Angela Monaghanand Julia Kollewe 

Tension escalates as Greece threatens to seize German assets – as it happened

The President of the European Central Bank says the ECB’s €1.1 trillion bond-buying programme is working as the euro falls to a fresh 12-year low
  
  

A Greek and a European Union flag wave across Acropolis hill, in Athens, Greece, on 3 March 2015.
A Greek and a European Union flag wave across Acropolis hill, in Athens, Greece, on 3 March 2015. Photograph: Orestis Panagiotou/EPA

That’s all for today, folks. We’ll be back tomorrow. Thanks for all your great comments.

On Wall Street, stocks have recovered somewhat from recent losses. The Dow Jones industrial average is currently up more than 30 points at 17,696.17, a 0.2% gain, while the S&P 500 is also 0.2% ahead at 2,047.52.

Andrew Wilkinson, chief market analyst at Interactive Brokers Group in Connecticut told Reuters:

There’s a growing acceptance that the Fed will raise interest rates possibly as soon as June, and people continue to reel in shock as to how far the ECB is likely to remain at zero.

In the meantime, on the back of a big fall, for stocks it looks like people are regrouping again today.

The euro sank to a 12-year low against the dollar, falling as low as $1.0537. This helped lift Germany’s Dax to a record high [see 16:53], as major exporters like Volkswagen and BMW will benefit from a weaker euro.

Updated

Bank of England policymaker Martin Weale also indicated that he could vote for higher borrowing costs in coming months. One of the four independent members of the Bank’s nine-strong monetary policy committee, he said that despite global worries about low inflation the decision about whether to raise interest rates was finely balanced.

Read our story in full here.

The FTSE 100 stocks that are most exposed to the euro (i.e. get more than half their revenues from the eurozone) include Imperial Tobacco, 3i, Vodafone and Easyjet. In the other indices, Thomas Cook, Flybe, Hansteen and Capital & Regional all generate the bulk of their business in the eurozone.

The IMF loan to Ukraine is (obviously) based on an economic reform programme supported by the fund. Here is Lagarde’s statement in full.

The change in the IMF-supported program from Stand-By Arrangement to Extended Arrangement under the EFF, which is consistent with the more protracted nature of Ukraine’s balance-of-payment needs, will provide more funding, more time, more flexibility, and better financing terms for Ukraine.

The Ukrainian authorities continue to demonstrate a strong commitment to reform. They have maintained fiscal discipline in very difficult conditions; allowed the exchange rate to adjust; and have increased retail end-user prices for gas. Many key measures are front-loaded under the new program—including further sizable energy tariff increases; bank restructuring; governance reforms of state-owned enterprises; and legal changes aimed at combating corruption and strengthening the rule of law.

To help cushion the impact of adjustment, especially for the poorest groups, measures are being taken to strengthen and better target the social safety net.”

The program is ambitious and involves risks, notably those stemming from the conflict in the east of the country. I am heartened that the cease-fire agreed last month in Minsk seems to be largely holding for now, and hope that a further loss of life can be avoided.

I wish the authorities well as they embark on this new economic reform program. With continued firm implementation, there is reasonably strong prospect of success.

IMF grants Ukraine $17.5bn loan

Breaking news: The IMF has signed off on a four-year loan programme for Ukraine worth $17.5bn. IMF chief Christine Lagarde said described it as ambitious, but added that there is a “reasonably strong prospect of success”.

Updated

European stock markets close higher (except Athens)

European stock markets have closed.

  • FTSE 100 index rises 18.67 points to 6,721.51, a 0.3% gain
  • Germany’s Dax closes 2.7% higher at 11,805.41, setting a fresh record closing high
  • France’s CAC gains 2.4% to 4,997.28
  • Italy’s FTSE MiB adds 2.2% to 22,833.04
  • Spain’s Ibex up 1% at 11,009.7
  • The Greek stock market lost 2.5% to 797.3

Updated

Martin Weale sees risk of sharp fall in sterling

Here in the UK, Bank of England rate-setter Martin Weale sees the risk of a sharp fall in sterling because of the country’s large balance of payments deficit.

Britain’s current account deficit was equivalent to 6% of GDP in the third quarter of last year, matching the biggest deficit on record.

After giving a speech in London, Weale said, echoing comments he made last month:

Certainly it seems to me that there is a risk of a sharp movement in the exchange rate. I would be inclined to say more of a risk of a sharp downward movement.

The economy always springs surprises, and what’s been happening to sterling in the last few weeks has been one of those surprises.

Greek wages edged up 0.3% in the fourth quarter of last year compared with a year earlier, according to the Hellenic Statistical Authority. Seasonally adjusted, the wage index grew 1.4%, after an 8.3% decline in the same quarter in 2013.

The Greek stock market has ended the day 2.5% lower at 797.30 points, below the 800 point level for the first time in 18 sessions. Bank shares suffered some of the heaviest losses, including National Bank, Eurobank and Alpha Bank.

Anti-German sentiment has not been confined to the Greek justice minister, writes Helena Smith. Senior officials in Athens have been railing against Berlin today.

Before Greece’s justice minister Nikos Paraskevopoulos raised the prospect of seizing German assets to pay war reparations, Dimitris Stratoulis, the minister in charge of social security, was also railing against Berlin’s hegemony of Europe.

The role of Europe’s paymaster as dominant player in Europe was over, he told ANT 1 TV today. And, he said it would only get worse when the anti-establishment Podemos party was also catapulted into power later this year. He said:

“Germany’s Europe has finished, [the Europe] where Germany forbids and all the other countries execute orders is over. In November when [Spain’s anti-austerity party] Podemos is elected, things will be even worse for them.

The radical left Syriza party was not elected to placate Germany, he said, but to offer relief to austerity-hit Greeks.

We were elected so the Greek people could breathe.

German chancellor Angela Merkel narrowly escaped a much bigger rebellion among her conservatives last month, many of whom would have opposed Greece’s bailout extension had it not been for her finance minister Wolfgang Schäuble’s powers of persuasion.

Germany’s parliament overwhelmingly passed the extension on 27 February, even though a record number of conservatives voted against. (29 of the 32 parliamentarians who voted against came from Merkel’s CDU and its Bavarian sister party CSU.)

One senior conservative told Reuters that the CSU, “would have unanimously voted “no” had Schäuble not drummed up support personally two days before the vote.

Another leading conservative said Schäuble’s meeting with CDU lawmakers was equally important in securing their backing at a time when confidence in the Greek government was “kaputt” in the Bundestag, the lower chamber. The lawmaker said: “The vote was hanging by a thread”.

This is indicative of the growing discontent within Merkel’s conservative ranks, amid fears that Greece might need a third bailout.

Germans are also outraged by Athens’ anti-German rhetoric, in particular Tsipras’ comments on seeking war reparations from Berlin.

In contrast, Merkel’s coalition partner, the centre-left Social Democrats, and the opposition Greens, voted unanimously in favour of the four-month extension.

Updated

The pound has hit its lowest level against the dollar in 20 months, amid growing expectations that US interest rates will rise in coming months. Sterling fell almost 1% to $1.4929 at one stage.

The dollar, for its part, has gained more than 10% against a basket of six major currencies so far this year, led by its rise against the euro. This puts it on track for its best quarterly performance since 1992.

Back on Greece, the Guardian’s correspondent Helena Smith says the planned return of the troika is already causing ruptions within the governing Syriza party.

Energy minister Panaghiotis Lafazanis, who heads the far Left Platform in the governing Syriza party, told an international conference on energy security in Athens:

“Greece is a very small country to remain a dependent economic protectorate of the troika.” The anti-austerity government would resist the demand to privatize companies in the energy sector, he insisted.

The Left Platform, which represents about 30% of Syriza, issued a lacerating statement after Monday’s euro group denouncing German tactics towards Greece.

“The country’s lenders are not only not relenting, they are intensifying their pressure and blackmailing tactics so the government will submit and mercilessly enforce the new-memorandum,” it railed.

“At the same time the neo-colonialists in Brussels, and especially [German finance minister Wolfgang] Schäuble… are warning that they won’t accept “unilateral actions,” that is measures that would ease [the plight] of the Greek people.

Updated

A eurozone policymaker has rejected the idea that the central bank is helping to push the euro lower to gain competitive advantage in the region.

Ewald Nowotny, head of Austria’s central bank and a member of the European Central Bank’s governing council told an audience in Frankfurt:

The ECB, as a central bank, does not have [the] exchange rate as a policy. It’s a side effect of other things.

Exchange rates ... are not a major dominant factor for the global economy. I think it would be wrong to assume that what is going on right now is a c currency war.

Wall Street opens higher

US stock markets are up slightly in early trading following sharp falls on Tuesday.

  • Dow Jones: +0.2% at 17,702.78
  • S&P 500: +0.1% at 2,046.06
  • Nasdaq: +0.2% at 4,336.48

Cyprus seeks distance from Greek euro drama

Reuters is reporting that doubts over Greece’s future membership of the eurozone are straining its relationship with Cyprus.

Cyprus wants to reverse a perception that the two countries are inextricably linked, worried that it could be dragged down with Greece, should Athens’ finances collapse and force the Greeks to abandon the euro.

The fate of Cyprus, a divided island on Europe’s frontier with the Middle East, could prove an important test of the durability of the eurozone and the wider European Union in the face of political uncertainty in Greece.

“(Sharing a) language is one thing but being the same economy is completely different,” said Harris Georgiades, finance minister of a country largely populated by Greek Cypriots. Linguistic solidarity leads Cyprus and Greece to give each other’s contestant the top score each year in the Eurovision song contest.

“There are cultural ties but that’s it. We are following our own course,” Georgiades told Reuters in an interview.

Unlike Greece, Cyprus has been largely diligent in implementing reforms required in return for an international bailout it received in 2013. There has been little public protest despite the deep recession that ensued.

Their paths have diverged more sharply since the radical leftist Syriza party won power in Greece in January, denouncing austerity and demanding a reduction of its official debt.

The centre-right Cypriot government blames former Communist President Dimitris Christofias for delaying a cleanup of Cypriot banks that made the eventual bailout more painful.

Cyprus hopes to return to borrowing on bond markets this year, Georgiades said, while Athens has little such prospect.

Trade ties are modest. Greece ranks second behind Britain in selling services to Cyprus, such as holidays, but it lags far behind Russia, Britain and Germany as a customer.

The former British colony has also severed its banks’ links to Greece that resulted in heavy losses when Greek bonds were restructured or ‘haircut’. It was those losses that fatally compromised the Cypriot financial system and prompted its bailout.

“We hope that there will be no problems in Greece,” said Chrystalla Georghadji, the governor of the Central Bank of Cyprus. “But if there are any problems, the banks here are ring-fenced.”

Germany: no plans to talk to Greece about war reparations

The German government has dismissed threats from the Greek government, which has claimed it is ready to seize German assets as compensation for Nazi war crimes.

Steffen Seibert, spokesman for German chancellor Angela Merkel said:

It is our firm belief that questions of reparations and compensation have been legally and politically resolved.

We should concentrate on current issues and, hopefully, what will be a good future.

A spokesman for the German finance ministry said there was no reason to hold talks about reparations and that the demands were a distraction from the serious financial issues facing Greece.

Greek shares are down 1% this morning with the main ATG index at 808.69.

Greece has yet to come up with a package of reforms that its creditors are happy with. A final tranche of funding under the existing bailout will only be released if agreement is reached on reforms.

The proposals offered up by Greek finance minister Yanis Varoufakis have thus far been rejected by eurozone finance ministers as too vague and inadequate.

A reminder of what the initial proposals from Greece were:

1) Creating an Office for Fiscal Responsibility, to monitor government policy

2) Improving budget preparation

3) Hiring ‘casual onlookers’ to fight tax evasion -- citizens and tourists wired up with recording kit to find evidence of firms dodging VAT.

4) Tackling Greece’s unpaid tax problem, by offering a discount to those in arrears and writing off some of the ‘unrecoverable’ debts.

5) Offering new licences to online gambling sites, replacing the current system which doesn’t raise any revenue

6) Reforms to force government agencies to share information better, rather than bombarding citizens with requests.

7) New allowances for food and rent for poorest Greek families, and reconnecting power supplies to those who have been disconnected for not paying their bills.

Hostility between Germany and Greece is building. Germany’s finance minister Wolfgang Schaeuble described Varoufakis as “foolishly naive” on Tuesday, referring to the Greek finance minister’s comments to the press.

And today Greece has raised the stakes by suggesting it will not be lectured by a country that has Germany’s past. See last post below.

Athens threatens to seize German assets over WW11 reparations

Tensions between Greece and Germany have been raised a few notches, with reports from Athens that justice minister Nikos Paraskevopoulos is threatening to seize German assets to compensate Greek victims of Nazi war crimes.

This report from Greek daily newspaper ekathimerini:

Justice Minister Nikos Paraskevopoulos has said he is ready to sign an older court ruling that will enable the foreclosure of German assets in Greece in order to compensate the relatives of victims of Nazi crimes during the Second World War.

Greece’s Supreme Court ruled in favor of Distomo survivors in 2000, but the decision has not been enforced.

Distomo, a small village in central Greece, lost 218 lives in a Nazi massacre in 1944.

“The law states that in order to implement the ruling of the Supreme Court, the minister of justice has to order it. I believe this permission should be given and I’m ready to give it, notwithstanding any obstacles,” Paraskevopoulos told Antenna TV on Wednesday.

“There must probably be some negotiation with Germany,” said Paraskevopoulos, who first announced his intention Tuesday during a Parliament debate on the creation of a committee to seek war reparations, the repayment of a forced loan and the return of antiquities.

During the same debate, Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras expressed his government’s firm intention to seek war reparations from Germany, noting that Athens would show sensitivity that it hoped to see reciprocated from Berlin.

Tsipras told MPs that the matter of war reparations was “very technical and sensitive” but one he has a duty to pursue. He also seemed to indirectly connect the matter to talks between Greece and its international creditors on the country’s loan program.

“The Greek government will strive to honor its commitments to the full,” he said. “But it will also strive to ensure all unfulfilled obligations toward Greece and the Greek people are fulfilled,” he added. “You cannot pick and choose on ethical issues.”

Tsipras noted that Germany got support “despite the crimes of the Third Reich” chiefly thanks to the London Debt Agreement of 1953. Since reunification, German governments have used “silence, legal tricks and delays” to avoid solving the problem, he said. “We are not giving morality lessons but we will not accept morality lessons either,” Tsipras said.

Updated

The euro falls further

The euro is now down more than 1% against the dollar at €1.0572. That’s the lowest since April 2003.

It was as low as €1.0561 earlier this morning.

The euro has also hit a seven-year low against the pound, at 70.14p.

Greece sells €1.3bn of T-bills

Greece has successfully sold €1.3bn of Treasury bills, covering the amount it needed to refinance a maturing issue.

The issue was more costly for the government however, with the paper sold at a yield of 2.7%, up from the 2.5% yield at a previous sale in February.

From Reuters:

Issuing short-term T-bills is the only source of commercial borrowing for the leftist government of Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras. The country’s EU/IMF creditors have set a 15 billion euro cap on such issues, which has already been hit.

Athens has asked for the ceiling on outstanding T-bills to be raised as foreign investors have increasingly fled its sales in recent months, but its euro zone partners have refused on fears it would be tantamount to central bank financing of governments.

We are hearing that the Troika’s meeting with Greek officials has indeed been delayed and that representatives from the ECB, IMF and EC will arrive in Athens tomorrow - a day later than expected.

It is not clear why.

More if and when we get it.

An update from Athens. Confusion reigns over whether the troika - ECB, IMF and EC - are meeting Greek officials today or not.

That was the expectation at the conclusion of the eurogroup meeting of finance ministers on Monday, but there has been no information as yet today. We have put in calls and will keep you updated.

Meanwhile, the Guardian’s correspondent in Athens, Helena Smith, brings us this report on the subject.

Officials in Athens are saying it is not at all clear when international auditors representing Greece’s creditors will descend on the capital.

Officials in prime minister Alexis Tsipras’ anti-austerity government are suggesting that it had still not been decided when inspectors will arrive.

Speaking on local radio this morning, alternate economics minister Dimitris Mardas indicated they would not fly into Greece until Thursday. “If it is agreed they will come tomorrow, we are ready,” he said.

But Mardas, who is responsible for revenue collection, ruled out the inspection review resembling anything from the past. “Lets emphasise what won’t happen. What won’t happen is the hauling from ministry to ministry by the threesome that we saw in the past. We are not going to see various ministers running behind the troika. That is over.”

Tsipras is facing considerable - and growing discontent – from the far-left faction of his Syriza group.

Updated

The Treasury has responded to the disappointing UK industrial production/manufacturing figures.

A spokeswoman emphasises the quarterly figures, which paint a more picture - industrial production up 1.1% and manufacturing up 2.6%.

She said:

Today’s figures from the ONS show manufacturing output grew by 2.6% in the three months to January compared to a year ago.

The UK has seen the fastest growth in the G7 but is not immune to the risks facing the global economy.

The job is not yet done and all of the progress we have made will be at risk unless we carry on working through the long term economic plan which is delivering economic security.

So nothing new in the well-rehearsed lines there.

UK industrial production falls unexpectedly

UK industrial production and manufacturing both fell unexpectedly in January according to the latest figures published by the Office for National Statistics.

Industrial production fell by 0.1% over the month, dragged down by manufacturing output which fell 0.5%.

Economists had forecast growth of 0.2% for both.

The main reason for the falls appears to be a decline in computers and other electronic products.

On an annual basis, industrial production increased by 1.3%, while manufacturing output was up 1.9%.

The reason why industrial production didn’t fall further was a 2% rise in mining and quarrying over the month of January. It followed a 1.4% fall in December, and the ONS said January’s increased appeared to be driven by a rebound in oil and gas extraction in the north sea.

Christian Schulz, senior economist at German bank Berenberg, said the figures suggested British industry “had a subdued start into the new year”:

The volatile monthly changes should not be over-interpreted, but with German manufacturing flat and French manufacturing down only marginally in January, we cannot exclude that sterling’s current strength against the euro may hurt the export-dependent sector.

While UK manufacturing output should be relatively price-insensitive, the pound’s rise by 11% against the euro since December could become a significant head-wind for market share and profitability for UK producers in Europe in the near-term.

At this early stage, the disappointing January industrial output data puts only a very minor downside risk to our call for strengthening UK GDP growth in Q1 (to 0.8% quarter-on-quarter from 0.5% quarter-on-quarter in Q4).

How low can the euro go against the dollar?

Michael Hewson, chief market analyst at CMC Markets, says its looking like parity.

Few would have imagined in May last year when EURUSD was trading just shy of 1.4000 that nearly 10 months later the currency would have slid nearly 35% to be trading just short of 1.0700 with the potential to go even lower.

A good part of this move lower has occurred in the past three months sliding from 1.2480 at the beginning of December, as currency markets bet on the fact that the European Central Bank would finally pull the trigger on a large scale easing (QE) program.

Six years to the day from when the Federal Reserve started its bond buying program in 2009 the ECB finally pulled the trigger on its highly flagged stimulus program, putting aside the legal niceties that buying bonds with a negative yield surely has to be construed as monetary financing.

The weakness in the euro has been compounded by the fact that the US economy shows continued signs of an improvement, with the possibility that after last week’s stellar jobs numbers, that next week’s FOMC meeting could well see the removal of the word “patience” from the Fed’s statement with respect to the timing of a rate hike.

This would be important given that markets have inferred from previous comments made by Fed Chair Janet Yellen that the removal of the language of patience could suggest the prospect of a rate hike within the timeframe of the next two meetings.

For now the euro looks to be headed towards parity. The next target sits at 1.0500 (the March 2003 lows) and it remains a very short hop from there to parity.

Updated

ECB's Draghi: QE is already working

Mario Draghi, president of the European Central Bank is oozing optimism at a conference in Frankfurt.

His view is that the ECB’s €1.1 trillion programme of quantitative easing - with bond purchases starting two days ago - may already be protecting eurozone countries from the Greek crisis.

We saw a further fall in the sovereign yields of Portugal and other formerly distressed countries in spite of the renewed Greek crisis.

This suggests that the asset purchase programme may be shielding euro area countries from contagion.

We are aware that our measure may entail some financial stability risks but currently these risks are contained.

Other points made by Draghi:

  • The slowdown in eurozone growth has reversed
  • Economic recovery should gradually broaden and hopefully strengthen
  • Upwardly revised ECB forecasts are conditional upon the full implementation of all the Bank’s announced measures
  • We are deploying monetary policy in a way that will stabilise inflation
  • There is good reason to believe that as our balance sheet expands, it will support a rebound in inflation expectations

Euro falls to fresh 12-year low

The euro has hit another 12-year low against this morning, falling to $1.0640. It has fallen 12% since the beginning of 2015, and 35% since last May.

It is a story of dollar strength as well as euro weakness, as the US Federal Reserve moves closer towards an interest rate rise while at the opposite end of the scale, the European Central Bank is injecting €1.1 trillion into the financial system through quantitative easing.

Parity here we come?

The euro is also down 0.3% against the yen, at 129.12 yen, the lowest since mid 2013.

European markets open slightly up

Following yesterday’s sharp sell off, led by the FTSE 100 which closed down 2.5% or 174 points at 6,702.84, European markets are slightly up in early trading.

It’s hardly a major rebound though, as those weak China numbers and an uncertain future for Greece weigh on confidence.

  • FTSE 100: +0.4% at 6,729.94
  • Germany’s DAX: +0.3% at 11,539.55
  • France’s CAC: +0.6% at 4,909.12
  • Italy’s FTSE MIB: +0.8% at 22,518.86
  • Spain’s IBEX: +0.6% at 10,964.5

Weak China data raise slowdown fears

Fears over a sharper-than-expected slowdown in China were raised overnight following a slew of weak data from the national statistics bureau.

Industrial output grew 6.8% over the first two months of the year, compared with the same period last year, disappointing expectations of a 7.8% increase and the weakest rate of growth since late 2008.

Retail sales also disappointed over January and February, with growth of 10.7% the weakest in a decade and weaker than the 11.7% increase forecast by economists.

And finally, investment - a crucial indicator of the health of the Chinese economy - increased by 13.9%. It was the weakest growth since 2001, and came in below expectations of a 15% rise.

Julian Evans-Pritchard, China economist at Capital Economics:

Today’s activity data have put pay to our expectation that GDP growth would strengthened slightly in Q1, with a slowdown now looking more likely.

Overall, the weakness in today’s figures is surprising given that a sharp slowdown in Q1 of last year will have provided a flattering base for comparison.

The upshot is that economic momentum appears markedly weaker than suggested by the recent recovery in export growth and PMI readings. As such, a further slowdown in GDP growth in this quarter now looks likely.

Greece opens its doors to lenders, China disappoints

A Greek and a European Union flag wave across Acropolis hill, in Athens, Greece, on 3 March 2015.
A Greek and a European Union flag wave across Acropolis hill, in Athens, Greece, on 3 March 2015. Photograph: Orestis Panagiotou/EPA

Good morning, and welcome to our rolling coverage of the world economy, the financial markets, the eurozone and business.

Markets fells sharply as a combination of factors weighed heavily on investor minds on both sides of the Atlantic.

The euro fell to a 12-year low against the dollar, largely as fears over Greece’s future persisted. Dollar strength and fears over China meanwhile weighed on commodity prices, pushing the value of energy companies lower.

Overnight China gave investors more reason to be fearful, with data on factory output, retail sales, and investment disappointing expectations and raising concerns over a sharp slowdown in the world’s second largest economy. More on that soon.

The other major event on the agenda today is Greece’s meeting with its creditors. Greek officials will meet with representatives from the European Central Bank, European commission, and the International Monetary Fund in Brussels and in Athens. The aim of the meeting is to make progress on Greek reforms so that a loan instalment can be released before Greece runs out of money.

We will bring you all the latest developments.

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*