Here’s our news story on today’s Bank of England Brexit warning:
The IMF’s new, less-rosy, growth forecasts didn’t help the mood in the markets today either.
Jameel Ahmad, Global Head of Currency Strategy & Market Research at FXTM says:
The headline that the IMF has downgraded its economic growth projections for the first time since July 2016 is naturally not positive news for investor sentiment. There are a few ways that this news can be digested. One is to accept that expecting global growth at a rate of 3.7% in comparison to 3.9% still represents a healthy pace of growth when you consider the severe turbulence that the global economy has faced over the past 10 years.
But on the other side, there are concerning comments from the IMF that a combination of trade tensions and stress in emerging markets is behind the modest downgrade in growth expectations, along with even more worrying comments that the IMF is concerned that global growth might have plateaued, indicates to a degree that there are also reasons for investors to be uneasy about the IMF downgrade.
And here are those forecasts again:
IMF cuts world economic growth forecasts as import tariffs, emerging market issues bite. Now forecasts 2018 and 2019 global GDP +3.7%, both down from 3.9% previously. Big cuts to Germany, Brazil, S Africa this year, and emerging markets in general next. https://t.co/2CGGv8dNYF pic.twitter.com/5sGEKUifAn
— Jamie McGeever (@ReutersJamie) October 9, 2018
Trading today was dominated by the now-familiar worries over the US government bond market, and Italy’s face-off with EU budget rules.
Fiona Cincotta of City Index sums up the day:
The FTSE managed to sustain the high note it opened on throughout most of the day despite briefly being spooked by the US markets when Wall Street opened. A mixed bag of gainers dominated London trading, some more obvious than others. Miners and oil firms drew strength from higher commodity prices and banks, retailers and insurers had a chance to rally during a lull in negative news.
The Italian economic drama continues being played out with the Italian finance minister trying but failing to reassure both the markets and his European colleagues that Italy is keen to reach an agreement over its budget with the EU. The market remains far from reassured as is visible from the rising risk premium on Italian bonds and the spread between Italy’s 10-year paper and German Bunds. The week is likely to see more volatility as Italy makes a decision on the government’s draft budget plans which it will then submit to the European Commission for review early next week.
A late recovery has helped the FTSE 100 end the day a little higher.
The blue-chip index has closed at 7,237, up 4 points or 0.05%, after several days of losses.
Other markets perked up too, with Italy ended 1% higher after economy minister Tria tried to calm worries about its budget.
Updated
Wall Street has opened cautiously, following the news that the IMF had cut its global growth forecasts.
The Dow Jones industrial average has dipped by 40 points, or 0.15%, as investors keep fretting over rising bond yields and the knock-on impact on other markets
OMG:
London stock market hits six-month low
In the markets, the FTSE 100 has sunk to a fresh six-month low after the IMF slashed its global growth forecasts.
The blue-chip index has dropped by over 0.5% to below 7,200 points, for the first time since April.
Other markets are suffering similar losses, as traders fret about possible US interest rate rises, and the Italian budget row.
Connor Campbell of SpreadEx says the Italian government has sent another ripple of concern through the markets today.
Addressing the Italian parliament in Rome, finance minister Giovanni Tria ended up doing little to reassure nervous investors.
Though he said there will now be a ‘constructive dialogue’ with the EU Commission, the fact he called the output targets contained in the budget ‘prudent’ suggested Italy isn’t ready to shift on the spending plans that have so upset Brussels.
Speaking of Italy.... economy minister Giovanni Tria has called for constructive talks with EU partners over the 2019 budget.
Testifying at a parliamentary commission this morning, Tria said Italy needed a new strategy to boost growth.
“There will now be a constructive discussion with Europe to show the well-founded reasons for this government’s growth strategy.”
Anxiety over Rome’s plans is hurting Italian bonds again today. The difference, or ‘spread’, between the interest rate on Italian 10-year bonds and safer German ones is over 300 basis points (Italy yields 3.66%, while Germany only yields 0.5%).
Tria tried to channel Mario Draghi’s famous ‘Whatever It Takes’ speech, suggesting that the government wouldn’t be bullied by the financial markets.
A spread at 400, 500? We are committed to making the spread reflect the (economic) fundamentals. If it goes to 500, the government will do what it needs to do,.
If everyone sells, we will have capital outflows and we will have to face the situation. Faced with a financial crisis, the government will do what it must do, as (ECB president Mario) Draghi did.”
Over in Bali, the IMF is risking a row with Italy’s new government.
The Fund’s chief economist, Maurice Obstfeld, insisted today that Rome should comply with Brussels’ rules on budget deficits, rather than boosting spending as ministers have promised.
Otherwise, Obstfeld warned, the market selloff of Italian debt could gather pace, hurting its economy and potentially fuelling the eurozone crisis again.
“Our concern about Italy is that there is a real imperative for the fiscal policy to maintain the confidence of markets.
“And we have seen the spreads increase over the past months. This has certainly contributed to our downgrade of Italian growth and makes the economy more susceptible to shocks.
“So we think it is important that the government operate within the framework of the European rules, which are also important for the stability of the eurozone itself.”
Italy’s populist leaders, though, insist that they will stick to their guns, arguing that this will drive growth higher.
ITALY'S SAVONA SAYS BELIEVES ITALY GDP CAN GROW BY 2 PCT IN 2019, 3 PCT IN 2020
— FxMacro (@fxmacro) October 8, 2018
Back in July, Venezuelan fruit seller Pacheco told our reporters about the pain of rampant inflation:
“It’s crazy to accept notes of 100, 500, or 1,000 bolivares,” said Pacheco, a wiry 61-year-old, whose humble stall clings to the fringe of one of the major markets in Ciudad Guayana, a city in Venezuela’s southern Bolívar state.
He now only accepts newly minted 100,000 bolívar notes, which due to demand are hard to come by. “Otherwise it’s a box [full of notes] that afterwards we have to take to the bank,” he said.
More here:
IMF: Venezuelan inflation to hit ten million percent
There’s no cheer for Venezuela in today’s World Economic Outlook.
The International Monetary Fund predicts that prices in its ravaged economy will surge by 1.37 million percent this year, as its hyperinflation accelerates.
By 2019, the Fund believes inflation will have soared even further, to a scarcely believable 10,000,000%, as the government prints more and more money to meet its obligations.
Venezuela’s plight is so extreme that the country had to be removed from the IMF’s wider forecasts for emerging markets.
Back in August, President Nicolas Maduro slashed five zeroes off the bolivar, and hiked the minimum wage by 3,000 percent.
But the IMF clearly has little faith in Maduro’s efforts to tackle the crisis, saying:
Venezuela’s hyperinflation is expected to worsen rapidly, fueled by monetary financing of large fiscal deficits and loss of confidence in the currency.
With currency reserves plunging, Venezuela’s oil sector collapsing and rampant shortages of food and medicine, thousands of people are quitting the country and trying to migrate elsewhere.
Venezuela is deep in recession, and the IMF believes that the devastating slump will continue until at least the end of next year.
Venezuela’s economy continues to decline for the fifth consecutive year, following a 14% drop in 2017.
Real GDP is projected to shrink by 18% in 2018 and a further 5% in 2019, driven by plummeting oil production, and political and social instability.
Updated
Professor Costas Milas of the University of Liverpool has crunched data from the last four IMF reports, including today’s one.
It shows that the IMF has steadily downgraded its forecasts for investment in the UK economy, as a share of the economy, since the EU referendum.
Prof Milas says:
As the Referendum takes place and we move on, IMF downgrades its subsequent forecasts for Total Investments (% of GDP) in the UK. This can be seen here:
He adds:
Without doubt, lower investment spending takes its toll on the economy as evidenced from IMF’s successive forecasts for UK GDP growth, as shown here:
The IMF remains hopeful that Britain and the EU will reach an agreement, avoiding the perils of a cliff-edge Brexit.
Maurice Obstfeld, the IMF’s chief economist, said the UK was in a position to use government funds, should it need to, in the event of a No-Deal Brexit, but this was not what the Washington-based forecaster was expecting.
At a press conference in Bali today, he said:
On Brexit, our baseline forecast, which underlies our forecast for the U.K. and for the eurozone, is that a deal will be reached. It will be one in which trade in goods is essentially tariff‑free, which would allow most supply chains to remain intact. It is one in which the regime for financial services would be, you know, quite favorable to the U.K. And I recognize that that is an optimistic scenario, but we tend to assume that when some set of economic arrangements is clearly in the joint interest of the negotiators, that somehow, they will manage to make this come about.
Obviously, if this does not come about, if there are arrangements which are more restrictive of trade, which put up more barriers which disrupt supply chains, then this is going to be more challenging for both the U.K. and its eurozone partners. And there are some very critical areas where, you know, a technical agreement does have to be reached; for example, on how to handle clearing of derivatives over the transition from old arrangements to new arrangements.
We know the negotiators have been working very hard. In fact, there has been a remarkable amount of progress on a lot of issues, and this often goes unnoted. But there are some very key elements that have not been resolved and that seem very difficult. So, until we get more information, we will keep with our assumption that reason and good policy will prevail. And hopefully we will be proven right.
Here’s some reaction to the IMF report:
Quite something that Conservative commitment to tight fiscal policy is too much even for the IMF https://t.co/MOXZ4YrezJ
— Tom Hancock (@hancocktom) October 9, 2018
Calm markets with a nervous feel, a focus on politics, a background of discord between Brussels and Rome, Washington and Beijing, and the IMF mot-du-jour is ‘plateauing’ which loosely translates as ‘about to slow down’
— Kit Juckes (@kitjuckes) October 9, 2018
Also says #monetary policy should be flexible. #IMF urges #UK to lift #public #spending after a hard #Brexit https://t.co/sbnKEgdujP via @financialtimes
— Howard Archer (@HowardArcherUK) October 9, 2018
Bank of England tells EU to pull its finger out on Brexit planning
The Bank of England has issued its strongest warning yet to the European Union that its lack of planning for Brexit is creating growing risks for almost £70tn of complex financial derivatives.
Threadneedle Street said the EU had made only limited progress to protect the financial system and that time was running out with little more than six months before Britain leaves the EU.
The Bank’s Financial Policy Committee warns:
“In the limited time remaining, it is not possible for companies on their own to mitigate fully the risks of disruption to cross-border financial services.”
Sounding the alarm over the complex financial derivatives - currently sold across the UK-EU border by banks to companies looking to protect themselves from movements in interest rates – the FPC said the EU needed to take urgent action to plan for Brexit.
Failure to make adequate preparations could mean the derivatives, worth more than three times the value of the EU economy, are rendered illegal the moment the UK leaves the EU.
Britain has already taken action to arrange temporary permissions to grant EU banks access to the UK market, although the European Commission has yet to reciprocate.
The game of brinksmanship could have benefited the EU for shifting more UK business to European financial capitals such as Frankfurt and Paris after Brexit, although officials believe very few derivatives contracts are yet to be moved by the finance industry, which is overwhelmingly centred in the City of London.
The IMF has also slashed its outlook for emerging market economies, following a swathe of crises in Turkey, Argentina and beyond.
It now expects developing economies to expand by 4.7% this year and in 2019, down from 4.9% and 5.1% previously.
The Fund blames “country-specific factors, tighter financial conditions, geopolitical tensions, and higher oil import bills”.
It also cautions that the trade war between the US and China will drag on growth across Asia.
IMF cuts world economic growth forecasts as import tariffs, emerging market issues bite. Now forecasts 2018 and 2019 global GDP +3.7%, both down from 3.9% previously. Big cuts to Germany, Brazil, S Africa this year, and emerging markets in general next. https://t.co/2CGGv8dNYF pic.twitter.com/5sGEKUifAn
— Jamie McGeever (@ReutersJamie) October 9, 2018
On the other hand.... perhaps the IMF and the UK government are of one mind on the Brexit issue...
My colleague Phillip Inman doesn’t believe the Treasury will be pulling its hair out:
The Treasury has said it needs to keep its powder dry in case of a bad Brexit.
Hammond’s stance is that he may need to use fiscal space in the event of a bad Brexit. He has never said there are few policy options available, as if he would just let UK crash. Likewise, the Bank of England has never said it will raise interest rates.
It has said that option remains on the table. But as we all know, it is more as likely to cut them in tandem with a Treasury spending spree.
The IMF has also cautioned that UK growth remains weak, partly due to uncertainty over Britain’s exit from the EU:
In the United Kingdom, growth is projected to slow to 1.4 percent in 2018 and 1.5 percent in 2019 (from 1.7 percent in 2017). This forecast represents a downward revision of 0.2 percentage point for 2018 relative to the April 2018 WEO [World Economic Outlook], driven by weak growth in the first quarter of the year, partly due to weather-related factors.
The medium-term growth forecast remains at 1.6 percent, weighed down by the anticipated higher barriers to trade following Brexit.
The Treasury, and the Bank of England, may not be happy with the IMF’s recommendation to spend more if Britain crashes out of the EU without a deal.
As Chris Giles of the Financial Times explains:
The fund’s advice will frustrate both the BoE and Treasury, which had presented a united front, saying there were few policy options available to soften the blow of a so-called no-deal Brexit.
They have argued that crashing out of the EU represents a big disruption to supply across the economy, which would knock public finances and fuel inflationary pressure, requiring higher interest rates.
While the IMF did not directly dispute this view, it implied that a lack of demand might be the bigger problem in a hard-Brexit scenario, which would require action to aid growth.
The IMF’s views could also be a boon to the opposition Labour party.
At last month’s party conference, Jeremy Corbyn outlined several spending pledges, including more free childcare for pre-school children, while also maintaining the triple-lock on the state pension, the winter fuel allowance, and free pensioner bus passes.
Labour are also pushing the renationalisation of energy and water providers, and railways.
Those policies cost money; but according to the Fund, there is ‘flexibility’ to boost spending plans, certainly in the short term.
Updated
The IMF has also urged the Bank of England to be cautious about raising interest rates.
With Brexit uncertainty hanging over the economy like a fog, the BoE should show flexibility, it argues:
In the United Kingdom, where the output gap is closed and unemployment is low, a modest tightening of monetary policy may be warranted, although at a time of heightened uncertainty, monetary policy should remain flexible in response to changing conditions associated with the Brexit negotiations.
IMF: UK can spend more
The International Monetary Fund has given Theresa May a boost, arguing that her government has the flexibility to boost public spending.
In its latest World Economic Outlook, the Fund says that the UK has the room to ease back on cuts, perhaps as soon as this month’s Budget.
The Fund says the UK can spend more, or tax less, without breaching the government’s own targets, arguing:
In the United Kingdom, the fiscal targets—which envisage the cyclically adjusted public sector deficit falling below 2 percent of GDP and public debt beginning to decline by 2020–21—provide an anchor for medium-term objectives while allowing for flexibility in the short term.
The Fund also argues that chancellor Philip Hammond should loosen the purse strings on public spending and taxation, to protect the economy from a hard Brexit.
As the Fund puts it:
The pace of fiscal consolidation can be eased if risks materialize and growth slows sharply.
Last week, May declared that “people need to know that the austerity” prompted by the financial crisis a decade ago “is over.” The PM was vague on details, and her comment were criticised by Labour.
But if the Fund is right, Hammond does indeed have some wriggle-room to ease the chains of austerity in October 29th’s budget.
Introduction: IMF cuts growth forecasts
Good morning, and welcome to our rolling coverage of the world economy, the financial markets, the eurozone and business.
Donald Trump’s trade wars are starting to have a serious impact on the global economy, the International Monetary Fund has warned.
The IMF has slashed its latest growth forecasts, downgrading the US, China, the eurozone and the UK, as tit-for-tat tariffs bite. It now expects the global economy to only expand by 3.7% in 2018 and 2019, down from 3.9% before.
In its latest world economic outlook, the Fund says:
In the United States, momentum is still strong as fiscal stimulus continues to increase, but the forecast for 2019 has been revised down due to recently announced trade measures, including the tariffs imposed on $200 billion of US imports from China.
Growth projections have been marked down for the euro area and the United Kingdom, following surprises that suppressed activity in early 2018
IMF cuts 2018 #GDP growth forecast to 3.7% (from 3.9%) on #Tradewar! pic.twitter.com/KoUW8Qoiu0
— jeroen blokland (@jsblokland) October 9, 2018
Maurice Obstfeld, the IMF Economic Counsellor, warned against the rising tide of protectionism, saying that without multilateralism “the world will be a poorer and more dangerous place”.
My colleague Phillip Inman is attending the IMF’s Meeting, and reports:
The Washington-based lender’s economists are usually reluctant to name and shame individual countries, but it is clear that attacks by the Trump administration on the postwar consensus of open trade and cooperation over issues such as climate change has prompted more direct references to the US than previously seen.
In its world economic outlook, which is published twice a year, with the latest issued before the fund’s annual meeting in Bali this week, officials warned that the lingering threat of higher trade barriers meant there was a greater likelihood it would downgrade its growth forecasts during its next review.
Officials at the fund said much of the decline in global growth was also the result of many developing countries being hit hard by a depreciation in their currencies, which had increased the cost of imports and especially oil.
Last month, the US president slapped extra duties on $200bn (£153bn) of Chinese goods and China retaliated with extra duties on $60bn of US goods. This followed an earlier increase in US duties on the import of steel, aluminium and cars.
The warning is likely to weigh on markets today, following recent losses that have driven the FTSE 100 down to a six-month low.
The agenda
- 7am BST: German trade figures for August
- 9.30am BST: Bank of England’s Financial Policy Committee statement from its meeting last week
- 3.35pm BST: BoE deputy governor Ben Broadbent testifies at House of Lords