labour’s Stephen Kinnock also asked Dominic Raab, the foreign secretary, if the government would extend the Brexit transition in the light of the coronavirus crisis.
In response, Raab went further than he did when Ben Bradshaw asked this. (See 1.19pm.) He replied:
As far as I’m aware the negotiations can still proceed, given all of the logistical arrangements we’ve put in place. We are confident we can get this done. And, actually, I don’t think delaying Brexit negotiations will give anyone the certainty on either side of the channel that they need.
Gavin Williamson says routine Ofsted inspections to be suspended
Back to schools for a moment, and Gavin Williamson, the education secretary for England, says he does not want to close schools, despite the National Education Union call for schools to be shut. (See 11.50am). But he says he is suspending routine Ofsted inspections.
We are committed to supporting schools to stay open at this difficult time. As part of our measures to help them, we are temporarily suspending routine Ofsted inspections. https://t.co/690QHNKDCi
— Gavin Williamson (@GavinWilliamson) March 17, 2020
From my colleague Jennifer Rankin
European commission to launch today EU-wide procurement scheme of ventilators, as Ursula von der Leyen had promised.
— Jennifer Rankin (@JenniferMerode) March 17, 2020
"A very big majority of member states" are interested says EC spox.
I understand the UK *cannot* take part under transition terms.
Updated
Layla Moran, the Lib Dem MP, asks if the government will subsidise airline companies.
Raab says the government will work with the industry to see what support it can provide.
Updated
Raab refuses to rule out using RAF or Royal Navy to repatriate vulnerable Britons
Mark Pritchard, a Conservative, asks if the Royal Navy or the Royal Air Force could be used to repatriate the most vulnerable.
Raab says that would be a last resort, but he says he is not ruling anything out.
Airlines UK, an industry body, has said that the Foreign Office’s decision to advise against all non-essential travel abroad will bring “more devastation” to airline companies. Commenting on the announcement, Tim Alderslade, its chief executive, said:
This is of no surprise given recent developments but clearly it will bring more devastation to the airline and wider travel industry, which were already dealing with a truly critical situation and now face an uncertain future, with international passenger aviation from the EU and UK effectively suspended until further notice.
Labour’s Ben Bradshaw asks if the government will now agree to extend the Brexit transition in the light of the coronavirus crisis. Raab avoids the question, but he says the engagement that the Foreign Office has had with Cuba, over the Braemar cruise ship, shows that the government is working with other countries post-Brexit.
Raab says freight lorry drivers who are involved in supplying shops count as people engaged in essential travel.
Back in the Commons Dominic Raab, the foreign secretary, says there are not just tens of thousands of Britons abroad, but hundreds of thousands. That is why people must be “realistic” about what the government can do to help them all, he says.
There have been 12 new coronavirus cases in Wales, according to Public Health Wales.
We can confirm that 12 new cases have tested positive for Novel Coronavirus (COVID-19) in #Wales, bringing the total number of confirmed cases to 136.
— Public Health Wales (@PublicHealthW) March 17, 2020
More here: https://t.co/OzjFW7ydN6 pic.twitter.com/ADNPPfduOm
Richard Drax, a Conservative, says schools that have have to cancel trips will not get their money back unless the Foreign Office specifically advises against travel to a particular country.
Raab says the Foreign Office is advising against all but essential travel globally. He suggests that should be clear enough for the insurance companies.
In her response to Dominic Raab a few minutes ago Emily Thornberry, the shadow foreign secretary, cited the experience of a constituent called Tom, one of 65 Britons stuck in Peru, as evidence that consular staff were not doing enough to help people. She said:
Tom’s flight today to Britain is cancelled and his calls to our embassy in Lima have not been answered. And why is that? Because the embassy itself has decided to close down for 15 days just when its services were needed most.
The secretary of state said in his statement that our consular teams are working around the clock to provide the best information to UK nationals, well I’m afraid that simply isn’t the case in Tom’s experience.
Across the world there are tens of thousands of British nationals in the same position as Thomas and all with the same message for the British government - help bring us home, as far as we’re concerned, our travel is essential.
She also said the government could not “pass the buck” on repatriation.
Yes it’s difficult, yes it’s expensive, but that is the nature of the crisis that we face.
In the Commons Labour’s Hilary Benn asks in what circumstances the government would be willing to bring people home.
Raab says people should read the Foreign Office travel advice.
But he says the Foreign Office is also aware of the vulnerability of some people, like those on the Braemar cruise ship.
Updated
From the BBC’s political editor, Laura Kuenssberg
Cabinet minister says about to enter period where 'govt will involve itself in lives of millions of people in way we haven't seen since the war' - says collective mood at cabinet was 'grim determination' to get through 'unprecedented challenge for any govt in peacetime'
— Laura Kuenssberg (@bbclaurak) March 17, 2020
In the Commons Labour’s Chris Bryant asks why Dominic Raab is warning that people may not be able to return to the UK in the future, but also not advising people who are abroad to come back home now.
Raab says these decisions are individual judgment calls that people will have to make for themselves.
As the Times’ Steven Swinford points out, Dominic Raab’s announcement makes the prospect of a bail-out for the aviation industry even more likely.
Feels like huge bailout for airlines are now inevitable after Government advises against all non-essential international travel for 30 days
— Steven Swinford (@Steven_Swinford) March 17, 2020
British people who are abroad being warned their 'flights may be cancelled at short notice' and travel restrictions could be put in place
Here is more from the Foreign Office press notice about this announcement.
Whether travel is essential or not is a personal decision and circumstances differ from person to person. It is for individuals themselves to make an informed decision based on the risks and FCO advice. Anyone still planning to travel should check the validity of their travel insurance.
UK inward and outward travel has already fallen by a significant amount since the outbreak of coronavirus. Ryanair, Virgin and EasyJet have cut flights by 80% this month and IAG has decreased capacity by 75%.
The UK’s extensive diplomatic network is continuing to work around the world to support British people at the greatest risk of exposure to the virus.
In the last week 430 changes have been made to FCO Travel Advice – more than in the entirety of 2019.
We will continue to do everything in our power to get those British nationals affected the care, support and advice they need. We are also working urgently to ensure international governments have sensible plans to enable the return of British and other travellers and, crucially, that they keep borders open for enough time to allow people to return home on commercial flights.
British people who become ill overseas should, in the first instance, seek care and support from the country they are in.
In the Commons Dominic Raab is now responding to questions posed by Emily Thornberry, his Labour shadow.
She asked what non-essential travel means. Raab says the Foreign Office leaves it up to individuals to decide. But he says the Foreign Office’s wish is for people not to travel.
He says the Foreign Office has a hotline for MPs who need more detailed information.
Raab says it would not be possible for the UK to be able to repatriate all Britons abroad, because there are so many of them.
He says the UK advice has been to follow the best expert advice.
Detail of Foreign Office advice against all non-essential foreign travel for 30 days
Here is the Foreign Office press notice about this announcement.
Today the Foreign & Commonwealth Office (FCO) has advised against all non-essential international travel, initially for a period of 30 days. This advice takes effect immediately.
This change in travel advice reflects the pace at which other countries are either closing their borders or implementing restrictive measures in response to the global coronavirus pandemic.
Often there is little or no notice when countries take these steps and restrictions are also being imposed in areas where no cases of coronavirus have yet been reported. They are therefore very difficult to predict.
British people who decide that they still need to travel abroad should be fully aware of the increased risks of doing so. That includes the risk that they may not be able to get home, if travel restrictions are put in place. Anyone still considering travel to be realistic about the level of disruption they are willing and able to endure, and to make decisions in light of the unprecedented conditions we face.
We are not currently advising British people to immediately return to the UK if they are overseas, except for a few countries detailed in our travel advice. However, British people should keep in mind that flights may be cancelled at short notice or other travel restrictions may be put in place by foreign governments.
If people do want to return to the UK soon, then they need to take account of the fast moving situation and plan accordingly, while flights remain available in many places.
Coronavirus: @DominicRaab is giving a statement about the FCO's latest travel advice. They're now advising against non-essential travel *globally,* initially for 30 days.
— Heather Stewart (@GuardianHeather) March 17, 2020
Raab says freight is not included in that advice: "we do regard this kind of travel as essential." Says FCO will work with industry to ensure it can "maintain the flow of goods, whilst protecting the wellbeing of staff."
— Heather Stewart (@GuardianHeather) March 17, 2020
Dominic Raab says Britons are being advised to avoid any non-essential travel abroad
Dominic Raab, the foreign secretary, is making a statement to MPs about new travel advice.
He says for the next 30 days the government is advising against any non-essential travel globally.
He says this is partly because of the risk of people not being able to return, because so many countries are closing borders.
I have amended the post at 11.50am above to reflect the fact that the list of underlying health conditions that should lead to people effectively self-isolating, according to government advice, includes asthma and diabetes.
The government says its advice (pdf) to people to avoid large gatherings and to work from home where possible applies in particular to the over-70s. Jeremy Corbyn is 70. But he is due at PMQs tomorrow, and he is not planning to stay away from work. This is what he said about this when asked in an interview yesterday.
I raised this very specific issue, not for myself but for other people. It’s more important that those who have underlying health problems, be it diabetes, be it heart conditions, be it lung conditions, be it people with emphysema, or industrial injuries that they’ve suffered, they’re likely to be more vulnerable than those that are healthy. So it is not just an age thing.
Personally speaking, I will carry on with my work, I will carry on accepting the responsibilities that I have in this position.
Culture secretary Oliver Dowden working from home after family member falls ill
Oliver Dowden, the culture secretary, will be away from the office for the next two weeks. He has revealed on Twitter that he is self-isolating because a member of his family is ill.
A member of my family currently has #covidー19uk symptoms so in line with government advice I will be remaining at home.
— Oliver Dowden (@OliverDowden) March 17, 2020
I’m feeling fine and will of course be working on @DCMS priorities in these very challenging times, and continuing to support my constituents in Hertsmere https://t.co/H9oeGduop0
Here are the full details of the government’s advice for households where someone has fallen in.
Schools should close, says national education union
Today, the leadership of the National Education Union has written to the Prime Minister Boris Johnson, calling for the Government to close schools and colleges and protect vulnerable educators or those caring for at risk family members.
— National Education Union (@NEUnion) March 17, 2020
Here is the text of the letter.👇 pic.twitter.com/dQ19ij6FLL
The National Education Union, the largest teaching union, is calling for schools to be closed. In an open letter to the prime minister, Mary Bousted and Kevin Courtney, the NEU’s joint general secretary, say they are calling for school closures, on at least a temporary basis, in the light of the announcement yesterday saying the over-70s, pregnant women and people with serious health conditions should self-isolate.
They say they will be advising teachers who fall into any of these categories to stay away from work from Monday. (There are probably quite a lot of pregnant teachers in schools. The list of conditions that count as serious health conditions for these purposes is here [pdf], and although it covers a lot of people who would be too ill to teach anyway, it does include asthma and diabetes. There are unlikely to be many teachers in schools over 70.)
In their letter Bousted and Courtney go on:
Given your failure to release modelling comparing different scenarios of school closures, we are now forced to call on you to close schools, at least for some time and at least in some areas.
We know that very many of our members who aren’t in the categories of heightened risk would be willing to volunteer to play a role in helping our society get through this crisis.
We suggest during a period of full school closure that teachers and school leaders could work on plans for more limited opening.
In its own statement this morning the NASUWT, a rival teaching union, also complained that the status quo was unacceptable. It said:
Schools are struggling with ever diminishing staffing levels and are being driven to make arrangements for changes to staff working conditions which have the potential to compromise the health and safety of staff and pupils. This situation cannot be allowed to continue.
The UK government, working with governments and administrations across the UK, must now make a definitive decision about the steps being taken to protect the school workforce and the closure of schools.
UPDATE: I have amended the post above to reflect the fact that the list of underlying health conditions that should lead to people effectively self-isolating, according to government advice, includes asthma and diabetes.
Updated
Most firms won't be able to claim insurance even if ordered to close by government, says insurance industry
Some of the owners of pubs and other businesses affected by the government’s advice yesterday that everyone should avoid all “non-essential contact” with other people have been complaining that the government has been advising the public to avoid these places, not closing them by order. If premises were forced to close, they would at least be able to claim insurance, it has been said.
But the Association of British Insurers has issued a statement today saying that, for most businesses, even if the government were to order their closure, they would not be protected by insurance. The ABI says:
Irrespective of whether or not the government orders closure of a business, the vast majority of firms won’t have purchased cover that will enable them to claim on their insurance to compensate for their business being closed by the coronavirus.
Standard business interruption cover - the type the majority of businesses purchase - does not include forced closure by authorities as it is intended to respond to physical damage at the property which results in the business being unable to continue to trade.
The Conservative party’s spring conference, which was due to start on Friday 3 April in Harrogate, has been cancelled, ConservativeHome’s Paul Goodman reports.
Conservative Party Spring Conference cancelled.
— Paul Goodman (@PaulGoodmanCH) March 17, 2020
Robert Peston, ITV’s political editor, has written an interesting blog on the challenge facing Rishi Sunak as he draws up his coronavirus financial rescue packaged. Peston says the scale of the challenge is likely to take the Conservatives into unlikely ideological territory. He says:
As one Tory minister put it to me, these principles imply that Boris Johnson will almost certainly have to oversee a government that for a good year or maybe longer will look quite socialist.
“We’ll find ourselves implementing most of Jeremy Corbyn’s programme” is how he put it.
As I mentioned, the Treasury and Bank of England will find themselves having to play God in respect of deciding which businesses to save.
And the simplest way to make sure no one goes to work and spreads the virus when they should be self-isolating is to introduce that most debated of modern welfare concepts, the universal basic income - which gives an entitlement to everyone to a minimum income.
Even Tories are talking to me about the probable need for a temporary universal basic income, to get round all that confusion of which welfare payments kick in to whom, and to save many younger people in particular falling through the existing state safety net.
Airports may shut down “within weeks without government intervention”, according to the Airport Operators Association. Karen Dee, the association’s chief executive, said:
Governments across the world are supporting their national aviation industries, as many parts of the global travel industry have come to a halt.
As some airlines call on the UK government to act similarly, we are clear that airports will shut down in weeks unless urgent action is taken to support the industry.
The association is urging the government to implement a series of measures to support the aviation industry, including possible emergency financing, requiring banks to temporarily not enforce financial performance-based banking covenants and the suspension of business rates and other taxes.
The government’s coronavirus press conference, featuring Boris Johnson and Rishi Sunak, is now scheduled for around 4pm, we’re told.
There are two statements in the Commons today.
There will be two statements today on:
— Labour Whips (@labourwhips) March 17, 2020
1. COVID-19 Foreign Secretary update - @DominicRaab / @EmilyThornberry
2. Economic update. @RishiSunak / @johnmcdonnellMP
The Dominic Raab statement is due at 12.30pm, after Foreign Office questions. But Rishi Sunak is not due to make his statement until 7pm, presumably after the government’s coronavirus press conference (although the timing of that has not been confirmed yet).
Teachers experiencing 'rising sense of panic' because of lack of clarity over coronavirus advice, union claims
A teaching union has claimed there is a “rising sense of panic” in schools because the government’s coronavirus advice is not clear enough. In a statement Chris Keates, the NASUWT acting general secretary, claimed teachers were not getting definitive instructions. She said:
All of the announcements continue to be couched as guidance or advice, which is simply serving to increase anxiety and uncertainty.
The NASUWT has to date been advising our members in the context of the advice issued by governments and administrations and public health bodies across the UK.
However, the lack of clear information with regard to the steps to protect teachers, head teachers and other staff working in schools in the context of commentators constantly referring to the threats posed by children carrying Covid-19 is causing chaos and confusion and placing intolerable pressure on all staff in schools and their families.
The NASUWT has consistently raised a series of concerns with ministers since this national crisis began to unfold and whilst we have sought not to second-guess the science and medical advice and worked to support members in the increasingly difficult situation, the lack of specific information for schools understandably has created a rising sense of panic.
The National Association of Funeral Directors is due to meet with Whitehall officials later today. Ahead of the meeting, chief executive Jon Levett said:
Funeral directors across the UK have been working to develop contingency plans and are ready to step up to support the government and the nation in these unprecedented and worrying times.
However, consistency of advice is key and this is what we are aiming to achieve from our meeting with the Cabinet Office today.
Funeral directors need a very clear national policy to work to and we are concerned by inconsistencies of guidance appearing across the UK which is making it impossible for funeral directors to give accurate advice.
For example, if there are restrictions on numbers of people gathering, bereaved people need to know exactly what this means for funeral services and how funeral directors can support them.
CBI tells MPs hundreds of thousands of jobs at risk if government does not provide proper support
At the business committee Labour’s Pat McFadden asks Rain Newton-Smith if the CBI has an estimate of the number of jobs at risk.
Newton-Smith says she cannot say, because it depends how the government responds.
But she says this is a “critical” moment for business. The airline industry needs support, she says. And the same applies to hotels and retail. She says potentially “hundreds of thousands of jobs” are at risk.
Q: Should the government provide subsidies to cover pay for staff who are laid off?
Yes, says McTague.
He says the government will have to take the role of a “benign employer”.
Updated
In the Commons the business committee has just started taking evidence from business and union figures about coronavirus.
The witnesses are: Rain Newton-Smith, chief economist, at the CBI; Martin McTague, policy and advocacy chair at the Federation of Small Businesses; Alasdair Hutchison, policy development manager at the Association of Independent Professionals and the Self-employed; and Paul Nowak, deputy general secretary at the TUC.
Newton-Smith says the chancellor needs to offer loans today, so firms can stay in business.
Rupert Harrison, who was chief of staff to George Osborne when Osborne was chancellor, has posted a thread on Twitter explaining what sort of help he thinks business will need to survive coronavirus. He says there will have to be a colossal bailout, worth at least 10% of GDP - or perhaps twice that.
It starts here.
Two weeks ago I said we would need mass disaster insurance style cash flow support for businesses. I'm pretty sure this where we're now heading https://t.co/LPLcsEgP20
— Rupert Harrison (@rbrharrison) March 17, 2020
And here are his conclusions.
All of this may well come to 10% of GDP or even much more than that. But that is manageable as a one off impact and better than the alternative
— Rupert Harrison (@rbrharrison) March 17, 2020
Actually I think 10% of GDP is going to be too little - could need to be twice that
— Rupert Harrison (@rbrharrison) March 17, 2020
Faisal Islam, the BBC’s economics editor, says that means Harrison is proposing a package that could be worth up to £450bn.
£450billion in guarantees/ support... says former top Treasury adviser.
— Faisal Islam (@faisalislam) March 17, 2020
but if it were needed to be done, twere best it done quickly to prevent layoffs and provide cash flow needed during shutdowns: https://t.co/W4IaZoCAR8
This is a mind-boggling sum. Total government spending this year will be around £928bn. The danger for Rishi Sunak, the chancellor, is that having figures like this in the public domain could make any less ambitious announcement this afternoon look disappointing.
OBR chief says coronavirus means it's 'not a time to be squeamish' about government debt
In the Treasury committee Robert Chote, chair of the Office for Budget Responsibility, says the £12bn coronavirus package in the budget seemed reasonable at the time. But the situation is changing by the day, he says. He says now it should be seen as just a “downpayment”.
He says Oliver Blanchard, the former chief economist at the IMF, said recently that now was “not a time to be squeamish about public sector debt”. Chote goes on:
There will be a time to think about what the appropriate medium-term policy setting is for normal times to deal with the legacy of this. But for the moment you are dealing with the problem on a daily basis. As I saw, £12bn was the number that seemed perfectly reasonable as part of a perfectly reasonable package at that time. But it’s moving by the day.
Here is the Blanchard quote Chote was referring to.
The world is de facto at war (against the virus, rather than against each other---this is the good news...) With this in mind: US Federal deficits as a ratio to GDP: 1942: -12%, 1943: -26%, 1944: -21%, 1945: -20%. Let's not be squeamish.
— Olivier Blanchard (@ojblanchard1) March 16, 2020
Updated
Cabinet is starting today at 10.30am, not 9.30am as usual, we’ve been told.
Pub industry faces being destroyed unless it gets government help, PM told
The British Beer and Pub Association has written to Boris Johnson, demanding urgent steps are taken to prevent mass job losses and permanent pub closures. In the letter, that was sent last night, the association’s chief executive Emma McClarkin said:
The UK pub and brewing industry is tonight facing an existential crisis as a direct result of the guidance issued by the government today.
Thousands of pubs and hundreds of thousands of jobs will be lost in the very short term unless a proactive package creating cash and liquidity is provided immediately to the industry.
Forced pub closures without a meaningful support package will have a catastrophic financial and social impact.
McClarkin urged the government to cancel all business rates payments for six months, as well as all tax payments including PAYE, VAT and corporation tax for pubs and hospitality businesses. She also called for the cancellation of beer duty payments for six months, and the postponement of the planned national minimum and living wage increases due in April. She went on:
I cannot emphasise strongly enough how critical it is that action is taken now. Failure to do so will destroy the industry.
Robert Chote, the chair of the Office for Budget Responsibility, has just started giving evidence to the Commons Treasury committee. He is appearing alongside two colleagues, Andy King and Prof Sir Charles Bean, who are both members of the OBR’s budget responsibility committee.
There is a live feed here.
Asked about the package of measures in the budget to help counter the economic effects of coronavirus, Bean said the proposals were fine as far as they went, but that something on a larger scale was now needed.
He said that, with businesses facing the loss of cash flow, there was a “very good argument that the state should be, essentially, the insurer here”.
He also said that “big early action” would be best.
Asked the same question, Chote says the OBR is not supposed to offer policy advice to the government. But he says circumstances are different, and he says there is a range of options on the tax front. He also speculates about whether there is a need to put the economy on the equivalent of a wartime footing.
This is what George Osborne, the former Conservative chancellor, posted on Twitter last night explaining what he thought the government had to do about coronavirus.
Time for a massive government scheme to underwrite bank loans to businesses - and help them and their employees through this crisis. £100s billions pounds in scale. Budget measures last week were fine, but not enough
— George Osborne (@George_Osborne) March 16, 2020
Boris Johnson chairs cabinet as Rishi Sunak set to announce coronavirus financial rescue package
Good morning. Yesterday we had one of the most dramatic and consequential announcements from a British prime minister since the second world war, but today ministers are due to follow it up with at least two more major interventions.
First, Rishi Sunak, the chancellor, is due to give details of what the government will do to help the businesses and individuals facing bankruptcy and unemployment because of Boris Johnson’s guidance that will effectively shut down parts of the economy.
And, second, Matt Hancock, the health secretary, is due to give details of the emergency powers legislation being introduced to give the government the ability to enforce these new rules if necessary.
As usual, Politico Europe’s Jack Blanchard has a good preview. Here is an extract from his London Playbook briefing.
Chancellor Rishi Sunak will join Boris Johnson at his daily Downing Street press conference later this afternoon after a furious backlash from businesses against the government’s approach. Treasury officials — like the rest of government — were completely blindsided by yesterday’s dramatic clampdown, and were last night hastily considering a range of options that might keep small businesses afloat. One well-placed source told Playbook to expect a “big economic package,” but admitted full details were unlikely to be ready by this afternoon. “We will continue to engage with business and are working rapidly to provide more support,” a Treasury spokesman said.
Caught on the hop: The truth is that Downing Street itself was not really ready for this rapid escalation, with events moving at a breakneck speed throughout the past few days. As such the PM could offer only hopelessly vague assurances at yesterday’s press conference that businesses would be supported, even as he urged Brits to stay away from pubs, restaurants, theatres and other entertainment venues. His words have left tens of thousands of small business owners fearing ruin today, with the Daily Mail describing it as “doomsday” for the high street.
And here are some of the latest developments this morning.
- Sadiq Khan, the mayor of London, has said that London’s transport network could be massively scaled back in the coming weeks. In an interview this morning he said:
What we may do over the course of the next few days is go to a Saturday or Sunday service during the week and then maybe even scale that down even more over the course of the next few days and weeks.
- Jonathan Van-Tam, the deputy chief medical officer for England, has rejected claims that the government’s suppression strategy has been introduced too late. He told the Today programme:
We are following the science very carefully and consider the measures we announced yesterday have been announced at the right time - not too early and certainly not too late.
We don’t rule out taking further measures if these are necessary but much of this depends on how the next two weeks play out.
- Prof Neil Ferguson, from the MRC Centre for Global Infectious Disease Analysis at Imperial College, who worked on the study that led to the government announcing its far-reaching suppression strategy yesterday, also denied that the government was acting too late. He told the Today programme:
I think we are still behind the epidemic seen in other European countries, so there’s always a balancing act involved in these sort of measures in order to balance the impact of those measures, the costs on the economy against the impact on the epidemic.
I overall think we have got the timing about right.
I think we’re about three weeks or so behind Italy, two weeks behind France and Spain, so we are making these decisions in a more timely manner than other European countries but certainly there wasn’t any time to lose.
Ferguson also said that, looking at what was happening in Italy, his team had concluded that the UK could face 250,000 deaths if the government did not escalate its social distancing strategies. He explained:
Initially when we came up with these sort of estimates they were viewed as what’s called a reasonable worst case, but as information has been gathered in recent weeks from, particularly Italy, but other countries, it’s become increasingly clear it’s not the reasonable worst case, it’s the most likely scenario [assuming no change in policy].
- Labour has said the economic rescue measures being announced today must be “on a scale sufficient to meet this crisis”. This is from John McDonnell, the shadow chancellor.
We need unequivocal statement from Chancellor today that people’s incomes will be protected businesses will be fully supported to prevent any going out of business as result of the virus, and it has to be on a scale sufficient to meet this crisis. No small measures. Get it right.
— John McDonnell MP (@johnmcdonnellMP) March 17, 2020
Here is the agenda for the day.
10.30am: Boris Johnson chairs cabinet.
9.30am: Robert Chote, chair of the Office for Budget Responsibility, and colleagues give evidence to the Commons Treasury committee.
10am: Business groups give evidence to the Commons business committee about the impact of coronavirus.
11.30am: Dominic Raab, the foreign secretary, takes questions in the Commons.
2.30pm: Sir Patrick Vallance, the government’s chief scientific adviser, gives evidence to the Commons health committee. At 3.15pm Sir Simon Stevens, the chief executive of NHS England, and colleagues will give evidence.
Afternoon: Boris Johnson and Rishi Sunak, the chancellor, are due to appear at the government’s daily coronavirus press conference.
At some point today Matt Hancock, the health secretary, is also due to give details of the government’s coronavirus emergency legislation.
I expect to be focusing entirely on the UK political aspects of the coronavirus crisis. But this is a global story that goes well beyond Westminster politics, and even politics generally. For the full picture, do read our general coronavirus live blog, which is here.
You can read all the latest Guardian politics articles here and here is the Politico Europe roundup of this morning’s political news.
If you want to follow me or contact me on Twitter, I’m on @AndrewSparrow.
I try to monitor the comments below the line (BTL) but it is impossible to read them all. If you have a direct question, do include “Andrew” in it somewhere and I’m more likely to find it. I do try to answer questions, and if they are of general interest, I will post the question and reply above the line (ATL), although I can’t promise to do this for everyone.
If you want to attract my attention quickly, it is probably better to use Twitter.
Updated