Graeme Wearden 

Turkey hikes interest rates; Bank of England ‘s Brexit warning; John Lewis’s profits slump – as it happened

All the day’s economic and financial news, as UK central bank leaves interest rates on hold and Turkey announces a whopping rate hike
  
  

A party ship on the river Main passes the European Central Bank in Frankfurt, Germany, yesterday.
The European Central Bank in Frankfurt, Germany, which set interest rates today Photograph: Michael Probst/AP

Finally, here’s our news story on Turkey’s blockbuster interest rate hike

Good night! GW

In the City, the FTSE 100 index of top shares has ended the day down 0.4% at 7,281 points, a drop of 31 points.

Summary

Time for a quick recap.

Turkey’s central bank has defied political pressure and unleashed a huge interest rate hike. Borrowing costs have been raised to 24%, from 17.75%, just hours after president Erdoğan demanded lower interest rates.

The news sent the lira soaring, as traders welcomed this show of strength by the Central Bank of Turkey.

The Bank of England was rather less dramatic, voting to leave UK interest rates at their current rate of 0.75%. The BoE also warned that Brexit uncertainty is becoming a more significant problem for companies.

The European Central Bank trimmed its growth forecasts, and flagged up that protectionism and emerging market turbulence is a growing threat. It still plans to freeze its bond-buying stimulus programme in December, though.

Moody’s, the rating agency, has warned that a No-Deal Brexit would hurt the UK, possibly pushing it into recession. Moody’s also said automotive, airlines, aerospace and chemical-making companies would be worst hit.

John Lewis has seen its profits evaporate in the last six months, plunging by almost 99% to £1.2m. It blamed tough competition, adding that Brexit uncertainty made forecasting future prospect difficult.

Britain’s Brexit secretary hit back, saying businesses should stop blaming the EU exit for their own problems. Dominic Raab’s comments may not help smooth relations between Westminster and UK Plc, as business leaders fret about a cliff-edge Brexit.....

Updated

Just in: president Trump has claimed that China’s markets are “collapsing”, as he denies feeling pressure to reach a trade deal.

He’s not right -- China’s stock market did hit 31-month lows this week, but it’s not entirely given up the ghost. And if it had, it would be bad news for the entire global economy, not a reason to brag.

Agathe Demarais, Turkey analyst at the Economist Intelligence Unit, says today’s Turkish interest rate hike is a “welcome signal”.

However, it won’t fix all Turkey’s economic challenges.

Here’s her take:

  • “The Turkish central bank hiked rates by a whopping 625 basis point, to 24%. In doing so the central bank aims at sending a clear signal of independence and credibility to international financial markets. It also signals that normalising monetary policy conditions is a higher priority than propping up fast decelerating economic growth in the wake of the August currency crisis.”
  • “The rate hike is a welcome signal for international financial markets. In addition, the recent sharp depreciation of the lira means that previously high external imbalances are quickly narrowing, which should have a positive impact on the Turkish currency.”
  • “However, the lira will remain under pressure in the coming months owing to tightening global liquidity conditions and tensions between Turkey and the US. In addition, Turkish corporates remain highly indebted in foreign currency, which means that the local currency value of their debt repayments has spiked over the last few weeks. Some corporates might experience issues in repaying their external debt in the coming months, which will weigh on economic growth.”

Back in the markets, the American dollar has fallen after today’s US inflation data was weaker than expected.

That’s giving a range of battered emerging market currencies some relief, with the Turkish lira leading the charge.

The pound is also benefitting, rising by 0.5% to $1.311.

Updated

Asked about Italy’s populist government, Draghi insists firmly that several Italian ministers have pledged to stick with EU budget rules.

He also doesn’t see signs of contagion from Italy to other eurozone countries.

Good point!

Draghi wasn’t ECB back then, of course.

Q: What do you think of Jean-Claude Juncker’s proposal to make the euro a reserve currency, challenging the US dollar?

Draghi says he is interested to see more details on the proposals, and is ready to work with the Commission on their plans.

Q: Looking back a decade ago, what did you learn from the Lehman Brothers collapse?

Draghi says the financial crisis actually began earlier than 2008. The first serious signs of a crisis date back to September 2007 [the month in which the credit crunch blew up, claiming Northern Rock].

Looking back, Draghi cited the “extraordinary cooperation” and “unprecedented international effort” between countries to tackle the global crisis.

Draghi adds that while measure have been taken to make finance safer, risks have moved from the financial sector to the world of shadow banking.

Q: How much of a threat are the problems in emerging markets to the eurozone, and the world economy, and is it due to US monetary policy?

Draghi says the spillovers from Turkey and Argentina have “not been substantial”. The countries most vulnerable are those with the weakest economic fundamentals, he adds.

Q: The ECB’s new forecasts show inflation hovering around 1.7% in the next few years - is that consistent with your mandate?

Yes, it’s consistent with the mandate, says Draghi crisply, reminding reporters that the mandate is to keep inflation “close to, but below 2%”.

ECB cuts growth forecasts

As rumoured yesterday, the ECB has trimmed its growth forecasts.

It now expects GDP to only increase by 2% this year (down from 2.1%) and by 1.8% next year (down from 1.9%).

It’s inflation forecasts are unchanged, though.

Back in Frankfurt, Mario Draghi has warned that risks from protectionism, and emerging market volatility, have risen.

But still, he argues that the risks to the euro area growth outlook are “broadly balanced”.

Just in: US inflation rose by less than expected last month.

Prices only increased by 0.2%, compared to forecasts of 0.3%. That pulled the annual inflation rate down at 2.7%, versus expectations of 2.8%, down from 2.9% in July.

Over in Frankfurt, European Central Bank president Mario Draghi is giving his press conference.

He confirms that the ECB left interest rates unchanged, and intents to leave them at their present record lows until at least next summer.

Draghi also confirms that the ECB expects to stop buying new bonds through its asset purchase scheme after December, but will keep re-investing the proceeds from the scheme “for an extended period of time”, and as long as needed to maintain “favourable liquidity conditions” and “an ample degree of monetary accommodation”.

Paul Greer, portfolio manager at Fidelity International, says the Turkish central bank should have acted sooner to raise rates and strengthen the lira.

However, he also fears today’s rate hike will drive the economy into recession.

“Going forward the focus will now fall on Turkish growth which is slowing very quickly as the economy, and the current account deficit in particular, rebalances. Today’s move, while helping to moderate inflationary pressures, will accelerate the slowdown and probably push Turkey into a recession.

The next challenge for Turkey will be how does the economy deal with this slowdown, particularly in the banking sector where capital ratios have been eroded and asset quality will further diminish.

Relief that Turkey’s central bank has delivered such a chunky interest rate hike is driving shares up in Istanbul.

The benchmark BIST 100 index has gained 1.5%, as trader express optimism that Turkish inflation could be tamed.

Now it’s the European Central Bank’s turn.

The ECB has left its interest rates at current record lows, meaning the headline cost of borrowing sticks at just zero.

The governing council has also confirmed that it will halve the pace of its stimulus programme in October, to €15bn per month of bonds per month, ending it in December.

Neil Wilson of Markets.com says Turkey’s interest rate hike is a show of strength from the country’s central bank, in the face of political pressure:

It represents a major and important reassertion of the central bank’s independence and shows they will not be bullied by politicians, although to a large degree its hand was forced by the 18% print on August inflation.

There was also a commitment to do more if necessary and that will be regarded as a sign that policymakers are serious, although it’s maybe a tad short of being a ‘whatever it takes’ type commitment – indeed the move on the lira only takes it back to where it was at the end of August.

Updated

The Turkish lira has been through a roller-coaster ride today:

Turkey announces monster rate hike

BOOM! The Turkish central bank has announced a massive increase in borrowing costs.

The Central Bank of the Republic of Turkey has hiked its benchmark interest rate to a blistering 24%, up from 17.75%.

The CBRT said it was acting to bring price stability under control, after seeing inflation hit 17.9% last month. It also vowed to impose further monetary tightening if needed.

This news has sent the lira surging against the US dollar, jumping to 6.1 lira to $1, from 6.5 earlier today.

This is a real show of independence by the central bank, given Recep Tayyip Erdoğan’s demands for rates to be cut (see earlier post). How will the Turkish president respond?...

Updated

The Bank of England is also worried by the rising risks of a full-blown trade war, and its impact on emerging markets.

The Bank’s monetary policy committee say::

The global economy still appears to be growing at above-trend rates, although recent developments are likely to have increased downside risks around global growth to some degree.

In emerging market economies, indicators of growth have continued to soften and financial conditions have tightened further, in some cases markedly.

Recent announcements of further protectionist measures by the United States and China, if implemented, could have a somewhat more negative impact on global growth than was anticipated at the time of the August Report.

BoE: Brexit uncertainty is weighing on businesses

The Bank of England has warned that uncertainty over Brexit has risen recently.

The Bank’s regional agents have detected that UK businesses are more worried, which chimes with other economic data -- and also fits with today’s warning from Moody’s.

The minutes of today’s meeting say:

Most indicators of exports and investment intentions had held up in recent months, although there had been a sharp fall in the IHS Markit/CIPS goods export orders index in August.

Some respondents to that survey, and the associated equivalents for the service and construction sectors, had noted uncertainty around the UK’s withdrawal from the European Union. And reports from the Bank’s Agents had also suggested that companies were becoming more uncertain about the economic outlook and were considering their Brexit contingency plans more carefully.

Only a small minority of companies had started to implement plans such as increasing stocks of components imported from the European Union or reassessing their transport and logistics arrangements. It would be important to monitor closely such developments, and their possible impact on broader economic indicators, over coming months

Bank of England leaves rates unchanged

Newsflash: The Bank of England has left UK interest rates on hold at 0.75%.

It has also left its quantitative easing programme unchanged.

Hold onto your hats.. we’re about to get the Turkish and UK interest rate decisions...

Over in Turkey, president Erdoğan has made an astonishing intervention ahead of today’s interest rate decision.

Erdoğan attacked the Central Bank of the Republic of Turkey, saying it had failed to bring down inflation (which hit a 15-year high last month).

Erdoğans says:

“As of today I have not seen the central bank fix inflation rates as they promised.”

And he then repeats his argument that higher interest rates cause inflation, rather than curbing it (as conventional economics has it).

Damning interest rates as a “tool of exploitation”, the president says:

“Interest rates are the cause, inflation is the result. If you say ‘inflation is cause, the rate is the result’, you do not know this business, friend,”

These comments have sent the lira slumping against the US dollar, as traders worry that Turkey’s central bank might not raise interest rates today after all...

Bank of England governor Mark Carney has been spotted leaving Downing Street, where he must have been attending today’s cabinet meeting to discuss a no-deal.

You may wonder how Carney can also be setting UK interest rates... but actually the BoE voted yesterday.

Here’s the full quote from John Lewis chairman Charlie Mayfield, as he refuses to get into a verbal punch-up with Dominic Raab:

“This whole thing is so frothy. I didn’t say Brexit was the reason for our result.

The fact is sterling is weaker, it’s more expensive to import goods... so we have to absorb that within our margin.

I’m not going to get into some sort of ding-dong with the secretary of state for all things EU.”

Updated

Here’s our guide to what’s gone wrong at John Lewis:

John Lewis chairman Charlie Mayfield has held a conference call with journalists to discuss its plunge in profits.

He’s declined to get into a war of words with Dominic Raab over the ‘blaming Brexit’ row. Instead, he’s revealed quite how tough the last few months have been, with JL’s department stores making their first half-year loss in at least 10 years.

Updated

Moody’s chief credit officer for Europe, Colin Ellis, is concerned that the risks of a no-deal Brexit have risen.

He says:

“We still think the UK and the EU will eventually reach an agreement to preserve many - but not all - of their current trading arrangements, particularly around trade in goods. However, we believe the prospect of the UK leaving the EU without any agreement has risen materially.

“The precise impact of a ‘no deal’ outcome is impossible to define because both the UK and the EU would likely take swift steps to limit short-term disruption. But it would clearly pose more significant credit challenges than a negotiated exit.”

Updated

Moody's: No-deal Brexit could cause a recession

Breaking: Credit rating agency Moody’s has warned that Britain’s economy would suffer significant harm if the country leaves the EU without a deal.

In awkward timing for Dominic Raab, Moody’s warns that many companies would be hurt, hinting it could slash their credit rating.

The agency also predicts that the pound would plunge -- which would drive inflation up and create even more pain for retailers such as John Lewis. A Hard Brexit could also drag the country into recession, it adds.

Here are the key points from today’s Moody’s report:

  • UK Sovereign: It would damage the UK’s economic, fiscal and institutional strength. The immediate impact would likely be seen first in a sharp fall in the value of the British pound, leading to temporarily higher inflation and a squeeze on real wages over the two or three years following Brexit. This in turn would weigh on consumer spending and depress growth, with a risk of the UK entering recession.
  • EU Sovereigns: EU countries including Ireland, the Netherlands, Cyprus and Malta could experience negative consequences, particularly in areas such as trade.
  • Corporates: In the UK, it would be significantly credit negative for a number of sectors due to factors such as tariffs, the weaker pound and regulatory changes. The most severely affected sectors would be automotive, airlines, aerospace and chemicals.

Later today the government will publish new impact papers outlining the impact on the UK if a Brexit deal isn’t reached, including the impact on driving licences, passports and phone bills.

Our Politics live blog will be tracking all the details:

Financial blogger Lotty Burns has more sympathy than Dominic Raab for John Lewis’s predicament:

European credit analyst Tomas Hirst suggests Dominic Raab should resist the temptation to put the boot into British businesses -- as the weak pound is causing real problems for importers.

Here’s a video clip of Dominic Raab criticising businesses who are “tempted to blame Brexit” for disappointing results:

Updated

Raab savages John Lewis over Brexit worries

Britain’s Brexit secretary Dominic Raab has launched a stinging attack on John Lewis for daring to suggest that Brexit uncertainty is hurting.

Asked on the Today Programme about businesses’s concerns about the Brexit negotiations, Raab insisted that Britain’s economy was a sunny place:

“It’s probably rather easy at this moment in time for any business which isn’t doing rather well to point to Brexit.

But let me just give you the facts. This week we’ve had economic growth accelerating, we’ve had real wages accelerating…

Q: But growth is still the lowest in the G7...

Raab interjects:

We’ve had Anglo-Dutch firm Relx revise its structure to be based in the UK.

Q: But John Lewis says the fall in sterling has created inflationary pressures, which has pushed their prices up.

Raab take another swing at grumbling retailers, declaring:

Actually inflation has come down to 2.5%, some people said it would hit 4%

I don’t doubt that uncertainty around these negotiations will have an impact on business. That’s why we are putting all our energy into getting the good deal that we want with our EU friends and partners, while making sure we manage the risks if it doesn’t happen.

All I’m gently saying it’s rather easy for a business to blame Brexit and the politicians rather than taking responsibility for their own situation.

I’m sure John Lewis would argue they are taking responsibility, with plans to invest up to £500m in the business.

Also, if Raab actually reads the JL statement, he’ll see they blame tough competition and investment costs rather than Brexit....

Updated

John Lewis: No-deal Brexit would be very bad

John Lewis’s chairman, Charlie Mayfield, told the Today Programme that cost inflation has surged due to the weak pound (which is still 13% below its pre-referendum levels).

He also warned that Waitrose wouldn’t simply be able to stockpile all its food after Britain leaves the EU, explaining:

“The thing about stockpiling food (for Waitrose) is the stuff that’s most sensitive to these things is actually perishable, so you can’t really stockpile it, it rots, and you waste it. What we’re doing is we’re looking at all our import and export arrangements and so that we’re prepared as we can be.

Mayfield also warned that:

“The other thing is we’re making sure the business is financially sound so we have the highest liquidity position in a long time, in terms of having cash and resources available because there’s so much uncertainty and you don’t know what’s going to happen, you don’t want to find yourself in a tight squeeze.

“I really hope it won’t (be a no-deal Brexit). I’ve said before that would be a very bad outcome for the UK and the consequences are extremely unpredictable.

Updated

John Lewis Partnership chairman Charlie Mayfield has taken to the airwaves with a rallying cry to staff and customers.

Mayfield told BBC Radio that JLP won’t be “not hunkering”, even though UK retail is pretty tough today.

“You don’t succeed by retrenching so if anything we are investing more and pushing on with differentiation,.

The simple truth is that times like these call for cool heads and really determined ambition.”

John Lewis also warns that profits in the second half of the financial year (to the end of January 2019) will be sharply lower than a year ago.

It says:

With the level of uncertainty facing consumers and the economy, in part due to ongoing Brexit negotiations, forecasting is particularly difficult but we continue to expect full year profits to be substantially lower than last year for the Partnership as a whole.

We expect profit growth in Waitrose & Partners will be offset by the continuing margin pressure in John Lewis & Partners and by incremental costs of investment.

John Lewis says its department stores suffered from falling demand for “big ticket and bespoke items”, as consumers cut back.

This dragged sales at its “Home” division down by 4.2%.

Fashion sales rose by 1.2%, though, due to higher demand for womenswear, while sales of electrical items and technology jumped by 7.8%.

Here’s the top line from John Lewis today:

John Lewis’s pledge to match other retailers’ prices has also hit its bottom line this year.

The company says the plunge in profits...

...reflects our decision not to pass on to our customers all cost price inflation from a weaker exchange rate and from our Never Knowingly Undersold promise, where we have seen an unprecedented level of price matching as other retailers have discounted heavily.

Here’s some instant reaction to the John Lewis figures:

John Lewis profits slide 99%

Breaking: the John Lewis Partnership has seen its profits all-but wiped out in the last six months.

The group, which owns Waitrose and the John Lewis department stores, has reported a 99% slump in pre-tax profits (before exceptional items) to just £1.2m in the first half of the year. That’s down from aroud £83m a year earlier.

It blames the tough retail conditions, saying profitability has been eroded by “the most promotional market we’ve seen in almost a decade”.

That means discounting, as retailers have struggled to get shoppers to part with their money.

The costs of new shops and higher IT spending also ate into profits.

Showing a gift for understatement, chairman Sir Charlie Mayfield, adds:

These are challenging times in retail. Our profits before exceptionals are in line with what we said they would be at our Strategy Update in June.

We’re continuing to improve our offer for customers while ensuring we have the financial strength to continue developing our business going forward.

More to follow....

Updated

Introduction: Busy day for central bankers

Good morning, and welcome to our rolling coverage of the world economy, the financial markets, the eurozone and business.

It’s a huuuuge day for central bank news. Policymakers at the Bank of England, the European Central Bank and the Bank of Turkey are all meeting today to set monetary policy, and potentially unleash a few fireworks too.

Having raised interest rates to 0.75% last month, the BoE isn’t likely to do it again today. But it may drop some hints about when the next rate hike may come. We may also get an update on the Bank’s views on Brexit, now that governor Mark Carney has agreed to extend his term until January 2020.

The European Central Bank won’t be raising interest rates today either. But it will be downgrading its growth forecast for the region, according to a leak yesterday.

That could make for an awkward meeting today, as the ECB recently agreed to end its stimulus programme in December.

And what about Turkey? With inflation sizzling, and its currency crashing to record lows last month, the Central Bank of the Republic of Turkey (CBRT) has every excuse to hike borrowing costs substantially. However, there are political ramifications - president Recep Tayyip Erdoğan is a strident opponent of high interest rates.

So today’s meeting is real test of the CBRT’s independence.

On balance, traders expect a sharp rise in Turkey’s benchmark rates, from 17.75% to perhaps 21%. That would make life a lot tougher for borrowers, but could also strengthen the ailing lira.

Kathleen Brooks, research director at Capital Index, says there is a lot resting on today’s decision.

A rate rise would be symbolic for the global financial community. One reason why the lira fell so sharply over the summer was partly due to fears about the political atmosphere and President Erdogan taking control of the central bank for his own economic benefit.

He spoke out vociferously against rate hikes, saying that higher interest rates did not dampen inflation, which goes against traditional economic theory. He also placed his son-in-law in the finance ministry, both things spooked investors’ and triggered the Turkish financial market crisis.

If the CBRT can revert back to traditional economic methods for deciding policy, without Presidential interference, then global investors may regain confidence in the economic management of the country and return to its financial markets.

It’s also a big day for Britain’s struggling retail sector, with John Lewis and Morrison’s reporting results.

European stock markets are expected to dip in early trading:

The agenda

  • 12pm BST: Bank of England interest rate decision
  • 12pm BST: Bank of Turkey interest rate decision
  • 12.45pm BST: European Central Bank interest rate decision
  • 1.30pm BST: European Central Bank press conference
  • 1.30pm BST: US inflation figures for August
 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*