Graeme Wearden 

UK recession fears mount after worst month for companies since 2016 – as it happened

Data firm Markit warns that UK private sector weakened in June, suggesting the economy may have contracted in April-June
  
  

Canary Wharf from Greenwich Park.
Canary Wharf from Greenwich Park. Photograph: Eddie Mulholland/REX

Summary

Time for a recap:

Britain’s economy appears to have suffered its first quarterly contraction in almost seven years, after a slump in company activity during June.

Data firm Markit’s composite PMI, which tracks the private sector, reports that activity shrank in June for the first time since 2016. The service sector stagnated, while manufacturing and construction both shrank sharply.

Economists believe this means UK GDP contracted by at least 0.1% in April-June - ending a run of growth that dates back to 2012.

If the economy continues to shrink in July-September, then Britain would be in a full-blown recession by the autumn [a recession = two quarters of negative growth].

Chris Williamson, chief business economist at IHS Markit, warned that the economy could struggle in the current quarter.

“The latest downturn has followed a gradual deterioration in demand over the past year as Brexit-related uncertainty has increasingly exacerbated the impact of a broader global economic slowdown.

Risks also remain skewed to the downside as sentiment about the year ahead is worryingly subdued, suggesting the third quarter could see businesses continue to struggle.”

Duncan Brock, Group Director at the Chartered Institute of Procurement & Supply, also fears economic turmoil ahead:

With a dampened mood across the sector, if a General Election is also thrown into the pot of political turmoil in the coming months, then the service sector runs an even greater risk of following the manufacturing and construction sectors into cutbacks, cost-cutting and reduced workforces.”

Here’s the full story:

In other news:

Eurozone government bond yields have fallen to record lows, after IMF managing director Christine Lagarde was named as the next head of the European central bank.

Lagarde is expected to maintain loose monetary policy and low interest rates, and possibly press on with new stimulus measures.

Some financial experts, though, are concerned that she doesn’t have a central banking background....although her managerial and communication skills could be vital.

Stock markets continue to rally, on hopes of lower interest rates across the world soon. Wall Street has hit a record high, Britain’s FTSE 100 is at an 11-month high, and eurozone equities are at their highest in two months.

But Brexit fears are still rife - Sainsbury’s have warned that a no-deal crisis could leave children without toys this Christmas, as Britain hasn’t got enough warehouse space to stock up.

The latest surveys of America’s services sector confirms that its economy is slowing, as business confidence takes a knock....

Newsflash: The US stock market has hit a new all-time high at the start of trading in New York.

The S&P 500 has hit 2,980 points for the first time ever, up 7 points or 0.25%.

Why are stocks so high, when there are worrying economic signs in the UK, the eurozone and the US? Because investors believe central bankers will cut interest rates soon to prop up economic growth.

Donald Trump’s efforts to cut the US trade deficit have suffered a blow.

The US trade deficit rose to a five-month high in May as imbalances with China and Mexico widened, according to Commerce Department data.

The gap between what America imports and exports rose by 8.4% year-on-year in May to $55.52bn. That includes a $30bn deficit with China, up 12.2% on a year ago, despite the new tariffs imposed by Trump’s White House.

April’s deficit was also revised up, to $51.2bn.

It’s possible that the deficit was swelled by US companies rushing to buy products in case America and China’s trade war worsened (instead, they agreed to restart talks).

Ouch! Disappointing jobs data from America suggests the UK isn’t the only economy slowing.

Just 102,000 new private sector jobs were created by US firms in June, according to data from payroll operator ADP. Economists had expected 140,000 new hires, so this is a bit of a blow.

It may suggest that the wider US employment report, due on Friday, will also disappoint. Economists had expected the Non-Farm Payroll to increase by 163,000, after May’s very weak 75,000. Perhaps they should revise those forecasts down a little....

Updated

A recession is typically defined as two quarters of negative growth in a row.

If Markit are right, then the UK is halfway there, for the first time since the financial crisis a decade ago.

UK GDP

Associated Press’s economics expert Pan Pylas also fears Britain is close to falling into recession, judging by this morning’s PMI data.

Britain’s economy showed alarming signs of a sharp slowdown, possibly even into recession, as uncertainty over Brexit combines with a less benign global backdrop, according to a closely watched survey of business activity in the U.K. released Wednesday.

The survey, from financial information firm IHS Markit and the Chartered Institute of Procurement & Supply, showed that the economy contracted in June at its steepest rate since the immediate aftermath of the country’s vote three years ago to leave the European Union.

The survey also found the second-steepest fall in output since the height of the global financial crisis a decade ago.

The survey’s main “all-sector” purchasing managers’ index fell in June to 49.2 from 50.7 the previous month, suggesting that a contraction is underway. Though some of the retreat was clearly due to firms adjusting their stock levels after boosting them to record levels ahead of the original Brexit date of March 29, the survey does clearly highlight the scale of the pessimism among firms

City traders are also concerned by the disappointing June PMIs. Could the Bank of England be forced to cut interest rates soon, to ward of a recession?

A recession is bad enough, but a no-deal Brexit could also ruin Christmas!

The boss of supermarket chain Sainsbury has warned that supplies of toys and electronics for Christmas could be hit if Britain crashed out of the EU on Halloween (the current deadline).

Mike Coupe, the chief executive of the supermarket group, which also owns the UK’s biggest toy retailer, Argos, said the current Brexit deadline of 31 October was “not far off the worst day possible” for retailers, who would find it difficult to stockpile goods because warehouses would already be packed ready for Christmas.

Here’s the full story:

Labour’s shadow chancellor, John McDonnell MP, says June’s weak PMI reports show the government is botching the job of managing the economy.

“This will spark yet more concern about the serious damage being caused by the Tory mismanagement of the economy and the threat of a disastrous no-deal Brexit.”

McDonnell’s counterpart, Philip Hammond (for a bit longer, anyway), is hoping that some international investment will help:

Updated

Fears that the UK economy is shrinking has knocked the pound lower.

Sterling is down 0.3%, hitting $1.256 against the US dollar (a two-week low) and €1.113 against the euro.

This chart from Bloomberg shows how the UK economy weakened sharply in the last few months:

They add:

The U.K. economy probably shrank for the first time since 2012 in the second quarter as Brexit uncertainty and fears for the global outlook took their toll on output in June, according to IHS Markit.

The report comes a day after Bank of England Governor Mark Carney warned of damage to the global economy from rising protectionism, adding that the U.K. faces the additional threat of a no-deal Brexit on business investment.

Updated

Here’s my colleague Richard Partington on today’s worrying UK data:

The UK economy has suffered its first quarterly contraction in seven years, a closely watched survey suggests, amid growing fears over a no-deal Brexit.

According to IHS Markit and the Chartered Institute of Procurement and Supply (Cips), growth in the UK’s dominant service sector, which accounts for four-fifths of the UK economy, came almost to a standstill last month.

After activity in the manufacturing and construction sectors plunged into reverse last month, Chris Williamson, the chief business economist at IHS Markit, said the combined picture for Britain suggests economic growth probably contracted by 0.1% in the second quarter.

The Bank of England has previously forecast zero growth for the second quarter but some economists expect GDP to have contracted. Growth raced ahead in the first quarter as the stockpiling rush in the run-up to the original 29 March deadline in the Brexit talks provided a shot in the arm for growth.

The last time UK GDP went into reverse was in the final quarter of 2012....

Here’s the full story.

PMI reports paint 'woeful picture' for UK economy

You can read the PMI survey yourself, online here.

It’s important to remember that the PMIs are not official government data -- they’re calculated by IHS Markit based on interviews with purchasing managers.

Their view on output, activity, orders and confidence are converted into a single number -- anything over 50 shows growth.

So, according to Markit, here’s what happened in June:

  • Services: STALLED, with the PMI falling to 50.2, a four-month low.
  • Manufacturing: SHRANK at the fastest pace in six years, with the PMI falling to 48
  • Construction: PLUNGED, with the PMI slumping to 43.1, the worst in a decade
  • Overall private sector: SHRANK for the first time since summer 2016, with the PMI dropping to 49.2

Nick Kilbey, sales trader at Foenix Partners, says it paints a bleak picture:

This morning’s UK Services print completed the trifecta of woeful PMI figures for the week as it dropped below expectations at 50.2 vs 51.0.

With Manufacturing PMI at 6-year lows, Construction PMI showing the steepest decline since the recession and BOE Governor Carney stating that the central bank is stepping up planning to overcome the potential impact of a no deal Brexit, the short-term future looks bleak for the UK.

The purchasing managers' indices, or PMIs, track services sector companies, manufacturers and building firms around the world.

They measure activity, output, business confidence and hiring levels, to produce a health check on how these sectors are performing.

PMIs are compiled each month from interviews with 'purchasing managers' at thousands of companies. They produce a single headline figure – anything above 50 indicates a sector is growing, while a figure below 50 shows a contraction.

Economists watch these surveys closely as they look ahead to coming months, while the official data, such as gross domestic product and retail sales, tends to be more backward-looking. 

Ranko Berich, head of market analysis at Monex Europe, says:

Whoever ends up in No 10 will inherit an economy on the brink of contraction - and will have very limited margin for error in the next phase of the Brexit mess.

Capital Economics also predict the UK shrank by 0.2% in the last quarter (they’d previously expected a 0.1% contraction).

Worryingly, they also fear the economy might not bounce back in the current quarter (July-September).

A shift in activity to before the Brexit date [29th March] accounts for some of the weakness. But the fact the surveys have not picked up towards the end of the quarter, and global manufacturing is slowing, means the risk is that the economy fails to bounce back in Q3.

Economist Howard Archer of EY Item Club fears that the UK shrank by 0.2% in the April-June quarter, having analysed today’s PMI report.

That would be the first quarterly contraction since 2012.

He adds:

An unwinding of the substantial stockpiling that occurred in the first quarter has clearly weighed on the UK economy in the second quarter, while it has also been hampered by extended Brexit uncertainties, an unsettled UK political situation and a challenging global economic environment.

It also looks like consumers took a marked breather in the second quarter after spending at a fair pace in the first quarter.

Updated

Quite....

If Markit’s PMI report is accurate, Britain’s next prime minister could inherit an economy half-way into recession.

Here’s Sky News’s take:

The authors of a respected economic survey are predicting the UK economy contracted in the second quarter of the year, raising fears of a potential recession ahead.

According to an all-sector calculation, following the final IHS Markit/CIPS purchasing managers’ index (PMI) reading for June, the economy will have recorded negative growth of 0.1% between April and June.

If such a performance was to be confirmed by official statistics - and then the economy failed to achieve growth in the current third quarter - it would leave the country in a technical recession ahead of its next Brexit deadline of Halloween.

Duncan Brock, group director at the Chartered Institute of Procurement & Supply, fears that an autumn general election could drive the UK economy deeper into the mire.

Here’s his take on today’s gloomy PMI report:

“Service sector growth slid back last month reversing the small gains made in May, as the wave of political uncertainty and weakening economy continued to undermine confidence and the appetite for new orders.

“This unwillingness to spend and invest by clients and consumers resulted in service companies upping the ante to compete for dwindling business opportunities. With the softest rise in prices charged to customers in three months, firms hesitated to increase their own prices for fear of losing ground in the marketplace.

“However, staff hiring at some companies went against the grain in this stagnating backdrop, as the rate of new job hires rose to its highest since August 2017. Service providers either built up their workforces in anticipation of a speedy political resolution, but others opted for the status quo fearful of a prolonged period of indecision.

“With a dampened mood across the sector, if a General Election is also thrown into the pot of political turmoil in the coming months, then the sector runs an even greater risk of following the manufacturing and construction sectors into cutbacks, cost-cutting and reduced workforces.”

Many of the companies interviewed by Markit warned that they are running short of new work to keep their staff busy, as they complete existing contracts.

Uncertainty over Brexit, and over who will replace Theresa May as prime minister, appears to be hurting the economy. Some companies fear that “domestic political uncertainty and subdued global economic conditions” would continue to hold back corporate spending.

Today’s PMI survey is very worrying -- it suggests the UK economy has suffered its second-worst month since the financial crisis!

UK private sector shrinks for first time since 2016

NEWSFLASH: Britain’s service sector slowed to near stagnation last month, as the wider private sector went into contraction.

That’s according to Markit’s latest survey of UK purchasing managers, just released, which suggests the UK contracted slightly in the April-June quarter.

Service providers reported that business activity was “close to stagnation in June”, Markit says, with subdued client demand and a further reduction in “work-in-hand”.

This dragged the Services PMI, which tracks activity in the sector, down to just 50.1, from 51 in May. That’s the lowest reading in three months, and virtually the 50.0 mark separating expansion from contraction.

But there’s worse news too. We learned earlier this week that manufacturing and construction both contracted month. Add in the services data, and it appears that the UK private sector shrank in June for the first time since 2016 - just after the EU referendum.

This suggests that the uncertainty created by Brexit means the UK economy shrank by 0.1% in the last quarter -- putting it half-way into a full-blown recession!

Chris Williamson, Chief Business Economist at IHS Markit, explains:

“The near-stagnation of the services sector in June is one of the worst performances seen over the past decade and comes on the heels of steep declines in both manufacturing and construction. Collectively, the PMI surveys indicate that the economy has slipped into contraction for the first time since July 2016, suffering the second-steepest fall in output since the global financial crisis in April 2009.

“The June reading rounds off a second quarter for which the surveys point to a 0.1% contraction of GDP.

“The latest downturn has followed a gradual deterioration in demand over the past year as Brexit-related uncertainty has increasingly exacerbated the impact of a broader global economic slowdown. Risks also remain skewed to the downside as sentiment about the year ahead is worryingly subdued, suggesting the third quarter could see businesses continue to struggle.

Updated

Data firm Markit has some good-ish news for Christine Lagarde -- the eurozone economy strengthened a little last month.

Its Eurozone PMI composite Output Index has risen to 52.2, up from 51.8 in May. That’s the highest reading since November 2018, signalling a pick-up in economic growth of the single currency area.

But the recovery is being driven by the service sector, with manufacturing contracting.

Updated

Lagarde has 'credibility risk' as ECB chief

Several City economists and analysts are expressing concerns over Christine Lagarde’s suitability to run the European Central Bank.

The problem, as mentioned earlier, is her lack of experience at the sharp end of monetary policy.

Jim Reid of Deutsche Bank reckons Philip Lane, the ECB’s new chief economist, will have to do a lot of heavy lifting on economics. Reid told clients this morning:

Given her relative inexperience with the ECB’s (complicated) policy toolkit, there is a credibility risk, especially if and when things get more complicated economically, but markets will like the fact that she is a skilled and well connected political operator.

The euro weakened a touch in response to the announcement, possibly reflecting the fact that a more hawkish individual was not chosen. It’s probable that the intellectual economic legwork will now need to be carried solely by Chief Economist Lane, the only trained economist at the top of the new leadership team (recently-appointed Vice President de Guindos is, like Lagarde, a lawyer by training). That said, a lawyer could prove to be useful in the current environment, with the focus on the legal limits of ECB asset purchases, “disenfranchisement,” the risk of debt restructurings, and the prohibition on monetary financing of governments.

Erik Nielsen, chief economist at Italy’s UniCredit, is also worried that Lagarde isn’t trained in monetary policy.

He told Bloomberg TV that Lagarde was a very intelligent person, and a great communicator, knows how to run big organisations:

In normal times she’d be fine, but it is not quite normal times now.

She is not known to have engaged in a monetary policy discussion at G7 level.

What if, or when, a downturn or a crisis comes, who does she rely on, without her own educational framework or experience at a central bank?

Marc Ostwald of ADM Investor Services worries that the European Central Bank would be more ‘politicized’ under Christine Lagarde, rather than sticking strictly to monetary

The appointment of Lagarde as ECB president will a) raise questions about politicization of the role, above all because b) in sharp contrast to Draghi, Lagarde does not have any background in economics or indeed monetary policy formulation.

By extension this puts even greater emphasis on finding a successor for the excellent, always thoughtful and extraordinarily Benoit Coeure as director of operations - who would have been the ideal choice as Draghi’s successor.

Mark Haefele, chief investment officer at UBS Global Wealth Management, points out that Lagarde does have other powerful skills, which she’ll need to run the ECB.

If confirmed – Lagarde would be the first ECB president ever without any experience in monetary policy. We think her management experience, including time as chairwoman of the IMF, would help her to lead the ECB as an institution.

However, Lagarde will likely face many challenges along the way. While the IMF chief is considered a qualified candidate, that won’t necessarily make Europe a more attractive place to invest over a tactical horizon.”

Oof! Italy’s two-year bond yield has just dropped below zero, hitting -0.03% for the first time in 14 months.

Updated

European stock markets hit two-month high

European stock markets are also rallying, matching the gains in the bond market, following Lagarde’s nomination.

The EU-wide Stoxx 600 index is up 0.4% at 390 points, its highest level since the start of May. Utility companies, healthcare firms and consumer goods makers are all up.

Banks are lagging, though (as a Lagarde-led ECB isn’t likely to help their profits by raising interest rates).

Britain’s FTSE 100 has romped to a 10-month high, up 0.5% at 7,597, helped by the pound’s weakness (down at $1.256 this morning).

I imagine that bonds would be moving the other way if EU leaders had chosen Germany’s Jens Weidmann as the new ECB president.

Weidmann has been a persistent critic of Mario Draghi’s money-printing policies, and thus more inclined to raise interest rates or resist further stimulus move.

Ipek Ozkardeskaya, senior market analyst at London Capital Group, explains:

Lagarde, who has built a solid experience fighting against the never-ending financial crisis, is expected to walk on Mario Draghi’s dovish footprints to help the Euro area coping with the weakening global economy.

Her nomination also means that Bundesbank’s more hawkish Weidmann is left out, which is good news for Bund investors.

Investors are expecting Christine Lagarde to take a similar approach to Mario Draghi, explains Frederik Ducrozet, a strategist at Pictet Wealth Management.

He told Reuters:

“We have to admit that we didn’t see this coming, especially after she strongly denied being a candidate last year.

She should provide continuity after Draghi, an important driving factor for markets. The ECB’s reaction function is unlikely to change dramatically under Lagarde’s presidency.”

Eurozone bond yields hit record lows

Boom! Belgium’s 10-year government bond yield has just plunged below zero for the first time ever.

This comes as French and German bond yields also tumble deeper into negative territory, as the eurozone bond rally gathers pace.

This suggests investors are optimistic that Christine Lagarde will take a dovish approach to running the ECB..... and are pessimistic about growth and inflation prospects.

Here’s Reuters take on this morning’s market action:

Government bond yields in much of the euro zone fell to fresh record lows on Wednesday, after European Union leaders agreed to name France’s Christine Lagarde as the new head of the European Central Bank.

Analysts expect Lagarde to continue current ECB chief Mario Draghi’s dovish policy stance. If approved by the European parliament, Lagarde would succeed Draghi when his term expires at the end of October.

Ten-year bond yields across the bloc fell 1-3 basis points in early trade. Germany’s 10-year bond yield hit a new record low of minus 0.39%, while French 10-year bond yields hit a new low of minus 0.079%.

Introduction: Lagarde picked to succeed Mario Draghi

Good morning, and welcome to our rolling coverage of the world economy, the financial markets, the eurozone and business.

At the start of this week, you’d have got decent odds on Christine Lagarde becoming the eurozone’s top central banker.

She certainly wasn’t seen as a front-runner to become the next president of the European Central Bank -- Bundesbank president Jens Weidmann or Banque de France governor François Villeroy de Galhau were more likely candidates.

But when the dust finally cleared in Brussels yesterday, after days of tough negotiations between EU leaders, the head of the International Monetary Fund emerged as the chosen successor to Mario Draghi.

Lagarde’s nomination is part of a package that finally breaks male dominance of Europe’s top institutions, with Germany’s defence minister, Ursula von der Leyen nominated to head the European commission.

Investors are reacting to Lagarde’s nomination by piling into eurozone government bonds. They’re calculating that the ECB will continue offering easy money and record low interest rates on Lagarde’s watch, rather than tightening monetary policy soon.

This is driving bond prices to fresh highs, forcing down the interest rate (or yield) even lower.

Germany’s 10-year bond, for example, is now trading at a yield of nearly minus 0.4%! That means investors are paying for the privilege of holding the debt until it matures.

Lagarde will join the ECB at a crucial time (assuming MEPs approve her appointment). With growth weakening and inflation low, policymakers are already pondering what fresh stimulus measures are needed.

Lagarde has already reacted, saying:

“I am honored to have been nominated for the Presidency of the European Central Bank.

In light of this, and in consultation with the Ethics Committee of the IMF Executive Board, I have decided to temporarily relinquish my responsibilities as Managing Director of the IMF during the nomination period.”

But, there’s already concern in the markets about Lagarde’s appointment. Although she’s run the IMF for several years, and also served as France’s finance minister, she is undoubtedly not a central banker. Before entering politics she served as a lawyer, not an economist.

Now, a legal background didn’t stop America’s Jerome Powell becoming head of the US Federal Reserve. Lagarde was also one of the key figures (for good or ill) through the eurozone crisis, so knows the challenges facing the ECB well.

But will she provide the same leadership as Draghi, who famously saved the euro in 2012 with a ground-breaking stimulus programme, in the face of firm opposition from hawkish colleagues.

Investors may question whether Lagarde can be trusted to do “whatever it takes” when the next crisis comes.....

Also coming up today

New PMI surveys from Markit will show how the world’s service sector companies fared last month.

With manufacturing struggling, and global trade under pressure, services is doing a lot of heavy lifting for the global economy. Eurozone and US services firms will probably report slower growth, while the UK could be lacklustre.

We also get a flurry of US data, ahead of tomorrow’s 4th July celebrations.

The agenda

  • 9am BST: Eurozone services PMI for June (expected to rise to
    53.4 from 52.9, showing faster growth)
  • 9.30am BST: UK services PMI for June (expected to be unchanged at 51)
  • 1.30pm BST: US trade balance for May (expected to widen to -$53.4bn, from -$50.8bn)
  • 3pm BST: US services PMI for June (expected to drop to 56, from 56.9)
  • 3pm BST: US factory orders for May (expected to fall by 0.5%, following an 0.8% drop in April)

Updated

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*