Angela Monaghan and Katie Allen 

Jackson Hole: Yellen leaves door open to rate rise before year-end – as it happened

Janet Yellen, chair of the US Federal Reserve, gives a highly anticipated speech as the 2016 Jackson Hole meeting of central bankers gets underway
  
  

Janet Yellen arrives for a reception on the opening night of Jackson Hole
Janet Yellen arrives for a reception on the opening night of Jackson Hole Photograph: Brennan Linsley/AP

Closing summary: Fed leaves door open to rate rise before year-end

On that note, it’s time to close for the day. Thanks for all the comments, we will be back on Tuesday.

Updated

Here is CNBC’s report on its interview with Fed vice chair Stanley Fischer, who gave markets more to mull over when he highlighted the US economy’s recent strength. Hints that the Fed could raise rates as soon as next month, saw US stock markets erase earlier gains.

US stocks trim gains as Stanley Fischer highlights stronger economy

Now Fed policymaker Stanley Fischer is talking about Janet Yellen’s speech, adding fuel to the debate over whether the US central bank could raise rates as soon as September.

He has been speaking to CNBC and appears to be hinting a near-term rate rise is still on the table. The dollar is strengthening and US stocks have trimmed gains.

Here’s a rather unsympathetic assessment of how financial markets reacted to Janet Yellen’s speech from David Lamb, head of dealing a FEXCO Corporate Payments. He says traders are “unable to see their terminals for the egg on their faces”.

Lamb comments:

“The currency markets frequently live and die by the ‘shoot first and ask questions later’ motto. Today they were asking awkward questions just seconds after firing.

“No sooner had the Fed’s Chair uttered the magic words ‘the case has strengthened’ and trigger-happy traders were snapping up dollars in expectation of an near-immediate rate rise.

“But as the seconds ticked by, it became increasingly clear that a hike is inevitable, but not imminent.

“Cue a huge correction that saw the dollar slump well below its pre-announcement levels – leaving many traders unable to see their terminals for the egg on their faces.

“The caveats came thick and fast. There’s a range of possible rate rise scenarios, they could still be blown of course, and the killer line – gradual hikes are appropriate.”

US stock markets are rallying in the wake of Janet Yellen’s speech, says Chris Beauchamp, chief market analyst at online trading company IG.

He believes Yellen opted to “please both hawks and doves”.

Beauchamp comments:

“The ‘Dip-buyers anonymous’ team is working at full steam this afternoon, as Janet Yellen finds the right tone to encourage investors to step back into the market at the end of a tedious week. Clearly a modest rise in rates is taken as a sign of confidence in the economy, while the passing reference to other policy measures being potentially necessary in future crises was viewed as leaving the door open to the kind of broader monetary stimulus practised by the European Central Bank and the Bank of Japan.”

Looking ahead, he adds:

“Given the enthusiastic reception equity markets have given Janet Yellen, it looks like the steady grind higher will continue into the end of August.”

Andrew Hunter, US economist at the consultancy Capital Economics says Janet Yellen’s comments are “consistent with a US rate hike by year-end”.

To re-cap, the Fed chair said the case for rate rises had strengthened, she rebuffed suggestions monetary policy had lost some of its power and made that now so familiar call from central bankers for fiscal policy to do its share of the heavy lifting.

But there was little in the way of guidance on when US interest rates might rise and so markets were left doing a little dance that I would sum up - if readers will forgive the lack of sophistication - as “Oh no, rate hikes!!! Oh, hang on, as you were, nothing’s imminent.” In other words, the dollar rose and then the dollar fell. Stocks trimmed gains and then recovered.

Hunter at Capital Economics says Yellen’s acknowledgement that “the case for an increase in the federal funds rate has strengthened” would appear to increase the likelihood of a near-term rate hike.

He continues:

“On balance, however, we think most officials will want to see more concrete evidence of a rebound in GDP growth and a rise in inflation towards the 2% target, with a December move still appearing the most likely outcome.

“In a fairly upbeat assessment of current economic conditions, Yellen acknowledged the recent strength of consumption, despite the weakness of GDP growth. She also highlighted that even that subdued pace of growth “has been sufficient to generate further improvement in the labour market”. However, she repeated the warning that the future path of monetary policy will depend on the incoming data.”

And on the consultancy’s view on when rates will rise, Hunter concludes:

“Overall, along with the more upbeat tone of the recent data, we think the odds of a September rate hike have probably increased. They will increase further if we are right in forecasting that non-farm payrolls increased by a solid 180,000 in August (data due next Friday). Nonetheless, with real GDP expanding by just 1.2% over the past 12 months and inflation continuing to run below target, we still think most Fed officials will want to wait until December before next raising rates.”

Here are some reassuring words for any readers struggling to make sense of today’s Jackson Hole speech from Janet Yellen.

Our economics editor, Larry Elliott, says the Fed Chair’s address provided an opportunity for “Wall Street to play one of its favourite games: interpreting a speech by Janet Yellen.”

He writes:

“Truly, in terms of making her pronouncements cryptic, the most powerful central banker in the world is the daughter and heir to her predecessor but one, Alan Greenspan.

Nothing Yellen has come up with comes close yet to Greenspan’s “I know you think you understand what you thought I said but I’m not sure you realise that what you heard is not what I meant” but her presentation at the Jackson Hole symposium was a pretty good effort.”

Full analysis following soon

Rob Carnell, chief international economist at the bank ING says it was a speech full of caveats from Janet Yellen and that “a September rate hike remains awkward to sell to markets unless the inflation data start to move higher”.

He has pulled out two main messages, and one sub-message, from the lengthy Jackson Hole speech.

“The first of the main messages was that the economy has continued to improve and that made the case for a rate hike more likely in the months ahead.

“But “more likely” does not mean “likely”, and markets are still reluctant to buy into a September rate hike story, at least without more information on the evolution of jobs growth, the pace of economic activity, or higher inflation.

“The second message, which we suspect markets may also have problems accepting at face value, is that in the event of a return to crisis, more quantitative easing, coupled with “forward guidance” would likely provide sufficient stimulus to avert catastrophe (our words). This message might very well be filed under the heading of “Well, they would say that wouldn’t they.”

“But buried at the end of the speech, after a section that seemed to draw heavily on the recent paper by the San Francisco Fed President, John Williams’, Yellen proposed an enhanced role for fiscal policy. She talked about the need for measures designed to improve productivity (fiscal, not monetary), as well as enhancing (fiscal) automatic stabilisers. A cynic might paraphrase the speech as “Things are looking brighter, but if it all goes wrong don’t panic, there’s always fiscal policy”.”

David Morrison, senior market strategist at Spreadco has been looking at that rollercoaster market reaction to the speech by Janet Yellen.

He comments:

“Her speech was undeniably hawkish. She said the case for a rate hike has strengthened in recent months. Also, the US economy continues to expand and has reached maximum employment with price stability. This saw the dollar pop higher initially and precious metals fall. Nevertheless, she anticipates that gradual rate hikes are appropriate...

“But as is so often the case, the initial market reaction can be misleading. As traders scanned below the headlines for the meat in the speech, perceptions over Dr Yellen’s thinking changed. Gold and silver have surged as the dollar slumped. Possibly this is connected to her comments that the overall economic situation remains uncertain.”

Janet Yellen has also used her speech to join the chorus of central bankers insisting they are not all out of ammunition.

Her speech to the Jackson Hole meeting, entitled “The Federal Reserve’s Monetary Policy Toolkit: Past, Present, and Future”, unsurprisingly concludes that it’s a well-stocked and effective toolkit.

Yellen says:

“Although fiscal policies and structural reforms can play an important role in strengthening the U.S. economy, my primary message today is that I expect monetary policy will continue to play a vital part in promoting a stable and healthy economy. New policy tools, which helped the Federal Reserve respond to the financial crisis and Great Recession, are likely to remain useful in dealing with future downturns. Additional tools may be needed and will be the subject of research and debate. But even if average interest rates remain lower than in the past, I believe that monetary policy will, under most conditions, be able to respond effectively.”

There are echoes of Bank of England governor Mark Carney, who shortly after the EU referendum said: “The charge that central banks are out of monetary ammunition is wrong, but the widespread absence of global price pressures demands that our firepower be well aimed.”

Also reacting to Janet Yellen’s speech at Jackson Hole, Lee Ferridge, head of multi-asset strategy at State Street Global Markets North America has shared this view:

“Despite recent hints of an ongoing policy rethink at the FOMC [Federal Open Markets Committee], Janet Yellen’s Jackson Hole speech did not break much new ground. Her comments could help arrest the dollar’s recent decline and deal a blow to the rally in risky assets that we have seen in recent weeks. A move at the September meeting remains less likely but a move before year end now looks a distinct possibility should US data continue to improve.”

Some more reactions coming in to Janet Yellen’s speech now, which as we noted earlier left the markets in a bit of a muddle.

The dollar initially strengthened as the Fed chair hinted at further rate rises but then lost those gains, possibly as the timing of any such tightening seems to be some way off. Similarly, stock markets initially trimmed gains on the prospect of higher interest rates and then rose again when traders had digested Yellen’s remarks and decided it was too soon to worry.

Aberdeen Asset Management fixed income investment manager James Athey comments:

“While the bulk of Yellen’s opening remarks at Jackson Hole focussed on monetary policy over the long term, she stated that in her opinion the case for a rate hike has strengthened in recent months. But the lack of any specific signal with regards to the September meeting means markets are unlikely to react adversely to this fairly throwaway comment. Yellen’s comments were largely focussed on the debate around the effectiveness of the Fed’s toolkit.

“Of course she defended the success of previous policy and indeed the ability of the Fed to respond effectively in the future, however she wasn’t shy of highlighting the need for government to assist in the heavy lifting through the use of supportive fiscal policy – a plea we regularly hear from ECB President Mario Draghi.

“However the elephant in the room is that the Fed may well be worshipping at a false idol. There’s more and more evidence to show that inflation just isn’t behaving in the way that economists think it should. The Fed should stop targeting consumer inflation and start looking at a wider suite of measures to judge the health of the economy and the appropriateness of their policy. Sadly it looks like the wide open plains of Wyoming have not inspired any soul searching.”

So it’s a hawkish message from Yellen, but is she telling us anything we didn’t know already?

Well, markets appear to be struggling to make sense of the message from Yellen. US stocks initially trimmed gains only to rise again. The dollar has now reversed its initial gains against the pound and euro.

Here are some of the early reactions (including from UK commentators, who are counting down to a long weekend with a public holiday on Monday):

Those remarks on a stronger case for rate hikes in the US have seen US stock markets trim some of their gains and pushed the dollar up against the euro and pound.

This key extract from the speech shows Janet Yellen and her fellow policymakers are still keen to come across as avid data watchers, but she clearly sees a better case for rate rises:

“In light of the continued solid performance of the labor market and our outlook for economic activity and inflation, I believe the case for an increase in the federal funds rate has strengthened in recent months. Of course, our decisions always depend on the degree to which incoming data continues to confirm the Committee’s outlook,” she said.

Yellen says case for rate hikes "strengthened in recent months"

Yellen has told her audience at Jackson Hole that the case for raising US interest rates has strengthened in recent months.

She cited improvements in the jobs market and hopes for modest GDP growth.

Here is the full speech.

Wall Street opens higher before Yellen speech

US markets are up in early trading as investors await Yellen’s speech at Jackson Hole. Twenty minutes to go.

  • Dow Jones: +0.3% at 18,495
  • S&P 500: +0.3% at 2,178
  • Nasdaq: +0.2% at 5,222

Before Janet Yellen speaks in less than an hour, there have been some important developments in the cruise liner industry.

David Hasselhoff of Knight Rider and Baywatch fame will set sail on his first official fan cruise on 4 November next year. The six-day tour on Costa Favolosa will begin in Italy and call at various European ports.

The ticket price starts at €599 (£513) and “David is on board with you for the duration of the cruiser”, apparently.

Events will include a concert, a get-together with the Hoff, an autograph session and – an evening with David “in the large theatre”....

Updated

Ben & Jerry’s have recalled some 500ml cartons of their Cookie Dough flavour ice cream over fears they might contain small pieces of metal.

Four batches are thought to have been affected and UK customers have been asked to check batch numbers printed at the bottom of their pots.

The ice-cream maker advised customers to throw the product away if it was from one of the batches. It said in a safety notice:

The company has identified a specific production period during which Ben & Jerry’s Cookie Dough 500ml may have been affected and, as safety remains a top priority, Ben & Jerry’s is voluntarily recalling four batch codes of Cookie Dough 500ml from sale.

As a precaution, everyone with a 500ml tub of Ben & Jerry’s Cookie Dough in their freezers at home should check the batch number on the bottom of their tub to make sure it’s not affected.

And, if it matches the batch numbers listed above, they should not eat the product and, instead, we ask them to discard the product in the usual household bin.

(The batch codes affected are L62110L011, L62111L011, L62112L011 and L62113L011.)

Fancy an ice cream anyone?

Simon Smith, chief economist at FxPro, thinks Janet Yellen should take a cautious approach to her Jackson Hole speech, which is coming up in a hour an a quarter.

Smith says:

Yellen will do her best to sound upbeat on the US economy, but not to tie her hands into tightening policy this year. The Fed has led the market down the garden path once too often on this front, not least at last year’s Jackson Hole summit, so she’d do well to keep her options open this time and not cause a similar furore this year.”

He adds makes the point that central bankers are running out of rope when it comes to monetary policy stimulus:

The issue is that monetary policy is reaching its limits, even the various forms of quantitative easing and negative interest rates being imposed. This is most true for Japan and the eurozone.

That may encourage central bankers to be even more aggressive in their approach, but there are always unintended consequences. This is certainly true in the eurozone, given the costs that negative rates impose on banks and (increasingly) their customers.

US growth revised slightly lower in second quarter

US GDP growth for the second quarter has been revised down a touch to an annual rate of 1.1%, from an earlier estimate of 1.2%.

The second estimate from the US Commerce Department was in line with the expectations of economists polled by Reuters.

It followed 0.8% growth in the first quarter.

Updated

European markets remain subdued as we await Yellen’s speech.

The FTSE 100 is down just three points at 6,820.

It’s a similar story across Europe, with the STOXX 600 index down 0.1 points to 341.9.

Japan's deflationary spiral deepens

Earlier in Japan, figures showed consumer prices fell for the fifth month in a row in July, dealing a blow to prime minister Shinzo Abe and his bid to combat deflation.

Annual deflation deepened last month, with consumer prices falling by 0.5% in the year to July. It followed a 0.4% drop in June and was the biggest fall in more than three years as businesses delayed price hikes because of weak demand.

The data will intensify the pressure on Japan’s central bank to announce more stimulus, on top of the huge amount of money it has already pumped into the world’s third largest economy.

Marcel Thieliant, senior Japan economist at Capital Economics:

While economic activity is on the mend, the slump in import prices suggests that underlying inflation will continue to fall in coming months.

The Bank of Japan will find it increasingly difficult to blame falling energy prices for the decline in overall consumer prices.

Updated

Ana Thaker, Market Economist at PhillipCapital UK, says investors will be looking to this afternoon’s US GDP number, as well as Yellen’s speech, for clues about the timing of the next rate rise.

Strong data combined with a hawkish Yellen could see the dollar rally as August comes to a close and markets look towards the [rate-setting] FOMC meeting in September.

The Fed are relying on strong economic data to advocate a long anticipated rate hike so data over the last half of 2016 is crucial to both markets and the Fed in determining the direction of policy and markets. We are at a crucial point in the course of monetary policy for the Fed and data points are more pertinent than ever.

Markus Allenspach, head of fixed income research at Julius Baer, says Yellen is unlikely to give any clear signals about September’s Fed meeting:

For weeks already, the market is waiting anxiously for Yellen’s speech, as members of the Federal Reserve often presented conflicting views in the public about the necessity and timing of rate hikes.

We doubt, however, that Yellen will give clear directions today; in her view, monetary policy decisions are taken by the FOMC as a committee.

Kansas Fed president: it's time to normalise rates

Esther George, president of the Kansas City Federal Reserve and host of the Jackson Hole meeting, has been speaking to Bloomberg from the event.

Having already voted against the majority for a rate rise, she suggests she’ll vote again for higher rates at the Fed’s September meeting.

When I look at where we are with the job market, when I look at inflation and our forecasts for that, I think it’s time to move.

Where it will look by the September meeting we’ll have to wait and see if anything changes fundamentally.

Ahead of Yellen’s speech, traders are forecasting a one in three chance of a US rate rise in September.

Back to the main event of the day in Jackson Hole, Wyoming.

Once Friday’s proceedings get underway at Jackson Lake Lodge, we won’t have long to wait for Janet Yellen’s speech as the chair of the US Federal Reserve is first up at 8am Mountain Time (3pm in the UK).

The meeting runs from 8am to 2pm on both Friday and Saturday, with a series of papers presented, speeches given, and discussions held. As Larry Elliott, the Guardian’s economics editor put it, “Jackson Hole is Davos for central bankers”.

The Bank of England’s Minouche Shafik will give a speech titled adapting to changes in the financial market landscape at 3.50pm UK time.

Other topics up for discussion on Friday include negative interest rates, and “alternative monetary frameworks”. The main topic on Saturday is central bank balance sheets.

The full agenda is published here.

Martin Beck, senior economic advisor to the EY Item Club, says predictions of a self-inflicted Brexit recession are overdone.

An uncertainty-driven slowdown still seems likely. But with a number of recent surveys from the CBI and others showing bouncebacks from post-vote lows, strong official retail sales numbers for July, and the support offered by the package of measures announced by the Bank of England, predictions that the economy will fall into recession look unduly pessimistic.

Pound rises as UK consumer confidence jumps

The pound is up slightly against the dollar at $1.3203 (+0.1%). It is flat against the euro at €1.688.

UK data this week has generally been better-than-expected and a survey published overnight by YouGov/Cebr showed a surge in consumer confidence in August.

The headline index increased 3.2 points to 109.8 in August. It was the biggest monthly jump since February 2013 after the economy performed better than expected.

The August rise followed a sharp drop in July, suggesting initial shock and fears over the June Brexit vote subsided this month.

YouGov interviews about 6,000 consumers a month, asking them about their household finances, property prices, job security and business activity in the workplace.

The only indicator to show a drop in August was job security over the next 12 months.

Here is the Guardian’s full story on the second estimate of Q2 growth, which was confirmed at 0.6%:

Samuel Tombs at Pantheon Macroeconomics is decidedly gloomy about the outlook for the UK economy. He says consumers will start to feel the pinch from rising inflation next year:

Looking ahead, consumers might be able to maintain strong growth in their spending for another quarter, but when inflation picks up in earnest early next year and firms follow through on plans to freeze hiring, they will have to slow down.

Meanwhile, the slight rise in business investment in Q2 provides little reassurance about the post-referendum outlook, since few businesses anticipated the Leave vote and surveys suggest firms are recoiling from major financial commitments in Q3.

As a result, we continue to see a high risk that the economy enters a mild recession over the coming quarters.

Deloitte’s chief economist Ian Stewart, says the consumer recovery is going strong:

The UK entered the post-referendum period with good momentum.

Household spending accounts for roughly two-thirds of the economy and is growing at the fastest rate in eight years. We see few signs that Brexit has derailed the consumer recovery.

Scott Bowman at Capital Economics, says the Brexit vote will weigh on growth in the second half of the year:

UK households shrugged off pre-referendum uncertainty, driving an acceleration in GDP growth in the second quarter.

Looking ahead, growth looks set to slow significantly in the second half of the year as uncertainty related to the Brexit vote takes its toll.

We think that growth will fall to around zero in Q3 and Q4, mainly due to falls in business investment.

Here are three key charts from the second estimate of Q2 growth, which came in at 0.6%...

1. The UK economy has grown every quarter since the first quarter of 2013:

2. On the output side of the economy, only the services sector is back above pre-crisis levels:

3. Households shrugged off uncertainty in the run-up to the 23 June referendum, as consumer spending continued to be a key driver of growth:

Updated

Joe Grice, chief economist at the ONS has commented on this mornings figures which confirmed the UK economy grew by 0.6% in the second quarter, following 0.4% growth in the first quarter.

Today’s figures reinforce the picture that the economy grew strongly in April, and then remained relatively flat in May and June.

Business investment grew in the second quarter, partly thanks to companies spending on transport equipment such as cars and planes. However, levels of investment remained lower than at the same period last year.

Our survey returns, which include the period leading up to and immediately following the referendum, show no sign so far of uncertainty having significantly affected investment or GDP.

ONS: no evidence of Brexit impact on investment in Q2

The ONS says there is no sign in the GDP data that uncertainty in the run-up to the EU referendum affected investment.

The second estimate of growth (confirmed at 0.6%) gives a more detailed picture of how different parts of the economy performed between April and June. Specifically it shed some light on the spending side.

Business investment increased by 0.5% over the quarter, beating expectations of a 0.8% fall and a 0.6% fall in the first quarter.

Household spending was the strongest in almost two years in the second quarter, up 0.9% from 0.7% in the first quarter.

In terms of output, services growth was confirmed at 0.5% and industrial output growth was confirmed at 2.1%.

Construction output was revised down however, falling by 0.7% and not 0.4% as initially thought.

Breaking: UK economy grows 0.6 in second quarter

Growth of 0.6% in the second quarter has been confirmed by the Office for National Statistics.

More soon.

Updated

French consumer confidence rises in August

French consumer confidence ticked up in August, to 97 from 96 in July.

It followed a drop in confidence in the previous two months according to the INSEE figures.

Confidence among households about their personal finance situation improved sharply, jumping seven points to highest level since October 2007.

Updated

French GDP: zero growth in second quarter

The French economy was flat in the second quarter, a second estimate of GDP from the statistics office INSEE showed.

Zero growth between April and June followed 0.7% growth in the first quarter.

INSEE said there was a sharp slowdown in household spending, while trade made a positive contribution after imports fell more than exports.

European markets are subdued before Yellen speaks

There is little movement in European markets this morning as investors await Janet Yellen’s speech at Jackson Hole.

They will be looking for clues from the Fed chair about whether to expect the next rise in US interest rates in September, December, or 2017.

  • FTSE 100: -0.2% at 6,802
  • Germany’s DAX: +0.1% at 10,537
  • France’s CAC: +0.1% at 4,409
  • Italy’s FTSE MIB: -0.7% at 16,587
  • Spain’s IBEX: 0.3% at 8,623
  • Europe’s STOXX 600: -0.03% at 342

The Jackson Hole economic symposium has been hosted by the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City since 1978.

Representing the Bank of England are Minouche Shafik, deputy governor for markets and banking, and Kristin Forbes, an external member of the Bank’s Monetary Policy Committee.

Bank of England governor Mark Carney, and European Central Bank president Mario Draghi, will not attend.

Also coming up today...

We will get the second estimate of UK growth in the second-quarter from the Office for National Statistics. Economists polled expect growth to be confirmed at 0.6%.

But Michael Hewson, chief market analyst at CMC Markets, says there is a risk that the number could be revised lower, “particularly since we did see some evidence of a slowdown in late May and June as the referendum date approached”.

The latest estimate will provide more details on how the different parts of the economy performed between April and June.

So far the consumer side of the economy appears to have held up well since the Brexit vote on 23 June, but those numbers as well as business investment figures will be closely scrutinised in the coming months for signs of waning confidence.

In the US (before Yellen speaks at 3pm UK time) we will get the second estimate of Q2 growth from the world’s largest economy.

European markets are expected to open slightly lower this morning as traders pause for breath before Yellen’s speech.

The agenda: Janet Yellen speaks at Jackson Hole

Good morning, and welcome to our rolling coverage of the world economy, the financial markets, the eurozone and business.

The day has finally arrived. At 8am Mountain Time, or 3pm UK time, the chair of the US Federal Reserve Janet Yellen will deliver her keenly anticipated speech at the 2016 Jackson Hole symposium.

The event is hosted by the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City, and got underway last night with a reception and dinner at the Jackson Lake Lodge in Grand Teton National Park, Wyoming.

The full agenda for the meeting of the world’s central bankers can be found here. This year’s theme is Designing Resilient Monetary Policy Frameworks for the Future.

But the main event awaited by investors all week is Yellen’s speech. The title of the speech is The Fed’s Monetary Policy Toolkit, but traders and commentators will be looking specifically for any hints on the timing of the next Fed rate rise.

This is what markets have been waiting for all week. We will bring you commentary in the run-up to the speech, the speech itself, and reaction thereafter. Thank you for joining us.

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*