Will.i.am tells Davos about growing up poor
And finally, here’s Jill Treanor with the full story of will.i.am’s trip to WEF:
William Adams, better known as will.i.am, has come to Davos after being named as one of the young global leaders by the World Economic Forum where the subject of inequality has been high on the agenda.
Oxfam used the event to highlight that top 1% will control more wealth than the remaining 99% by next year.The singer producer, entrepreneur and judge on BBC1’s the voice has been asked about what it like to be rich. He said
“I remember what it feels like to stand in the welfare line”.
”I never really looked at myself as a 1% because I was always poor. I need to go back and tell kids in the neighbourhood that what they tell you on the news about the 1% is that there’s not like a wall there that you can’t be part of it,”.
He said that while some companies “don’t give a shit about anybody” there were some that did.
“There’s a lot of companies that care, there’s a lot of billionaires that care, there’s a lot of opportunities to go from here to there”.
He came to Davos, he said, to give his perspective on the balance between the private sector and public sector. The 39-year-old backs the i.am.Angel foundation which provides scholarships and mentoring for school children.
“There’s a private sector for prisons but not for education....there’s an imbalance between opportunities in inner cities around computer science engineers, mathematics and prisons. I hurts my heart and my soul that there is such a thing as private investment angle in prisons in America and not education. It’s a human rights issue”.
And that’s time to wrap up for the day. We’ll be back tomorrow for the final day of WEF. Thanks and goodnight. GW
Events at Davos have concluded with a press conference with William Adams, known to millions as will.i.am.
The singer, song-writer, producer and philanthropist was discussing his charitable work. He’s been in Davos this week, lobbying business leaders about the importance of training young people.
Finishing up my #wef15 interviews at davos pic.twitter.com/O56O7ZXdqi
— will.i.am (@iamwill) January 23, 2015
We’ll have the full story shortly....
The US State Department has confirmed what John Kerry told Davos earlier - that he will be visiting Nigeria, on Sunday.
He’ll be meeting the current leader, Goodluck Jonathan, and his rival -- and former head of state -- Muhammadu Buhari.
State Dep says Kerry in Nigeria on Sunday to meet both with President Goodluck Jonathan and opponent Muhammadu Buhari.
— Jasper Wenban-Smith (@JWenbanSmith) January 23, 2015
The New York Times reported today that the rise of Boko Haram is driving voters to support Buhari:
Boisterous crowds packed the streets for the retired general, while young men climbed lampposts, walls and billboards to glimpse his gaunt face. Others danced on careening motorcycles, brandishing homemade brooms, symbols of his campaign.
With Nigeria’s presidential election only weeks away, Boko Haram’s unchecked rampaging here in the country’s north is helping to propel the 72-year-old general, Muhammadu Buhari, to the forefront......
To Loosen Boko Haram’s Grip, Nigerian Voters Look to Ex-Leader Who Ruled With Iron Hand
Smartphones can also empower women in the developing world, Melinda adds. First because they can be cheaper to run than old plastic phones, and second because if their husband is working in another town he can send money to her electronically.
Updated
Is it better to give financial support to women rather than men in the developing world?
Melinda Gates says it is:
Research suggest that for every marginal dollar you give a woman she’s 90% likely to plough it back into her family. So if you empower that woman, you empower everything else.
There are three priorities, giving a woman access to health care, decision-making powers in her household, and economic opportunity.
Education is also crucial. Research shows that, for an educated woman in the developing world, there is 50% more chance that their child survives the early years and it’s twice as likely that she’ll educated her daughter.
There’s then a cringe-worthy moment as the moderator asks whether the Gates’ share their economic resources. Joint cheque book, guys? Bill and Melinda let it go.
Melinda Gates is explaining how progress has been made in vaccine to reduce deaths from diarrhea, pneumonia, etc. A package of vaccines costing $30 can protect a child from a group of diseases, and underpin the local health system.
Rwanda has the biggest drop in childhood mortality in the history of the world, she adds, because of its vaccination programme.
Bill chips in too – explaing how technology is helping too. Vaccines are being shipped in specially designed thermoses so they are kept cool enough until they reach patients.
There’s a couple of events still happening in Davos tonight, including Bill and Melinda Gates discussing Sustainable Development Goals. Here’s a feed:
John Kerry demands renewed fight against terrorism
That was quite a speech from John Kerry, desperately depressing in parts too, when he touched on the way young people are suffering from religious extremism (highlights start here)
The broad pitch to Davos, and the watching world, was for a new long-term global commitment to fighting the conditions that allowed Daesh/ISIS, Boko Haram et al to thrive, as well as these terror groups themselves.
By targeting the ‘very environments from which these movements grow”, Kerry has set the tone of the debate ahead of the White House conference next month.
And you couldn’t accuse Kerry of holding back, when he described terror groups as “a form of criminal anarchy, a nihilism, which illegitimately claims an ideological & religious foundation.”
There was also a welcome acknowledgement that economic inequality is another factor driving extremism - shared prosperity can help push it back.
.@JohnKerry, US Secretary of State, on the need for shared prosperity #equalgrowth #wef15 http://t.co/mJX3497lqv https://t.co/aaRUTuAlOk
— World Economic Forum (@wef) January 23, 2015
And he also emphasised that winning will be expensive.
So, stirring talk, but was there much action?
Well, Kerry set ejecting Daesh, the Islamic extremists holding parts of Iraq, as a key priority.
At @wef in Davos, @JohnKerry refers to ISIL as Daesh; calls it "a collection of monsters" from which civilized world "will not cower."
— Mark Knoller (@markknoller) January 23, 2015
And it’s also significant that he will be heading to Nigeria soon; elections are taking place next month, under the shadow of the Boko Haram uprising.
I will tweet the entire speech momentarily but John Kerry also announced he is traveling to Nigeria. #Davos
— Katie Couric (@katiecouric) January 23, 2015
Thirdly, Kerry also made a determined effort not to label all extremists as “Islamic”, telling Davos that it is wrong to blame Muslims generally for the crimes and massacres being perpetrated.
In Davos, John Kerry made an explicit case for not using the term "Islamic" extremism.
— Ken Dilanian (@KenDilanianAP) January 23, 2015
John Kerry: It's our turn to uphold values of freedom
Rounding up, secretary of state Kerry returns to the Nigerian girl and Syrian boy who chose live over death when choosing not to blow themselves and others up.
We must follow their example, he says, and take the steps he’s outlined in this speech.
And he reiterates that he remains optimistic. Some people say the entire system is unravelling. I see just the opposite - countries are negotiating trade deals, fighting ebola, helping Ukraine, moving towards a climate change deal.
We have fought harder fights before, and won, Kerry declares.
We are the descendants of those who survives plague, tyranny, the Holocaust. Now it’s our turn to stand up for our values and the rule of law, and take the images of Paris and Peshawar in our hearts.
And with that, Kerry gets a somewhat louder and longer round of applause than the other speakers I’ve caught this week.
John #Kerry in #Davos: ungoverned spaces are open doors to chaos. Good governance is a lasting response to terrorism. pic.twitter.com/awbaU1dvIN
— Espen Barth Eide (@EspenBarthEide) January 23, 2015
Fighting inequality is another crucial step, says Kerry. Vital to increase education opportunities for girls around the world, and to address youth unemployment.
We can move from talk to action at the White House summit in February, says Kerry.
And it will be expensive. Just like the Second World War was.
We have spent trillions in Iraq in the decade since we went to war there, Kerry says. And he adds:
Just imagine if we’d saved trillions in a battle we didn’t have to fight for one we have to fight.
Speaking at the @wef in Davos today, US Secretary of State John Kerry said he plans to travel to #Nigeria in a few days.
— Vladimir Duthiers (@vladduthiersCBS) January 23, 2015
Kerry has, appropriately, mentioned Nigeria twice in first 5min of his #Davos address. Stark contrast to Obama's #SOTU, with 0 mentions.
— ian bremmer (@ianbremmer) January 23, 2015
Hard truth is that too many people in too many places feel trapped, says John Kerry.
And he sums up how this can lead them to extremism. As one person put it to Kerry’s State Department:
The terrorists oppress us, the police rob us, the government ignores us and the west doesn’t acknowledge us or wants to kill us
Only a long-term, comprehensive approach can stop these extremist groups growing. Military action is only part of the solution.
Kerry explains how groups start by paying young people a little to join them, then brainwash them, then send them our to recruit others.
This fight will not be decided on the battlefield, but in the classrooms, workplaces, places of worship of the world.
Kerry concedes that it is hard to make thrilling films about the merits of parliamentary democracy or effective public services.
But, exciting or not, uncoverned or undergoverned places become a breeding ground for terrorism.
And weak governments, who cannot rule effectively or who are so corrupt that they attract fighters determined to eject them, are another part of the problem.
But it’s about more than the Middle East, Kerry says, citing Yemen and Nigeria as other countries suffering from extremism,
There is nowhere you can leave as an ungoverned state. And there is no place for negotiation.
Eliminating the terrorists who confront us today is only part of the solution to stopping the endless cycle.
Freeing Iraq from its Daesh occupiers are the crucial first step in winning the war against extremism, Kerry says.
He’s running through recent successes - military attacks and clampdown on their finances.
After years of delay, Baghdad recently agreed oil supply deals, and its army is strengthening.
But this success is not irreversible. The momentum has been slowed, but not stopped.
Updated
The worst thing we could do to address the rise of Islamic extremism would be to blame all Muslims for these crimes, Kerry says.
We are making strides against extremism, Kerry pledges.
Like those who marcher in Paris, we must act as one.
Kerry tells another awful story, of the Peshawar school massacre where attackers slaughted a class of young children.
In minutes, a scene of peace and education turned into death and destruction, with”small lifeless bodies” littering the ground.
And when their teacher returned, and was challenged by the assassins, she said I am their mother. That was her last words, Kerry says.
There are no rounds of history, religion, politics, economic disadvantage or personal ambition that caa defend the slaughter of children. None.
<Applause from the audience>
We cannot stop violent extremism without understanding what’s driving it, Kerry tells Davos.
We can’t change minds without knowing what’s in them ,
Despite the conflict in the world, I remain optimistic, says Kerry. Then he runs through a terrible list of examples of the state of the world today:
He cites a 14 year old Nigerian girl discovered in a crowded marketplace, with explosives strapped to body - but she refused to pull the tab, saving her life and others.
Another potential suicide bomber, a Syrian boy, showed security guards he had a bomb tied to him but he didn’t want to die. A third escaped from religious extremists, after finding the promises made to him were false.
Those three examples represent the most basic choice - between death and life, between destroying and building.
Kerry also cites Boko Haran videos have shown fighters saying shootings and violence will be their religion.
Updated
John Kerry begin by saying he was saddened to hear of the death of Saudi King Abdullah, who died overnight.
He played an important role in the fight against extremism, Kerry says. Will miss his partnership and friendship.
John Kerry is starting to address Davos. Liveblog http://t.co/kvSvYgqf48 pic.twitter.com/dEWGw8Q9dS
— Graeme Wearden (@graemewearden) January 23, 2015
Coming up... US secretary of state John Kerry is due to give a special address to Davos....
Back in the financial world, US stock markets have opened lower. No eurozone QE boost across the Atlantic today.
Poor company results appear to be behind the falls. Fast-food chain McDonald’s said sales in 2014 dropped by 7% and annual profits plunged by 15%.
- Dow Jones: -0.3% at 17,760.52
- S&P 500: -0.1% at 2,060.73
Summary: Hollande calls on business to fight terrorism and climate change
French president Francois Hollande has called on business leaders attending the World Economic Forum in Davos to help fight terrorism.
Speaking some two weeks after the Paris attacks that gripped the world and mobilised France, Hollande said the financial world could help by choking off the illegal trafficking mechanisms used to fund terror networks
I call on the financial system to ensure that the sources of terrorist funding are dried up. That we fight tax evasion and money-laundering.
Don’t leave it too late.
The fight against terrorism must be global, he added, divided between states and companies, especially large ones, who must do what they can, he added.
Hollande calls on financial system to help efforts to cut off terrorists from their money and stop money laundering #wef15 #GNatDavos
— Francis Matthew (@FrancisMatthew1) January 23, 2015
In a wide-ranging speech, the French president hailed the support shown by the world since the Charlie Hebdo and grocery store attacks.
France, he said, would be at the forefront of the terrorism fight – reiterating his earlier pledge on this issue. Prosperity and security are interlinked.
Climate change also featured in his speech; the challenge of the 21st century, as he called it. Hollande tried to bolster support for December’s Climate Conference in Paris, warning that businesses must help provide the funding to break the world’s dependency on fossil fuels.
We cannot treat the earth as a commodity any more, he argued
On economics, I fear Hollande’s speech may not have pleased viewers in Berlin. He welcomed the ECB’s new stimulus package, arguing that it gives flexibility for a new approach on growth. Germany’s fear that eurozone members will slacken up on economic reforms may have been fanned.....
And curiously, Hollande argued that the $1.1trn QE programme announced yesterday is a sign of ECB success in repressing inflation, rather than a response to the threat of deflation.....
Frances O’Grady, the TUC’s general secretary, is not impressed with George Osborne’s earlier performance at Davos, describing the Chancellor as complacent.
George Osborne’s complacency in Davos about the state of the British economy may come back to haunt him.
His remarks were notable for what he left out, rather than what he said. He failed to address the plain need for investment to shore up the real economy or to create the skilled, well-paid jobs young people in particular need.
And he did not even mention the need to ensure that the rewards of growth are shared more fairly if Britain’s economy is to become sustainable. George Soros may now recognise the need for inclusive growth to tackle inequality. The other George apparently does not.
AM
Front row seat for #Davos "Recharging Europe" session. A little more diversity might help us find the real answers? pic.twitter.com/7hZNUre0z1
— Frances O'Grady (@FrancesOGrady) January 23, 2015
That was a powerful speech, I enjoyed it, says one delegate as we squeeze our way out of the hall.
Hollande wraps up by repeating his earlier point that business and politicians must work together to fight climate change. And that’s the end. Warm applause, but unfortunately no Q&A session. Summary to follow.
Hollande: We cannot accept attacks on people for their faiths
The French president returns to the Paris attacks earlier this week.
We cannot accept attacks on Jews because they are Jews, or attacks on Muslims because they are Muslims.
There is no greater pride for the president of the French Republic than to see the world offer its support, he continues. So many world leaders standing with us.
Surely only in France would we se so many people on the streets...four million people...not demonstrating against something but in favour of how France is today.
France must also be a major economic power - no political power without economic power. So the economy must be a major factor in security.
There cannot be prosperity without security. So we have shared interest, and show responsibility.
The economy is not there just to create wealth but to redistribute wealth, he insists. That’s rather socialist for Davos....
Updated
Hollande backs eurozone QE
President Hollande has welcomed the European Central Bank’s new quantitative easing programme, but I’m not sure he’s quite grasped why it happened.
The new stimulus programme is a “very important step to inject liquidity into the markets” he says.
And the European Central Bank can do it because it has achieved its objective of limiting inflation.
With inflation close to zero it can make more money available
[Up to a point.... the ECB’s target is actually inflation just below 2%, not -0.2%. And it is the threat of deflation that forced the ECB’s hand]
Anyway, Hollande’s view is that the ECB”s huge money-printing scheme “compels” Europe to be more daring as it reduces the barriers to growth and unemployment.
And he says France will make structural reforms, with more incentive to create competition and labour market reforms.
Inequality between countries and within countries is the biggest problem facing the global economy today.
We need investment in infrastructure....Europe must not lag behind. He welcomes Jean-Claude Juncker’s investment plan.
Onto economics, and Hollande makes two indisputable points - growth is too low and unemployment is too high (both particularly in France, of course)
Ukraine, and the Middle East crisis, are weighing on confidence and growth.
Fighting global warming is going to be expensive, Hollande warns, and businesses will have to share the cost.
We need to find €90bn for a Green Fund, that will ensure global temperatures only rise by 2 degrees this decade.
And he’s now calling for a huge investment in Green technologies to create a Green economy.
Businesses need a predictable carbon price if they are to plan ahead, Hollande points out (two years ago, Europe’s carbon pricing scheme hit serious problems)
Hollande: Climate change is the challenge of the century
Hollande turns to climate, declaring that “We need to fight global warning. “
It is vital that December’s Climate conference in Paris delivers an agreement to fight climate change.
This is the major challenge of the 21st century. The time is past when human kind thought it could draw on unlimited resources.
The Earth is not a commodity, a source of revenue. It is a shared asset we must protect and care for.
We’re heading into a post-carbon world where we cannot keep relying on fossil fuels....
Speaking directly to the delegates at Davos, Hollande urges these business leaders to help.
I call on the financial system to ensure that the sources of terrorist funding are dried up. That we fight tax evasions and money-laundering. Don’t leave it too late.
And I call on all business to help the most fragile states, in a spirit of solidarity.
Terrorism is global and can affect any country, they are using the Internet as a weapon . President Hollande @Davos pic.twitter.com/a2ajMFAUrj
— Carlos Creus Moreira (@carloscmoreira) January 23, 2015
France has values that we want to share with the whole world, Hollande says.
To do that, we must fight the illicit flows which are funding terrorism.
Europe must strengthen border controls, to identify terrorists. We need a passenger identity register to protect our future.
Must make sure Internet is not used for hatred and violence, Must invest in cyber defence.
Hollande: France will lead fight against terrorism
Businesses, including the largest corporations, also have a responsibility to act to fight terrorism, he explains.
France has waited too long to address the causes of terrorism, he says.
France is in a broad coalition to support those in Iraq who are in the front line against ISIS.
We will on the ground more than ever in Africa to help...France cannot do everything, France cannot act alone.
Wherever it can do, it will. But we need international co-operations.
Hollande cites militant Islam, Al-Queda, Boko Haram, as terrorist threats.
Terrorism fuels itself through all kinds of illicit trafficking - drugs, weapons, human beings.
The internet is being used as a weapon by terrorists, he says.
Hollande: terrorism uses all the technologies available to it, even those which can be used for prosperity - ie the internet
— Tony Connelly (@tconnellyRTE) January 23, 2015
Hollande begins by passing on his own condolences to the Saudi Royal Family.
And then he moves onto the Paris terrorist attacks.
For three days, we faced with dignity a huge challenge. The rest of Europe fully understood what was at stake.
Freedom, liberty, the very foundations of our society were under attack. All countries in the world are vulnerable to terrorism. We must all prepare, because our main duty is to provide clarity and clear mindedness.
And we’re off. Davos founder Klaus Schwab is introducing president Hollande now.
I was incredibly impressed by the exemplary response and solidarity of the French people to the Paris terrorist attacks, Schwab says.
Europe needs a strong and confident France as it looks for a path to growth, and offers opportunities to all. One lesson of Paris attacks is that we must support the weakest and youngest who can otherwise fall into the hands of those who want to cause chaos and harm.
Finally, Schwab reminds us that there is a crucial Climate Change conference in Paris in December.
Coming next..... Francois Hollande’s special address to Davos. The main hall has filled up ready.
It was supposed to start 10 minutes ago, having been rescheduled from this morning after the King of Jordan cancelled his appearance and flew home following the deal of Saudi King Abdullah.
The video of Emma Watson’s appearance at a Davos breakfast event this morning is available.
She was speaking about gender inequality in her capacity as a goodwill ambassador for UN Women. AM
The business blog’s very own Graeme Wearden has emerged from the main conference centre in Davos to capture a snap of this piper.
As the Guardian’s Jill Treanor reported earlier in our Davos diary:
A light shower of snow is falling on Davos at the start of the third day of the annual World Economic Forum, so spare a thought for the piper outside the “chalet” occupied by Aberdeen Asset Management, just along from the Belvedere. Chilly business.
AM
QE delivers Greek boost ahead of election
Greek shares are leading European stock markets higher following Thursday’s big quantitative easing unveil.
The huge dose of medicine for the eurozone’s sickly economy has put European shares on course for their biggest weekly gain in more than three years.
The FTSE 100 is also heading for its biggest weekly rise in more than three years (although it is currently underperforming other indices, up just 0.2% on the day).
The Greek ATG share index is up almost 6%, with shares in Attica Bank, National Bank of Greece, and Piraeus Bank up sharply.
Greece will be eligible for the ECB’s bond-buying programme, but subject to stricter conditions because of its EU/IMF bailout arrangements.
Traders appear to be shrugging off the potential impact of a Syriza victory at Sunday’s Greek election. It seems they are hopeful that the radical left, anti-austerity party would be willing to reach a compromise with the country’s lenders if they win, rather than lead Greece out of the euro altogether.
The panel ends with two points on currencies.
Osborne tries to calm fears that UK exporters will suffer from the weaker euro:
It is in the UK's interests that our friends on the continent do well, says @George_Osborne , when asked about weaker € vs £
— Graeme Wearden (@graemewearden) January 23, 2015
While George Soros, the billionaire who knows the currency markets like the back of his limo, says the breaking of the Swiss franc peg against the euro was inevitable.
Indeed, he’d have predicted it if he was still in the money-making game.
Switzerland now faces an uncompetitive currency and a slowing economy.
And that’s the end of the session on Europe’s future (highlights start here)
George Osborne rarely lets a chance for political point-scoring go past.
Asked about the rise of non-mainstream political parties, Osborne says it’s Labour’s fault.
A political system is a reflection of hopes and fears of the people in the country, Labour has not provided an answer to the tough decisions we’ve taken, so people who are unhappy are looking to other parties.
But when it comes to a general election, people move back to mainstream parties who they trust, he added.
Updated
Back to George Soros, who urges Europe to give Ukraine more financial support to cope with the violence in its eastern regions.
Europe is not sufficiently aware of the danger posed by a resurgent Russia, he says..... there is an assault on the very foundations of the values that Europe is based on.
Schauble: No QE help for Greece without reform programme
Greece cannot get help from Europe’s new QE scheme unless it is in a reform programme, German finance minister Wolfgang Schauble declares.
Asked about Sunday’s general election, he says he will wait for the Greek people to decide who should govern them. But I’ve seen two Greek elections (in 2012) where the people decided to stick with what has to be done, he says.
Unlike many economists, Schauble is not recognising that Greece’s debts may be so high that a restructuring is inevitable.
Schauble also denies that Greece’s current plight is the fault of Europe, or Brussels, or Berlin.
The reason for the problems of the Greek people are the mistake in the past.
But what about the claim by opposition leader Alexis Tsipras that Greece is being subjected to “fiscal waterboarding”?
That is political campaigning, Schauble replies. You can like it or not like it. I don’t like it.
@TradeDesk_Steve I think the people of Greece are going to tell Herr Schauble exactly where he can stick his programs.
— Paul Kingsley (@PaulKingsley16) January 23, 2015
Wolfgang Schauble is challenged about a report in the Der Spiegel newspaper that Angela Merkel has looked at a plan for Greece to leave the eurozone.
Schauble tried to sweep it aside:
If I cared about what was in the media I would never get by job done in 48 hours a day.
Pressed on this, he replies: We don’t model any exit.
Have struggling Eurozone countries done enough to persuade German taxpayers to show solidarity?
Spanish finance minister Luis de Guindos says that Europe has loaned €210bn to Greece, including €26bn from Spain.
Our exposure to Greece is €26bn. As much as our bill on unemployment benefits.
Solidarity between European countries is there.
In good times you should run budget surpluses to bring your #debt down - @George_Osborne #globaltrade #wef15 http://t.co/Np1i6UTn6K
— World Economic Forum (@Davos) January 23, 2015
Osborne: UK deficit is still too high
“I agree with Wolfgang”, says George Osborne. Credibility in the markets comes from fiscal responsibility.
The finances of several European countries are not on a strong enough footing, Osborne says.
Britain’s deficit has now been halved to 5% of GDP on his watch, but it’s still too high. So it would be a mistake to risk financial credibility by raising spending, he argues.
(Fact Check: in cash terms, Britain’s deficit has only been cut by around a third, from £150bn to £90bn)
Schauble hits back at George Soros, saying that HE knows more about the German budgets than the billionaire philanthropist.
Germany is committed to meeting European rules on budgets, he says, so it is running a budget surplus. Other countries aren’t taking these rules seriously.
Ouch! I don't know if George Soros is the best authority on German policy... says Finance Minister Schauble #wef15 pic.twitter.com/DA4gOoTaAf
— Katy Barnato (@KatyBarnato) January 23, 2015
Back to George Soros, who makes a plea to Europe to use its credit in the markets to fund a large infrastructure project.
At current low borrowing costs, you could create employment, grow economies, and the value of the euro would appreciate.
Germany would benefit too, he says, citing a new port which has potholes in the road leading up to it.
Nice quote from Spanish finance minister, Luis de Guindos.
Deflation is like cholesterol, he tells Davos. There’s a good type and a bad type. We currently have the good sort in Spain, as falling prices are giving households more spending power.
A quick show of hands shows a massive majority for Britain staying in the EU rather than leaving.
George Osborne appeared to abstain, though -- repeating that he wants the UK to stay in Europe once its relationship with the EU is reformed.
UK's Osborne: We want to be in a reformed EU. 1) Europe needs eco reform 2) UK 2nd lrgst Europe econ. Not joining €. But must be respected
— Louisa Bojesen (@louisabojesen) January 23, 2015
Osborne also welcomes the new eurozone quantitative easing programme, but adds that it’s not enough - need structural reforms are needed too.
Osborne: Euro countries who haven't reformed are being punished
Now George Osborne is speaking. He starts by joking that fellow panelist George Soros taught Britain at if you peg your currency against others then “you open up a heap of trouble.”
Europe must create jobs, and reform, the UK chancellor says. He pays credit to Spain.
There are example of countries who have taken reforms and benefitted, and some who have not taken action and are being punished.
So are you for being in Europe, or Out, Mr Osborne?
The chancellor replies that he wants to be in a reformed Europe.
Was it more important to preserve ECB independence than to listen to German concerns over QE?
Wolfgang Schauble says he never comments on ECB policy.... but the German finance minister does flag up that there is a risk of moral hazard.
He ducks a question on whether Germany will be covering the debts of other nations now.
What about the negative reaction in the German papers?
I have read it, yes, Schauble replies. But I will not play your game (by commenting on it).
Updated
Soros: ECB QE will widen gap between rich and poor
George Soros says his main concern is that the ECB’s new quantitative easing programme will actually widen the divergence between rich and poor.
He tells the panel on Europe’s future that:
It will benefit the owners of assets. Wages will remain under pressure, through competition and unemployment.
This will reinforce a major concern between rich and poor. It will have political consequences.
Soros predicts some “fairly substantial moves coming” in the market -- he won’t be taking advantage though; the man who beat the Bank of England has retired from money making:
We need a better balance between fiscal and monetary policy.
Governor Visco is discussing the ECB’s new QE programme. He says it was important to have a consensus decision.
The size, composition, and timing are all crucial for QE.
He also says he’s confortable that 80% of the burden will fall on national central banks
Updated
Heads-up: the Davos debate on Recharging Europe, including George Osborne, Wolfgang Schauble, Luis de Guindos -- three of Europe’s most powerful finance ministers - is starting now.
George Soros is also on the panel, along with Italian central bank governor Ignazio Visco.
Live feed here:
Ignazio Visco, the governor of Italy’s central bank, has been discussing the European Central Bank’s €1.1tn QE injection into the eurozone economy.
Speaking in Davos, he suggested the €60bn a month bond-buying programme might continue beyond the provisional end date of the end of September 2016, should inflation fail to pick-up sufficiently.
The eurozone slipped into deflation in December, when prices fell by 0.2%. The ECB’s official target is for an inflation rate that is close to, but below, 2%.
Speaking to Bloomberg Television earlier, Visco said:
We are open-ended. That is, if we see that there are difficulties in achieving this target that we have, we have to continue.
He added that the element of risk-sharing involved in the programme was something eurozone members could build on.
We are a union, we have to trust each other and we have to build trust. But we are not a fiscal union. We have to build on this, it is a good starting point.
AM
The Bank of Japan governor, Haruhiko Kuroda, is not worried that diverging paths taken by central banks in the US and Europe will hamper his efforts to fight deflation at home.
In an interview with Bloomberg TV at Davos, Kuroda welcomed the ECB’s decision on Thursday to launch a €1.1trn bond-buying programme.
I don’t think it makes our job more difficult.
He said the euro had not fallen very much against the yen in the wake of the ECB move, and noted that the euro had already weakened previously.
The US Federal Reserve is expected to lift interest rates this year after ending quantitative easing last October. Kuroda said this expected “normalisation” of policy reflects strong US growth, which is good for the world economy.
Back in Davos, economist Nouriel Roubini has been warning developing countries to press on with economic reforms before financial turbulence increases:
When times were good many emerging markets moved away from structural reform: @Nouriel #wef15 #globaltrade http://t.co/L6c7gkfJbl
— World Economic Forum (@Davos) January 23, 2015
This is a time for doing these structural reforms: @Nouriel #wef15 #globaltrade http://t.co/3VyHFVqAN9
— World Economic Forum (@Davos) January 23, 2015
Yesterday, Christine Lagarde predicted volatility and spillover effects once the US starts to raise interest rates. That would probably pull some money out of the emerging markets.
Euro falls below 75p for first time in 7 years
On financial markets, the euro has fallen below 75p for the first time in seven years. It hit a low of 74.93p. The pound was boosted by the surprise rise in UK retail sales. The euro started sliding on Thursday after the ECB’s decision to unleash quantitative easing.
Shares are continuing their rally, after the ECB set out its bigger-than-expected bond buying programme. Germany’s Dax is more than 150 points ahead, a 1.45% gain, while France’s CAC is 75 points higher, or 1.65%.
The FTSEurofirst 300 index of top European shares has hit a seven-year peak, trading 1.7% higher at 1478.
Updated
In the UK, retail sales volumes grew by 0.4% last month from November, official figures showed. It was the weakest December performance for two years, but confounded fears of a 0.6% fall, with the Black Friday shopping bonanza bringing forward many pre-Christmas purchases into November.
The data was skewed by the fact that the US-inspired discount day was included in November’s figures for 2014, but within December’s data the year before.
Sales in the three months to December jumped 5% on a year earlier, the best performance in a decade. December was fuelled by supermarket sales and motorists taking advantage of cheaper petrol to fill up their tanks.
The European Union will discuss increasing emergency funding for Ukraine next week according to Reuters.
Aid could be increased to as much as €2.5bn, more than the €1.8bn already proposed by the European Commission, unnamed diplomats told Reuters.
EU finance ministers will consider proposals at their meeting in Brussels on Tuesday. The loans would be for this year and next, in three or more tranches.
Euro falls below $1.13 for first time since 2003
The fall-out from the ECB’s decision to launch quantitative easing in a bid to inject some life into the eurozone’s ailing economy continues.
The euro has been sliding since the announcement came on Thursday afternoon from the ECB’s President Mario Draghi, and is now $1.263. It is the first time below $1.13 since September 2003.
The single currency also fell to a 14-month low of 133.58 yen. AM
#Euro drops like a stone after #ECB's historic QE decision. Below $1.13 for 1st Time since Sep2003. pic.twitter.com/6GYSN4C5pU
— Holger Zschaepitz (@Schuldensuehner) January 23, 2015
The King of Jordan has cancelled his appearance at Davos today, following the death of Saudi King Abdullah.
Other Arab delegates also left Davos prematurely, ahead of the funeral of the Saudi king.
This means French president Francois Hollande will now speak at 2.15pm CET, not 11.30am as earlier planned.
Oil prices rise following Saudi King's death
Oil prices have risen this morning following the news that Saudi Arabia’s King Abdullah has died, aged 90.
Saudi Arabia is the world’s biggest exporter of oil.
Brent crude jumped $1.18 to $49.70 a barrel, a 2.4% gain, after the royal court announced the death. The US benchmark for March delivery rose $1.02, or 2.2%, to $47.33 a barrel.
My colleague, Julia Kollewe, reports that the uncertainty over what his death means for Saudi’s oil policy, is driving prices higher.
The 90-year-old monarch, who was admitted to hospital in December with pneumonia, has been succeeded by his half-brother, Crown Prince Salman. He vowed to maintain the same approach as his predecessors in a speech on Friday.
The key question is whether Salman, 79, keeps Ali al-Naimi as the country’s oil minister, a position he has held since 1995. Many analysts do not expect Saudi oil policy to change.
Oil prices have more than halved since the summer, when crude was more than $100 a barrel, amid an oil glut and weak global demand. A shale boom in the US has turned the US from the world’s biggest oil importer into a major producer, pumping over 9m barrels a day.
Saudi Arabia, the world’s biggest oil exporter, led a decision by the Organisation of the Petroleum Exporting Countries in November to keep the cartel’s production unchanged at 30m barrels a day.
Daniel Ang, an investment analyst at Phillip Futures in Singapore, said: “As we are uncertain of how the new king would react to the current supply glut, we believe that the market is pricing in this uncertainty causing prices to spike. However, this premium would likely only persist temporarily. This premium should wear off once the market is clear of the new king’s view on the oil situation.”
AM
Updated
Mark Carney challenges tech firms over tax
Technology firms are paying a very small rate of tax, Mark Carney has declared, at the end of the inequality debate.
The governor explained:
Some of the firms that take advantage of international tax system are tech firms.... a sense of responsibility is needed.
The amount of tax paid by technology companies is actually very small: Mark J. Carney #wef15 #equalgrowth http://t.co/q8GVuUrO0v
— World Economic Forum (@Davos) January 23, 2015
"The amt. of tax actually paid by technology companies is very small compared to the returns" -- #BankofEngand's Mark Carney at Davos.
— Eric Reguly (@ereguly) January 23, 2015
Markets rise sharply after Draghi pushes QE button
European markets are up sharply this morning.
Investors have a confident spring in their step this morning after Mario Draghi, President of the European Central Bank, announced a €1.1tn programme of eurozone quantitative easing on Thursday afternoon.
Fears over Sunday’s Greek election - and the uncertainty the outcome will bring - have been shrugged off.
- FTSE 100: +0.5 % at 6,833.47
- France’s CAC 40: +1.3% at 4,610.16
- Germany’s DAX: +1.3% at 10,567.39
- Spain’s IBEX: +1.3% at 10,645.3
- Italy’s FTSE MIB: +0.5% at 20,575.2
AM
Updated
US economist Bob Shiller, an expert on inequality, argues that the power of ‘civil society’ can keep the wealthiest in check, to a degree.
Winnie Byanyima is right about unequal power, he says, but the rich can be shamed out of pursuing it too much.
I think we should be happy that inequality is not worse, but Oxfam is going a good job in focusing attention on this problem.
Davos attendees think they are net contributors.
Evan Davies asks for a quick show of hands from the audience at the Davos debate on this question:
Are the net 0.1% richest people net contributors to the world, the “Steve Jobs” type, or net extractors who create very clever financial products and take out money?
And surprise, surprise.... there’s a flurry of hands that the richest are net contributor, by about eight votes to one.
Hardly a representative sample, of course.....
Emma Watson: what are YOU doing to address gender inequality?
Emma Watson, actress and campaigner for gender equality, has been speaking at a breakfast event in Davos.
Appearing in her capacity as a goodwill ambassador for UN Women (a United Nations organisation), Watson joined an illustrious panel, including UN secretary general Ban Ki-moon.
The purpose of Watson’s Davos trip was to launch a new one year pilot scheme - IMPACT 10X10X10 - as part of the UN’s HeForShe campaign. The aim is to engage governments, companies, and universities to be “instruments of change”.
Watson said she has been overwhelmed by the messages of support she has received since speaking at the launch of HeForShe in New York last September.
She says the campaign is about asking each and every person, what are you doing to reduce gender equality. HeForShe wants to hear about people’s experiences:
Girls - who have been your mentors?
Parents - did you make sure you treated your children equally?
Husbands - have you supported your wives’ aspirations?
Young men - have you spoken up for women casually taunted?
Media - have you thought about how women are portrayed publicly?
Chief executives - what are you doing in your organisations?
The “what now” is down to you. Decide your commitment, make it public, and please report back to us so we can support your story.
Watson says she’s had her “breath taken away” since her speech last September. One girl told her that it enable to escape the cycle of her father’s violence. The actress describes the drive for gender equality as “fertile ground”.
Women share this planet 50/50 and they are under represented, they are astonishingly untapped.
What is the impact you can have? What how when and with whom?
AM
Hello! Here taking questions on #Heforshe and #Impact10x10x10 here in #Davos. Send away! @UN_Women @HeforShe @e_nyamayaro @phumzileunwomen
— Emma Watson (@EmWatson) January 23, 2015
Updated
Lagarde reiterates that excessive inequality is bad for growth, and also points out that the wealthy have benefitted from the rise in asset prices since the financial crisis.
(that’s because of the stimulus packages run by central banks since Lehman Brothers)
Mark Carney, Bank of England governor, is making some important points about the causes of inequality.
1) Technological changes are driving down pay in some sectors
2) In a fully interconnected world, someone with very valuable skills can be very well rewarded.
Steve Jobs brilliance is applied globally, not locally.
Carney adds that the key challenge is to give equality of opportunity.
Some instant reaction to this inequality debate:
Debate the numbers all you want. People perceive the world as being unequal. Not solving it will spark social unrest. #BBCWorldDebate
— Eric Prenen (@eprenen) January 23, 2015
Updated
Sir Martin Sorrell defends wealth creators, such as himself.
He tells Davos that he founded a company with 2 people, and now employs 179,000 people in 111 countries and invests $12bn in human capital each year.
I make no apology for that whatsoever.
Sorrell adds that the improvements in fighting extreme inequality and fatal diseases in recent decades doesn’t get enough credit.
And he reminds Lagarde that there isn’t proof that equality drives growth.
Byanyima hits back - a year ago, we found that 85 people own as much wealth as the bottom 50%. It’s now down to 80 people. The situation is getting worse.
That’s not the best way to measure inequality, the BBC’s Evan Davies suggests, given just how poor the poorest are.
Oxfam: The 0.1% are shaping the rules of the market
Oxfam International’s Winnie Byanyima takes the floor, explaining how extreme wealth is distorting the way the world works.
The financial lobbyists in the US spent $400m in 2013 influencing political debate, and $571m in campaigning contributions.
They also spent $150m in the EU, lobbying governments.
This is about shaping the rules of the market in their favour, Byanyima says:
In an ideal situation we would have all people shaping the way the economy is governed and society is governed.
Extreme wealth results in political capture, and from there on public decision making is conducted in the interest of the wealthy.
The BBC then play two clips of wealthy men defending the rich, including British businessman Luke Johnson - who argues that our economy will suffer if we demonise wealth-creators as fat cats and plutocrats.
Bank of England governor Mark Carney goes next, explaining how financial innovation - some good, some not so good - in the run-up to the crisis has allowed the system to lose its focus on social capital.
He dubs it a “let them eat credit” approach - which allowed consumption to increase even as incomes didn’t.
Lagarde: Inequality is not good for growth, or for women
The BBC’s Evan Davies kicks off the inequality debate by reminding Christine Lagarde that the IMF pulled a screeching u-turn last year when she warned about the dangers of inequality.
Yes, Lagarde replies. When I did that, some IMF economists warned that this wasn’t a mainstream view. But now it is mainstream.
She explains:
If you increase the income share of the poorest, you get a multipling effect that you don’t get when you increase the income share of the richest.
Excessive inequality is bad for growth. Redistribution policies are not bad for growth, she adds - another thing economists had wrong before.
Inequality is not good for growth. Inequality is not good for women, and that’s an issue I’m very concerned about, gender inequality.
Updated
If you’re on twitter, you can use the hashtag #bbcworlddebate to contribute to this inequality debate.
It’s starting now, with video clips of citizens around the world giving their views on inequality, unemployment, and social exclusion.
Watch the inequality debate here
The BBC debate on A Richer World, but for Whom? is starting any moment. Here’s a webfeed:
Swiss bus stop #wef15 pic.twitter.com/KmNl5qd72l
— Kim Hjelmgaard (@khjelmgaard) January 23, 2015
Irony alert. Some Davos attendees will be listening to the perils of inequality just hours after bobbing along at a terribly exclusive Google party
Pretty good music at the Google party #Davos2015 https://t.co/ZInZJTKuat
— Nicholas Carlson (@nichcarlson) January 22, 2015
I need a dollar at Google party in #davos no irony at all https://t.co/BkpDD7bdbp
— emily bell (@emilybell) January 22, 2015
(for the record, Team Guardian spent last diligently filing copy, tracking Prince Andrew’s Davos reception, before discussing economic issues over a late supper #hardcore )
Updated
The Agenda: Income inequality, Europe's future....
Hello from Davos, where the third day of the World Economic Forum is beginning.
We’ll be hearing a lot about inequality today, from some of the richest and most powerful people on the globe.
The BBC is holding a big debate on this crucial subject, that aims to nail the issue, called “A Richer World, but for Whom?”
On the panel, IMF chief Christine Lagarde, Bank of England governor Mark Carney, US economics professor Robert Shiller, advertising magnate Sir Martin Sorrell and - proving some much needed balance - Oxfam International director Winnie Byanyima.
It’s easy to mock the idea of inequality being discussed in this bubble of private jets, limos and huge wealth. So don’t let us stop you.
Readers might also note that inequality has been high on Davos’s agenda for several years, and it’s still a major problem.
But some Davos attendees are genuinely determined to help. Take Bill and Melinda Gates, for example - they’ll be talking about their vision for Sustainable Development this evening.
The weak European economy is another issue in focus, a day after Mario Draghi (much missed at Davos) launched a long-awaited QE programme.
French president Francois Hollande is taking the stage later this morning.
UK chancellor George Osborne and Germany’s finance chief Wolfgang Schauble will be debating Europe’s future at lunchtime; clashing with the CBI’s annual lunch for British business.
We’ll also be tracking Middle Eastern issues, as Davos delegates digest the news that the Saudi King Abdullah has died.
Saudi Arabia’s King Abdullah dies at 90
US secretary of state John Kerry is giving this afternoon’s keynote speech.
And the day will round off with singer/producer/activist/reality TV judge Will.i.am; he’ll be talking about his “I Am Angel” – Foundation.
The agenda
- 9am CET / 8am GMT: BBC debate on income inequality
- 10.30am CET: Climate change debate; Lagarde, Jim Kim
-
11.30am: Francois Hollande special address - 1pm: CBI lunch, with guest speaker IMF’s Zhi Min
- 1pm: Recharging Europe, with Schauble and Osborne
- 2.15pm: Francois Hollande special address (moved)
- 4.40pm: John Kerry’s special address
- 5.45pm: Will.i.am interview on youth entrepreneurship and his foundation
- 6.15pm: Bill and Melinda Gates on sustainable development
Updated